Pre-logging entire food day vs log at end of day?

24

Replies

  • CaitlinW19
    CaitlinW19 Posts: 431 Member
    Personally, I do most of my logging in advance and find it works well for me. The main reason is though, then I know how many calories I have left for snacks, etc. where I can have a little more flexibility. Logging ahead helps me stick to a plan and use food in my fridge, instead of it going to waste. I pretty much know what I'll have for breakfast, lunch and dinner ahead of time, so really snacks are my wild card and then I can choose them around 1) what I feel like and 2) what fits into my day.
  • lamps1303
    lamps1303 Posts: 432 Member
    I always pre-log my days wherever possible. Keeps me on track.
  • Hikr56
    Hikr56 Posts: 128 Member
    Pre-logging really works for me. I especially like to log things like my coffee. With the added cream, it's 44 calories for my "mega mug". I have three a day so that adds up! I log all three of those first thing in the morning. Then I pre-log any little snacks that I'm going to have, ie., I know I'm eating a truffle later, so that goes on the list. Then I log the rest of my meals accordingly. I find that even if I have to adjust some things later on, it really helps me to stay within my daily calorie goal and macros. It also helps me to see it in black and white because I can see if I need to eliminate some foods that are too high in fat/sodium/protein, with more healthy choices like vegetables.
  • twowheeltam
    twowheeltam Posts: 13 Member
    I log it as I go, I'm really good about planning my meals for breakfast and lunch, but not usually dinner. If I really need to add an extra snack into my day, it doesn't throw off my whole meal plan for the evening. I adjust "on the fly" and may switch out my protein and do a vegetarian dinner, something like that.
  • Travelbug1955
    Travelbug1955 Posts: 61 Member
    I log everything as I do it. If I don't, I will forget some things and logging won't be accurate.
  • KKishaA
    KKishaA Posts: 160 Member
    Wowzers lots of responses so I won't quote each and every one of you but it does sound like pre-logging is the majority winner. I agree that it is different for everyone but in my case I can relate to the people that have been benefited by taking some of the energy out of having to decide what to eat in the moment (when you are more likely to say F-it!) by having everything preplanned. I tend to do the best on work days, and I think that is because for work days I plan ahead more! Duh! I bring what I am eating with me and that is it. Once I am home I go by how I am "feeling" and I'll be honest with you, I often feel like Cool Whip, which any of you can see if you look in my diary! I am still working out the details of what keeps me satisfied the longest in terms of protein/fat/carbs, but I have a feeling doing everything ahead of time is going to help out with that. Not to mention my grocery bill! I JUST made the comment to my boyfriend that we needed to have more organization in our shopping because I end up at the grocery store every day picking up odds and ends for what ever it is we feel like having for dinner that night but at the same time food we don't use because we didn't plan on it goes bad and we throw it out.....sorry little off topic there......
  • LolBroScience
    LolBroScience Posts: 4,537 Member
    I pre-log, but leave some wiggle room for adjustments.
  • mediamogulsteve
    mediamogulsteve Posts: 115 Member
    I pre-log as much as I can, which helps me determine how much I can have of "un-planned" foods. For instance, I know my breakfast, morning snack, dinner and dessert calories for today. Which allows me roughly 600 calories for lunch - which I'll need since I'm meeting my dad at a restaurant. So, I guess it's hybrid technique.
  • amyfullbrook
    amyfullbrook Posts: 97 Member
    For me I like to pre-log so I can see exactly how many calories I have left during the day if I fancy something. :) and it's easier to stick to the healthy options for me if I know I have them already logged in.
  • It's all about what will make you feel the safest and most accountable. I personally feel most reliable with pre-logging. I put in my breakfast and lunch first thing in the morning, and then when we are deciding what to do for dinner, I can see what calories I have left and I can choose accordingly. It keeps my hunger in check all day and gives me the satisfaction of having followed through with my plan on the day to day.
  • dlbredesen
    dlbredesen Posts: 122 Member
    I always pre-log on the days that I work. I usually log as I go on my days off with my goals in mind.
  • Amandawith3kids
    Amandawith3kids Posts: 367 Member
    i log before each meal, but not the whole day. the only thing i dont pre-log is snacks, because they are typically under 100 cals. i dont long the whole day because my schedule changes too much, and with 3 kids, i never REALLY know what is going to happen LOL. i've had too many surprise trips to the emergency room and missed meals and/or ate something different to log too far out. so i usually log while i'm cooking.
  • jillyrobb
    jillyrobb Posts: 36 Member
    I pre-log whatever my big meal is likely to be for that day, then adjust the rest of the day around that and whatever exercise I manage to squeeze in. Usually it's dinner, because I generally plan family dinners and shop for the week in advance, so I pre-log those each morning when I add my breakfast. Or if I know I'll be going out for lunch, I look up menus and do a rough log of what I intend to eat, then make sure there are salad ingredients in the fridge for dinner.

    If I don't pre-log, I inevitably find myself overdoing it at breakfast/lunch, so I get stuck eating a smaller dinner with no room for my evening glass of wine and handful of nuts or square of dark chocolate--and those are crucial to my sanity! I know full well that I'm an evening snacker, and any routine that forbids that would be unsustainable for me. With pre-logging, I'm always careful to leave about 250-300 calories for the end of the day, and I don't feel deprived at all.

