How much cardio when heavy lifting?
bleemoore81
Posts: 17 Member
Ok so I've been reading a lot more on here that people who haven't been loosing with cardio switched to more heavy lifting and that has helped. My question is for girls, how much, if any cardio do you do and how much heavy lifting? I feel like I can do 40-60 mins of cardio 3+ days a week and still not get anywhere. .. So I think I need to do less cardio and more weights?
0
Replies
-
What works well for me is 2-3 days of cardio, and about 2 sessions of weights each lasting at least a solid 45 minutes. Have any idea what body type you are? If not take the quiz at BodyBuilding,com, I found it good in terms of telling me what ranges I fall into as it helped me ballpark my macros but it also gives suggestions as per workouts to lose fat/gain muscle.0
-
In to follow.0
-
I'm not doing any cardio at the moment. I just started though. If you can, read the book The New Rules of Lifting for Women. It tells you that cardio is not necessary, you can achieve your goals with weight lifting all alone. However, if you really enjoy it then go for it, just make sure to eat accordingly to the amount of calories you'll be burning.
I haven't heard of cardio being detrimental to heavy lifting at all (just a couple of people that say it takes strength from them or something), and it's beneficial for your heart, but you don't have to do it if you don't want to.0 -
I do couch 2 5k (runs are about 30-40 minutes 3x a week)on my non lifting days. For lifting I follow sl 5x5 3 times a week. It works well for me.0
-
I do cardio for heart health 2-3 times a week, strength 2-3 times a week. Cardio at heart rate for at least 20 minutes above 120 and switch out from treadmill, cycling and elliptical.0
-
I felt my legs losing weight on a mini stepper but didn't feel any results anywhere else so I got a wieder ultimate body machine. I see changes in my arms now, I love it. I have a long way to go. I recently heard about this balance we should have and would like to know more. I'm happy doing both cardio and strength training, I would like to do it the right way.0
-
Lately I've been doing short 400m-800m runs between sets of weights and exercises like pull-ups, dips, etc... It's just enough to elevate heart rate to about 90% then do most lifting around the 80% range. The runs probably total 10-15 depending on distance and number of sets.0
-
I do circuit training which is the best of both, weight training that counts as cardio. I do some cardio too.0
-
I am def hour glass. Which I don't mind but the middle seems to be not as small anymore so want to get that back and look more hour glass again. Muffin top is not very fashionable lol0
-
Cardio sucks. I big fat hate it. I only do it at the end of a lifting session if I'm not brutally tired. And then it's 20 minutes on either the stairmaster or bike. And that's only 3-4 times a week. On a good week.0
-
Following0
-
What are your goals?0
-
I do 10 min of cardio to warm up. Then about 45 min of lifting.0
-
What are your goals?
Lose inches in arms waist hips and thighs, so basically all around.. And I am ok with not losing the weight if I can do inches. I was always around 130 and now more like 145-148 depending on the time of month.. I am now working on my diet which I didnt do so well with before. But overall I need to tone up and lose inches everywhere.0 -
Right now I am doing 5-6 days a week of cardio 45-60 mins and 3-4 days a week of 40-45 mins lifting. I was seeing a personal training for a few months but had to stop due to financial issues and this is the plan that she is having me do while we take a break. Prior to uping it I was doing 3-4 days week of lifting for about 30-40 mins and 3-4 days a week of cardio.0
-
What sort of cardio are you doing OP? And more importantly what is your heart rate during the cardio.
My trainer told me that for me to lose fat I should do an hour or so of cardio every day but only at a brisk walking pace as a lower heart rate will burn fat more effectively than aerobic excersise. I don't know how true this is though but it seems logical seeing as weightlifting is an anaerobic excersise and also good for burning fat.
Currently I do weights 4 times a week for about 40minutes as heavy as I can. I am also training to run 10km so I will run 3 times a week doing 1x 3-4k run, 1 x 3.2k run and 1 x 5-9k run. Then I'll cycle 3 or 4 times a week as well approx 40 - 50 kms each time. Finally, if I have time I will try to fit in a long walk once a week to train for my trek to Everest Base Camp. I'm aiming to be able to walk at a brisk pace for up to 7 hours. My goal average heart rate for my cardio is around 132 bpm. All that on 1700 cals a day.
I don't know if I'm doing too much cardio or not enough myself, as I am not really losing fat as quickly as I hoped to.0 -
No need for cardio unless you want to work on your stamina for a marathon or something... fat loss happens in the kitchen not the gym. I just do weights 3 days a week for 1 1/2 hours. Heavy lifting only though, no light weights... I think cardio just taxes and depletes the muscles, they need a day of rest in between workouts and with more working out? You kinda of hinder the process.0
-
I do 3/4 weight sessions a week, in the gym and will warm up for 10/ 15 mins with cardio, either using the spin bikes, or battle ropes and sled. if I want to do any additional cardio I try and do it out in the real world by either cycling or walking (If i do it in the gym I just get bored and go pick up the weights, at least if I go a couple of km on my bike, I can't just quit, I have to cycle home again!) I do it as much for the joy of getting out though as I do for the exercise.0
-
My trainer told me that for me to lose fat I should do an hour or so of cardio every day but only at a brisk walking pace as a lower heart rate will burn fat more effectively than aerobic excersise. I don't know how true this is though
My instinct is that your trainer talks bo***ks, but that in itself is as much an over simplification as what your trainer says.
Essentially by operating at the lower intensities your ability to operate for longer is enhanced, and as a result of operating for longer you're going to expend more. The whole "Fat burning zone" idea is very outdated and understanding of training effect is much more sophisticated now.I don't know if I'm doing too much cardio or not enough myself, as I am not really losing fat as quickly as I hoped to.
If your objective is a competitive time in the 10K then you're doing a reasonable amount, although you need to up your distances on the runs and start including tempo and interval training. For my 10K training at the moment I do a long run of anything up to 18k, a short run of 3-5k at recovery pace, then three tempo or interval sessions of between 6 and 9k per week, I also do one pace cycling session of 20-30K to balance out my leg development.0 -
I do 4 x 25 - 30minute weight training sessions per week.
With cardio MAYBE once a week I get a session in, when I feel like it.0 -
Lose inches in arms waist hips and thighs, so basically all around.. And I am ok with not losing the weight if I can do inches. I was always around 130 and now more like 145-148 depending on the time of month.. I am now working on my diet which I didnt do so well with before. But overall I need to tone up and lose inches everywhere.
That sounds like a fairly generalised objective set, with that in mind about 50/50 CV and lifting would be an appropriate mix. If you get more specific then a more tailored plan would be appropriate.
I assume, from the tone of the question, that your CV work is done on a hamser wheel in a gym; dreadmill, stationary bike, elliptihell etc, so I'd actually recommend getting outside to make it more interesting. I had the misfortune to have to use a gym the other night and was bored within about ten minutes, whereas on Saturday I'd been out on the trail for a good couple of hours and really enjoyed my run.
With all that in mind, I'd suggest three CV sessions per week. If you can get outside then aim for one of an hour and two of 30-40 minutes at slightly higher pace or intervals. If you're going to continue doing it inside an air conditioned box then the rowing maching gives you the most thorough whole body workout, with a significant amount of progress on core strength. If you do three 10km rows per week you've got a very complementary session that has a solid effect on your exercise efficiency. If you want to improve your oxygen uptake you need to be doing interval training. Improving your VO2Max has a very broad effect on your ability to exercise. Given that you have no specific goals in mind you probably don't need to do any Lactate Threshold work.
All that complements three to four lifting sessions per week. I'd echo the general advice in MFP that a whole body programme with Stronglifts 5*5 or New Rules would be a solid plan.0 -
.... read the book The New Rules of Lifting for Women. It tells you that cardio is not necessary,
Most plan authors get a bit ONE TRUE WAY(tm) about their plans, very few will acknowledge that there are other ways to achieve ones goals.I haven't heard of cardio being detrimental to heavy lifting at all (just a couple of people that say it takes strength from them or something),
There is a vein of thought within the renowned Broscience movement that CV work eats the muscles and anything faster than snails pace movement is BAD!!! While not even remotely close to being a reasonable position it's based on the principle that the body derives it's fuel from a range of sources, and the balance betwen sources varies according to exercise intensity. If one isn't eating enough to fuel the readily accessible stores, or is exercising for protracted periods of time, then some of the readily accessible fuel comes from muscle tissue. To get to that stage you'd be doing moderate to high intensity CV work for several hours per day, and not eating sufficiently in between. What runners describe as hitting the wall, or bonking.
Basically it becomes an excuse not to do CV work. I have to say that's understandable when one is doing CV on a hamster wheel in an air conditioned box, that's as boring as doing weight training.0 -
My trainer told me that for me to lose fat I should do an hour or so of cardio every day but only at a brisk walking pace as a lower heart rate will burn fat more effectively than aerobic excersise. I don't know how true this is though
My instinct is that your trainer talks bo***ks, but that in itself is as much an over simplification as what your trainer says.
Essentially by operating at the lower intensities your ability to operate for longer is enhanced, and as a result of operating for longer you're going to expend more. The whole "Fat burning zone" idea is very outdated and understanding of training effect is much more sophisticated now.I don't know if I'm doing too much cardio or not enough myself, as I am not really losing fat as quickly as I hoped to.
If your objective is a competitive time in the 10K then you're doing a reasonable amount, although you need to up your distances on the runs and start including tempo and interval training. For my 10K training at the moment I do a long run of anything up to 18k, a short run of 3-5k at recovery pace, then three tempo or interval sessions of between 6 and 9k per week, I also do one pace cycling session of 20-30K to balance out my leg development.
Hey thanks for that! Yeah, I have read quite a bit about the fat burning zone but don't really know what to think. I figure that you don't see many fat marathon runners so running obviously burns fat. I like walking though so will incorporate it into my routine especially as a rest day.
For my running training, I don't know if I'll actually ever race but would like to be able to run 10k at a reasonable pace. Im currently following Hal Higdon's 10k novice program and am halfway through week 1. Prior to this I have just been doing 5 - 6k runs interspersed with walking. I'll be doing my cycling on the cross training days.
I probably don't lift as heavy as most women here do but I do try and increase the weights each time I go by a little bit.
Edit - just read your post about the rowing. Great info and I might throw a few sessions in as well if I can't get out on the bike.0 -
For my running training, I don't know if I'll actually ever race but would like to be able to run 10k at a reasonable pace.
I'm a bit meh about racing, I enjoy getting out and I'm veering at the moment to increasing my distance and then running some long distance trails. I'm planning one later in the year that'll be three Half Marathon distances in three days. about nine hours of running but I'm not even close to doing it continuously yet.I probably don't lift as heavy as most women here do but I do try and increase the weights each time I go by a little bit.
I was reading an interview with Mo Farrah this week, with London on Sunday there is a big focus on him, and his resistance training is limited to twice weekly predominantly bodyweight work.0 -
I'm gonna throw my kettlebell into the ring. I work out three days a week, and my workout session is about 50 mins, which includes a warm-up/mobility session, the workout itself (which is akin to circuit training) and a mobiliy/yoga cool down. There's plenty of information out there about the combined cardio/weights benefits of kettlebells if it's something you're thinking about. There are also a lot of things to learn / myths to bust / ideas to get your head around if you're a woman interested in weight training (just because of the fitness culture that's been sold to women over the decades), so I'd suggest having a look at New Rules of Weight Lifting for Women and the other books people have already suggested.
I could go on all day about my experiences so far with kettlebells but I don't know if you're interested or even reading this so feel free to message me or FR me and I'll be happy to answer any questions!0 -
I have actually thought about getting a kettle ball. I have played with them a little and really enjoyed it. I heard they are great. I will add you. Thanks!I'm gonna throw my kettlebell into the ring. I work out three days a week, and my workout session is about 50 mins, which includes a warm-up/mobility session, the workout itself (which is akin to circuit training) and a mobiliy/yoga cool down. There's plenty of information out there about the combined cardio/weights benefits of kettlebells if it's something you're thinking about. There are also a lot of things to learn / myths to bust / ideas to get your head around if you're a woman interested in weight training (just because of the fitness culture that's been sold to women over the decades), so I'd suggest having a look at New Rules of Weight Lifting for Women and the other books people have already suggested.
I could go on all day about my experiences so far with kettlebells but I don't know if you're interested or even reading this so feel free to message me or FR me and I'll be happy to answer any questions!0 -
Right now, I'm doing generally 75-90 minutes of strength training 4 days a week and cardio 40 minutes 3 days a week riding my bike to/from the gym and extra sessions of cardio at home on the heavy bag whenever I'm in the mood. I like to eat all the food, but this seems to be working for me.0
-
I am totally down for getting out and doing cardio. The weather here is perfect so starting to do some biking and soon we will be going on river rides that are about 20 miles. I love that but have to do shorter rides and condition my booty to the seat.. lol. I also don't mind cardio in the gym. I just put on my headset and blast my music. I find myself going to the beat. If its a slow song I go slow and let my heart rate slow, Fast songs I speed up again. I can easily do this for 30-40mins. I am only spending about 15-20 mins on weights and I think that is where I need to change it sounds like. And Higher weight less reps? does that sound right. Sorry pretty new to weight lifting. Back in my 20's I gained about 30 pounds and just get the Elliptical for 30 mins and lost it all in a month. Now, I can't do that
I have not had kids but I am sure my eating habits don't help now so changing that for sure.Lose inches in arms waist hips and thighs, so basically all around.. And I am ok with not losing the weight if I can do inches. I was always around 130 and now more like 145-148 depending on the time of month.. I am now working on my diet which I didnt do so well with before. But overall I need to tone up and lose inches everywhere.
That sounds like a fairly generalised objective set, with that in mind about 50/50 CV and lifting would be an appropriate mix. If you get more specific then a more tailored plan would be appropriate.
I assume, from the tone of the question, that your CV work is done on a hamser wheel in a gym; dreadmill, stationary bike, elliptihell etc, so I'd actually recommend getting outside to make it more interesting. I had the misfortune to have to use a gym the other night and was bored within about ten minutes, whereas on Saturday I'd been out on the trail for a good couple of hours and really enjoyed my run.
With all that in mind, I'd suggest three CV sessions per week. If you can get outside then aim for one of an hour and two of 30-40 minutes at slightly higher pace or intervals. If you're going to continue doing it inside an air conditioned box then the rowing maching gives you the most thorough whole body workout, with a significant amount of progress on core strength. If you do three 10km rows per week you've got a very complementary session that has a solid effect on your exercise efficiency. If you want to improve your oxygen uptake you need to be doing interval training. Improving your VO2Max has a very broad effect on your ability to exercise. Given that you have no specific goals in mind you probably don't need to do any Lactate Threshold work.
All that complements three to four lifting sessions per week. I'd echo the general advice in MFP that a whole body programme with Stronglifts 5*5 or New Rules would be a solid plan.0 -
I walk on the treadmill at the highest incline at approx. 5-5.5km/hr for about 30 mins 6 days a week sometimes twice a day. I also do 5x 70-90 min weight sessions a week. I use programs off bodybuilding.com. I'm currently doing The Arnold Trainer, but I've also done Kris Gethins 12 week trainer which only does 2x20-25 mins sessions of light cardio a day no running, plus 4-6 weight sessions a week. The Jim Stoppani 6 week Shortcut to Shred is great for a weights and cardio workout in one, you get it all done in about 75-90 mins a day. You really need to lift weights to make your body change and not just little weights, you need to challenge your muscles to force them to change.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions