Carpal Tunnel
MaggieSporleder
Posts: 428 Member
Does anyone have any ideas for strength training exercises for someone with Carpal Tunnel? I have hardly any grip, and lifting anything over 5 lbs hurts all the way up my forearms. I can't do push ups, and even just jarring at times is excruciating. I have been losing weight for over a year now, but I have been putting off weight training because of these issues but I just feel weak, and I don't like it. And yes I am going to the Doctor soon, just wondering if anyone else had similar issues or any ideas.
0
Replies
-
Weight lifting actually helped my carpal tunnel and helped increase my grip strength. Mine wasn't as severe as yours sounds. I just woke up every morning with my hand asleep all the way up to my elbow and now it rarely goes numb at all.
I was able to do push ups with mild pain after they were done but it wasn't so bad that it kept me from doing them.
I would definitely consult with your doctor before doing any lifting and dont be afraid of taking it slow and easy, especially in the beginning and the strength will come with time.0 -
I had to take time off from lifting while I was being treated, but after I was given the ok to start lifting again, I would say it has improved my grip strength. It's definitely not great and I at times have to stop and re-grip. I can do push ups, but they have to be on a flat surface...for instance I can't do push ups on dumbells with a row incorporated.
I wouldn't suggest pushing yourself too far until you see a Dr. Good luck0 -
Weight lifting will indeed help this issue TREMENDOUSLY. However, you have to be smart. To start you may want to wear wrist wraps or some sort of wrist brace to help support your wrist. Avoid exercises that bend your wrist badly too. Even after a couple years I still do not do push-ups for this reason. If I do them, I grip a dumbbell (or similar implement) to keep my wrists straight. Having palms flat on the floor and my wrists bent will hurt them quickly. Even then, doing heavy bench press or shoulder press I will put some wrist wraps on for my maximal weights.
Do what you can and slowly work up in intensity. Definitely involve your doctor if your CT is that bad. I can tell you that my symptoms are non-existent after 2 years and I only have to be careful under the heaviest of exercises.0 -
lurker tagged :blushing:
...as someone who knows and loves someone with CT :smooched:0 -
Thanks for the answers. I deff have my braces, but I've never actually used them when I'm exercising cause they annoy me... Yeah I know keep them on. lol I'll be seeing Doc on Friday, so hopefully he will have some kind of plan for me.0
-
I have serious tendon problems in my right wrist in particular. It presses on my ulnar nerve and causes nerve problems too, so I have a good idea of what you mean. I still do weights, but I modify so I don't aggravate my wrist. I swap between machine weights and free weights depending on what I'm training and what I need to grip. My wrist just won't go in some positions without putting me in agonising pain. I have enough knowledge to put together my own programme though.
Can you see a personal trainer just for one session, or do you go to a gym where they write you a programme? That would be really beneficial and you'd be able to try various exercises and see exactly what you can and can't do. There are always different ways to train each muscle, and a PT will be able to show you alternatives that work for you. You don't have to start out heavy either - just use a light weight and see what happens. Good luck!0 -
I definitely didn't have it as bad as you do. I did develop carpal tunnel and cubital tunnel syndrome because I allowed my first baby to sleep in my arms for hours until my arms were numb. I started strength training to build up my strength. And it got better completely. It used to feel like pins and needles all the time, and it would really hurt if I banged my arm and when I was out in the cold. In dance I had to do a lot of spider crawls and things for long periods of time (for performance). And lifting weights helped balance out all the overuse. It helped a lot because I have very tiny wrists (also broke my wrist in the past in a biking accident).0
-
My gym is the Y, and they go thru trainers like nothing. That is an idea tho, surely they've dealt with stuff like this before. I'd not even thought about that.0
-
Have you been to the doctor for a diagnosis and discussion about your options based on the severity of your CT? I had to have surgery because the nerve was no longer sending signals to the muscle to move (certain directions). Weight training would have been downright dangerous without the ability to control the muscles enough to grip a bar. I had no grip strength because the nerves didn't work to send signals to the muscles-no amount of training would have fixed that. I don't know how severe your symptoms are, or if your CT has progressed to the stage of impacting muscle control, but unless your symptoms are mild and intermittent and controllable through careful positioning/etc, I would hesitate to do anything requiring your ability to hold something without talking to an MD first.
I wouldn't nix strength training though. There are lots of ways to strength train. Not all of them involve using barbells and dumbbells. Depending on the severity of your symptoms, you may be fine to do anything (or anything with some modifications). I would talk with the doctor first though. You've waited this long to start strength training, waiting another couple of days to talk with the doctor isn't going to hurt. And may keep a 45lb barbell from rolling out of your hands and only your toes.0 -
Yes, I definitely agree about seeing a doctor. I went to the doctor and had nerve testing which showed there was no nerve damage. So, mine was temporary swelling and pinched nerves from overuse. So, for me to balance that out with a well balanced strength training program was very helpful. But, I had no nerve damage. It was good I did all that before there was nerve damage. I also went to physical therapy because I had pinched nerves in my neck from past injuries, so I needed some massage. But, you need to go to an actual massage therapist that works in sport's medicine (recommend by the physio). The physical therapist will not often do massage.
Ideally you would find a personal trainer that understands physiotherapy or a physiotherapist that understands real strength training.
I'm just going to warn you some physical therapists can be major catastrophic downers. I was told I would never dance professionally again! :noway: She was wrong!
Physiotherapist and Physical Therapist are the same thing.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions