Need suggestions for cheese alternatives
kirdyq
Posts: 165 Member
I have given up dairy - well, mainly milk and cheese - and I'm feeling MUCH better.
However, I have so many recipies that call for cheese/dairy products.
What would you suggest to substitute for the following ingredients? I am so new to this, I have no idea where to begin.
Shredded cheeses
Sliced cheeses
Sour cream
Cream cheese
Any help would be greatly appreciated. I'd still love to make some of my old casseroles/soups/main dishes and recipes, but I just want to keep the cheese out!!!
However, I have so many recipies that call for cheese/dairy products.
What would you suggest to substitute for the following ingredients? I am so new to this, I have no idea where to begin.
Shredded cheeses
Sliced cheeses
Sour cream
Cream cheese
Any help would be greatly appreciated. I'd still love to make some of my old casseroles/soups/main dishes and recipes, but I just want to keep the cheese out!!!
0
Replies
-
This may sound stupid, but do things for people who are lactose intolerant count as dairy?
If they do then I don't know, try cooking asian dishes because they do not eat dairy.0 -
Greek Yogurt can sometimes be a great alternative to sour cream. For block cheeses you can always pick up soy cheese instead. It's certainly not an identical taste, but you can get used to it.0
-
I would just seek at recipes that don't require cheese to begin with, or still taste good without cheese. If you're making a recipe that you'd usually top with cheese, try upping the seasoning or spice level instead--that way, you still get a lot of flavor without adding cheese.
I haven't liked any cheese substitutes I've tried (I mean, they were fine, but nothing like cheese) and they probably wouldn't melt or cook the same in recipes.
I second the advice to find some good Asian recipes, as they won't require any dairy but still have the "comfort food" factor that cheesy foods do.0 -
I would put myself in the same boat as a lactose intolerant person. I have found that when I eat milk/cheese that I get horrible GI symptoms, and my face breaks out. My doc suggested giving up dairy to help with the GI symptoms and it has, knock on wood, been working.
I don't want to cook just asian. I want to be able to modify my normal recipes so that I can make them for our family and we can all enjoy the same dinner.
So I'm looking for substitution suggestions - I know they have to be out there, I am just new to this and I don't know where to begin.0 -
I can't do dairy but goats milk based dairy products don't seem to bother me. Not sure if that's an option for you. If it is, Whole Foods and Trader Joes have great goats milk options in the form of cheeses, spreads and yogurt. Daiya cheese shreds aren't a bad either. I've tried some almond milk cheese and wasn't happy with the consistency. I've also had varied success making my own nut cheeses/spreads and I'd be happy to share the recipes if that's something you are open to? I will warn you though, some of the better "make your own" options are time consuming.0
-
As a genuine turophile, I have to say there is no substitute for cheese.0
-
I also had to give up diary a while ago- I break out TERRIBLY If I consume any of it.
I found that diaya cheese is the closest thing I'm going to get as the real thing. It's not amazing, but it's alright if you have no other choice! lol it does taste good on pizza, though.
I also like Udi products. Udi doesn't use soy, milk, or gluten.
http://udisglutenfree.com/product-catalog/
here's their website if you want to check it out.0 -
The only dairy substitutes I know of are soy-based, and they're an acquired taste to say the least.
What specifically are the recipes you're looking to modify? Maybe that would be easier to give advice on. I just don't think there's anything out there that tastes like cheese other than cheese, but maybe if you're looking for a particular creaminess or saltiness there might be alternatives.0 -
Is it the lactose or the milk itself that you are having problems with? If it's just the lactose then there is some dairy that may not bother you. I only have a hard time with lactose if I am sick, but greek yogurt and hard cheeses don't bother me even if I am more sensitive to it.0
-
Hi! If you are looking for a alternative that has a similar taste, texture, melts like cheese, etc., you may want to try Daiya. It's a cheese alternative. The shredded is readily available at stores in the US and Canada (not sure where your are though). They also make a sliced Daiya (a bit harder to find) and a cream cheese alternative (very hard to find). Tofutti also makes pretty good cream cheese alternative that seems easier to find. If you have a natural foods store near you- they likely will carry them.
Here's there website which includes a store locator: http://us.daiyafoods.com/0 -
for sour cream i use PLAIN greek yogurt with onion powder(a little goes a long way) tastes the same
i know you didnt list it but for mayo, which many people love, you could purchase veganaise its a vegan version of mayo and its really could and could be a sour cream substitute if you want0 -
In my experience, there is no real solid substitute...nothing that tastes right or has the right texture. I'm a foodie so I take that pretty seriously.0
-
All your going to find is processed crap. I wouldn't trust fake cheese.0
-
For cheese, Follow Your Heart is really good. Daiya is kind of bland and tasteless. You can use nutritional yeast in a recipe to make mac and cheese.
No idea for sour cream, sorry. I haven't had any in ages.
Cream cheese, try Go Veggie. Depending on what you're looking for, Go Veggie has a lactose free line and a vegan line. Vegan is purple and lactose free is green packaging.
I know you didn't request these, but if you bake try using coconut milk. We bake homemade bread with Earth Balance and coconut milk and it still tastes great. Enjoy Life chocolate chips are vegan also.0 -
Vegans have cheese alternatives. Hope this helps0
-
Shredded cheeses - Shredded soy cheeses
Sliced cheeses - Sliced soy cheeses
Sour cream - Greek yoghurt (Most brands contain significantly less lactose than regular yoghurt, try Chobani) Plain greek yoghurt has a sour taste that is very similar to sour cream and is very high in protein.I love the stuff.
Cream cheese - Vegan Cream Cheese brand, like Tofutti0 -
Can you try some of your casseroles without adding cheese and see if you like it?
There are vegan cheeses, I have never tried them so I can't tell you how similar they are.
But to get rid of a food group will require you to change what you eat - you cannot always modify a recipe.0 -
0
-
All your going to find is processed crap. I wouldn't trust fake cheese.
I kinda agree. Meat substitutes can be iffy too. You could make your own vegan cheese though! I'm not vegan so I still eat yummy real cheese, but I would miss it if I gave it up and I have tried Daiya cheese at vegan restaurants. It was ok. I would love to try making my own because it sounds like a neat idea.
http://vegangela.com/2011/10/15/homemade-vegan-cheese/0 -
As a genuine turophile, I have to say there is no substitute for cheese.
Agreed! Yes I had to look up the word so don't judge.......LOL!!! :ohwell:0 -
LIfe without cheese sounds like a life without peanut butter.
It hurts my heart.0 -
Sea Salt + Olive Oil0
-
LIfe without cheese sounds like a life without peanut butter.
It hurts my heart.
There is always Almond Butter0 -
I also stay away from lactose. Parmesan in small quantities doesn't bother me, so I put that on pasta or veggies. I make tacos and quesadillas and sandwiches without cheese and sub avocado- still creamy. Same with dips- I sub avocado. I make pizza with TONS of veggie toppings and crumble drained can chicken all over the top and then a half cup of real shredded mozzarella for the ENTIRE large pizza- that way you don't eat a lot of it but it looks good and helps hold the pizza together. Avocado instead of cream cheese- spread it and add a slice of tomato or cucumber slices and salt and pepper to a bagel- delicious. Try your casseroles with red sauce instead of cheese. It sounds funny, but its tasty!0
-
I know where you're coming from, I try to avoid dairy 95% of the time, and it's hard. What I've found helps is to recreate the whole recipe, rather than focusing on just the cheesy parts. If you do a search online for whatever recipe you have and add "paleo," you'll find a lot of dairy-free options! Some of my family members wanted a Paleo Thanksgiving, so I obliged, and the green bean casserole was great!! The recipe used pureed parsnips in lieu of a cream-based soup, and the recipe called for nutritional yeast to give it a cheesy umami flavor (I omitted the yeast, because I could only find it in giant containers) -> http://detoxinista.com/2012/11/clean-green-bean-casserole-vegan-paleo/
Short story, to reiterate what a lot of others have said, there are no "good" cheese alternatives. You're going to have to retool your recipes altogether.0 -
I don't think there are any vegan substitutes that match hard cheese in terms of texture, but for melting, stirring it into sauces (e.g. for mac & cheese), etc vegan alternatives such as Daiya should work quite well. There's also vegan parmesan (made from cashews or other nuts) for sprinkling over dishes.
I made my own vegan cheese this week using this recipe: http://www.maplespice.com/2012/11/vegan-unprocessed-cheese-slices.html
Unfortunately, it didn't gel with the agar agar I used, so it's got texture of cream cheese spread now, but the taste was pretty awesome. I used it for a pasta bake (diluted with a little oat cream and water) and it was absolutely perfect. If you use almond milk instead of soya, it's soya free as well, if you don't want to overdo the soya products. It also works out a bit cheaper if you make it yourself.0 -
This site has a lot of helpful, easy recipes that could give you some ideas. http://www.skinnytaste.com/2008/03/recipe-index.html0
-
I am no longer trying to lose weight, and I eat Breakstone's Fat Free sour cream with impunity.
2 Tablespoons = 30 calories!
It's not perfect, but it is pretty good.
When I was dieting to lose weight it was a way to make the food I eat taste like the food I like to eat.0 -
Normally I don't use cheese alternatives--my pizzas don't have cheese on them. If I'm really needing an alternative then I'll use Daiya or Tofutti products.0
-
Shredded cheeses - Shredded soy cheeses
Sliced cheeses - Sliced soy cheeses
Sour cream - Greek yoghurt (Most brands contain significantly less lactose than regular yoghurt, try Chobani) Plain greek yoghurt has a sour taste that is very similar to sour cream and is very high in protein.I love the stuff.
Cream cheese - Vegan Cream Cheese brand, like Tofutti
Be careful with some of the Tofutti stuff. We went no dairy for awhile while my wife was breast feeding (kiddo had dairy allergies and is lactose intolerant). Living in NM we make quite a few traditional New Mexico foods which are often served with sour cream. I was buying Tofutti fake sour cream and cream cheese and came to realize that they use partially hydrogenated oils.
I would look closely at the label of any cheese alternative that would have a similar consistency to actual cheese...according to the Tofutti website, it is very difficult to make a cheese substitute without using partially hydrogenated oil (Trans-fat). A lot of dairy substitutes use partially hydrogenated oils.
For us...we just became accustomed to not eating dairy. My wife is no longer breast feeding and we do indulge in a little from time to time, but really...after months of no dairy we've kind of just gotten used to not having it or only having it in very small quantities. I used to scoff at a mere 1 oz of cheese...now I'm like, "holy crap...that's a lot of cheese."0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions