Can I split up the calories earned from exercise?
sharahart2
Posts: 6
Hello, I am totally new to this so forgive me if a silly question....
I ran for 45 minutes today -- earning about 600 calories. Can I use 300 of the calories to eat back today and save the other 300 calories to eat tomorrow? (since I won't be able to exercise tomorrow, it would be nice to have the extra 300 ).
Or do I have to use the calories burned all in the same day?
Thank you for your help!
I ran for 45 minutes today -- earning about 600 calories. Can I use 300 of the calories to eat back today and save the other 300 calories to eat tomorrow? (since I won't be able to exercise tomorrow, it would be nice to have the extra 300 ).
Or do I have to use the calories burned all in the same day?
Thank you for your help!
0
Replies
-
Many people on here prefer to look at a weekly average. You can see how you're doing for the week on the reports. So yes, you can bank them for tomorrow, although I would recommend recording them all today.0
-
If you start making a calorie bank your going to have a hard time keeping track.
Full disclosure, on my long runs sometimes I burn over 2100 calories and I will count those over the next few days.0 -
I go over some days and am under on others, I look at how it averages over the week. Hasn't done me any harm yet :-)0
-
How many miles did you run? 600 sounds high0
-
Don't split up your exercise calories. Think of the children!0
-
I tend to look at my weekly average. I find it hard to eat 300-500 calories less on days I don't workout, so I like to split it up.0
-
How many miles did you run? 600 sounds high
600 sounds entirely unrealistic. Probably more like 300.0 -
In for weekly averages.
That is, yeah go ahead.
ETA: How did you measure your calorie burn? MFP tends to estimate burns on the very high side.0 -
How many miles did you run? 600 sounds high
600 sounds entirely unrealistic. Probably more like 300.
echoing this...
OP, you should always do some kind of reasonableness test on your burn. 600 calories for 45 minutes is huge. When you're eating back exercise calories you want to be conservative...you want to make sure you are giving yourself enough fuel, but at the same time you don't want to overestimate. When I was doing this method I never logged more than 10 calories per minute for any activity...and 10 calories per minute was for a workout for which I could not hold a conversation.
With things like running and walking, 100 calories per mile is also a pretty conservative approach. Don't just take the database as gospel here.0 -
Try the TDEE method. Your activity is averaged across the week, giving you the same calorie goal every day.0
-
Couple of ways of looking at this.
First, for a big workout (1000+ range), you want to eat back around half your calories unless you want to be a walking zombie the next day -- you just can't expect most bodies to be able to pull that number of calories out of your internal stores in that short of time.
For smaller workouts, I'm not sure why you'd want to eat back more than a small percentange, unless you're way more accurate about measuring your food portions and exercise calories than most folks. In my book, a 300 calorie workout is my buffer against sloppy food measurement.
That in-between range (roughly 300 to 1000) depends on the person -- a smaller person is going to have less internal short-term reserves than a big guy like myself. I'm sure I could easily burn 600, not eat it back, and not feel it the next day (OTOH, I tried to do that once with a 1200+ burn...didn't work out so well the next day).
Gotta agree about the folks crying "foul" on the 600 calorie 45 minute run...doggone difficult to to go over 10 calories / minute.0 -
How many miles did you run? 600 sounds high
600 sounds entirely unrealistic. Probably more like 300.
I run with a heart rate monitor and a Garmin watch, which gave me the calorie burn -- ran 4.68 miles at an avg pace of 9:37/mile. I also weigh 175 so no, 600 calories is not ludicrous.
I only want to split the calories between two days. Thank you for those who replied to my question without having to question my calories burned0 -
Yep. As others have said you can save them for the week. I exercise all week and save up around 900-1500 calories. Then on the weekend I let myself go over but track how much and make sure not to go over what I earned. It keeps this process from driving me insane because I get 1-2 days on the weekend that I can eat things I normally don't have the calories to eat (like pasta. I Pasta).
Forgot to add that I "reset" on monday morning. If I didn't eat my calories back by then, I don't get to. It is always better to be a little under than a little over on calories consumed.0 -
I've been a runner for 20+ years and that pace and distance will definitely get you a big burn. Good job!
I personally don't split my calories and instead eat them the same day. I find that gives me more motivation to exercise daily. But if it helps you, then definitely split it up as you'd like.0 -
How many miles did you run? 600 sounds high
600 sounds entirely unrealistic. Probably more like 300.
I run with a heart rate monitor and a Garmin watch, which gave me the calorie burn -- ran 4.68 miles at an avg pace of 9:37/mile. I also weigh 175 so no, 600 calories is not ludicrous.
I only want to split the calories between two days. Thank you for those who replied to my question without having to question my calories burned
If you find you aren't losing weight, and it doesn't make sense per your journal, then worry about the calories.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions