We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Calorie help please...

amcmillan730
amcmillan730 Posts: 591 Member
edited September 2024 in Health and Weight Loss
ok. when I first started... before mfp... I wasn't counting calories... I was just eating much better and exercising at least 5 days a week (cardio mainly).... and I lost steadily for a few weeks (water weight I'm sure). then I started tracking my calories... and continued to lose... (just slower)... until I hit a 3 week plateau. After the 3 weeks I spent one week NOT counting... and dropped 3 lbs that week. So now I haven't been counting calories or logging food. and have been losing about 1 lb a week (except last week and this week... but thats my eating choices im sure..) I've been thinking about starting to log again... but I'm wondering if I wasn't eating enough calories. MFP has me set at 1410. When I calculate my BMR on other sites... it says its around 2000-2200. So if I took the 500 calories out... that would put me at 1500-1700.


Questions... Comments... Concerns... lol

HELP!

Replies

  • TrainingWithTonya
    TrainingWithTonya Posts: 1,741 Member
    Honestly, any of the calculators you find online (MFP included) are only estimates. I could do a work up for you with the formulas I've been taught in my nutrition classes and see if I get a number closer to what you are consuming when you are not logging here. It's what I used for myself when I set up my MFP numbers. It actually gives me a higher calorie need, too, so you may be like me in that you do need more calories then the MFP calculations give you.
  • erinsolesky
    erinsolesky Posts: 20 Member
    I am a firm believer in logging calories. I have been logging for quite some time now and have lost a considerable amount of weight. I think that once you stop logging, you have more of a chance to slowly slide into bad habits. There have been so many times where I think I am making a good food choice, log it in later, and realize that it was not low-cal AT ALL. I think that if your base calorie goal seems too low, increase by 100-200 calories OR you can always go to they gym and exercise to make up for the calories. That has been such a help for me ... knowing that if I burn 600 calories exercising, I can eat it later. In all reality, if you have a base calorie goal of 1410, you then burn 600, that gives you over 2000 calories to eat. That is quite a considerable amount of food. As far as not eating enough food, that is also why I say to LOG your calories! You have to EAT!!

    I hope that helps and I also hope that you will continue to log your foods, exercise, and live a healthy lifestyle!
  • kasmir8199
    kasmir8199 Posts: 507 Member
    ok. when I first started... before mfp... I wasn't counting calories... I was just eating much better and exercising at least 5 days a week (cardio mainly).... and I lost steadily for a few weeks (water weight I'm sure). then I started tracking my calories... and continued to lose... (just slower)... until I hit a 3 week plateau. After the 3 weeks I spent one week NOT counting... and dropped 3 lbs that week. So now I haven't been counting calories or logging food. and have been losing about 1 lb a week (except last week and this week... but thats my eating choices im sure..) I've been thinking about starting to log again... but I'm wondering if I wasn't eating enough calories. MFP has me set at 1410. When I calculate my BMR on other sites... it says its around 2000-2200. So if I took the 500 calories out... that would put me at 1500-1700.


    Questions... Comments... Concerns... lol

    HELP!

    Great questions!!

    I have learned, from logging consistently, that I'm eating better quality foods now and getting more out of my calorie intake. So on the days that I don't log, I still have a feel of whether I'm in that target area.

    I do, however, think I'm under-eating. Actually, I know I'm under-eating. According to my BOD-POD measurements, I'm supposed to consume at least 1710 cals a day and I've been way below that (1300-1500). The scale hasn't moved in 2 weeks, but I'm still losing inches and getting more toned (from strength training).

    I think I'm going to aim to eat more. Weird how that's so hard to do now (with healthier foods) than it was when I ate poorly.
  • amcmillan730
    amcmillan730 Posts: 591 Member
    Honestly, any of the calculators you find online (MFP included) are only estimates. I could do a work up for you with the formulas I've been taught in my nutrition classes and see if I get a number closer to what you are consuming when you are not logging here. It's what I used for myself when I set up my MFP numbers. It actually gives me a higher calorie need, too, so you may be like me in that you do need more calories then the MFP calculations give you.

    That'd be great!! I found one site that had some formulas... and I came up with about 2100 cal I believe.
  • TrainingWithTonya
    TrainingWithTonya Posts: 1,741 Member
    Honestly, any of the calculators you find online (MFP included) are only estimates. I could do a work up for you with the formulas I've been taught in my nutrition classes and see if I get a number closer to what you are consuming when you are not logging here. It's what I used for myself when I set up my MFP numbers. It actually gives me a higher calorie need, too, so you may be like me in that you do need more calories then the MFP calculations give you.

    That'd be great!! I found one site that had some formulas... and I came up with about 2100 cal I believe.

    PM me with the following and I'll do the math.

    Age
    Height
    Weight
    Body Fat % (This is not BMI. If you don't know your body fat percentage, I can figure an estimate with the other information and your waist and hip measurements)
    Activity level not counting exercise (Scale of 1-5 with one being never getting off the couch and 5 being never sitting down)
    Normal calorie burn from exercise if you know it, or just a list of what you do for exercise, how intense you go (scale of 1-10 with one being laying on your couch and 10 being running a marathon), and how long you go.
This discussion has been closed.

Categories