We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

artificial sweetener?

fightdem
fightdem Posts: 38
in Food and Nutrition
Hey guys,

I wonder what does artificial sweetener do to your body/insulin. I've heard bad rumours about them, like coke with sugar is still better than diet coke with artificial sweetener. I have just realized that there're some sweeteners in my food. The thing is, i've been eating a lot to build muscle and bulk up. I eat clean everyday with high protein, high fat, low carbs. But in just a few days, my belly fat grows big. I know i've been eating a lot to build muscle and bulk up, but it's ridiculous if i can spot the difference in just a few days of calorie surplus. So please give me some explanation about this, is it just a normal process or is it the sweetener i've been using. Thanks before.

Replies

  • justjambo
    justjambo Posts: 20 Member
    If we need to add sugar to anything then we use agave syrup which has a low gi index. An alternative is stevia which we have but have never used yet.
  • jspicher81
    jspicher81 Posts: 26 Member
    Hi fightdem, great question!
    I just finished reading a book that mentioned this same example (diet coke vs regular coke) ... lm' going to paraphrase as best l can how l understood it. It mentioned that your body is "tricked" into thinking the artificial sweetener is real, and in preparation of the impending flood of sugar that it's expecting (after drinking a 20oz diet coke) it clears the deck and beings dumping/using up the glucose reserves in your body.

    The problem is that the "flood of sugar" never comes (as it's artificial sweetener) and now you're left with a glucose deficit which leaves your body needing something, anything to build up more sugar; and you're therefore left in a weakened state and more likely to do or eat something you probably shouldn't.
  • fightdem
    fightdem Posts: 38
    Hi fightdem, great question!
    I just finished reading a book that mentioned this same example (diet coke vs regular coke) ... lm' going to paraphrase as best l can how l understood it. It mentioned that your body is "tricked" into thinking the artificial sweetener is real, and in preparation of the impending flood of sugar that it's expecting (after drinking a 20oz diet coke) it clears the deck and beings dumping/using up the glucose reserves in your body.

    The problem is that the "flood of sugar" never comes (as it's artificial sweetener) and now you're left with a glucose deficit which leaves your body needing something, anything to build up more sugar; and you're therefore left in a weakened state and more likely to do or eat something you probably shouldn't.

    Thanks for the reply, no wonder i have the craving. I'll stop using sweetener, thanks !
  • jspicher81
    jspicher81 Posts: 26 Member
    Check out "The Willpower Instinct"
    http://amzn.com/1583334386

    It's a pretty good read, and explains how a lot of this stuff works.
  • craftywitch_63
    craftywitch_63 Posts: 829 Member
    I've been using Splenda regularly and I haven't noticed any problems. I track my blood sugar regulary and I haven't seen any radical differences between using sweetener and going without.

    I did a little experiment a few weeks ago. I took my fasting blood sugar, ate a tablespoon of sugar, then tracked my blood sugar for 2 hours. As could be predicted, my blood sugar went well over 200 mg/dL, and stayed there for quite some time, which was an increase of >100 mg/dL from baseline.

    The next day I repeated the experiment using Splenda (can't stand Truvia - it has a nasty, bitter aftertaste :sick: ) and my blood sugar stayed within about 20 mg/dL of baseline.

    This is in NO WAY meant to be taken as a scientific experiment, it's anecdotal at best, but at least I know the effects of artificial sweeteners, at least on my body, are minimal.

    :drinker:

    Edited to fix typo.
  • Jaxta65
    Jaxta65 Posts: 53 Member
    I've been using Splenda in tea for nearly 40 years. I only have sugar in the house for visitors. Don't even like the taste of sugar now. Obviously I eat foods with natural sugars. I tend to use honey if I want to sweeten something.

Categories