p90x vs Insanity

Both are great programs. I'm actually doing my second P90X/Insanity hybrid (have done 3 rounds of P90X also). Insanity is much more cardio intense with NO weights and, believe me, it's INSANE. P90X is a combination of weight training along with Kenpo, plyometrics and yoga.

For a first timer, Insanity could be tough. Whichever program you choose will really depend on your goals.

As far as which one I prefer? I actually prefer both combined although I'd probably never do a round of Insanity. Can't give up lifting heavy weights. :happy:

I haven't done P90X but I'm Team Insanity! LOL

I didn't even get into shape for it (tired that route and I ended up hating my body even more)

So if you have that mind set "Go Hard or Go Home", Insanity is worth (so is P90X - both intense workouts and give great results) (I admit I'm impatient and rather see fast results and Insanity gave me just that)

I seen all types of body shapes do Insanity and see changes when they post their progress pics.

Shaun T says to do it at your pace and the best you can do. Since the other people take their own short breaks through out the workout it doesn't make me feel guilty when I need a little break.

It's also about choosing a fitness trainer that will keep you going! In a few months I will be owning P90X since my husband wants it but for me I'm a Shaun T fan. Just love him whether its in Insanity or Hip Hop Abs . For the most part my body transformation was made by Shaun T LOL

I have done both (P90X twice). This is my first time doing Insanity, I started the first week of November. And to be honest I have seen faster results in Insanity. My first week I have lost 1.5 inches off my waist and the second week another 1- 1.5 inches. However I am not quite sure if it is really accurate I keep thinking I must have measured wrong or something but it's just me doubting myself that it is too good to be true. But it feels GREAT!!! I do however like P90X Tony Horton, he's funner and funnier and entertaining. Shaun T from Insanity is just like blah, push it!!! Tony's motto is Do you're best and forget the rest and I like that. I saw results with his program as well but it took just a little bit longer.
P90X works all the body and confuses your body's workout, whereas I think Insanity your body kind of gets use to it. I definitely like P90X AB workout better so I incorporate that in my Insanity workout instead of Shaun T's AB workout.
Also it depends on your time constraint. Insanity is nice because it is only like 40 mins and you burn a lot of calories.
P90X videos are an average of 50-75 minutes depending what day. But you really work all parts of your body and feel it everywhere.

When I finish Insanity I will let you know for sure the difference in my results.

Thanks for bring up this topic: P90X vs. Insanity.
I will be starting the Insanity Challenge in Jan. '11 (60 days), followed by P90X (90 days).
So reading this gives me an idea of what I need to expect.
I will keep everyone posted on how the body is changing, so if someone ask the same question again can give them evidence on both.

Good luck everyone with there weight loss.

I've done a round of P90X and I just completed Insanity. They both have their positives and negatives. I absolutely loved Insanity, but would not have even come close to completing it if I hadn't done P90X first. The cardio in P90X doesn't compare to that of Insanity, but P90X has the strength trainging part down. Which is why you are seeing alot of P90X/Insanity Hybrids around lately.

And just when you thought Insanity was crazy enough, along comes P90X MC2 and Insanity: The Asylum (both coming soon). LOL! I love new challenges. 8-)

I've done 3 rounds of P90X and then I followed it up with a round of Insanity. I like both programs, but for totally different reasons.

If you want a great all-around program, P90X would be the way to go. I also am a big believer in strength training for a variety of reasons. If you are trying to lose weight, strength training is going to increase your lean muscle mass and help boost your metabolism. Also, as a woman, you need strength training to help prevent bone density issues in later years.

I was already in pretty good shape when I started Insanity, but even after 3 rounds of P90X, it was very challenging. I did get into tremendous cardiovascular shape, however, I found that I was losing lean muscle mass in the process. While they do say that you get your strength training using body weight (there are push ups and such), it's no comparison to actually lifting weights.

I also found Insanity to be VERY hard on my knees. After my 60-day round, I was glad to be done and my knees were more glad. I won't ever do another full 60-day round of it...it's just too much wear and tear on my body, but I will throw a workout in here and there to humble myself. : )

I found that Turbo Fire was a much better cardio program for me...while it may not seem as 'extreme' as Insanity, it's still a great workout and I find that I actually burn more calories doing those cardio workouts than I did Insanity. Coupled with a strength program, it's a good combination.

I am on my second week of Insanity. When I go to log my exercise workout in my fitness pal I have been using the Aerobics- High Impact to log the number of minutes done. Is there a better way to log this? Insanity is not listed in the drop down menu of choices. How can we get it in there?

I am on my second week of Insanity. When I go to log my exercise workout in my fitness pal I have been using the Aerobics- High Impact to log the number of minutes done. Is there a better way to log this? Insanity is not listed in the drop down menu of choices. How can we get it in there?

I just use circuit training

I'm not sure if this website is reliable but this is what I've been using
www.insanitycalories.com