FitBit wristbands
l_ashley
Posts: 154 Member
Hello MFP community!
I am interested in getting the FitBit Flex or FitBit One for christmas. I was wondering if anyone had one of these two products. If you do, how do you like it and what are the pros and cons of it?
Thanks!
I am interested in getting the FitBit Flex or FitBit One for christmas. I was wondering if anyone had one of these two products. If you do, how do you like it and what are the pros and cons of it?
Thanks!
0
Replies
-
Bump - would really like to know this too. I thought that wearing it all the time I would not like - but after doing some research it seems that it works fine to wear all the time including in the shower, etc. What's everyone's take?0
-
If you're hoping to get one for accuracy, don't bother. Any relatively motionful (that should be a word) hand movement will get registered as a step. Sweeping/mopping? In one stationary position you'll get dozens and dozens of steps and this throws off all your numbers. Calories burned, distance, etc. You learn over time how unreliable these things are.
The verge did a pretty good write up where the editor wore both the force and the one for a day to compare steps. The force was thousands of steps off. I could understand a couple hundred, but thousands?! Thousands almost makes it worthless. Same with my nike fuel band. Scratch your head? Step. Reach for the remote in a certain way? More steps. It's...frustrating trying to make sense of it all.
I have the one and its probably the most accurate way of going as far as trackers go. Clips to your belt or bra so it tracks steps when your center mass moves as opposed to limbs you use to move around all the time. Wristband trackers are more for encouragement than accuracy, so if you think it's cool and just want it cause its fun, i say go for it. If you care about accuracy, get a fitbit one.
Gotta be honest though, i've worn my fitbit one ever since march and the past couple weeks i just stopped wearing it. The steps are dead on, but the calorie count and other things just seem a little...funny. Sedentary i burn 3000 calories but if i get 8,000 steps i burn 2600? Yeah ok. Lately i just downloaded a pedometer app on my iPhone and thats what i use.0 -
I have a fitbit! I've had mine for about a month...and as far as accuracy goes, I think mine is pretty spot on. I guess I'm more concerned about seeing how many calories I'm burning, than if my steps are 100% accurate. I'm 5'2, and on a "normal" day when I'm at work, it says I burn ~1500-1700 calories. This makes sense to me as I'm a hairstylist, and that means I have a fairly active job. Of course some days I'm busier than others, and my fitbit seems to reflect that. When I've had a really busy day in the salon, it clocks me in at about 1800 calories, normal day, between 1500-1700 calories, and on the days I don't work, and don't work out, it claims about 1200-1300 calories. For me, and my height and weight, that seems very reasonable. I have the flex, and really like the features that come with it, I wouldn't feel compelled to buy the Force, since I'm really happy with the features.
My husband has the Nike Fuel band, which is great for him because it's more geared towards getting activity in, vs, giving you a baseline of what you burn daily. You can still set goals for steps and fitness with my fitbit, but comparing with my husband, it seems if you're after a device that is more "athlete" or fitness centric, the Fuel band would probably suit your needs more.0 -
I have the One and really like it. I'm not one for wearing something on my wrist, and the Flex was missing a couple items (a display, stairs ... these items have been added to the new "Force"). My 18 year old has the Flex and is fine with it. My 14 year old and I have the One, it's easier to wear inconspicuously (he plays basketball and can't wear anything on his wrist during games, but no one notices he has the One on). Both my parents and my brother and his wife got the One as well.
I've found the calorie counts and steps to be quite accurate (I also have an Omron pedometer that I wore before and just continued wearing to compare) and I keep alternate calorie counts (from machines/HRM) ...
I LOVE the Fitbit and its feedback. I did a post all about it on my blog.
http://jenbsjourney.blogspot.com/2013/08/wondering-about-fitbit.html0 -
I have the Zip. I just clip it to my bra and forget about it. I find it quite accurate as far as steps and the calories seem pretty close too. It's a great motivator to just get moving more.0
-
I have the Flex and have been using it since July. It does seem to occasionally register steps when you are stationary but all in all, I don't worry too much about those extra steps since I'm doing 1 hour a day of exercise.0
-
I have the One. I love it! I'm still trying to figure out how it calculates the floors tho.0
-
Bump - would really like to know this too. I thought that wearing it all the time I would not like - but after doing some research it seems that it works fine to wear all the time including in the shower, etc. What's everyone's take?
DITTO!0 -
I have a Fitbit One and my husband has a Fitbit Flex.
Overall I like the One best. It has an altimeter and tracks stories of stairs, which has been a big motivator for me in stair climbing. It can also be worn anywhere on your torso. It also has an LED display so you can see your stats directly on the device if you wish.
The Flex has the advantage of being water resistant, which the One is not. (I did "waterproof" my One successfully for a mud run.) However, there is no altimeter, and although the FAQ says it measures steps when pushing carts or strollers, we have tested it and it does not. I push a lot of strollers, so that doesn't work for me.
I love the sync back to myfitnesspal with calories burned and I love Myfitnesspal syncing my food logging back to Fitbit.
I also have the Aria scale which Fitbit syncs to mfp.0 -
Are any of them heart rate monitors, or just pedometers? I'd like something to track my heart rate during running or exercise videos, and I don't want to shell out $$ for something that is cool but doesn't have the one function I want most.0
-
I got my Fitbit Flex in September 2013 and I love it. I had been using an expensive pedometer for about a year before I got the Flex so I knew what my average steps should be and I found the step count to be very accurate on the Flex. I know wearing the Flex everyday motivates me to keep moving. Since I synced the Flex to MFP my weigh loss has increased as I now manage my real exercise calories instead of just my projected ones. I am not a gadget person but I really recommend the Flex.0
-
I got my Fitbit One in May; it's been lifechanging for me.0
-
I have a Fitbit One and my husband has a Fitbit Flex.
Overall I like the One best. It has an altimeter and tracks stories of stairs, which has been a big motivator for me in stair climbing. It can also be worn anywhere on your torso. It also has an LED display so you can see your stats directly on the device if you wish.
The Flex has the advantage of being water resistant, which the One is not. (I did "waterproof" my One successfully for a mud run.) However, there is no altimeter, and although the FAQ says it measures steps when pushing carts or strollers, we have tested it and it does not. I push a lot of strollers, so that doesn't work for me.
I love the sync back to myfitnesspal with calories burned and I love Myfitnesspal syncing my food logging back to Fitbit.
I also have the Aria scale which Fitbit syncs to mfp.
Good info. I'm a newb (as my son calls me) to all the weight loss gadgets, and I'm hoping to change that after Christmas. I'm very analytical, so accuracy is important.0 -
I have had the zip and the flex...both track steps (probably a bit over on the flex because of arm movement). My only issue is I cannot wear the Flex as it causes a painful rash everytime I do. Not sure of the exact contents of the wristband as I can wear other rubberized bands with no issues. So at the moment the tracker from the flex goes in my pocket.0
-
I've had the Flex for going on 4 months now and find it to be a great motivator. I agree, it's not 100% accurate, but its pretty darn close. I figure for ever "mis-tracked" step it registers, there is probably another one it misses. If you're looking for an overall trend of your daily activity, it is great. There are a few tricks I've learned to get more use out of mine. For instance, if using an elliptical, if worn on your wrist, the flex wont pick up your strides, however if you stick it in your pocket it will pick up most of them (I lose about 1/10th of a mile on an elliptical). Same goes for using it while pushing a shopping cart (or stroller), just stick it in your pocket and it will register those steps. It is flawed, but over all I think it does a great job of keeping me motivated to move more throughout the day. I feel that I "need" to meet certain goals each day and will go out of my way to do so.0
-
I have the new Fitbit Force, and I gotta say, since I've had it (about 1 week) its seems to me that its not the most accurate with steps ( fine with me.. I use it for a estimate of calorie burn) as something else might be.
I use it mostly for motivation to keep moving and to have higher and higher goals to meet each day. I haven't learned all the features yet, but I love the sleep tracker and OMG the battery lasts forever!!!! Love that! And I like to be able to use it as a watch too!
The most accurate thing to get would probably be a heart rate moniter, so if its spot-on accruacy you are looking for, do some research on that maybe.
Yup.. mostly I use mine to try to challenge myself to do more each day till I'm having more active hours than non active hours of my day. It works great for that!
All in all, I'd say I'm pretty happy with mine! I'm glad I got it. Its $30 more than the Flex, but you can see the numbers and not just dots on the screen, and its a watch! Its worth the extra $30 in my opinion. 0 -
Are any of them heart rate monitors, or just pedometers? I'd like something to track my heart rate during running or exercise videos, and I don't want to shell out $$ for something that is cool but doesn't have the one function I want most.
Then I would go with a chest strap HRM, which are to be worn during exercise. Fitbit is more for all day wear and activity, to count steps and estimate calories on more general activity.0 -
Thanks for the input everyone! I am leaning toward the flex - I think I would wear the wristband much easier than the One. I am more concerned about getting an accurate TDEE estimation because I haven't had great success in losing and maybe I'm not accurate on my TDEE estimation. I don't really care that it doesn't track my actual workouts because I do have a HRM for that. Looking on Amazon right now!0
-
I've had my FitBit Flex for just 2 weeks, but I really do like it. I've found that it is pretty accurate, probably as accurate as any pedometer. I enjoy being able to track my calories burned and see who close I am to my daily goal. It is definitely a huge motivator, and really puts into perspective how close you are to your food intake versus calorie output. I feel that it makes using MFP much more accurate for weight loss, as it adjusts your daily allowance based on your physical activity information.
This has been a great investment for me!0 -
I just got the Force and I love it! I had the zip which I liked but I wanted an all over activity tracker which the zip didn't really provide for me. I've worn it in the shower and it's fine, I haven't had any issues and it's great. I think it's pretty accurate as far as my steps go, I know where I was according to my zip and this is about the same.0
-
I'm getting a Flex for Christma and I can't wait!
Question for those of you who have one....I have a desk job where I'm always typing and answering phones, shuffling papers, etc so my hands are always moving. Have any of you found that the hand movements interfere with your counts at all? That's one thing I'm concerned with.0 -
I have a fitbit one and love it, it makes me do more cos I can see if I am being lazy 0
-
I'm getting a Flex for Christma and I can't wait!
Question for those of you who have one....I have a desk job where I'm always typing and answering phones, shuffling papers, etc so my hands are always moving. Have any of you found that the hand movements interfere with your counts at all? That's one thing I'm concerned with.
Great question - I work a desk job too and would like to know that answer.0 -
I'm getting a Flex for Christma and I can't wait!
Question for those of you who have one....I have a desk job where I'm always typing and answering phones, shuffling papers, etc so my hands are always moving. Have any of you found that the hand movements interfere with your counts at all? That's one thing I'm concerned with.
Unfortunately it does register casual movements that you'd do at a normal desk job as steps0 -
I'm getting a Flex for Christma and I can't wait!
Question for those of you who have one....I have a desk job where I'm always typing and answering phones, shuffling papers, etc so my hands are always moving. Have any of you found that the hand movements interfere with your counts at all? That's one thing I'm concerned with.
Unfortunately it does register casual movements that you'd do at a normal desk job as steps
Yikes that could be a problem. I have smallish ankles, maybe the large wristband will fit my ankle and I can wear it like that. I guess I'll give it a try and see how "off" it seems. I'm mostly sedetary at work so if it tells me I've had a lot of steps I will definitely know it's wrong.
Thanks for your reply!0 -
Wearing it on your ankle would be like using a scale with one foot on the floor. It's not programmed to be accurate that way.
If you don't want incidental arm movements counting as steps, I'd get a One or Zip model. Though if you have about the same incidental arm movement regularly, it's not going to matter much. The value is as a baseline of your activity, not so much to count your actual steps.0 -
I had the Fitbit One for a year and loved it, I started using a Flex in October and love it also. I really don’t have problems with accuracy, I wear it on my non-dominant wrist (you set up through your account the wrist you plan to wear it on) and compared it to the One for a while receiving the same results. Each LED light reflects 20% of your progress, so with steps set up an LED lights for every 2,000 steps taken (if daily goal is 10,000) – gives you an idea of where you are for the day. You can also choose for it to track calories burned or miles walked with the LED lights instead. It was hard to get used to not seeing the number when I wanted to but with the LEDs I have an idea and can just check my iPhone really quick if I want to know exact since it updates via Bluetooth. I also think the sleep function is easier. At first it felt weird to wear it on my wrist since I don’t wear a watch, but now I don’t even think about it. It does not track heart rate though, so if you’re looking for a device that measures that you’ll need a HRM – I wear both during cardio.0
-
I actually haven't found that to be true, in terms of it tracking "hand movements". Im constantly moving my hands at work, but I haven't had that problem. There is a function on the dashboard when you get and install the stuff for the fitbit where you can pick whether its highly sensitive, or not as sensitive to movement. I picked the "not as sensitive" option just because I didn't want it tracking my hands moving and counting it towards steps. Seems to have circumvented that as a problem--at least from what I've noticed.0
-
I've used a torso-clip Fitbit for a long time and tried the Flex for a day and also didn't find it added a lot from incidental arm movement. I returned it for other reasons but the steps count was similar between both models.
By the way, I had read on someone's blog that the Flex 5-light display actually gives you more than just 20%-to-goal increments. I believe the next un-lit light flickers for the number of 20% increments it is toward being lit. E.g., so if you have walked 8800 steps toward your 10,000 goal, you'd get 4 solid lights (representing your 8,000 steps) and the 5th light would flicker 4 times to represent the 800.0 -
I actually haven't found that to be true, in terms of it tracking "hand movements". Im constantly moving my hands at work, but I haven't had that problem. There is a function on the dashboard when you get and install the stuff for the fitbit where you can pick whether its highly sensitive, or not as sensitive to movement. I picked the "not as sensitive" option just because I didn't want it tracking my hands moving and counting it towards steps. Seems to have circumvented that as a problem--at least from what I've noticed.
^^^^ I am with you there. I have had mine for almost a month and it does not pickup my hands moving and counting as steps..0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.5K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions