Input on Therapy...

farmers_daughter
farmers_daughter Posts: 1,632 Member
I've been going to the same therapist for a couple years, maybe 3. I have anxiety, I'm sure I have alot of other issues but that's the general issue. In the last year I've really turned around, and things have clicked. I think. I feel that my life is a bit better.

However the therapist I use, for one, not alot of people like her, they won't go into much detail except, she's divorced and doesn't have her *kitten* together so why would you go to her?

I will admit, that we've come to an agreement on a lower fee, since I have to pay out of pocket and my insurance is stupid.

I hear people say things or make a face whne I mention her and I wonder. Well should I go somewhere else, everyother month, instead of every month and to pay what I'm paying now (what I can afford)

Should I really be in therapy for 3 years? Is that a sign somethings not right?

Replies

  • This content has been removed.
  • hearthemelody
    hearthemelody Posts: 1,025 Member
    I would have to agree, who knows your therapist personally in your group of friends? Is it a small town perhaps?

    Therapy is for you. If it is helping you, screw what others think about it.

    Why start over with a new therapist because of gossip?
  • MiloBloom83
    MiloBloom83 Posts: 2,724 Member
    If it works for you, keep going. If the benefit is there, keep going. What is important is what she does for you, not what others "opinions" are. You know what opinions are like, right?
  • silvergurl518
    silvergurl518 Posts: 4,123 Member
    If you feel it is still helping you, no, I do not feel three years is too long. However, I am curious as to the company you keep if everybody you know has an opinion on your therapist.

    i agree. how does everyone know who your therapist is? i love mine...but i keep my therapy life private.
  • firstsip
    firstsip Posts: 8,399 Member
    I've been going to the same therapist for a couple years, maybe 3. I have anxiety, I'm sure I have alot of other issues but that's the general issue. In the last year I've really turned around, and things have clicked. I think. I feel that my life is a bit better.

    However the therapist I use, for one, not alot of people like her, they won't go into much detail except, she's divorced and doesn't have her *kitten* together so why would you go to her?

    I will admit, that we've come to an agreement on a lower fee, since I have to pay out of pocket and my insurance is stupid.

    I hear people say things or make a face whne I mention her and I wonder. Well should I go somewhere else, everyother month, instead of every month and to pay what I'm paying now (what I can afford)

    Should I really be in therapy for 3 years? Is that a sign somethings not right?

    No.

    Like certain physical conditions, mental disorders generally don't get "cured," they get "managed." Many people, when they feel like they've come far, will reduce sessions from one a week or one every two weeks to one a month, or even one every few months.

    If you like your therapist and feel you benefit from her, keep going. Do your peers ALSO go to her, hence their opinion? Or are there reviews online?
  • InForBacon
    InForBacon Posts: 1,508 Member
    If you feel it is still helping you, no, I do not feel three years is too long. However, I am curious as to the company you keep if everybody you know has an opinion on your therapist.

    i agree. how does everyone know who your therapist is? i love mine...but i keep my therapy life private.
    Except now the entire world of MFP knows. Way to keep your mouth shut!
  • farmers_daughter
    farmers_daughter Posts: 1,632 Member
    It is a small town :(, when I say alot, probably not as many as I made it out to be, there are my very close friends, about 3 that know I go to her, they've said things like "my doctor said she doesn't have her stuff together" or that "I know her and um....." , and then there are those that I've over heard talking about her.
    And then today, it kind of got brought up in a conversation with a new co-worker of mine, and she said "it's not .... is it?"

    If that helps.

    I don't see me changing anytime soon, I do feel that she has a good "grip" on me.... that sounds bad, but I'm not sure how else to say what I'm thinking.
  • farmers_daughter
    farmers_daughter Posts: 1,632 Member
    If you feel it is still helping you, no, I do not feel three years is too long. However, I am curious as to the company you keep if everybody you know has an opinion on your therapist.

    i agree. how does everyone know who your therapist is? i love mine...but i keep my therapy life private.
    Except now the entire world of MFP knows. Way to keep your mouth shut!
    Ha ha no....you guys I don't care that you know....I don't know any of you. Now someone will prove me wrong and this will be all over yahoo or something..... oh well.. just asking others :)
  • This content has been removed.
  • firstsip
    firstsip Posts: 8,399 Member
    It is a small town :(, when I say alot, probably not as many as I made it out to be, there are my very close friends, about 3 that know I go to her, they've said things like "my doctor said she doesn't have her stuff together" or that "I know her and um....." , and then there are those that I've over heard talking about her.
    And then today, it kind of got brought up in a conversation with a new co-worker of mine, and she said "it's not .... is it?"

    If that helps.

