fitbit?

I had not heard of the Basis Band so I thought I would check it out. It is pretty cool (assuming it works as advertised) however it does NOT have a true HR monitor and if that is what you want - You would need to wear a HR monitor with a chest strap in addition to the Basis Band.

DC Rainmaker, a great site for activity tracker reviews, tested the Basis last year and came to the same conclusion--it doesn't track workouts well. The release of the Vivofit and Loop are game-changers.

http://www.dcrainmaker.com/product-reviews

They have 3 different ones right now not 2.

Not all phones will sync to it at all. Not even every iPhone will.

The One is better IMHO because you dont need to wear it on your wrist & therefore it will pick up every step...that's what it is designed for in the 1st place...not hand movements. It is easily hidden, not easily lost & the only time you need to charge it is when you are in the shower. It wont fall off your wrist, cause a rash, get dirty, look dirty.

I love my One.

not easily lost

"I lost my Fitbit One" is one of the more common messages over in the One forum. Mine got snagged on my seatbelt and fell out every few times I exited my car, despite facing it the correct way. I suspect it depended how "stiff" the pocket was on the pair of shorts/pants that it was clinging to. I located my lost One several times before I realized that all the time I was spending locating it could be better utilized.

In fairness, my girlfriend had better success, but then she used her bra strap!

I started with the FitBit Zip a month ago got so addicted to it that I used my Birthday money to upgraded to the One a couple of days ago so I can track stair climbing and sleep. Wished I'd gone with the One in the first place ~ I was able to get it for the same price as the Zip ~ Awesome little gadgets!

I have a Flex now and had a Fitbit One until I lost it playing soccer last fall. The Flex works for me because I run, play soccer and do lots of activities where the clip-on One would fall off (which is how I lost it).

For me, the most valuable part about the Flex has been sleep tracking. I learned rapidly that I wasn't getting enough and used it to help goad me into altering my nighttime habits.

-Tex

SoonToBeFitti said:

The wristband tracks your sleep, which is a great feature, you just have to remember to turn the option on.

What I noticed with the Flex was they tried to pack a lot of options into one small device, so you had to remember multiple "tap" sequences to turn things on and off. But one of the good things about it was it's silent alarm feature, and it's rechargable battery. Unfortunately the battery lasts three to four days at most, but it doesn't take long to charge.

Actually you don't have to remember to turn it on to track sleep. You can go into the phone app and then tell it from what time you started sleeping and ended sleeping and it will show how well you slept. If you forgot when you went to be or woke up you can just put a time you know for sure you were up for sure then look at when it shows the first time you went to be and about the time you got up. will be Red bars and then just change the time to those and it will only show the actual sleep you got.

As for the taps the only tap you have to remember is double tap. To show you the %of your step goal. The triple tap is to put it into sleep mode which you can just hit a button on your phone to enter sleep mode or just do as I previously said.

I have the Fitbit One and love it! I love that it's discreet and can be clipped anywhere (I usually wear it on my bra strap), and I also like that it has a display.

going to buy a fitbit one in a few minutes so excited.

I've had the Flex for almost a year now and love it. I wear it 24/7 except for the once a week charging (2-3 hours) and when my bird wants to sit on that arm because he's not a fan. I shower with it with no problem, I took it in a pool once - it's supposed to be water resistant to 10 meters but since it's not tracking steps while you're swimming, I don't see the point of wearing it in the water and don't. It's comfy, I forget it's there. I think it's more of what fits your particular likes, I like that I don't have to slip it on and off when I change clothes or shower, or go to sleep. That works for me. I have several colored bands so I change it each time I charge it and keep it fun (waiting for the new red one). I don't mind not having a display, either I'm at home near my computer and check the dashboard on the website or if I'm at work or out, I have the app on my phone and it's easy enough to access. I don't even tap it to see the dots during the day. I like what I refer to as my little fireworks display when I hit my 10K :happy: The alarm feature is great - anything that doesn't make shrill noises works for me. It's gotten me walking more. When I started I was lucky to do 3-4K a day, now I almost always hit 10K and try to get to 15K once a week (today). I added some people to the leaderboard so when I see someone just ahead of me, I find myself doing laps around the house to beat their numbers even though it's not a contest and it's all in my little brain I sync it to MFP but log everything here, just my preference.

Whatever you choose, do your research and make sure to use it and get a lot out of it. I think it's a great tool and definitely worth the investment.

The Fitbit One, I really enjoyed. It tracks steps and altitude well, although it's not so good at distance.Seeing in real-time how you're doing vs. your goals and friends is motivating. The awards, too!

The big knock is it's easily lost. The Fitbit Force tried to fix that, but was recalled for causing burns.

However, now that the Garmin Vivofit and Polar Loop are in the market, those are what I'd recommend. They not only measure your steps but also your workouts. At some point, most people transition from getting in a few extra steps to doing actual workouts (hiking, swimming, jogging, bicycling, yoga, weights). These can count your steps as you begin and keep pace as your needs become more advanced!

Distance is spot on if you set your stride up correctly & dont go with the default one.

As for the One being easily lost. I've had mine a year and a half and never once lost it, misplaced it or washed it by accident. People who lose it or whatever are just simply not taking care of an investment they paid for. You would not lose a bike. A car. Hell I've never even lost a mobile phone. People are simply careless.Force was never going to fix people doing stuff like that.

I clip mine to my underwear at the hip & not my pants. It never gets 'hooked' on anything & I'll assume everyone wears some form of underwear?

I have a FitBit Zip. LOVE it. When I first heard about/started thinking about step tracking, I came across the FitBit Force, then I read about the rash issue...if something can cause a rash, I will get that rash, so then started thinking about the Flex. I was really thinking I wanted a wrist band tracker. But then read that the Flex has no actual display, and didn't want to be "tied" to my phone to view the recorded info. Considered the One. Ended up getting the Zip...reasoning:
-The Zip IS less expensive...and I do not have many stairs in my life, so tracking stairs doesn't really matter to me.
-Zip doesn't track sleep....but I know I sleep, I sleep well, if for some reason I don't sleep well...I know that too....don't need a tracker to tell me that
-I don't wear a watch, and after having the Zip, realize that a wrist-worn tracker would drive me insane.
-Zip has a display...but I usually just look at the info on my app anyhow, so that was not an issue after all.
-Zip has an actual battery...I've had it for at least 2 months, sync with my phone often, and the battery is still showing as "full".

I washed my Zip about 2 weeks after purchase, it seemed to work fine but I exchanged it for a new one just in case since I still had the receipt.

Zip seems accurate....unless you are wearing it on a hard-tail motorcycle

I also have the FitBit Aria Scale, and love that the scale, FitBit app, and MFP apps all sync.

I really love my Fitb One. I don't want one on my wrist - for various reasons (too visable, I type at a computer all day with my wrist on the wrist-rest, etc.) . The One hides easily in my pocket.