Increase of Strength = Muscle Gain?
Options
![albayin](https://dakd0cjsv8wfa.cloudfront.net/images/photos/user/bea6/50d0/af3c/d365/71c2/c4fa/d60d/0b7c66de6f17ef2e6ec44d263d1bf62dd5a5.jpg)
albayin
Posts: 2,524 Member
I just realized that now I can deadlift 110 lb failing at 7th rep. I started out with 2x20 lb dumbbells a year ago...My weight/size didn't change very much although my body does show more muscle definition comparing to a year ago. Does this "increase of strength" mean that I might have gained more muscle than I though? Or just mean that I started out too light without knowing my true strength?
Thank you~:flowerforyou:
Thank you~:flowerforyou:
0
Replies
-
Beyond addition and growth of the muscle cells themselves, strength gains also have to do with motor neurons and their increased efficiency.
EDIT: Here, read this: http://www.humankinetics.com/excerpts/excerpts/learn-how-muscles-build-up-strength0 -
You can increase strength, a considerable amount if you are new to lifting, without gaining physical muscle mass.0
-
Not necessarily. You can increase strength without increasing muscle mass.
Great work! That's awesome progress!:flowerforyou:
0 -
Initial gains of strength are due to neuro muscular changes. Size comes later. You can get a lot stronger before you gain any size.0
-
you can make substantial strength gains without putting on mass. Neural adaptation is substantially responsible for strength gains...you do reach a point eventually where you require more mass, but you can make significant progress for quite a long time without adding mass.0
-
that makes sense...I just didnt know what it was now it seems more clear to me...:) So my goal to look leaner and thinner, would this be the right appoach for my goal? diet aside (I think I got that part already)0
-
that makes sense...I just didnt know what it was now it seems more clear to me...:) So my goal to look leaner and thinner, would this be the right appoach for my goal? diet aside (I think I got that part already)
Seems to be right on track.
I started out with 45lbs (bar + Plates) and have increased my strength a tonne, I have gone down almost 2 sizes with only 3lbs gone...lots of apparent fat loss...strength gains.....and maintaining my current muscle...
I can hardly wait till I get to do a bulk...hehe looking to definately gain some muscle too.0 -
that makes sense...I just didnt know what it was now it seems more clear to me...:) So my goal to look leaner and thinner, would this be the right appoach for my goal? diet aside (I think I got that part already)
Seems to be right on track.
I started out with 45lbs (bar + Plates) and have increased my strength a tonne, I have gone down almost 2 sizes with only 3lbs gone...lots of apparent fat loss...strength gains.....and maintaining my current muscle...
I can hardly wait till I get to do a bulk...hehe looking to definately gain some muscle too.
but people keep saying to me that if I want to look thin, I shouldn't lift heavy because I look more muscular hence I don't look "thin". I am not after runway model thin but just want to go down a size or two and visually thinner too...all this heavy lifting didn't seem helping me to get there, yet...of course I have only done this for less than a year...0 -
I belong to a culture group where most women I know in my lift wear size 0, or 00 no matter their height...This makes me feel very depressed because I always look bigger than them and I was called "fatty" "chubby" since I was little...I still cant fit in size 0 so I am still not "thin"...0
-
Lifting won't make you look fat. You will look a lot better if you lift before cutting. From a guy's perspective most men prefer a little bit of muscle as opposed to "skinny fat". I'm even okay with a lot of muscle as long as they are not bigger than me0
-
I can't think of a woman I know that looks "too muscular" but spends less than 3 hours per day lifting heavy weights. Where on your body are you afraid of putting on too much muscle and "looking fat"?0
-
I belong to a culture group where most women I know in my lift wear size 0, or 00 no matter their height...This makes me feel very depressed because I always look bigger than them and I was called "fatty" "chubby" since I was little...I still cant fit in size 0 so I am still not "thin"...
:huh: Not everyone can be a size 0. I know I can't.
Lifting weights will preserve muscle as you lose weight through calorie deficit. It's the calorie deficit that produces the weight loss, not the weight lifting. Preserving muscle is essential for good health, especially as you age. Strong women live longer, have less chance of osteoporosis, broken hips, etc. The end results will be nice shapely arms, shoulders, hips, and butt due to the muscle you have preserved. But yes, someone with muscle might be physically bigger than someone without. To me, being slightly bigger is worth having a better shape and being in better health.0 -
I can't think of a woman I know that looks "too muscular" but spends less than 3 hours per day lifting heavy weights. Where on your body are you afraid of putting on too much muscle and "looking fat"?0
-
I can't think of a woman I know that looks "too muscular" but spends less than 3 hours per day lifting heavy weights. Where on your body are you afraid of putting on too much muscle and "looking fat"?
You're 41. Shouldn't you be past the age of trying to be like everyone else? Sometimes you just aren't and that's not a bad thing.
I'll always be "big". I'm 5'9" and large framed. I'm big and that's okay. Screw the notion that women have to be small and weak to be feminine. It's okay to be big, strong, healthy and female.0 -
My problem area is particularly around hips and thighs (pear shape anyone?). Before lifting, my upper body was kinda of thin and skinny, wearing xs. Now I can clearly see the muscle tones around my shoulders and upper arms. I don't mind much since they kinda balance off a bit my heavy bottom. But the thing is now I look overall a lot bigger, not just the lower half...This annoys me a bit. Some people call me "wonder woman", which I know they are joking but...frustrates me a lot since my goal is really to look smaller not bigger...
Just for the record, my thighs and butt didn't shrink either; they are still huge.0 -
I can't think of a woman I know that looks "too muscular" but spends less than 3 hours per day lifting heavy weights. Where on your body are you afraid of putting on too much muscle and "looking fat"?
You're 41. Shouldn't you be past the age of trying to be like everyone else? Sometimes you just aren't and that's not a bad thing.
I'll always be "big". I'm 5'9" and large framed. I'm big and that's okay. Screw the notion that women have to be small and weak to be feminine. It's okay to be big, strong, healthy and female.
LOL I guess I might still live in other's dogma even when I am 80...0 -
Just for the record, my thighs and butt didn't shrink either; they are still huge.
I'm 100% serious: join roller derby. You will see your body differently, and celebrate the leg muscles instead of being self conscious about them.0 -
You can't change your genetics with exercise. I am thick........I can be thick fat or thick muscular. I can't look like a model anymore than I can grow 6 inches.0
-
I wish I knew the user's name on here but there is a woman that is a member, I will try to find her again for you, she GAINED lbs and LOST inches, was physically smaller and more "shapely" rather than "thin". The choice is yours to make but women don't possess the Testosterone required to "bulk" and by toning and lifting weights you won't appear at all "Heavy" but you will rather have a nice physique. My end photo was taken when I was steady lifting weights. I stopped lifting shortly after the photo. I have maintained my weight but when I did a tape measure check in today for the first time since May, I have actually gained about a half inch of "mass". My clothes still fit the same and I feel fine, the difference I made was I stopped lifting in lieu of training for an upcoming bike ride... I started back to lifting two about weeks ago and don't intend to ever give it up the way I did last year. I will work in some weight training every week.0
-
OP, try some Creatine and watch that fail rep go higher0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 392.1K Introduce Yourself
- 43.6K Getting Started
- 259.9K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.7K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.4K Fitness and Exercise
- 403 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.8K Motivation and Support
- 7.9K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.4K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 999 Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.4K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions