Would appriciate some more advice PLEASE

Hi

I am 219.5lbs and work out at the gym 3-4 times a week. I do weights and cardio. Just lately I am getting really tired and have muscle fatigue, and the weight has stopped coming off and I am wondering if its because I am having too few calories.

MFP has calculated my daily calories to 1480, but I have just done 2 different calculations off 2 different sites (Fat2fit and the frog one) and they both come out at 1778 and 1976 if I do no exercise, or 2038 and 2265 if I exercise 1-3 days aweek.. Now if I take off say a 20% deficit that would bring it down to around 1630 cals a day. Could any one tell me if that sounds more like what I should be having or not. Any advice would be greatly recieved . Thank you

Replies

  • AllOutof_Bubblegum
    AllOutof_Bubblegum Posts: 3,646 Member
    Even 1,630 for your weight sounds crazy low. I am only 5'0", and I'm still losing inches eating 1,800 doing weights and cardio, same as you. I'd shoot for 1,800 to 2,000 and see how that works for your energy levels,
  • MelodyandBarbells
    MelodyandBarbells Posts: 7,724 Member
    Was just curious how you determined that you're eating 1400 calories per day, do you weigh and measure everything you eat using a food scale and measuring cups/spoons (liquids only?). Do you log weekends, fruits, vegetables, cheat days, holidays, splurges, etc? Unfortunately it's also possible that you've lost your initial weight being in a deficit, and now that some weight has come off, you're eating closer to your current maintenance calories, which have reduced according to your smaller size, and are no therefore longer losing weight.

    That aside, if you're getting fatigued to the point that you can't get through a day, you could always increase your calories. But see above. If you increase when in maintenance or a surplus, you'll just gain more weight. You may have told MFP you want to lose 2 or 2.5 lbs a week. If you change it to one lb a week, the numbers may match your TDEE calculator numbers? They could also be more sustainable if you have issues sticking with too aggressive a target

    For better advice you may need to set your diary to public so people can comment specifically on food and exercise logs. For example something you're eating might make someone highly lethargic, you never know!

    Read this: http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/1080242-a-guide-to-get-you-started-on-your-path-to-sexypants
  • MelodyandBarbells
    MelodyandBarbells Posts: 7,724 Member
    Just wanted to add, there's no magic formula. I just now read up on your first thread and You got fantastic advice the first time around. Did anything given in the previous thread jump at you? Any action you plan on taking?
  • CorlissaEats
    CorlissaEats Posts: 493 Member
    Just take 10-15% off the max tdee number.

    I found that I lost more consistently when I ate enough and maintained a 500 cal deficit or less. I'm female, 5'8", started at 217lbs and am down to 183lbs now. I aim to eat 1902 cals now, but my over time average intake is around 2040 cals. I do recalculate every 2 pounds, and my diary goal of 1902 cals is my sedentary tdee. Ive been experimenting with several different formulas and so far i like using my sedentary tdee the best because my actual burn numbers are higher and it encourages me to move more to create a deficit. I rarely eat back my calories.

    I have also done the adding exercise numbers and manually subtracting 15% and that formula worked. Again I set my diary to my sedentary tdee of 2012 at that time(+/-204lbs) and did manual math. It allowed me to eat more on the days I worked out but it also had me eating quite a bit less on days I didn't exercise and it put me too close to my BMR number. I switched it up because I got really sick twice in January and February and that was a signal to me to reevaluate.

    The current formula I'm using has me exercising a little less and eating a little more but I find the balance is better. I weigh everything so that my numbers are as accurate as possible. I have been "dieting" for 245 days and I have at least another 245 days until I could reach my loss goals. Long term, its a tiny bit slower but it has to be sustainable. You didn't gain overnight, it doesn't come off overnight.
  • pangy1958
    pangy1958 Posts: 151 Member
    Thank you both for your advice.

    I weigh and measure everything that I eat and log it down. Even when my husband cooks he always weighs everything. I got the 1480 from the MFP. It started at 1580 but as I lost weight they automatically reduced it. I have just changed the setting from no exercise which I was when I stared my journey to slightly active and the calories have increased to 1770 cals per day.

    Once again thank you both
  • MelodyandBarbells
    MelodyandBarbells Posts: 7,724 Member
    Thank you both for your advice.

    I weigh and measure everything that I eat and log it down. Even when my husband cooks he always weighs everything. I got the 1480 from the MFP. It started at 1580 but as I lost weight they automatically reduced it. I have just changed the setting from no exercise which I was when I stared my journey to slightly active and the calories have increased to 1770 cals per day.

    Once again thank you both

    If you change to lightly active and you're not truly lightly active, you could essentially be logging your exercise calories twice. The MFP app gave some examples. Sedentary: desk job, bank teller. Lightly active: teacher, salesman. Active: waitress, mailman. Very active : carpenter, bike messenger. Basically how much built in exercise you get during the day. And then you'd still add on exercise calories

    However if you're sure you want to increase for any reason , you certainly should. Just wanted to make sure you understood how the activity settings worked
  • TavistockToad
    TavistockToad Posts: 35,719 Member
    Does MFP give you 1400 cals to lose 1lb per week?
  • pangy1958
    pangy1958 Posts: 151 Member
    I exercise 3-4 days a week.
  • pangy1958
    pangy1958 Posts: 151 Member
    Does MFP give you 1400 cals to lose 1lb per week?
  • pangy1958
    pangy1958 Posts: 151 Member
    Yes that was for 1lb a week loss
  • MelodyandBarbells
    MelodyandBarbells Posts: 7,724 Member
    When I plug in 219 lbs as current weight and lose 1 lb a week, MFP gives me 1610 calories (sedentary)
  • pangy1958
    pangy1958 Posts: 151 Member
    When I plug in 219 lbs as current weight and lose 1 lb a week, MFP gives me 1610 calories (sedentary)

    Well I have just done it again and it has come up 1470 calories. You have to remember that since I have started this my original calories it set at 1570, when I had lost 10lb MFP reduced it and again with another 10lb resultoing in now 1470. If you put it in as a new mwmber it will give you a higher calorie and reduce it as the weight goes down.

    Seeing as I work out 3-4 times a week I think I am going to have the higher calories for slightly active and on the days I don't i will have 1470 cals.

    Thank you for your advice i am grateful
  • santd
    santd Posts: 234 Member
    I must admit when i used to use MFP exercise calculations they were way over estimated. I had to save my own calculations when working out on the stationary bike, rowing machine, and treadmill is a lot lower but closer to the real figure. If you eat into their figures, you could be eating calories you haven't really burnt.

    when walking I use the 'walk' app on apple, which calculates a lot better than the MFP.
  • beautifulwarrior18
    beautifulwarrior18 Posts: 914 Member
    You're definitely not eating enough. I use the fitness frog measure and I eat around 2000 a day. Also, are you giving yourself rest days?

    And as far as counting exercise, I'd recommend buying a Heart Rate Montior. I have a polar FT4 on Amazon for $60.