    However, I do think it's a good idea to post-log for a few weeks when you first start MFP, just to see what your normal patterns are, where you're typically overdoing it, and where you can make adjustments to accommodate whatever is important to you--whether it's a big breakfast, lunch with the office gang, or your evening beverage.
  • ItsCasey
    ItsCasey Posts: 4,021 Member
    I usually pre-log my days, but I don't always stick to exactly what I logged. Sometimes the foods are the same, but the amounts change. Sometimes I'll eat something right before I lift and end up having to alter my dinner plans. In the beginning, it was helpful for me to stick to exactly what I logged because I mostly just cared about calories back then. Now that I have macro goals and follow IIFYM, I've gotten pretty good at adjusting things on the fly, so I don't feel bound to what I planned out first thing that morning.
  • deliacm
    deliacm Posts: 66 Member
    I always pre-log my family's dinner, then figure out my breakfast and lunch based on my remaining calories. Pre-logging also let's you make decisions on guilty pleasures through the day. It let's me decide whether I can have that 190 calorie candy bar and still eat dinner. ????
  • Pirate_chick
    Pirate_chick Posts: 1,216 Member
    As long as you're logging you're doing it right. Mon-Fri I tend to pre-log in the morning. On the weekends I log as I go.
  • amymb3469
    amymb3469 Posts: 22 Member
    Personally, I prelog, it helps keep me accountable.
  • Apple31415
    Apple31415 Posts: 98 Member
    Everyone is different for sure. I'm going to feel restricted if i pre-log. I'm fairly new but I see that it is a learning process. I'm getting better and better at making good choices on the fly having gotten a "feel" from logging in the last 5 weeks after each meal. I'm learning what a portion is and how food choices affect my macros. I like remaining flexible and choosing as the day goes and am happy with what i'm learning along the way! This is such a personal preference and probably should be a trial and error thing....For me, it would be a chore to pre-log and plan out meals in advance.
  • what is your macro %?
  • Broderick50
    Broderick50 Posts: 842 Member
    I try and prelog mine. That doesn't mean that I stick to it to the tee but when I go off of it I change and update it. I find that if I don't prelog then I have awful eating days. But like most said its what works for you.
  • beccyleigh
    beccyleigh Posts: 846 Member
    I log what I plan to eat that day, I prefer this way as I am a late night picker so if I leave enough calories over from the day then I know the night time fridge hits wont make a dent in the overall calories in/out.

    Some day I don't log at all, like saturdays & sundays, my eating is sporadic & as i do a lot of cooking at weekends I tend to nibble & gave up trying to log that, so pre-log Mon-Fri with end of day adjustments & no logging at all at weekends.

    You just have to find what works for you :)
  • SemperAnticus1643
    SemperAnticus1643 Posts: 703 Member
    I do better when I pre-log. That just means that I have already got my food ready for the day. Most post logging days end up being bad.
  • HavtaLose
    HavtaLose Posts: 59 Member
    I recently (about a month ago) started pre-logging my day and packing my snacks and lunches according to that. It also forced me to plan my dinner ahead. This has helped me tremendously in sticking to my daily limit which is also 1500 and it forces me to re-consider any unhealthy snacks I might want to eat during the day as that would take away from dinner or the healthy snack choices I packed. It will also help you keep an eye on your macros if you prelog, I for example suck at staying at my sugar intake :) And another thing I love about this is being able to change things before eating. So let's say you prelog your day and you realize there are way too many carbs in it, change what you had planned to make for dinner. Or if you see you need much more protein, change your snack to hit the protein macro.

    This.
  • eddiesmith1
    eddiesmith1 Posts: 1,550 Member
    I log when i prepare it - I never know what lunch will be until I see what the chef at work has put out (on days where the main just doesn't work for me like perogies I stick to a salad with hard boiled egg). I could probably prelog breakfasts for a month but i just do it while I eat. I log Dinner once I make it, but work to a plan in my head (I pre-plan the week in y head when i shop, if I have a heavy lunch I have a lighter dinner and vice versa) . When I eat the main meals I take into account I want room to snack at night.
  • smc864
    smc864 Posts: 570 Member
    I pre-log, but it isn't set in stone. I like to plan my meals a couple days in advance now, but if I change my mind and decide I want something else it's no big deal.
  • SezxyStef
    SezxyStef Posts: 15,267 Member
    I prelog M-F...usually 2 or three days in advance. I know what is in my freezer and when my husband will be home for dinner...(he does shift work).

    It makes it easier for me to hit my macros and keep in check. I just have to learn to prelog on the weekends...:laugh:

    It can change tho...for example last night we were suppose to have dry garlic pork...husband forgot to buy it...no biggy we still had pork...
  • wyattj99
    wyattj99 Posts: 454 Member
    I log every morning except Sunday's my rest day but complete it at night cause somethings can change.
  • good4meFL
    good4meFL Posts: 5 Member
    I pre-log everything thru lunch and when I decide what I am going to eat for dinner I log it before I begin cooking to make sure I have enough calories left to eat what I planned. I find this works best for me. I need the structure.
  • Francl27
    Francl27 Posts: 26,371 Member
    I have to log as I go, or prelog, or I have no idea how many calories I have left for the day and can't plan my snacks accordingly. I'll prelog what I know I will eat (like if I know what's for dinner, I'll prelog it), but I adjust before I eat it (I know I'm going to have chicken for example, but I don't know exactly how much, so if I prelog before I eat it, I know I can have more or less veggies with it etc).

    If I logged everything at the end of the day I'd probably be over every time, or my macros would be totally wrong or something. My diary is a tool, it's a bit pointless if I don't use it for actually planning my meals and snacks.
  • Karababy51
    Karababy51 Posts: 124 Member
    I've always logged my meals as soon as possible right after I eat them. Except for breakfast, I don't always know what I want to eat that day or what DH wants for dinner so pre-logging wouldn't work for me. I can see how it would come in handy for others though. As for the end of the day method, I have so much going on all day and my memory isn't always the best, so I'm afraid I'd forget something if I tried to do it that way. o.O hehe

    Whatever logging method helps to keep you accurate, consistent, and stay within your calorie budget is the best option. :flowerforyou: