Two hernia surgeries in 2012 - help

I gave myself an umbilical hernia back in 2010 when I helped lift an early 1970's model Chevy off of a curb when it hit ice and slid and hit the curb to miss me. I felt it only fair to help the guy get back on the road. So, like a moron, I lifted the car off the curb myself and sent him on his way. Later that night I noticed a little ball above my belly button and then eventually went to the doctor and discovered it was a hernia. My family has a history of umbilical hernias - most of my cousins have had surgery and out of my 8 aunts and uncles on my mother's side of the family 7 of them had hernia surgeries. I think it's a genetic thing as well for us.

Anyhow, I dealt with it the best I could and just lived with it. Then in 2012 when I weighed myself at 398 in February I decided I HAD to start exercising and getting a grip on things. I bought DDPYoga which I love and did help me lose quite a bit of weight and I bought a Smooth Fitness Elliptical. I worked out and ate better and from March through May I went from 398 to 342. But one day I was on the elliptical and it felt like someone was stabbing me - intense hot searing pain in my abdomen. It kept on for a couple of days and I went to see a doctor about the hernia. It was partially strangulated and he scheduled me for a surgery the following week. So I had surgery in late May 2012 - he done his surgery with a small incision. When he repaired the one he discovered another hernia that was pushing on the existing hernia and repaired that also. I think "that" was the pain I was actually feeling because I had somehow developed another hernia in the process.

His repair lasted all of 2 months before I saw the bubble on my stomach again. I had tried to be careful and follow his advice. He had told me I could resume working out in about a month and I did and then another month later I had the hernia back out. I then went to see the doctor who I initially wanted to do the surgery but was out of the office on medical leave herself at the time of my first surgery. She eventually did the surgery in mid December. She done the surgery laprascopically and I had 18 tiny holes all around my stomach as well as holes in my sides. It's a much different and more painful to recover from procedure IMO. However, her surgery has withstood this past years worth of wear and tear on my body and still holding up.

But I am also now pretty gun shy about working out in general. I don't want to be shelved again for another month or 6 weeks and when you are a big guy the recovery is much harder. Now, I always used to work out to lose weight and I lifted weights and like to work out and do cardio and all that. My "good" doctor - the female - told me that I should be able to work out with little issues as long as I don't try to lift over 50 pounds. I'm worried that I will strain the repair loose again. Has anyone else dealt with hernia issues and can tell me how you got around your problems and was able to workout?

I'm most hesitant about the yoga to be honest - and it's the thing I liked the best. Resistance based yoga kept my heart rate up and I sweated buckets and became much more limber by doing that DDPYoga. But some of the exercises are like the planking and other things that stretch your midsection. I'm not sure if that would be good for me or not - common sense is telling me not right now but I may just be thinking more cautiously than I should be.

So, can anyone shed any light on my issues? Thanks in advance.

Replies

  • CraigTorg
    CraigTorg Posts: 12 Member
    I wish I could post something to help but I am in the same boat as you are. I had an umbilical hernia repaired about three months ago. It was caused by an old appendectomy scar (and I think my stupidity of lifting a whole set of exterior stairs). I am also looking for answers on exercise and activity I can do. Like you, I loved to lift weights. That isn't even a thought right now but I would love to get back to that point.

    I'm interested to read any answers to your question. I really hope that solution is not light activity for the rest of my life :/
  • Sorry to say I'm not sure there is much to say, you really need to work with your doctor on this one and listen to your common sense and her advice, not random internet people's advice. The good news is that just walking alone with calorie restriction can be enough to lose weight and get two of the biggest health beneficial factors into your favor (healthy weight and 150 minutes per week aerobic exercise), as well as reduce your risk of recurrence.

    Maybe this will amuse you, if you like Weird Al: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X8Ow1nlafOg
  • mjudd1990
    mjudd1990 Posts: 219 Member
    Anything that increases your intra-abdominal pressure is going to carry the possibility of re-herniation. As yoga requires a lot of core stabilization it may not be the best thing to start out with. I would recommend doing as much low-impact cardio work as you can and try to get your weight down first. . Your long term goal should be to really strengthen your core but again this is somewhat tenuous as any sort of straining could cause another hernia. Be sure to slow ease back into any yoga or lifting and consider investing in a weight lifting belt to give you extra support at least initially. Above all just be sure you and your doc are on the same page and try to run any changes to your exercise regimen by them first.
  • Annie_01
    Annie_01 Posts: 3,096 Member
    I too deal with the hernias except I have never had mine repaired. Maybe after I get some weight off I will consider it.

    Right now there is not much left of my stomach muscles...so I am cautious about what I do and have found that it impedes me from being able to do any exercise that requires a strong core. Certainly not any heavy weights.

    I just love when I am doing some type of workout and they say to suck your bellybutton in to your spine...I try...nothing happens! LOL

    Often I just modify routines to work around it...I do a couple of yoga stretching videos...then some just plain old fashioned core exercises...twisting and side bends.

    I was reading something this morning about an exercise called the Russian twist on bodybuilding.com. I don't know if I can do it but I think I will try even if I have to modify a little to make it easier. You might check it out.

    I am sorry that you are faced with this...but I have to admit...I am glad that I am not the only one having to work around this. At times it makes me feel like a wimp!
  • downndirtytn
    downndirtytn Posts: 9 Member
    Thanks for the replies. I am going to talk to my hernia doctor again next week if I get the opportunity. Hopefully she can shed some light on the situation. I have a feeling she'll keep me reigned in on the amount of weight I can lift and probably frown on the yoga until I get my weight down at least 100 pounds or so - or at least that's what I'm guessing. It does make sense that all this weight on my midsection could cause an unnecessary hernia that would set me back yet again and I don't need that for sure. Maybe with enough weight lost the chances of tearing the hernia loose again will diminish.
  • Greytfish
    Greytfish Posts: 810
    Talk to your doc about what he/she recommends. The Doc may be able to send you to PT forst for some conditioning.

    Look into Bikram yoga if you like yoga before. Lots of strength and things that get your heart rate up, but easy to modify to suit your situation and fitness level.