Why get a personal trainer?
slepygrl
Posts: 249 Member
Hey Everyone!
I wanted some input. I'm thinking about hiring a personal trainer. I'm just not sure why I would need one??
Here's my story.
About 2 years ago I went balls to the wall nuts fitness wise. I was motivated, and VERY focused. I ran, weight trained, ate right. Lost 60 lbs. GO ME!!
Then about 6 months ago, it all ended. I just couldn't do it anymore. I was tired. I felt like I was working so hard but not getting any results. I was still fat (171 at my lowest) I felt stuck. Then I found 20 of the 60 lbs I lost.
I want to get to healthy place. I do enjoy working out. I would like to get down to about 140 and stay there.
Thoughts? Suggestions?
Thanks!
I wanted some input. I'm thinking about hiring a personal trainer. I'm just not sure why I would need one??
Here's my story.
About 2 years ago I went balls to the wall nuts fitness wise. I was motivated, and VERY focused. I ran, weight trained, ate right. Lost 60 lbs. GO ME!!
Then about 6 months ago, it all ended. I just couldn't do it anymore. I was tired. I felt like I was working so hard but not getting any results. I was still fat (171 at my lowest) I felt stuck. Then I found 20 of the 60 lbs I lost.
I want to get to healthy place. I do enjoy working out. I would like to get down to about 140 and stay there.
Thoughts? Suggestions?
Thanks!
0
Replies
-
If a personal trainer will help you get and stay motivated to get and remain healthy, I would say that was a good investment. We spend/waste our money on worse things.0
-
Based on your post I think you could benefit from one. If you were going balls to the wall and not getting the results you wanted you may not have been training for your goals or eating for them. A trainer is also good to help you learn proper form so you do the exercises correctly for the intended results. So many people doing bad form don't realize they are getting bad results or injury for that very reason. Even if you hire one for 2-3 months it is beneficial.
But it's up to you and your goals. If motivation is a factor then of course having someone who keeps you accountable is a nice added bonus.
best of luck0 -
i think they are a waste of money.0
-
I'm considering having a personal trainer help me with my form.0
-
I use a trainer twice a week. Best thing I have done. He pushes me really hard through my workout routine. If you workout without a trainer I find you don't push yourself as hard. I hope this helps. Good Luck!0
-
i think they are a waste of money.
Agreed.0 -
Hey Everyone!
I wanted some input. I'm thinking about hiring a personal trainer. I'm just not sure why I would need one??
Don't get one until you know why you need one.0 -
Trainers are like everything, there are good ones and "not so good ones". Makes sure you find a trainer who is not going to cookie cutter a work-out for you. You want one who has experience with people who have reached the same goals that you have. Make sure he or she listens to what you want. I actually have two different trainers, one for lifting and one who is more focused on functional/medibolic exercise.
I find that I train MUCH harder with them pusing than when I did it alone. They also work with me on nutrition as well. I am SO GLAD, I hired them. It has been a great experience and while it has been a long road getting to my goals, I know they are in it for the long run.
If you just accept the first trainer you find, it might not be the right fit.0 -
i think they are a waste of money.
For me, they are well woth the money, however, I was not able to do it by myself and needed thier additional knowledge and experience, If you can get to your goals with what you are doing, that is great and you do not need them. However, if you can't or are stuck, then you may need to hire one.0 -
It's always an ongoing quest to find motivation.
For some people, having a weekly appointment with a PT is motivation. You've paid, so you're not going to miss the appoinment. Then the PT gives you feedback on technique, teaches you some new stuff, helps you clarify your goals - all helps with motivation. And then they give you homework; you surely don't want to come in next week and tell him/her that you haven't been back to the gym since last week. So yes, it can make a difference. If you think this sounds like it would motivate you, it would likely be worth your while.
As an alternative that is similar, and has some of the same advantages, I have found great motivation and enjoyment being in my multisports group. There are coaches who know what we are up to and what our goals are, can help with planning and technique, so you get some of the same PT advantages. But we also have the group dynamic, we go to run events, swim meets, triathlons, etc., together.
But overall my message is Connection is Huge.
If you can connect with a PT one-on-one, that is good. If you can connect with a group, in my opinion that is even better.0 -
I see my PT three times a week and have benefited wholey, he helps drive me, pushes me, and makes sure my form is proper.
To anyone who thinks they are a waste of money, congrats on being able to motivate, push and exercise properly on your own.
Not of all us have that, I for one will keep my PT, and he can have some of my money!0 -
Hey Everyone!
I wanted some input. I'm thinking about hiring a personal trainer. I'm just not sure why I would need one??
Don't get one until you know why you need one.
That would be the point of this post....0 -
It depends entirely on what your needs are (that you cannot meet yourself) and whether or not that specific trainer can fill those needs.
Saying that all trainers are useless is about as silly as saying that everyone needs a trainer.0 -
You've already said,
for motivation and results.0 -
Personally, I think you would benefit more from a workout partner. Are you friendly with anyone in your gym? Is there someone there who looks amazing that might want a partner too?
I have spent lots of money on personal trainers but I was motivated the most when I had a workout partner. My first husband pushed me very hard. I hated him for it but I was in the best shape of my life. Between marriages, I worked out with a friend of mine who was in phenomenal shape. Again, I had TONS of motivation. I also liked having someone waiting on me at the gym that I wasn't paying.
My husband now is the type that is naturally gifted with regard to physique. He doesn't have to work out and mostly doesn't. For a time, we went to the gym together, and again, I found that motivation.
Just some food for thought.0 -
I haven't used a PT but I think it's a great idea. They'll be able to help you design a workout routine and nutrition plan to help you meet your personal goals. I also like the idea of a workout partner. Workout partner will obviously be cheaper than the PT, but the PT will be able to improve your form, etc.0
-
I've just been researching PT at my gym as I'm thinking I would like to get the help of one.
For me, the primary reason is I would like to lift weights and feel I want help with good technique.
Secondary I feel a little lost in the gym, I run, row, cycle, play with dumbells but I don't follow a work-out or really know what I should be doing to maximize my time there. I personally feel like I need more structure and will see better results with the help of an expert.0 -
I use one for motivation. If it helps you - go for it! You can always try it for a while and then change if you don't like it.0
-
If I ever got one it would be to help me with form on my lifting that's it...but I don't need one for that...I just put them on youtube...and have knowledgable folks here take a look for me.
Personal trainers can be good but exp.
If you want one to stay motivated try paying yourself...put the money you would spend on a PT in a jar.
Start over again with a reasonable deficet, weighing your food and getting back into exercise.
Then after 6months buy yourself something for sticking with it.0 -
So you can achieve with them what you cannot seem to do alone. That would be the main reason.
A.C.E. Certified Personal/Group FitnessTrainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition0 -
So you can achieve with them what you cannot seem to do alone. That would be the main reason.
A.C.E. Certified Personal/Group FitnessTrainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
ultimately this.
the reason could be related to any or all of the following or others
> motivation
> accountability
> team work (2-3 people together)
> someone pushing you
> someone giving you a reason to be better through the week
> giving you different work outs than your old tired routine
> giving you feed back on form
> teaching you new lifts
>coaching you through a training program
if you can do it on your own- great- do it on your own. but if you are struggling -find someone who will help you achieve your goals.
Trainers aren't for everyone- but knowing the amount of crap and fantastic 'form'/exercising at the gym- more people than not could use a solid coach.0 -
Ask the trainer for a "fitness consultation"
Tell them what you have done, and what you are trying to do and what exercises you like or might be interested in and what your goals are. They should be ablet o come up with a different workout for you, that you will enjoy and will be different.
Fitness consultations should be free of charge.
I just did this and the trainer introduced me to plyometrics and agility drills. I love it!Secondary I feel a little lost in the gym,
I wish I could afford a trainer, but I can't. i have to rely on fitness consultations and free appointments and free seminars and offers to get them. I also pick their brains as often as I can get away with.0 -
I work with a trainer once a week to work on glutes. That's where I need the most work, and I know I won't push myself as hard as I could be on glute day, so I hire her for the extra push.
