We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Is it a Cheat Meal or Cheat Day?

Laquincy
Laquincy Posts: 76 Member
edited February 10 in Food and Nutrition
My friend and I were talking. He told me originally it was considered a cheat meal and not a entire cheat day. Anyone have any input to this? Do you have a cheat day or cheat meal?

Replies

  • 365Keto
    365Keto Posts: 15
    When I used to work out seriosly I took a cheat day, it's easier than restricting it to a single meal. After that day I could keep a strict diet without feeling the usual cravings.
    It might not be every week, but it's good to have one every once in a while.
  • GemmaRowlands
    GemmaRowlands Posts: 360 Member
    None - I just made sure my weekly calories were within my limits. Sometimes I wouldn't count exercise cals on the day I did the exercise but instead at the weekend, or on a day I knew I was going out.

    That way, even though it may be going over calories on one day, I would know I wouldn't gain weight because I'd already thought of it in advance.

    I've always been very money minded, and managed to think of it almost like finance in a way.

    Anyhow, it worked, and I've now successfully maintained for over a year.
  • rxqueen81
    rxqueen81 Posts: 3 Member
    I say cheat meal. But I also agree with 365Keto.
  • Dawn810511
    Dawn810511 Posts: 98 Member
    I would say cheat meal instead of cheat day. And the way I do it is I will have a cheat meal whenever I reach an individual goal, like for example, my first goal is to reach 150lbs. I'll have a cheat meal then, like maybe go out to eat at a nice restaurant or something like that. Then when I reached my next goal, then my next goal, then the next goal, and so on.
  • dc1745
    dc1745 Posts: 69 Member
    I like to think of it as a "Free Meal" or "Free Day", not a cheat meal. Cheating denotes something forbidden.
  • Laquincy
    Laquincy Posts: 76 Member
    When I used to work out seriosly I took a cheat day, it's easier than restricting it to a single meal. After that day I could keep a strict diet without feeling the usual cravings.
    It might not be every week, but it's good to have one every once in a while.

    Thanks for the advice
  • BurnTheFatFeedTheMuscle
    BurnTheFatFeedTheMuscle Posts: 4 Member
    I generally have 2-3 cheat meals a week to eat "normally" with friends, take care of cravings and remind me how crappy I feel when I have crappy food. I'll do cheat days for special occasions such as Thanksgiving, Super Bowl Sunday, etc.
  • Laquincy
    Laquincy Posts: 76 Member
    I would say cheat meal instead of cheat day. And the way I do it is I will have a cheat meal whenever I reach an individual goal, like for example, my first goal is to reach 150lbs. I'll have a cheat meal then, like maybe go out to eat at a nice restaurant or something like that. Then when I reached my next goal, then my next goal, then the next goal, and so on.
    Cool, so a reward system. Makes it that much better.
  • Foodiethinking
    Foodiethinking Posts: 240 Member
    I have a cheat meal every few days.. I input my food before I eat to see if I have room to play around and also helps me stick to it. I also allow room for snacks etc. I make sure plenty of vegetables go with dinner which might be a couple of pieces of southern fried chicken or add loads of mushrooms to my pasta if I'm having a cream-based sauce. :)
  • hilts1969
    hilts1969 Posts: 465 Member
    My friend and I were talking. He told me originally it was considered a cheat meal and not a entire cheat day. Anyone have any input to this? Do you have a cheat day or cheat meal?

    Live like a nun Monday through Friday and like a devil at the weekend, cheat weekends are ace
  • Fit2Strip
    Fit2Strip Posts: 280 Member
    It's only cheating if you get caught.
  • thegilly6
    thegilly6 Posts: 137 Member
    I tend to go bigger than that. I like cheat events, a vacation, a birthday week, the Christmas break. I make sure I eat everything I've been craving those weeks then it's full "game-on" come Monday morning. Sure, I put on a few pounds. Most of it seems to be water weight because it drops off so quickly but I get back down to where I was in about a week's time.
  • Francl27
    Francl27 Posts: 26,371 Member
    Whatever you want. I can't really recommend cheating and eating too much all day long though.
  • binniesmart
    binniesmart Posts: 74
    [/quote]

    Live like a nun Monday through Friday and like a devil at the weekend, cheat weekends are ace
    [/quote]

    I tend to do this, but try and make one day good and one day relaxed. I log religiously mon-fri, then relax a bit at the weekends, safe in the knowledge I have exercise calories or a little slack from though the week. All goes to pot on holidays/xmas etc. Need to work on those longer spells of indulgence...
  • rgrange
    rgrange Posts: 236 Member
    Cheat month. I do it hardcore.
  • Amym26
    Amym26 Posts: 83 Member
    I do a cheat meal not an entire day. But, I suppose it depends on each person individually and how well they can handle the extra calories. I do a cheat day once every few months for special occasions only.
  • SexKittenlovesitrough
    SexKittenlovesitrough Posts: 486
    to be honest I don't think it matters, being over on calories is being over on calories...

    some days for me that equates to a cheat day because I choose to graze my extra calories...

    some days it's a meal because I make arrangements to have a meal that is over on my calories...

    lets put it this way...

    Saturday you conspire to eat your regular food however on Saturday A you munch on cheez it's all day to the tune of a 300 calorie overage...

    Saturday B you choose to eat within calorie limits and then choose to have a burrito bowl at your favorite place for an overage of 450 calories...

    either way you shake it...day/meal...

    both days you were willingly and purposefully over by 300/450 calories and as such had a "cheat"

    it's really in how you look at it.

    some would say that making it a cheat "meal" over a cheat "day" helps them to keep a binge in check, that could be true...but I think as long as your cheats are constructively planned to be enjoyable, fulfilling and within a moderate cheat ratio (aka not more than a 3500 (one pound gain) differential on TOP of your daily allowance.

    you can call it/do it, how you want.
  • astartig
    astartig Posts: 549 Member
    I'm in keto so cheating for me means eating carbs. I am doing a carb up day every week or so now. if something special is going on (like new years or christmas) I consider it a totally free day within reason. no ridiculous stuffing of self but eat what I want. Maybe I'll go a couple hundred calories over, maybe I won't. my normal carb up day I try to eat within my calorie allotment but whatever I want to eat within that scope.
  • Benphi91
    Benphi91 Posts: 31 Member
    Cheat day.

    I save them for nights out drinking.
  • airdiva1
    airdiva1 Posts: 198 Member
    When I started out, my cheat meal was planned for twice a month.
    However, I only did one that first month.
    I allow myself one day a month to enjoy whatever. But I still exercise.
    If I do have a craving for something on a non cheat day, I balance it out with extra exercise. If I want an extra tablespoon of almond butter? Walk an extra mile! Want a sweet potato? Walk extra
    One day I wanted a 16 oz steak. I walked 7 miles in addition to my normal walking. That way I balanced it out.
  • lynn_glenmont
    lynn_glenmont Posts: 10,126 Member
    Neither. I have "eat to maintenance days," and occasionally even "eat over maintenance days," so long as the week is at or under maintenance (in actual practice, I don't think I've had a week where my deficit was less than about 1700 calories since I started logging on MFP, although the stuff I eat on "maintenance" days tends to give me a lot more sodium than I usually consume, so I have occasionally had a higher weigh-in after a week with maintenance days).
This discussion has been closed.

Categories