    I don't see me changing anytime soon, I do feel that she has a good "grip" on me.... that sounds bad, but I'm not sure how else to say what I'm thinking.

    Doesn't sound bad at all! I feel you. You develop a rapport with people over time; therapists, doctors, etc.

    If you feel it's benefiting you (as you said, you feel you've come a long way with her), stay.

    Others might have heard things, etc., but it's all meaningless unless confirmed by the person in question, yeah? Gossip is gossip, even in professional settings (I've had doctors make odd comments about other doctors when they've heard who I've been seeing, my favorite being, "Oh, Dr. ___? I... went to Med School with... his wife." followed by a wistful stare).

    Even if people had a negative opinion based on their own personal experiences, that also shouldn't factor in. YOU have good chemistry with her, and that's all that matters for you.
  • farmers_daughter
    farmers_daughter Posts: 1,632 Member
    This might help you.

    http://blahtherapy.com/

    sweet! thank you!
  • csmullins78
    csmullins78 Posts: 61 Member
    I don't think it matters one little bit what she has going on in her personal life when it comes to her ability to be a good therapist. So what if she's divorced! Who the heck cares!

    As for the length of time in therapy...

    Shoot, I expect to be in therapy for the rest of my life. Therapy is a wonderful thing with the right therapist. If you're concerned about the length of time you've been in therapy, maybe you could sit down with your therapist and discuss your goals for therapy.
  • LishieFruit89
    LishieFruit89 Posts: 1,956 Member
    You've found a therapist you like.
    You've made progress with said therapist.
    You can afford her and have a payment plan figured out.

    Why on earth would you switch?

    People are going to find fault in anything you do, no matter what.
    Don't listen to them if you like your therapist.

    3 years is a long time to some, for others it's the tip of the iceberg.
    No shame in being in therapy for 3 years or longer at all.
  • fannyfrost
    fannyfrost Posts: 756 Member
    Therapy is a personal thing and what works for one person doesn't work for another. 90% of it is, do you feel comfortable talking to your therapist. If yes, then everyone else's opinion means nothing.

    FYI, a good therapist is in in therapy themselves.

    I wouldn't change just because people have something to say. Small town, a lot could be rumors.
  • Wenchilada
    Wenchilada Posts: 472 Member
    I've been going to the same therapist for a couple years, maybe 3. I have anxiety, I'm sure I have alot of other issues but that's the general issue. In the last year I've really turned around, and things have clicked. I think. I feel that my life is a bit better.

    However the therapist I use, for one, not alot of people like her, they won't go into much detail except, she's divorced and doesn't have her *kitten* together so why would you go to her?

    I will admit, that we've come to an agreement on a lower fee, since I have to pay out of pocket and my insurance is stupid.

    I hear people say things or make a face whne I mention her and I wonder. Well should I go somewhere else, everyother month, instead of every month and to pay what I'm paying now (what I can afford)

    Should I really be in therapy for 3 years? Is that a sign somethings not right?

    No.

    Like certain physical conditions, mental disorders generally don't get "cured," they get "managed." Many people, when they feel like they've come far, will reduce sessions from one a week or one every two weeks to one a month, or even one every few months.

    If you like your therapist and feel you benefit from her, keep going. Do your peers ALSO go to her, hence their opinion? Or are there reviews online?

    Just wanted to offer some input... I had been seeing the same therapist for 4 years. I initially went to him for PTSD after I had a major medical crisis. The PTSD was more or less managed after a year or so, but I kept seeing him because it was easier than trying to find someone new, even though my therapy needs had changed (dealing with anxiety and a neurological issue I was born with) and he wasn't really well-suited to helping me with those things. I also had some personal drama that came up, which hindered my progress with my PTSD and other issues, and while it may have been useful to have someone to professionally gripe to, I could just blog about it for free. :P I spent the last couple of years basically using that hour each week as a sounding board, and talking to myself to figure things out as to what I needed to do next. Which, I suppose that's good in its own right, but still, it was not all that helpful. I felt like he would always try to reassure me that I was a good person, instead of challenging me to do better at the things I was still struggling with and calling me out on my bullcrap. It took him saying something that really offended me this past summer to get me to start looking for a new therapist. (Not a matter of calling me out on anything - just something irrelevant and opinionated that really, really upset me, especially considering that I'd worked with him for 4 years.) I finally bit the bullet and started looking for a new therapist this fall, and ended up writing an email to a counseling agency in town, basically telling them what I was looking for and where I was coming from with regard to mental health history and therapy background. They placed me with someone who seems to be a pretty good fit so far.

    Like others have said, I don't think there's a fixed time limit on how long therapy should go - it depends on if your goals and needs are being met. If things aren't improving for you after, say, 3-6 months, it's time to start looking for a new therapist. And if the goals you set have been met, and you don't have anything else you can be helped with by that particular therapist or their style of therapy, that would also be a good time to consider a change. Identifying and evaluating measurable goals is really important, and it's also important that your therapist doesn't become a "friend" in the sense that they don't just agree with everything you say because they think you're a nice person (even if you are a nice person!).
  • DMZ_1
    DMZ_1 Posts: 2,889 Member
    I've been going to the same therapist for a couple years, maybe 3. I have anxiety, I'm sure I have alot of other issues but that's the general issue. In the last year I've really turned around, and things have clicked. I think. I feel that my life is a bit better.

    However the therapist I use, for one, not alot of people like her, they won't go into much detail except, she's divorced and doesn't have her *kitten* together so why would you go to her?

    I will admit, that we've come to an agreement on a lower fee, since I have to pay out of pocket and my insurance is stupid.

    I hear people say things or make a face whne I mention her and I wonder. Well should I go somewhere else, everyother month, instead of every month and to pay what I'm paying now (what I can afford)

    Should I really be in therapy for 3 years? Is that a sign somethings not right?

    Many therapists (psychologist/psychiatrists/counselors) have messed up personal lives.

    Therapy for 3 years isn't that unheard of. I don't know your issues. Only you & your therapist should know that. I wouldn't worry about your duration in most circumstances.
  • Cre8veLifeR
    Cre8veLifeR Posts: 1,062 Member
    It takes how long it takes to excavate, accept and move on. Are therapists supposed to be perfect? If I were going to marriage therapy (which only has like a 16% success rate anyway) and my therapist was divorced I may question it lol. I have a lot of friends who are therapists and most of them are kooky! I would be too if I listened to other people's stuff all day.

    There are a thousand ways to heal thyself. Who is to judge you on what works for you? That's why there are so many different books on self-help - What works for some doesn't work for others. I will tell you this though, therapy is most effective on people who are introspective, can accept reality, can forgive what needs forgiving, can change what needs changing, and live in the present. Some things are scary and hard to face and deal with. Do what works for YOU. Ignore the judgy-judgers. :smile:
  • TR0berts
    TR0berts Posts: 7,739 Member
    I don't think it matters one little bit what she has going on in her personal life when it comes to her ability to be a good therapist. So what if she's divorced! Who the heck cares!


    So much this. I find that many times, we may "know" what we need to do regarding whatever situation we're in. Well, more accurately, we "know" what others should do, if they were in a certain situation. However, once we become emotionally invested in what's going on - as in, it's our situation - things get fogged up, and our thought processes aren't as clear as they should be, so we end up doing rash (often wrong) things.

    In addition, this therapist has been through something terrible herself. Now, she has a potential frame of reference for some of her clients. While it may not be ideal for her, at least she now has a better idea of the things some others may be going through.

    Like firstsip mentioned - mostly you manage issues with therapy. At some point, sessions will become rarer. If you're lucky, you'll get to the point where you don't need the sessions, as you'll learn how to deal with whatever is going on either by yourself, or with the help of family and friends. But there's no guarantee that will be the case.
  • PlanetVelma
    PlanetVelma Posts: 1,223 Member
    If you feel it is still helping you, no, I do not feel three years is too long. However, I am curious as to the company you keep if everybody you know has an opinion on your therapist.

    i agree. how does everyone know who your therapist is? i love mine...but i keep my therapy life private.

    Same here! Well, sort of. I think my MFP friends know more about my therapy progress than my family. LMAO!!!

    To the OP: Having grown up in a small town, sometimes people have nothing better to do than talk smack.
    or start rumors. So I wouldn't take what "they" say too seriously. :)

    Therapists are human just like the rest of us! Also, some "issues" cannot be cured - like a previous poster indicated it's about management & coping techniques.

    Good luck!
  • salembambi
    salembambi Posts: 5,585 Member
    its hard finding a therapist that works for you
    so if she is working for you keep her
  • Smiling_Sara
    Smiling_Sara Posts: 203 Member
    its hard finding a therapist that works for you
    so if she is working for you keep her


    as someone who is just starting out trying to find one, this is a scary statement.
  • salembambi
    salembambi Posts: 5,585 Member
    its hard finding a therapist that works for you
    so if she is working for you keep her


    as someone who is just starting out trying to find one, this is a scary statement.

    I just this week got an appointment with a new psychiatrist.. i have been waiting about a year...I HOPE I LIKE THEM AHHH

    sorry to scare you about it but I have found it to be very hard to find one and then find one you actually get on with