Friends who wants to compare...drive me nuts!

Hi all!

My friend A and I used to be basically the same weight and height (though slightly different body types) and we joked about that all the time. Since October I've lost about 12 pounds and went down 1-2 pant sizes. I haven't seen A at all since October, until earlier this month, during which time I noticed she has gained probably as much weight as I have lost, and she noticed my weight loss.

Since that visit, A keeps making passing comments about how we are the same size and all that, or tells me about how small she is, or that she hasn't gained weight (unprompted-- I never said anything) or subtly compares our bodies and deem them equal. It drives me nuts.

A and I both are self-conscious with our bodies, so I understand why she would do this. It probably makes her extra self-conscious to see my progress. That said, her comparisons really bothers me.

Anyone has similar experiences? Or have ideas on how to deal with this kind of comments? I really don't know how to respond without being mean!

Replies

  • abadvat
    abadvat Posts: 1,241 Member
    "Friends who wants to compare...drive me nuts!"
    You do realise that you have been comparing from the begining of the thread till the end of it?!
  • tiptoethruthetulips
    tiptoethruthetulips Posts: 3,372 Member
    You don't have to respond, just ignore and change the subject every time she starts doing it.

    That said you probably do not see her all that often...so does it really matter? Let her have her insecurities.
  • JesterMFP
    JesterMFP Posts: 3,596 Member
    Is she a close friend? Talk to her. Tell her it makes you feel uncomfortable when she makes those kinds of comments.
  • IrishGabriella
    IrishGabriella Posts: 48 Member
    Just ignore her.
  • Seabee74
    Seabee74 Posts: 314
    Reminds me of .....
    Sticks and stones will break my bones but names will never hurt me !!!
    Or some other 5th grade thing ??
    Sheeeeeesh.....
    Let it Go !!!!
  • Babarrosa1
    Babarrosa1 Posts: 98 Member
    Hi all!

    My friend A and I used to be basically the same weight and height (though slightly different body types) and we joked about that all the time. Since October I've lost about 12 pounds and went down 1-2 pant sizes. I haven't seen A at all since October, until earlier this month, during which time I noticed she has gained probably as much weight as I have lost, and she noticed my weight loss.

    Since that visit, A keeps making passing comments about how we are the same size and all that, or tells me about how small she is, or that she hasn't gained weight (unprompted-- I never said anything) or subtly compares our bodies and deem them equal. It drives me nuts.

    A and I both are self-conscious with our bodies, so I understand why she would do this. It probably makes her extra self-conscious to see my progress. That said, her comparisons really bothers me.

    Anyone has similar experiences? Or have ideas on how to deal with this kind of comments? I really don't know how to respond without being mean!

    I actually had a friend like this. We both joined the gym and started losing weight together. The difference was that I didn't count calories and mainly focused on eating clean and and she restricted calories everywhere she could, and that she focused on cardio while I lifted and did cardio. We both saw results, and eventually she hit a plateau that she couldn't break through and more or less started copying everything I was doing, except for the eating. I had no issue she was my best friend.

    Anyways, the way she was eating came back to haunt her, she couldn't sustain it. I lost around 30lbs, and she lost only about 15 in the same amount of time. She would start making sly digs about my body (even though I lost the weight I was still self conscious) it started with small comments like 'oh your arms need a bit more work' and 'oh your hips are still womanly, i loooove curves like that'. Eventually they got nastier and nastier, until my own best friend literally over the course of weeks turned into my biggest bully ever about my weight.

    Quite obviously we don't really talk anymore which is kind of hurtful. I do my best to stay in touch with her but there was a while where I didn't see her and when I did that cemented the end of our friendship. I had lost a total of around 50lbs, was feeling great and she had gained back all the weight she had lost and some more. She ended up larger than what she had started off at.

    My advice to you would be, if she's not saying anything nasty or demoralizing to you, just leave it. She'll deal with it by herself. Or even, invite her to work out with you, because clearly she's feeling self conscious. But if it does get to that stage, talk to her and don't pretend like nothing is wrong like I did.

    PM me if you wanna talk more! :)
  • neanderthin
    neanderthin Posts: 10,266 Member
    Ask her to try on your new cloths.
  • Mr_Knight
    Mr_Knight Posts: 9,532 Member
    That said, her comparisons really bothers me.

    But...your entire OP is a comparison with her body....?
  • Wtn_Gurl
    Wtn_Gurl Posts: 396 Member
    You probably should be telling her the things your telling us, as she needs to know it bothers you.
  • LexiMelo
    LexiMelo Posts: 203 Member
    Ask her to try on your new cloths.

    LOL! That would be so mean! :laugh:

    It's always awkward when your friend gains weight. I have a friend kind of like this who eats paleo and therefore "doesn't need to count calories". But I'm not going to get into a debate about it with her because we've both made up our minds about how we want to eat and aren't going to convince each other. I just let the results speak for themselves and avoid any comments.

    Your friend doesn't sound like she is being mean, just defensive. It sounds like you don't want to be compared to her. My best friend and I have yo-yo'd where sometimes I'm the thin one, sometimes she is…it would behoove you to be kind and supportive to her in case the tables are turned someday. :flowerforyou: