Comfort Food Alternatives?

I've found that I can control most of my cravings, except my cravings for those things that are so, so delicious and comforting, but are completely bad for you. I'm talkin' potato chips, perogies, chocolate cake, creamy pasta, apple crumble, COOKIES... Basically anything packed with cream, sugar, carbs and FAT!

I'm a big baker, and I love to cook, so I'm wondering if anyone has any health-i-fied comfort food recipes, or ingredient alternatives, that I could add to my arsenal?
«1

Replies

  • stormbornkraken
    stormbornkraken Posts: 302 Member
    There is no good substitute for true German chocolate cake. :sad:
    Fruit is a sweet alternative but cannot satiate the way the real stuff does.

    But bump as I am willing to listen to others insight.
  • SloRose
    SloRose Posts: 67
    Yes! You're in luck, my sister sent me this website rippedrecipes.com, they're all baking recipes for cakes, cupcakes, brownies, all clean eating though! We experimented with a couple recipes last night guilt free!!!! They also list the calories. Not just desserts ether, all types of recipes!
  • kaylaweinzatl
    kaylaweinzatl Posts: 3 Member
    I just found this website today >> http://www.fitsugar.com/How-Replace-Butter-When-Baking-21875486
    I know butter isn't the only bad thing in desserts but its the most fattening!
    I just tried the avocado and applesauce substitutes and it worked fabulous! I couldn't even tell!
  • ndj1979
    ndj1979 Posts: 29,136 Member
    eat less of said comfort foods and still enjoy them…or eat less during the day and then enjoy them once a week on Sunday …

    I love chicken parm, lasagna,spaghetti and meatballs, etc…when I want them I just make less of it, or I have less during the day to accommodate the higher calories….
  • Rlyxpop
    Rlyxpop Posts: 6 Member
    This is a recipe for cauliflower mashed potatoes. I am really looking forward to trying it. :)

    http://undressedskeleton.tumblr.com/post/32193615702
  • trisH_7183
    trisH_7183 Posts: 1,486 Member
    This is my 1st site to use when looking for recipes.It has nutritional & WW info for every recipe,plus most are delicious.

    http://www.skinnytaste.com
  • JCM1969
    JCM1969 Posts: 141 Member
    YES! Skinnytaste!
    Im making skinnytaste spaghetti squash and cheese tonight. I swear I like it more that regular mac and cheese.. which tends to be so rich I get a belly ache!
  • squeakybuttcheeks
    squeakybuttcheeks Posts: 54 Member
    I still eat all of these things, just a lot less. Creamy pasta is my weakness. I just eat less :heart: GL!
  • JJSABA
    JJSABA Posts: 4
    This is my 1st site to use when looking for recipes.It has nutritional & WW info for every recipe,plus most are delicious.

    http://www.skinnytaste.com

    I agree. I always look to skinnytaste for inspiration. Some i follow exactly, others I derive to make them even healthier and less in calories. Great blog!
  • Julettashane
    Julettashane Posts: 723 Member
    eat less of said comfort foods and still enjoy them…or eat less during the day and then enjoy them once a week on Sunday …

    I love chicken parm, lasagna,spaghetti and meatballs, etc…when I want them I just make less of it, or I have less during the day to accommodate the higher calories….

    i do this
  • BethFox
    BethFox Posts: 27 Member
    eat less of said comfort foods and still enjoy them…or eat less during the day and then enjoy them once a week on Sunday …

    I love chicken parm, lasagna,spaghetti and meatballs, etc…when I want them I just make less of it, or I have less during the day to accommodate the higher calories….

    I do the same. I also find that since juicing and adding a pint or so of raw juice a day into my diet that my comfort food cravings have lessened. More nutrients seems to kill the need for fat and salt and sugar.
  • Calliope610
    Calliope610 Posts: 3,783 Member
    Comfort food, ie. "food that comforts me and makes me feel better" is eaten based on emotional triggers, rather than physical hunger triggers.

    The best "comfort food alternative" (IMHO) is to learn how to develop better coping skills when dealing with emotional situations/triggers.

