1050 or 1200? Before or after Exercise?

I have been reading articles on weight loss and keep finding that none of them are on agreement about calorie intake. I am new at this, learning how to eat healthy and gym memberships thing. I was hoping that someone may be able to help me out a little.

I am 5'10 and weigh 225 lbs, I am trying to loose between 50-75 pounds. I found on WebMD that if I wanted to lose 1-2 pounds a week I should eat 1050 calories/ day and do at least one hour of cardio 5 times a week. After reading other posts most people are warning others of eating so few calories. Is it safe?

Also, is the total calorie intake of 1050 or 1200 not including calories burned? If I eat 1050 calories and burn 500 then do I need to eat 500 more calories?

Please no mean responses, I am new at this I am really needing some support as I learn how to be healthy.

Thank you

Replies

  • paxbfl
    paxbfl Posts: 391 Member
    Everyone's number is different depending on their age, size, etc. Use an online calculator to find your BMR (basal metabolic rate - the calories your body needs to survive) and TDEE (total daily energy expenditure - the calories your body burns in a day with all activity factored in). Net between these numbers, and you'll lose weight. Here's one calculator:

    http://scoobysworkshop.com/accurate-calorie-calculator/

    Make sure you are eating at least your BMR or 1200 calories, whichever is HIGHER. I'd recommend that you eat a bit more and exercise a lot more to arrive at the same number. If your goal is 1200, eat 1500-1700 and burn 300-500 calories a day from a workout to arrive at that 1200 number. You'll feel a lot better - less hungry, more energized, etc.

    Be careful, though... MFP says you have XXX calories remaining, and it will add your exercise calories to that number. Don't go crazy and eat all your exercise calories back. Put as much of that toward weight-loss as you can (as long as you're over your BMR/1200 calories and you feel good).

    Good luck!
  • megsmom2
    megsmom2 Posts: 2,362 Member
    follow MFP's numbers. And DO eat back your exercise calories...as long as you are getting accurate numbers for how much you burned. MFP numbers for cardio are notoriously generous. Get a HRM for accuracy...or eat back 60% or so.
  • jennicole4
    jennicole4 Posts: 90 Member
    I think 1050 is probably too low to be sustainable. You will be less likely to stick with a plan if you're hungry or feeling deprived all the time and 1050 is very few calories..

    I am 5'0, so 10 whole inches shorter than you. I eat 1270 per day and eat back most of my exercise calories.

    BMR = Basal Metabolic Rate (the amount of calories you need to survive at whatever weight if you were in a coma)

    I used this calculator - http://www.exrx.net/Calculators/CalRequire.html and plugged in 24 hours of rest to find my BMR.

    I calculated for my current weight and for my ideal weight. I set MFP to the calories for my ideal weight BMR and I eat back most of my exercise calories. It's more of an "eating for the person I want to be" thing. This is working well so far. As I get closer and closer to goal, I know the weight loss will slow down, and I may adjust my calories down or increase exercise to create a bigger deficit.

    You don't HAVE to do cardio 5 days per week. Any exercise is better than no exercise, but as long as you are eating at a deficit, you will lose. Finding exercise you enjoy is most important. Look around on the threads. Lots of ladies have AMAZING results with strength training. Some people swear by walking. Others use exercise videos. Just find something that you won't get burned out on quickly and get going! I am doing FocusT25 right now, but when I finish, I definitely want to move on to strength training because the results are seriously that good! There are groups on here for just about everything. Get in with some people who are like-minded and you will generally find good people with similar goals. You get to share in their victories and motivate them when they need it. They will do the same for you.

    Anyway, best of luck to you and feel free to add me if you'd like!
  • auddii
    auddii Posts: 15,357 Member
    Here is some good reading:
    http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/1080242-a-guide-to-get-you-started-on-your-path-to-sexypants

    Since you say you want to lose about 75lbs, 1050 seems pretty low (hell, I think it's pretty low even if you were 5'2" and weighed 115 and wanted to lose).
  • Thank you.

    According to the site you gave me these are my numbers:

    BMR = 1830
    TDEE = 2837
    goal to lose 20% fat = 2269

    Does this mean I should eat 2269 calories/ day? That seems like a lot!
  • NicNac86
    NicNac86 Posts: 130
    Everyone's number is different depending on their age, size, etc. Use an online calculator to find your BMR (basal metabolic rate - the calories your body needs to survive) and TDEE (total daily energy expenditure - the calories your body burns in a day with all activity factored in). Net between these numbers, and you'll lose weight. Here's one calculator:

    http://scoobysworkshop.com/accurate-calorie-calculator/

    By netting between these numbers, pax means:

    calories consumed (stuff you eat and drink) - calories burned (exercise) = Net calories. MFP works this out for you on your news feed page.

    So if you'd eaten 1200 calories during the day and exercised 300 away, you'd only be netting 900 calories, which isn't enough for anyone!
  • erickirb
    erickirb Posts: 12,294 Member
    I would suggest setting your goal on MFP (this site) to lose 1.5lbs/week and eat back what you burn from exercise. Let the program do all the calculating for you. Once you get a hang of it you may want to look into changing macro's or using TDEE, but i would start simple.
  • WOW! Thanks for all the help everyone.
  • Lesa_Sass
    Lesa_Sass Posts: 2,213 Member
    I am 5"3.5, 45 years old and 119 pounds trying to get back down to where I was this summer (I went to India and gained weight doing the whole Eat Pray Love thing)

    I am eating 1500 per day plus my exercise cals back and am losing. So, chances are good that you will lose too eating way more than 1200.
  • lrmall01
    lrmall01 Posts: 377 Member
    I would suggest setting your goal on MFP (this site) to lose 1.5lbs/week and eat back what you burn from exercise. Let the program do all the calculating for you. Once you get a hang of it you may want to look into changing macro's or using TDEE, but i would start simple.

    I second this. You are new - just trust MFP for about a month and see how things are going. Read through the help section of the website to understand how it works and give it an honest try before trying to "outsmart" the tool.

    Good luck!
  • kawookie
    kawookie Posts: 813 Member
    Okay being 5'10" and currently 210, let me assure you that 1050 is way too little.

    I started at 250 and I have lost 40+ in 4 months eating 1400+ a day plus eating back part (or all) of my exercise calories. I am currently set at 1450 and I exercise 30 minutes- 60 minutes a day. This is mostly because I have a sedendary job so I need to exercise to get a reasonable amount of movement during the day.

    If you are more active you might need to eat more calories than I do. I started with the numbers MFP recommended and it has worked well for me. I would suggest this as a good starting point (your height, weight and amount per week to lose) and see how it goes. Eating too little can ruin your metabolism so I suggest starting with the recommended guidelines for a few weeks and see how it goes. You can always tweek it after you understand better how your body works.
  • TeaBea
    TeaBea Posts: 14,517 Member
    Thank you.

    According to the site you gave me these are my numbers:

    BMR = 1830
    TDEE = 2837
    goal to lose 20% fat = 2269

    Does this mean I should eat 2269 calories/ day? That seems like a lot!

    Yes that's what it means. You are exercising & you are 5'10"

    1,050 is a crazy low number......you want to lose weight in a healthy way (mostly fat loss) ....not lose weight at any cost.
  • I used WebMD and they told me to eat at least 1200 calories and burn off x amount to get to the number you mentioned.
    So eating 1400 calories and burning 470
  • auddii
    auddii Posts: 15,357 Member
    For those of you looking at webmd and getting 1050 and 1200 calories, it looks like you're looking at the "fast weight loss" section. While you might feel like you are in a hurry because you are sick of being overweight, it's usually better to avoid the fast weight loss tips because they just aren't sustainable long term.

    If you look at some of the other articles, they recommend 10 calories per pound you currently weight to lose weight. OP, that's almost smack on with what the calorie calculator gave you. It can work. I lose eating at 1900 calories a day. If you think 2200 is too high and you want to lose faster, try 2000 a week. Keep in mind, if you do this, you do not record your exercise or eat back exercise calories. (If you want to keep track of how much exercise you are doing, you can say you did x number of minutes of a certain exercise, but then change the calorie burned to 1 - MFP doesn't let you enter 0.)

    Since you're larger, you can probably handle a bigger deficit, so maybe try the 2000 calories. However, you DEFINITELY don't need to do 1200 calories a day, let alone 1050.
  • kgreenRDLDN
    kgreenRDLDN Posts: 248 Member
    I have been reading articles on weight loss and keep finding that none of them are on agreement about calorie intake. I am new at this, learning how to eat healthy and gym memberships thing. I was hoping that someone may be able to help me out a little.

    I am 5'10 and weigh 225 lbs, I am trying to loose between 50-75 pounds. I found on WebMD that if I wanted to lose 1-2 pounds a week I should eat 1050 calories/ day and do at least one hour of cardio 5 times a week. After reading other posts most people are warning others of eating so few calories. Is it safe?

    Also, is the total calorie intake of 1050 or 1200 not including calories burned? If I eat 1050 calories and burn 500 then do I need to eat 500 more calories?

    Please no mean responses, I am new at this I am really needing some support as I learn how to be healthy.

    Thank you

    I just put my info in for 2#/week loss and got an extremely low number-1064cal/day- as well....however the print below that number states:

    •Limit your calories from FOOD to 1314 calories per day. Burn an additional 250 calories per day or 1750 calories per week through FITNESS. Note: The amount of calories you eat (1314) minus the calories you burn through fitness (250) equals your daily calorie goal (1064). Things like doing laundry, grocery shopping, and walking all count as fitness, so be sure to note these as well.

    So they are not saying to only eat 1064 calories, but that by the end of the day your food calories minus your exercise calories burned should equal 1064. Food calorie goal is 1314.
  • KaterinaTerese
    KaterinaTerese Posts: 345 Member
    I have been reading articles on weight loss and keep finding that none of them are on agreement about calorie intake. I am new at this, learning how to eat healthy and gym memberships thing. I was hoping that someone may be able to help me out a little.

    I am 5'10 and weigh 225 lbs, I am trying to loose between 50-75 pounds. I found on WebMD that if I wanted to lose 1-2 pounds a week I should eat 1050 calories/ day and do at least one hour of cardio 5 times a week. After reading other posts most people are warning others of eating so few calories. Is it safe?

    Also, is the total calorie intake of 1050 or 1200 not including calories burned? If I eat 1050 calories and burn 500 then do I need to eat 500 more calories?

    Please no mean responses, I am new at this I am really needing some support as I learn how to be healthy.

    Thank you
    EDIT: I'm 5'5"

    I eat at 2100 calories a day and lift 3x a week. There is no reason for someone your height to have such a low intake. I would really encourage you to eat a day as you used to and log it carefully. Then subtract 250 calories from that for a week. If you see no results, drop another 250. Go very slowly, because I slashed my intake drastically, lost quite a bit but was constantly sick, and miserable for about two years, trying to always meet such a low and unnecessary calorie goal.
  • jdhobson
    jdhobson Posts: 42 Member
    Find your numbers via myfitnesspal - and go a little under. That's what I have done for the entirety of my weight loss. I was a big guy at one time so i started out at 2200 calorie suggestion. I ate 1800-2000 based on if I was able to exercise or not. As my weight dropped, I also drop calories. MFP now suggests me to eat about 1500 calories a day to lose weight. I eat 1700 and workout daily.

    Just eat based on the number the website gives you and stay active. Be patient and stay positive. The biggest part of losing weight is staying committed.Commitment is the one thing that will guarantee success.

    Good luck! Add me if you'd like some support! :)
  • paxbfl
    paxbfl Posts: 391 Member
    Those numbers sound about right.

    But given that they are higher than you were expecting, why eat back exercise calories? You're already going to be eating quite a bit.

    Eat around 2,000 calories a day, and you'll be safely over your BMR and won't be super hungry. You'll feel good and you can stay with this program indefinitely. Then find a workout you enjoy doing (I liked the elliptical when I started because my knees hurt from the extra weight. As I got into shape I started running again.) Then don't eat those calories back - just put them toward weight-loss, and you'll lose weight faster.

    The next question is whether it's ok to NET under your BMR. For me, personally, I was ok netting under (after exercise) as long as I ate over to begin with. In fact, I still do that some days. My BMR is 1870, I eat around 2300 and burn 500 calories to net around 1800.

    I wonder how many calories you've been eating. I was surprised. I counted my calories on a "normal" day and discovered I was eating between 3,500 and 4,000 calories a day. It's no wonder I had a hard time losing weight! :)