Does anyone NOT track their food intake?

I am approaching my 80 day streak and feel that despite my slow progress I am doing well. I tracked beautifully for the first two months and lately its been harder to do. I am still weighing food, still keeping portions in control, and eating better. I can't help but feel guilty though. I know I need to track more but sometimes I just get obsessed and irritated when I cant find things in the database etc. I do still put my recipes in the recipe builder so I have an idea of what I am eating.

Just wasnt sure if any other mfp people succeed without hardcore tracking. Either way I plan to monitor my progress and track if I feel I need to, but at this point I feel its more frustrating than helpful.
«1

Replies

  • WBB55
    WBB55 Posts: 4,131 Member
    I can't lose if I don't track. I can maintain, but I can't lose. But that's me.
  • marissanik
    marissanik Posts: 344 Member
    For now... I still have about 20lbs to lose so I would say not tracking would be counter-productive to reaching my goals. However, once I hit my goal weight I plan on not tracking anymore. Only tracking again when I gain weight.
  • Holly_Roman_Empire
    Holly_Roman_Empire Posts: 4,440 Member
    That's a funny question to ask on a site that's made for calorie counting.

    Plenty of people have successful weight loss without calorie counting, without MFP, etc. With that said, most of the "I stopped losing weight" threads are from folks that either stopped logging or are not logging accurately. If it works for you, fantastic. If not, keep logging.
  • I_Will_End_You
    I_Will_End_You Posts: 4,397 Member
    I don't track. I only did for a few weeks in the beginning. I didn't feel it was necessary for me as I had a good handle on what/how much I was eating.


    Edited for typo.
  • The_1_Who_Knocks
    The_1_Who_Knocks Posts: 343 Member
    On days I've decided to treat myself, I don't track. That is once a week or once every 10 days.
  • 125KC
    125KC Posts: 71 Member
    I track what I eat everyday, 85 day streak, and slow continuous loss, however I do not track obsessively - i guesstimate, I don't weigh and measure all my food, I use what the "box says" a portion is. I also will overestimate at times if I'm unsure. I can see where some may want and/or need to take it to that next level, but for me, it's a time thing, and to date my system seems to be working.
  • _Zardoz_
    _Zardoz_ Posts: 3,987 Member
    You do realise that this is a calorie counting website and the whole point is to track your food
  • I'm on day 101 and feeling awesome about it. I need it to hold myself accountable. And seeing those big numbers in the streak makes me want to keep going. One of my friends has a streak over 610 days... it's so impressive and she's a great inspiration.
  • krawhitham
    krawhitham Posts: 831 Member
    I think it depends on the reason *why* you gained the weight in the first place.

    For example, if there was a death in the family and you gained 50 lbs in a matter of 6 months due to grieving, but before then had no weight issues, maybe tracking for the first couple of months would be a good idea to get into the swing of eating right again

    BUT, if you've been overweight your whole life and yo-yo dieted and have trouble losing weight, it may be more advantageous for you to continue to track throughout your weight loss and even into maintenance, because you don't know when you'll go back into old habits.

    It truly depends on why you've gained weight in the first place, and how good you can be with self control and monitoring proper portions.
  • bcattoes
    bcattoes Posts: 17,299 Member
    Just wasnt sure if any other mfp people succeed without hardcore tracking. Either way I plan to monitor my progress and track if I feel I need to, but at this point I feel its more frustrating than helpful.

    I used to track religiously, then it became too cumbersome so I only tracked on weekdays and not the weekend. Finally, I stopped tracking altogether. The database is a realy problem IMO. I don't eat the same foods every day so it took a while to find correct entries and log them. But I think the real reason logging wasn't a good fit for me is that I don't like to eat the same number of calories every day. For a while I was averaging them by the week, but that just seemed like even more work. And I obsessed over it all too much.

    I had lost most of my weight before joining MFP, so I knew I didn't need to log to stay on track. Actually, I found constantly trying to meet some arbitrary calorie goal was causing me to start gaining again. So, I stopped and now I'm losing those few I gained back.

    Different things work for different people. I still use this site for fitness motivation and to play on the forums.
  • You do realise that this is a calorie counting website and the whole point is to track your food

    No I didn't realize this?! Of course I realize this. I am just asking what others do or if anyone does things a little differently. Everyone is different.
  • Thank you for all of your comments. To the people who are saying "You DO realize this is a calorie counting site" yes I do! I was just wondering what others do and what works for them.
  • Geobec1981
    Geobec1981 Posts: 7 Member
    I track every day for all meals including snacks. I find it a real eye opener and I am reading more on what food contains and how it will effect me. I alone am responsible for every single morsel that passes into my stomach. I have my "junk" food days where I dont necessary eat junk food, just more of what I like maybe washed down with some ice cold beer! I also exercise five to six days a week and track that too. To date I have gone from 111kg at the end of Jan 2014 to 97kg as of 6 April 14. It makes me feel fantastic and with a young family I need all the energy I can muster!!
  • maasha81
    maasha81 Posts: 733 Member
    I don't track as religiously any more since I have a fair idea now what a real portion is like after doing this for so many months. I'm also in maintenance mode so I don't feel the need to count every single calorie.

    For some people, counting calories can be counter-productive ...it was stressful, obsessive and you may end up just not accomplishing your goal. In that case, you do need to try another way.
  • missbirrell
    missbirrell Posts: 133
    I track everything because otherwise I'll overeat.
  • SezxyStef
    SezxyStef Posts: 15,267 Member
    if I don't track I lose track and will gain weight.

    proof of that was one night I thought I would use quick adds...for a night of company and food...I guesstimated 1200 calories (after weighing the food)...

    But I decided to actually log everything individually...it ended up being 2300 calories...:sad:

    I could have been 1100 over my calorie allotment and not even realized it...that is 1/3 of a pound...so no I track now and will continue until I am at a point where I don't have to...

    I mean really it takes what 2mins a meal??? esp with the phone app.
  • chelstakencharge
    chelstakencharge Posts: 1,021 Member
    580 days and still tracking....I don't think I could ever not track again
  • Snow3y
    Snow3y Posts: 1,412 Member
    Why would you be on this website if not to track food?
  • shadow2soul
    shadow2soul Posts: 7,692 Member
    Well when I first started losing weight, I didn't count calories at all. I actually did lose weight this way, but I do have to admit that I was very, very picky about what I ate.

    I started, just to see what it was like. Turned out that it was much easier than I thought it would be and I didn't have to be as picky about what I ate. MFP made it simple for me to see how my food choices affected my weight and made it easy to make changes without leaving out foods that I love. It was starting to become a habit for me. I would log things as I was cooking without thinking about it.

    When I discovered I was pregnant (yep..I'm 34wks right now), I stopped counting for awhile. I also stopped my daily weigh-ins. Surprisingly enough, I didn't start gaining weight till about 18-19wks along. I have started logging food again, but only to make sure I'm consuming enough for me (pre-pregnancy maintenance) and my baby (465 extra for 3rd trimester...was 280 extra for 2nd trimester and 85 extra for 1st trimester). I'm not very strict about it and it doesn't bother me if I go over. I just want to make sure that I eat enough for the little one and at the same time make sure I don't consume 5000+ calories in one day (something I did with my first pregnancy).

    I could probably still lose weight (once this pregnancy is over) without logging food/counting calories, but I like seeing the trends and how certain things affect my weight.
  • MeanderingMammal
    MeanderingMammal Posts: 7,866 Member
    people succeed without hardcore tracking

    I think you're in the realms of what do you mean by success and hardcore.

    Personally I find that I understand my intake well enough that I'm seeing progress whilst not geting obsessive about tracking. But for me success is my 10km time, my average running and cycling speed and my long range endurance..

    I don't even weight myself very often.
  • IsabellaGiano
    IsabellaGiano Posts: 158 Member
    I am approaching my 80 day streak and feel that despite my slow progress I am doing well. I tracked beautifully for the first two months and lately its been harder to do. I am still weighing food, still keeping portions in control, and eating better. I can't help but feel guilty though. I know I need to track more but sometimes I just get obsessed and irritated when I cant find things in the database etc. I do still put my recipes in the recipe builder so I have an idea of what I am eating.

    Just wasnt sure if any other mfp people succeed without hardcore tracking. Either way I plan to monitor my progress and track if I feel I need to, but at this point I feel its more frustrating than helpful.

    I don't always track accurately.
    I don't always have a scale, I often eat outside.
    Sometime I cannot find the food I'm looking for in the database -but it is rare, mostly I found TOO MANY entries and I get confused.

    And I'm going well.
    Anyway, I loose consistently when I can track, while if don't the results tend to be lower or, if I completely try to do all by myself, well.. :)

    So, yes, you can succeed even not tracking accurately. BUT. Pay attention... is this "tracking stress" due to your real difficulties, or just because if you track everything you have to struggle more to be in your calory goal?
    Is this difficulty something real, or just a way to stop your way?