My *kitten* hurts all week until the day before we meet again, so I don't consider it a waste of money at all.0 -
My gym offers a fitness consultation with a trainer every 6 weeks to review your goals and then to develop a workout plan for you as well as a quarterly appointment for measurements.
This is a really nice thing to have but I really like having a trainer. For one thing I have paid weekly for my trainer so that ensures that I am working hard to have more to give and learn in my sessions. The other advantage is new training ideas and someone to push me a bit harder. She gives me workouts I can do during the week on my own and they change as my fitness level and goals do.
I would reccomend trying it for a month to see if that does motivate you anymore and if you are learning from it. A month isn't a ton of money (at least at my gym) and gives you a good idea of how well you work with personal training and if it is right for you.0 -
bump... I'm thinking about it also. I need feedback and tips on my form. I don't need motivation to go to the gym but motivation/confidence to put more weight on the bar and maybe new ideas on helping me reach my goals though other types of exercise and nutrition would be a plus.0
-
[/quote] the reason could be related to any or all of the following or others
> motivation
> accountability
> team work (2-3 people together)
> someone pushing you
> someone giving you a reason to be better through the week
> giving you different work outs than your old tired routine
> giving you feed back on form
> teaching you new lifts
>coaching you through a training program
if you can do it on your own- great- do it on your own. but if you are struggling -find someone who will help you achieve your goals.
Trainers aren't for everyone- but knowing the amount of crap and fantastic 'form'/exercising at the gym- more people than not could use a solid coach.
[/quote]
^^Well said.
Most gyms will give you one personal training session for free. I used this one to have them check my form on exercises I wasn't sure I was doing correctly. Most times, like at 24 where I work out, the trainers are happy to help if you say "hey will you critique my form real quick on this deadlift?" and they'll give you a minute.
I use workouts from bodybulding.com- they are free and they have 100s of them to choose from according to your goals. For me, this takes care of needing to have someone build a workout for me. I read a book called Burn the Fat, Feed the Muscle by Tom Venuto, which gives diet and exercise advice. MFP helps you get a baseline for where your calories should be (you need to move it up or down from there according to the results you are getting).
I motivate myself and keep myself accountable. I have written out SMART goals, and I keep them in front of me. I give working out the importance of showering (sometimes if I'm too tired, I'll just take a quick one, but won't skip for too long). I have found various workout buddies, and I have friends on here who will call me out if I haven't worked out for a while.
All that to say, you have to decide if hiring a trainer will be worth it to you. Don't put up with them spinning your wheels though (the mistake I made years ago when I had trainers). Make sure you are assertive and let them know what you feel is helpful or not helpful. Give them your measurable goals and milestones, and decide if their help is giving you enough of a boost to get there.
All the best! :flowerforyou:0 -
You said one comment that I relate a little to me and why I was told I needed to work with a trainer. I had a history of training hard and seriously and I had been out for long enough that there were issues I would go too fast ad hard and get injured. I must agree my trainer did have to tell me no more than once at the beginning and keep me at a slower pace than I was comfortable with. He also was able to work with me on making sure I used opposite muscle groups and kept it balanced. I didn't have to pay as much since he was just informing me what to do and changing when needed as we got to know each other. But he was keeping his eye on me and did even then kick me out at times. I could not have gotten where I am withut him without injuries.
But with this said there are good ones and bad ones and he is good and charged only for sessions that we spent more than 15 min together but monitored weekly. Knowing where you are coming from what your goals are and if it matches with their knowledge and background and philosophy is important. Interview them ask them questions It should be personal level not gereric0 -
I have been working with a trainer for the last 6 months. I'm the type of person that if I take a class or try to work out with a dvd at home I injure myself. My trainer makes sure that all exercises are done properly. She also makes it fun, every work out is different. We maybe working the same muscles but using different tools and techniques. She is totally worth it! I have never really liked to exercise. Ok I'll admit it just the thought of exercising was horrible. I now love to go to the gym. She pushes me to do more than I think I can do and is always encouraging when I have an off day. Most gyms will give you a free tryout session or at a reduced cost for the 1st time. Give it a try you won't regret it!
0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions