dr oz 3 day detox cleanse
Replies
-
This content has been removed.
-
Detoxing is a good thing to do. Yes your kidneys, liver, and skin are detoxifying organs but the reason for a detox is to give these organs a break and not have to focus on anything else but the impurities already in your body. Detoxing is even more necessary if you have had a history of bad eating and have medical conditions such as being over weight or even the common cold.
False...there are no giving you body organs a "break"...that would lead to other failures in your body...then ultimately death. And every major medical hospital in the nation: Mayo, Harvard, Cleveland, Hopkins, they all agree that you can not cure the cold only treat the symptoms. You can't "detox" a common cold out of your body.0 -
But medical and scientific journals show no evidence that detoxing with foods/drinks exists. And really being overweight is about overconsumption and the common cold is a virus which is NOT affected by foods but whom you share your indoor time with.Detoxing is a good thing to do. Yes your kidneys, liver, and skin are detoxifying organs but the reason for a detox is to give these organs a break and not have to focus on anything else but the impurities already in your body. Detoxing is even more necessary if you have had a history of bad eating and have medical conditions such as being over weight or even the common cold.
A.C.E. Certified Personal/Group FitnessTrainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition0 -
No proof? Let's not get started on what some medical journals are willing to publish versus not. I've seen first hand what detoxing and proper dieting do to people with stomach issues, obesity, women health, etc. I don't say this because I've heard it, I say it because I've seen it.0
-
I don't mean a literal break. I meant to "lighten the load" of their work. Don't take things to literal if they don't make logical sense it makes you sound a little obsessive.Detoxing is a good thing to do. Yes your kidneys, liver, and skin are detoxifying organs but the reason for a detox is to give these organs a break and not have to focus on anything else but the impurities already in your body. Detoxing is even more necessary if you have had a history of bad eating and have medical conditions such as being over weight or even the common cold.
False...there are no giving you body organs a "break"...that would lead to other failures in your body...then ultimately death. And every major medical hospital in the nation: Mayo, Harvard, Cleveland, Hopkins, they all agree that you can not cure the cold only treat the symptoms. You can't "detox" a common cold out of your body.0 -
No proof? Let's not get started on what some medical journals are willing to publish versus not. I've seen first hand what detoxing and proper dieting do to people with stomach issues, obesity, women health, etc. I don't say this because I've heard it, I say it because I've seen it.
LOL.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
No proof? Let's not get started on what some medical journals are willing to publish versus not. I've seen first hand what detoxing and proper dieting do to people with stomach issues, obesity, women health, etc. I don't say this because I've heard it, I say it because I've seen it.
LOL.
x20 -
No proof? Let's not get started on what some medical journals are willing to publish versus not. I've seen first hand what detoxing and proper dieting do to people with stomach issues, obesity, women health, etc. I don't say this because I've heard it, I say it because I've seen it.
Riiiiiigggggghhhhhhhttttt. Your personal experience trumps years of rigorous study and research.
0 -
Peer reviewed clinical studies are subject to refutation by the scientific community at large. You're speaking from an anecdotal point of view. And anecdotes aren't evidence.No proof? Let's not get started on what some medical journals are willing to publish versus not. I've seen first hand what detoxing and proper dieting do to people with stomach issues, obesity, women health, etc. I don't say this because I've heard it, I say it because I've seen it.
There are lots of people who claim to have seen UFO's, Vampires, Bigfoot, Loch Ness monster, etc. According to your view, these people's word should be taken as absolute truth.0 -
No proof? Let's not get started on what some medical journals are willing to publish versus not. I've seen first hand what detoxing and proper dieting do to people with stomach issues, obesity, women health, etc. I don't say this because I've heard it, I say it because I've seen it.
0 -
No proof? Let's not get started on what some medical journals are willing to publish versus not. I've seen first hand what detoxing and proper dieting do to people with stomach issues, obesity, women health, etc. I don't say this because I've heard it, I say it because I've seen it.
Do you also give your lungs a break by not breathing?
I'm going to go with science over naturopathic nonsense on this one.0 -
Every time someone mentions detox or cleanse, an extremely polarized discussion develops. I believe that a detox or cleanse can have benefit, however. But please read my whole post before you latch on to that and annihilate me.
A detox is nothing more than a short term VLCD. The pushers of detoxes want you to believe that their product or method has some extraordinary properties that will somehow leave your body in a better metabolic state or free of undefined toxins, and this is simply untrue. A trendy detox and a 24-hour fast essentially accomplish the same thing - they deplete glycogen and can have a diuretic effect. They're not fixing anything metabolically or chemically in your body because its unlikely that anything needs fixing. (and if something DOES need fixing, consult your doctor, not the internet)
Contrary to what the vehemently anti-detox crowd will purport, it's not going to harm you either.
Where a detox or cleanse can add value is in the mental game of weight loss. Some people will use a detox to draw a line in the sand, or reap the mental benefit of seeing the scale move a little bit. If this is something that will give you the energy and focus you need to move forward with a sane nutrition plan, it's done some good.
Detoxes and Cleanses are placebos, nothing more. Just don't misinterpret what the detox or cleanse is ACTUALLY accomplishing.0 -
No proof? Let's not get started on what some medical journals are willing to publish versus not. I've seen first hand what detoxing and proper dieting do to people with stomach issues, obesity, women health, etc. I don't say this because I've heard it, I say it because I've seen it.
Do you also give your lungs a break by not breathing?
I'm going to go with science over naturopathic nonsense on this one.
Not to mention having to wear a latex body suit with a tube for breathing...so your skin can have a "break."0 -
I agree!Your body has a liver and kidneys to de-tox. Yes, we overload their capacity with environmental toxins, stress, and all the highly processed food we put in our bodies, which they are not designed to process. So eat real, wholesome food in moderation and move more. Consistency and sanity win the race over fads and quick fixes, every time.0 -
I've seen a pin on Pinterest circulating of this honey, lemon, cinnamon Dr OZ cleanse. It claims that you can lose up to 20lbs in 10 days. :laugh: I'm am trying for the life of me to see how any sane person could believe that... :noway:
It doesn't do squat for "detoxing" or weight loss, but it is really tasty. So it has that going for it, I guess.It's bogus. They lose water (and maybe muscle) weight, and then will gain it all back in a couple of days.
And if Dr. Oz promotes it, you know it's a scam.
^ This. Dr. Oz is a quack.
Only in terms of his Oprah/weightloss stuff. He's still one of the world's preeminent heart surgeons.
I think that's one of the saddest things, that this brilliant, talented surgeon has destroyed his professional reputation by claiming to be an "expert" on things he knows nothing about. But he's raking in the money, so I can't really be too sad.0 -
Dr. Oz; I wouldn't do anything he promotes. He's getting PAID!!0
-
This forum needs a detox of Dr. Oz posts.0
-
I've seen a pin on Pinterest circulating of this honey, lemon, cinnamon Dr OZ cleanse. It claims that you can lose up to 20lbs in 10 days. :laugh: I'm am trying for the life of me to see how any sane person could believe that... :noway:
It doesn't do squat for "detoxing" or weight loss, but it is really tasty. So it has that going for it, I guess.It's bogus. They lose water (and maybe muscle) weight, and then will gain it all back in a couple of days.
And if Dr. Oz promotes it, you know it's a scam.
^ This. Dr. Oz is a quack.
Only in terms of his Oprah/weightloss stuff. He's still one of the world's preeminent heart surgeons.
I think that's one of the saddest things, that this brilliant, talented surgeon has destroyed his professional reputation by claiming to be an "expert" on things he knows nothing about. But he's raking in the money, so I can't really be too sad.
Aye.0 -
A detox is not a purchased product, it is a time period where one stops their regular diet to let the body begin repairing the issue causing problems. Juicing and fasting allows for the body to receive nutrients and proper rest so it doesn't need to worry about heavy foods needing processing. That's a detox. I don't care for what Dr. Oz is pushing. Go buy greens, vegetables, and fruits then watch how well your body responds.Every time someone mentions detox or cleanse, an extremely polarized discussion develops. I believe that a detox or cleanse can have benefit, however. But please read my whole post before you latch on to that and annihilate me.
A detox is nothing more than a short term VLCD. The pushers of detoxes want you to believe that their product or method has some extraordinary properties that will somehow leave your body in a better metabolic state or free of undefined toxins, and this is simply untrue. A trendy detox and a 24-hour fast essentially accomplish the same thing - they deplete glycogen and can have a diuretic effect. They're not fixing anything metabolically or chemically in your body because its unlikely that anything needs fixing. (and if something DOES need fixing, consult your doctor, not the internet)
Contrary to what the vehemently anti-detox crowd will purport, it's not going to harm you either.
Where a detox or cleanse can add value is in the mental game of weight loss. Some people will use a detox to draw a line in the sand, or reap the mental benefit of seeing the scale move a little bit. If this is something that will give you the energy and focus you need to move forward with a sane nutrition plan, it's done some good.
Detoxes and Cleanses are placebos, nothing more. Just don't misinterpret what the detox or cleanse is ACTUALLY accomplishing.0 -
Every time someone mentions detox or cleanse, an extremely polarized discussion develops. I believe that a detox or cleanse can have benefit, however. But please read my whole post before you latch on to that and annihilate me.
A detox is nothing more than a short term VLCD. The pushers of detoxes want you to believe that their product or method has some extraordinary properties that will somehow leave your body in a better metabolic state or free of undefined toxins, and this is simply untrue. A trendy detox and a 24-hour fast essentially accomplish the same thing - they deplete glycogen and can have a diuretic effect. They're not fixing anything metabolically or chemically in your body because its unlikely that anything needs fixing. (and if something DOES need fixing, consult your doctor, not the internet)
Contrary to what the vehemently anti-detox crowd will purport, it's not going to harm you either.
Where a detox or cleanse can add value is in the mental game of weight loss. Some people will use a detox to draw a line in the sand, or reap the mental benefit of seeing the scale move a little bit. If this is something that will give you the energy and focus you need to move forward with a sane nutrition plan, it's done some good.
Detoxes and Cleanses are placebos, nothing more. Just don't misinterpret what the detox or cleanse is ACTUALLY accomplishing.
No one has said anything about being dangerous...unless people are looking to do that alcohol enema or anything similar, or extend the said "detox" or "cleanse" and then entering eating disorder areas.
But when your body has it's own ability to clean itself, there is no point in spending and wasting money on the books and materials for the detox when in reality it does nothing.
Further more, the VLCD period in the detox that leads to the rapid weight loss can actually be harmful to the person trying to lose weight, because once they are done and the body puts back on the weight by refilling glycogen, the person is upset because the weight is back. Which that can set them up for just giving up because it can lead to a failure attitude.0 -
A detox is not a purchased product, it is a time period where one stops their regular diet to let the body begin repairing the issue causing problems. Juicing and fasting allows for the body to receive nutrients and proper rest so it doesn't need to worry about heavy foods needing processing. That's a detox. I don't care for what Dr. Oz is pushing. Go buy greens, vegetables, and fruits then watch how well your body responds.Every time someone mentions detox or cleanse, an extremely polarized discussion develops. I believe that a detox or cleanse can have benefit, however. But please read my whole post before you latch on to that and annihilate me.
A detox is nothing more than a short term VLCD. The pushers of detoxes want you to believe that their product or method has some extraordinary properties that will somehow leave your body in a better metabolic state or free of undefined toxins, and this is simply untrue. A trendy detox and a 24-hour fast essentially accomplish the same thing - they deplete glycogen and can have a diuretic effect. They're not fixing anything metabolically or chemically in your body because its unlikely that anything needs fixing. (and if something DOES need fixing, consult your doctor, not the internet)
Contrary to what the vehemently anti-detox crowd will purport, it's not going to harm you either.
Where a detox or cleanse can add value is in the mental game of weight loss. Some people will use a detox to draw a line in the sand, or reap the mental benefit of seeing the scale move a little bit. If this is something that will give you the energy and focus you need to move forward with a sane nutrition plan, it's done some good.
Detoxes and Cleanses are placebos, nothing more. Just don't misinterpret what the detox or cleanse is ACTUALLY accomplishing.
Provide clinical proof that it gives your organs a rest please. Because you obviously don't know how your body anatomy works.0 -
So you don't need to get rid of crap?? I know almost every natural health page talks about how we need detoxies.
That's because they want to sell your products to "cleanse" and "detox" your body. 21st century snake oil......
Timely.......this was on CBC's Marketplace last week:
http://www.cbc.ca/marketplace/episodes/2013-2014/detox-challenge0 -
Dr Oz is a doctor like I am a brain surgeon.0
-
Skip this and just do coffee enemas. The health perks are the same plus they're way more fun!0
-
A detox is not a purchased product, it is a time period where one stops their regular diet to let the body begin repairing the issue causing problems. Juicing and fasting allows for the body to receive nutrients and proper rest so it doesn't need to worry about heavy foods needing processing. That's a detox. I don't care for what Dr. Oz is pushing. Go buy greens, vegetables, and fruits then watch how well your body responds.Every time someone mentions detox or cleanse, an extremely polarized discussion develops. I believe that a detox or cleanse can have benefit, however. But please read my whole post before you latch on to that and annihilate me.
A detox is nothing more than a short term VLCD. The pushers of detoxes want you to believe that their product or method has some extraordinary properties that will somehow leave your body in a better metabolic state or free of undefined toxins, and this is simply untrue. A trendy detox and a 24-hour fast essentially accomplish the same thing - they deplete glycogen and can have a diuretic effect. They're not fixing anything metabolically or chemically in your body because its unlikely that anything needs fixing. (and if something DOES need fixing, consult your doctor, not the internet)
Contrary to what the vehemently anti-detox crowd will purport, it's not going to harm you either.
Where a detox or cleanse can add value is in the mental game of weight loss. Some people will use a detox to draw a line in the sand, or reap the mental benefit of seeing the scale move a little bit. If this is something that will give you the energy and focus you need to move forward with a sane nutrition plan, it's done some good.
Detoxes and Cleanses are placebos, nothing more. Just don't misinterpret what the detox or cleanse is ACTUALLY accomplishing.
I know. That's why I said pushers, not sellers, and why I said product OR method. Words. They mean things.0 -
Every time someone mentions detox or cleanse, an extremely polarized discussion develops. I believe that a detox or cleanse can have benefit, however. But please read my whole post before you latch on to that and annihilate me.
A detox is nothing more than a short term VLCD. The pushers of detoxes want you to believe that their product or method has some extraordinary properties that will somehow leave your body in a better metabolic state or free of undefined toxins, and this is simply untrue. A trendy detox and a 24-hour fast essentially accomplish the same thing - they deplete glycogen and can have a diuretic effect. They're not fixing anything metabolically or chemically in your body because its unlikely that anything needs fixing. (and if something DOES need fixing, consult your doctor, not the internet)
Contrary to what the vehemently anti-detox crowd will purport, it's not going to harm you either.
Where a detox or cleanse can add value is in the mental game of weight loss. Some people will use a detox to draw a line in the sand, or reap the mental benefit of seeing the scale move a little bit. If this is something that will give you the energy and focus you need to move forward with a sane nutrition plan, it's done some good.
Detoxes and Cleanses are placebos, nothing more. Just don't misinterpret what the detox or cleanse is ACTUALLY accomplishing.
No one has said anything about being dangerous...unless people are looking to do that alcohol enema or anything similar, or extend the said "detox" or "cleanse" and then entering eating disorder areas.
But when your body has it's own ability to clean itself, there is no point in spending and wasting money on the books and materials for the detox when in reality it does nothing.
Further more, the VLCD period in the detox that leads to the rapid weight loss can actually be harmful to the person trying to lose weight, because once they are done and the body puts back on the weight by refilling glycogen, the person is upset because the weight is back. Which that can set them up for just giving up because it can lead to a failure attitude.
A fair point which I had not considered.0 -
Detoxing is a good thing to do. Yes your kidneys, liver, and skin are detoxifying organs but the reason for a detox is to give these organs a break and not have to focus on anything else but the impurities already in your body. Detoxing is even more necessary if you have had a history of bad eating and have medical conditions such as being over weight or even the common cold.
So much fail in just one paragraph! :laugh: :laugh: :laugh:Skip this and just do coffee enemas. The health perks are the same plus they're way more fun!
Did I miss the sarcasm font? :huh:0 -
I get the sense (from your other threads) that you're maybe not ready to do this.
But when you are, here's the thread again:
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/1080242-a-guide-to-get-you-started-on-your-path-to-sexypants
Read it, and try starting there. You'll see so much more success than you will with cleanses, VLCDs, and 1200 calorie diets (at your height/weight/age).
Trust.
:flowerforyou:0 -
I've been doing the non-juice detox since January 2. It's just clean eating - no processed foods. I feel great and not hungry. We're friends so you can see my diary. I don't go much for drinking my meals although before this clean eating started, if I was too busy for lunch I would have a slim fast. But I was hungry. Good luck to ya whatever you choose! :flowerforyou:0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions