How often should I eat?

Hi I am on a health journey. I am looking to lose 15 pounds and I am exercising 5 days a week. Alternating weight and cardio. My biggest obstacle is EATING. Or know what to eat and how often. I try to eat healthy, but I am not sure if I am eating enough, too much etc. I do track on here, but how often should I be eating? How many calories should my snacks be? Thanks for any input! Amy

Replies

  • WhisperAnne
    WhisperAnne Posts: 453 Member
    Hey Amy! how much is MFP telling you to eat daily? if you are wanting to lose weight just eat 500 calories less than your maintenance each day. Since you are active you will need more calories than a non active person.

    You should eat at least every 3-4 hours. Fill up on protein and healthy fats and veggies/fruit. Lean meat too.

    Eat less sugar and fried food.
  • ndj1979
    ndj1979 Posts: 29,136 Member
    eat whenever you want.
    just make sure you maintain your deficit and hit your macro goals for the day...
  • WhisperAnne
    WhisperAnne Posts: 453 Member
    If you would like to talk just friend request me!
  • ndj1979
    ndj1979 Posts: 29,136 Member

    You should eat at least every 3-4 hours. Fill up on protein and healthy fats and veggies/fruit. Lean meat too.

    ummm no ..meal timing and metabolism have zero relation.
  • Phoenix_Warrior
    Phoenix_Warrior Posts: 1,633 Member
    http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/1080242-a-guide-to-get-you-started-on-your-path-to-sexypants 

    As far as meal timing/frequency. This is a very personal thing. In terms of weight loss, timing will not have an effect. As far as what is sustainable for you and what will satisfy and keep you on track, that is what matters. What distance between meals/size do you find makes you feel best? I tried little meals throughout the day but I found, for me, that bigger meals helped me feel satiated longer and gave me more energy. Some find the opposite.
  • April_KT
    April_KT Posts: 332 Member
    Always different for different people but for me i try to eat every two hours, small healthy meal like fruit and a small amount of cheese or granola or veggies for snack a max of 400 calories on snack items during the day. I save most of my calories for meals. But like i said you could be different and there are some people on here who will tell you it doesn't matter even if you eat all your calories in one meal as long as you don't go over or stay too under. But some studies show eating every two hours keeps your metabolism going :)
  • jonnythan
    jonnythan Posts: 10,161 Member
    Eat at whatever frequency makes you happiest and helps you best adhere to your daily nutrition goals.
  • nikibean123
    nikibean123 Posts: 81 Member
    When I'm in the office 5 days a week, my day looks like this:

    9:15am - breakfast (porridge/brown toast/cereal

    11ish - snack (carrot sticks/banana/other fruit)

    12ish - snack/cup of tea (more fruit/slice of toast)

    1/1:30 - lunch (salad/sandwich/small hot meal portion/soup)

    4ish - snack (fruit/low fat crisps/anything crunchy)

    5ish - snack/cup of tea. (MORE fruit/something carby to stop me getting really hungry on the commute home as this takes about 2 hours)

    On weekends, I only eat the main meals really - I eat when I'm hungry until I'm not hungry anymore. Listen to your body!
  • k_c100
    k_c100 Posts: 5
    I'm a big believer in listening to your body - so when your belly rumbles (and I mean actually physically rumbling, not you feeling a bit bored and fancying a snack) that is time to eat. I personally eat my 3 standard meals a day, and have a snack around 11am and another protein based snack around 4/4.30pm to help me through my evening's exercise. All topped up with LOADS of water. Dont worry about this '5 small meals' idea or 'never snack, only eat 3 meals per day' - different systems work for different people. So listen to your body, if you find that exercise is too difficult and you are feeling dizzy/getting the shakes then that's a sign you havent eaten enough recently so have a pre-workout snack. And vice versa - if you feel sick eating too close to a workout then dont eat pre-workout. Find what feels right for you - that is the best way.

    In terms of number of calories, MFP gave me 1200 per day however I'm more active than that (I have a horse and ride/trudge through fields in mud etc) so 1200 isnt enough for me to function properly on. Instead I've decided on 1400 calories which is easily achievable for me and since Thursday (when I started) I have lost 4.4lbs, so I think I have found the right balance. I have got a lot more weight to lose than you though (39lbs).

    What to eat? Well technically a calorie is a calorie, so in theory you could eat all 1200 of your daily allowance in chocolate and lose weight. We all know that's not healthy though and probably wouldnt work! A protein based breakfast is always going to be the ideal (i.e. some sort of eggs or lean meat) but for someone like me this isnt feasible working in an office and eating breakfast in the office - so I have a bowl of cereal. I choose a high-fibre, un-sugared cereal like bran flakes. Lunch can be what you want - but as a general rule try and keep it low carb and high protein, low fat and low sugar. Same rules apply for dinner.

    A lot of this is trial and error, but generally as long as you are picking fresh healthy choices and they are low-ish in carbs, fat and sugar then you should see results. Low fat doesnt mean zero fat though - the body needs fat, but just choose healthy ones like olive oil, nuts and oily fish. I try and avoid processed food at lunch and dinner (unavoidable at breakfast) and dont have anything else to drink other than water (definitely no alcohol at the moment).

    As long as you stick to your calorie allowance, dont eat your exercise deficit (the calories you burn when exercising) and try and choose fresh healthy options where possible you will be fine. Good luck!
  • Azurite27
    Azurite27 Posts: 554 Member
    Eat as often as you need to to manage hungry and keep your energy up. If that means 3 meals with no snacks, thats fine. If you get really hungry between meals plan some snacks into your day. Personally I do best when I eat every 2-3 hours with smallish meals. But you need to find what works for you.
  • Thank you so much everyone! I lost 30 pounds on a shake and balanced meal diet a couple years ago. I only recently (This fall) put 15-20 back on :( I want to get rid of it and keep it off! I have a hard time remembering to snack during the day. So yes this tells me I may not need to. However, I am hungry in the evening! Finding a balance has proven difficult. I would love a meal plan, but I have to do this economically. So I am relying on me and this community :) I only used MFP to track calories/exercise in the past. I am going to work harder this time around and I will need the support and advice.
    MFP did say 1200 calories per day. I am not sure that will be enough with my workouts, but I will try to have a small snack prior to. I like to exercise in the AM so that tends to confuse my eating times! ;) Do I have breakfast then workout? Do I wait and have a break and then a snack first? Confusing...
    Thanks I look forward to advice and celebrating with you all!
    Amy
  • diannethegeek
    diannethegeek Posts: 14,776 Member
    Thank you so much everyone! I lost 30 pounds on a shake and balanced meal diet a couple years ago. I only recently (This fall) put 15-20 back on :( I want to get rid of it and keep it off! I have a hard time remembering to snack during the day. So yes this tells me I may not need to. However, I am hungry in the evening! Finding a balance has proven difficult. I would love a meal plan, but I have to do this economically. So I am relying on me and this community :) I only used MFP to track calories/exercise in the past. I am going to work harder this time around and I will need the support and advice.
    MFP did say 1200 calories per day. I am not sure that will be enough with my workouts, but I will try to have a small snack prior to. I like to exercise in the AM so that tends to confuse my eating times! ;) Do I have breakfast then workout? Do I wait and have a break and then a snack first? Confusing...
    Thanks I look forward to advice and celebrating with you all!
    Amy

    You're right that 1200 calories may not be enough if you're working out. If you use MFP's method of figuring your calorie intake, the website expects you to log your exercise and gives you more calories when you do. You should eat back at least a portion of these calories that you're burning. And please, make sure that you're chosen the recommended 1 pound/week loss or even 1/2 pound/week. 2 pounds a week is probably too aggressive if you just have 15-20 pounds to lose.