    You don't have to reply to nobody than yourself :)
  • bethlaf
    bethlaf Posts: 954 Member
    i track like religion , and as far as finding "correct" food entries, i use the "whole" or "raw" option, and find those work best, the ones without the asterix are the ones that are entered into the MFP database by the MFP programmers(we love you all muah)
    and those seem to me to be the most accurate, i "know" my food numbers and all, i just find that i am more reliable when i track , and when i make a food myself, i go in and "build" that food, its actually kind of encouraged me to reduce and change a lot of my "old" recipes ...

    this is working for me , i stopped tracking for about 6 months, and i gained a couple pounds... just 4... but that was what kind of forced me to come back and face the tracker every day again


    Edited for spelling
  • MattyFTM
    MattyFTM Posts: 68 Member
    If logging your food is frustrating you, it can't do any harm to try giving it up for a couple of weeks. Give it a trial, see if it works for you. Plenty of people do lose weight without logging every calorie that passes their lips. Trying it for a two or three weeks isn't going to do any massive harm. If you stop losing for that short period of time, it isn't the end of the world, you can always go back to logging.

    Just make sure that you are keeping an eye on what you are eating, and maybe have a ballpark figure for your daily calories in your head. It won't be completely accurate, but it'll ensure that you don't go massively over.

    Alternatively, you could find a middle ground and continue logging your food, but don't be quite so meticulous about it. Stop weighing, just estimate the weight. If you can't find the exact entry in the database, use a close alternative. This will give you a reasonably accurate number, whilst relieving you of much of the frustrations.

    Just find what works for you. Try out different methods to figure out what allows you to lose weight with as little frustration as possible.
  • snowflake954
    snowflake954 Posts: 8,399 Member
    Great idea! You seem to already be tired of tracking. Let us know how you're doing in a couple of months. Best. :smile:
  • bcattoes
    bcattoes Posts: 17,299 Member
    You do realise that this is a calorie counting website and the whole point is to track your food

    No I didn't realize this?! Of course I realize this. I am just asking what others do or if anyone does things a little differently. Everyone is different.

    The food log is a big feature, but this is a fitness site (My fitness Pal). I don't see that the food log is any more important than the exercise log. No matter how prefect your diet may be, you will not be fit without exercise.
  • RJKontos
    RJKontos Posts: 17 Member
    I track everything, it helps me being in control.
  • MrsKgettingfit
    MrsKgettingfit Posts: 28 Member
    No I don't. I did for a about a week but gave up. I don't have weight to lose atm so I use this site for motivation and getting tips on best forms of exercise etc.
  • jimwon953
    jimwon953 Posts: 20 Member
    I only joined this site a couple weeks ago, but I actually changed my eating habits nearly 6 months and have lost 2 stone before I started on here.

    On my last attempt at weight loss, I lost 5 stone by severely reducing the amount of food I ate. Thinking back, It was probably quite a dangerous diet really but it helped me drop from obese to juuust overweight according to the BMI graph.

    I am back at the same point now and have started on this site because I want to lose another stone to get comfortably into the middle of the normal range of BMI and then learn how to eat the right amount to maintain that weight so I don't start to regularly gain weight like I did before. I figure I'll be doing this for a year to get to that point (which would coincide nicely with my wedding next year).

    For me, the logging is not a problem because I am such a creature of habit. The things I eat are pretty much the same every week so once I had all that stuff built up in my 'Regular' lists I find it very quick and easy to log the food. I am not planning on doing this forever though, I figure 6 months to lose another stone and six months to learn how to maintain a weight will be good enough to set me off on good eating habits.
  • albayin
    albayin Posts: 2,524 Member
    On days I've decided to treat myself, I don't track. That is once a week or once every 10 days.

    LOL I thought I was cheating myself because I do this too...then I see people here saying they log everything even when they are over eating...
  • albayin
    albayin Posts: 2,524 Member
    You do realise that this is a calorie counting website and the whole point is to track your food

    No I didn't realize this?! Of course I realize this. I am just asking what others do or if anyone does things a little differently. Everyone is different.

    "Everyone is different" that's exactly the key...some who can lose weight without tracking but they are not you, and you are not them...DIdn't want to sound mean or anything but I have been there trying to copy other's success but only failure came to my way...but again, everyone is different and has different goals...