Skip to content
  • Register
    • We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

    Shoes for multiple activities + overweight

    Posts: 34
    edited February 12 in Fitness and Exercise
    Hi all! I've been using the same nikes for years and thinking that some of the pain when walking and workout out may be due to poor support. Before I buy new shoes though, should I be looking for running shoes, walking shoes, or cross trainers?
    Activities include Zumba, elliptical running, treadmill walking, and strength training. Ill do a mix within the same workout so I'd prefer not to have multiple shoes to switch in and out of, plus am 75+ lbs overweight. Thank you for any tips or advice!

    Welcome!

    It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.
    Sign In
    Register

    Replies

    • Posts: 65 Member
      As a former tennis player, all I have ever had is tennis shoes. When I started trying to get fit & lose weight, I ordered these..http://www.ryka.com/en-US/Product/82974-5180404/Ryka/Black_Plum_Coral/Womens+Exertion.aspx. Never have I had a more comfortable shoe in my life. Support & comfort. And I am also about 75 lbs overweight.
    • Posts: 184 Member
      When I was having issues with walking shoes I switched to running at the advice of a random stranger at the shoe store who suggested they would absorb shock better when walking on hard pavement. I asked him because he looked more knowledgeable and experienced than the teenage clerk and I find they are great.

      For hiking I like more grip on the terrain/ a trail runner or higher hiking shoe depending in the trail, rocks, etc.

      Zumba steps might necessitate a different type of shoe for those steps and may be more critical than walking as you say you will be doing multiple activities at one time.
    • Posts: 804 Member
      go to a proper running store - one that will do gait analysis, for example, and even better if they can do a foot scan- and tell them what you want your shoes for- every foot is different- I have flatter feet with "stability issues" for example - and BROOKS have a lot of options for me (Brooks Ariel to be specific) Aasics also have a few options- but every foot/ body is different- you need to know what works for you.- and as you and others mentioned you might need different shoes depending upon the activity
    • Posts: 34
      Thanks guys! It sounds like cross trainers might be a good option for me to start with. I will look for a specific athletic show store but the town I'm jn now is pretty limited!

      Thanks again for your advice!
    • Posts: 93 Member
      if ordering shoes online make sure you check that they will ship to your area. I live in Canada and can't order from Ryka. and had ordering problems from puma with my prepaid credit card. good luck!
    • Posts: 37 Member
      You can order Zumba shoes from their website, or just find shoes that have a low tread bottom/slick bottoms and a pivot point. You do lots of twisting and moving in Zumba so your shoes need to not grip too much. I have separate shoes for Zumba and then a pair for everything else.
    • Posts: 308 Member
      Thanks guys! It sounds like cross trainers might be a good option for me to start with. I will look for a specific athletic show store but the town I'm jn now is pretty limited!

      Thanks again for your advice!

      Shoe brands are like status cars.. it's unlike that 200$ pair of nikes is going to be any better than a 40$ pair of asics, if they are the right fit and style for your foot and what you are doing.

      Now, my wife runs, and runs about 20 miles a week.. what brand she gets is important to her, simply because for her style of running, they don't wear out as fast.

      As said above, go to a good running store (NOT footlocker.. they sell basketball shoes), and have a gait analysis, and get properly fitted for shoes.

      Many of us cram out feet into shoes that are too small, and often too narrow, which can lead to odd gaits and foot issues, which can hinder, rather than help, attempts to get into better shape.
    • Posts: 34
      show previous quotes

      Shoe brands are like status cars.. it's unlike that 200$ pair of nikes is going to be any better than a 40$ pair of asics, if they are the right fit and style for your foot and what you are doing.

      Now, my wife runs, and runs about 20 miles a week.. what brand she gets is important to her, simply because for her style of running, they don't wear out as fast.

      As said above, go to a good running store (NOT footlocker.. they sell basketball shoes), and have a gait analysis, and get properly fitted for shoes.

      Many of us cram out feet into shoes that are too small, and often too narrow, which can lead to odd gaits and foot issues, which can hinder, rather than help, attempts to get into better shape.

      I like that you mention the inflated price. All the lists I have read for "best shoes" are full of 150+ shoes and while I'm sure there is some merit there, it's out of my budget by a lot and I'm not sure they are worth it for my needs. Perhaps one day I will need something that nice but for now I just want a good solid shoe that works in a variety of activities.
    • Posts: 184 Member
      If you go to a store and they insist you need the pricier shoe, step back and read some reviews online and see if others used the model shoes in the same way and were satisfied.
    • Posts: 53
      Here is my experience, best shoes I ever had for walking..Nike Shox I found them very helpful for my back issues as well, couldnt get my size the last time I needed a new pair, so bought Asics, they are nowhere near as good, and they werent cheap! I had a foot specialist tell me once that womens athletic shoes are not made for overweight women, and dont hold up well when you are overweight. She said mens are designed to take a higher weight limit. Interesting eh??!! Thats my 2 cents for what its worth.
    • Posts: 1,946 Member
      Vibram Five Fingers!
    • Posts: 138 Member
      Hi all! I've been using the same nikes for years and thinking that some of the pain when walking and workout out may be due to poor support. Before I buy new shoes though, should I be looking for running shoes, walking shoes, or cross trainers?
      Activities include Zumba, elliptical running, treadmill walking, and strength training. Ill do a mix within the same workout so I'd prefer not to have multiple shoes to switch in and out of, plus am 75+ lbs overweight. Thank you for any tips or advice!

      If you're serious about each one then I'd get a running shoe ( get fitted ) for running and walking, a cross trainer for zumba and just chucks for strength training.

      If you are just going to buy 1 shoe, I'd go with a cross trainer
    • Posts: 895 Member
      Go to a running store and try on shoes until your feet say to you, "These feel so good I want to get out and walk, right now!!!"

      Twice I have had shoes that felt that way, my last pair of cross-country ski boots, and my current pair of running shoes. (Brooks Ghosts - men's narrow). Yep, I have to wear men's shoes because there is not much on offer in women's size 13!
    • Posts: 80 Member
      I get all my gym shoes from a place called "The walking store ' . The most important thing is proper fit, so I don't recommend buying them online. Every shoe fits different. Many years ago my doctor told me the 2 things to spend money on were mattresses and shoes. Cut back on clothes, but protect your feet, when you get older you will thank me.
    This discussion has been closed.

    Welcome!

    It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.
    Sign In
    Register

    Quick Links

    Categories