    I know, not as easy as following a skinnytaste recipe, but definitely more beneficial in the long run.
  • crevices
    crevices Posts: 226 Member
    as mentioned above, tons of recipes out there! what i usually do is think of something id like to eat, ex. brownies and start looking for 'healthier' (usually just lower calorie etc:embarassed: ) versions and variations

    a lot of people say just eat in moderation but i've never been able to do so. for example 'moderation' would be like 1/8th of a *real* lasagna but i was able to eat a whole homemade tray to myself because i used eggplant and zucchini as substitutes for lasagna sheets/noodles, and was able to add as much sauce and cheese as i desired. it was even more delicious than traditional lasagna i've had previously, no joke.

    find what works for you and your body, not everybody's the same
  • ValeriePlz
    ValeriePlz Posts: 517 Member
    Mrs. T's potato and onion pierogi are only 160 calories for 3 pierogi - and pour on the Frank's Red Hot (0 calories) for a delightful comfort food!
  • jeninthed
    jeninthed Posts: 20 Member
    vrs668 you are my pierogi savior! I have been craving these recently!
  • ValeriePlz
    ValeriePlz Posts: 517 Member
    Haha, happy to help. I also happen to be eating these for lunch. (I also dip them in plain Greek yogurt, which I use as a sour cream substitute.)
  • Amberlynnek
    Amberlynnek Posts: 405 Member
    I'm talkin' potato chips, perogies, chocolate cake, creamy pasta, apple crumble, COOKIES... Basically anything packed with cream, sugar, carbs and FAT!

    I'm a big baker, and I love to cook, so I'm wondering if anyone has any health-i-fied comfort food recipes, or ingredient alternatives, that I could add to my arsenal?

    Potato Chips : homemade baked veggie chips, veggie straws or snap pea crisps, Popcorn too - pinterest has a lot of savory popcorn ideas other than salt and butter

    Pierogi: Frozen ones can be pretty calorie friendly if you follow the portion size. Bake them instead of fry them.

    Chocolate Cake: 3-2-1 cake. Mix 1 box angel food with 1 box chocolate cake mix and store for use. 3tbsp mix, 2 tbps water, 1 minute in the microwave in a coffee mug. As long as you use angel food, the second box can be any flavor.

    Creamy pasta: Replace noodles with spaghetti squash. Create single serve rouxs with LF milk and light butter. Or use LF cream cheese or goat cheese as a base.

    Apple Crumble: There are a ton of friendly recipes online for this http://recipes.sparkpeople.com/recipe-detail.asp?recipe=11935

    Cookies: http://www.cookinglight.com/food/recipe-finder/healthy-cookies-00412000073008/

    healthy subs: http://www.fitnessmagazine.com/recipes/desserts/low-calorie/healthy-baking-tips-substitutions/

    Great healthy dessert recipes: www.chocolatecoveredkatie.com

    Stay away from undressed skeleton - her recipes do not turn out well at all!

    Its a good thing you love to bake, because healthy subs take a lot of extra work! Good luck!
  • nmncare
    nmncare Posts: 168 Member
    I'm talkin' potato chips, perogies, chocolate cake, creamy pasta, apple crumble, COOKIES... Basically anything packed with cream, sugar, carbs and FAT!

    I'm a big baker, and I love to cook, so I'm wondering if anyone has any health-i-fied comfort food recipes, or ingredient alternatives, that I could add to my arsenal?

    Potato Chips : homemade baked veggie chips, veggie straws or snap pea crisps, Popcorn too - pinterest has a lot of savory popcorn ideas other than salt and butter

    Pierogi: Frozen ones can be pretty calorie friendly if you follow the portion size. Bake them instead of fry them.

    Chocolate Cake: 3-2-1 cake. Mix 1 box angel food with 1 box chocolate cake mix and store for use. 3tbsp mix, 2 tbps water, 1 minute in the microwave in a coffee mug. As long as you use angel food, the second box can be any flavor.

    Creamy pasta: Replace noodles with spaghetti squash. Create single serve rouxs with LF milk and light butter. Or use LF cream cheese or goat cheese as a base.

    Apple Crumble: There are a ton of friendly recipes online for this http://recipes.sparkpeople.com/recipe-detail.asp?recipe=11935

    Cookies: http://www.cookinglight.com/food/recipe-finder/healthy-cookies-00412000073008/

    healthy subs: http://www.fitnessmagazine.com/recipes/desserts/low-calorie/healthy-baking-tips-substitutions/

    Great healthy dessert recipes: www.chocolatecoveredkatie.com

    Stay away from undressed skeleton - her recipes do not turn out well at all!

    Its a good thing you love to bake, because healthy subs take a lot of extra work! Good luck!

    You guys are awesome. :flowerforyou:
  • honsi
    honsi Posts: 210 Member
    The recipes on this website look good http://deliciouslyella.com/vegan-sweet-potato-brownies-gluten-free/
    but the ingredients look quite expensive. I also use skinnytaste.com
  • ValeriePlz
    ValeriePlz Posts: 517 Member
    Also, has anyone tried baking brownies with black beans instead of oil / eggs? I heard you can do it with all kinds of recipes and it really bumps up the protein and fiber, even the moistness! My coworker brought some in and I couldn't taste the beans, they were just nice, moist brownies.
  • Wow thanks for all the great tips everyone! I'm excited to try some of the new recipes. :)
  • AlysonG2
    AlysonG2 Posts: 713 Member
  • ottawaheather1970
    ottawaheather1970 Posts: 5 Member
    I love Skinny Taste! I've made her Pumpkin Cupcakes with great success - and less than 100 calories each! Those are my go-to sweets. I keep them in the freezer so they stay nice and fresh.
  • ottawaheather1970
    ottawaheather1970 Posts: 5 Member
    Also, has anyone tried baking brownies with black beans instead of oil / eggs? I heard you can do it with all kinds of recipes and it really bumps up the protein and fiber, even the moistness! My coworker brought some in and I couldn't taste the beans, they were just nice, moist brownies.


    I made the ones from the Skinnytaste.com website and no, you could not taste beans at all. I tried reducing the sugar as well but I took it down a little too much, so they are not so sweet. Mine turned out more like cake than a brownie but they were a big hit. Although not as big a hit as the Pumpkin Cupcake recipe. Yellow cake mix, 1 cup pureed pumpkin, 1 cup water, pumpkin spices - mix and bake.
  • palomino698
    palomino698 Posts: 36 Member
    Another vote for skinnytaste.com, fantastic recipes and adaptations that always work out perfectly and taste wonderful!
  • Ke11er
    Ke11er Posts: 147 Member
    http://atastylovestory.com/the-famous-brilliant-black-bean-chocolate-cake/

    This is a yummy chocolate cake made with black beans recipe. I'm not sure, but your question about black bean brownies has inspired me to try modifying this recipe to see if it would work. I'm thinking less eggs and it should become like brownies. Anyone ever tried that?
  • nomorebingesgirl2014
    nomorebingesgirl2014 Posts: 378 Member
    Ohh great post
  • tabbyblack13
    tabbyblack13 Posts: 299 Member
    I love the skinnytaste cloud cookies. I make the black & white verity but I use dark M&Ms instead because I get fun color changes to the batter from the M&Ms.
  • I've just logged on to the site... I may not sleep tonight! So good!
  • dsb188
    dsb188 Posts: 121 Member
    I'm not sure if you are doing low carb or what specific diet but when I first started dieting I did the following:

    ICECREAM:
    Two Frozen Bananas with Coco Powder in the ninja- It tasted as close to icecream as I could get.

    CHIPS:
    Kale Chips in lieu of potato chips. I even made a ranch seasoning, and bought some low salt bbq seasoning for them

    PIZZA:
    Cauliflower Pizza Crust (you've probably heard of this before)

    PASTA:
    I bought a juliener (spelling?) from ebay and I use it to cut zuchinni into super thin strips like angel hair pasta.

    Quesadillas/Mexican:
    I made cauliflower tortillas and made quesadillas

    Mac and Cheese:
    Cauliflower Mac and Cheese

    I love baking as well but I can't stand using artificial sugars. They taste so bad to me. I have the recipes for most of these if you want them.