Carby carbs carbssss, bleh

Is the 150 carb limit healthy? I just wanna make sure, cause if it is "pushing the carb limit" than I wanna make sure I don't go over.
«1

Replies

  • canadjineh
    canadjineh Posts: 5,396 Member
    I just like your topic title, lol!
  • : P
    Haha, ya
  • D:
    Does someone have an answer or personal experience.

    I dislike looking up stuff on google, I just find articles saying completely different things. Random studies and a bunch of "health experts" claiming lots of things for profit on their products.
  • bump
  • This content has been removed.
  • tycho_mx
    tycho_mx Posts: 426 Member
    for.... what?

    Before a meaningful bike ride, I eat about 100 g of carbs within 3-4 hours of riding. Then about 50 g carbs/hour. On a good day, that would be 250-300 g, not including "normal" meals. That still results in a caloric deficit and slow (but important) weight loss while avoiding impairing athletic performance.

    Lack of context makes any advice you get pretty meaningless...
  • ColdPlum
    ColdPlum Posts: 57 Member
    I would think if it more about percentage of your calories eaten. I like to eat low carb and have set my macros to have a goal of no more than 30% of my calories from carbs. You could go 80% if you wanted to. Lowest would be 20% (or 15% temporarily) It just depends on what kind of diet works best for you. You kinda just have to sort that out yourself.
  • _Zardoz_
    _Zardoz_ Posts: 3,987 Member
    for.... what?

    Before a meaningful bike ride, I eat about 100 g of carbs within 3-4 hours of riding. Then about 50 g carbs/hour. On a good day, that would be 250-300 g, not including "normal" meals. That still results in a caloric deficit and slow (but important) weight loss while avoiding impairing athletic performance.

    Lack of context makes any advice you get pretty meaningless...
    This
  • earth_echo
    earth_echo Posts: 133 Member
    Different programs vary, but for Atkins the first 2 weeks you aim for 20g/day (or less) and after that (Phase 2) carb count should be 60-80g/day.

    After you've eat low carb for a while, you'll know when you've overdone it. Some people handle carbs well, others don't.
  • jrose1982
    jrose1982 Posts: 366 Member
    I use this article for my carb level guidance.
    http://www.marksdailyapple.com/the-primal-carbohydrate-continuum/#axzz30tWMaFPQ

    Obviously, you can eat more carbs if you are very active, less carbs for the sedentary.
  • What carb limit are you talking about and who set it at that level?

    My food dairy put my carb intake at 150
    I didn't personally set it, it was just at 150 after joining.
  • I use this article for my carb level guidance.
    http://www.marksdailyapple.com/the-primal-carbohydrate-continuum/#axzz30tWMaFPQ

    Obviously, you can eat more carbs if you are very active, less carbs for the sedentary.

    Thank you, this was helpful <3
  • tracydr
    tracydr Posts: 528 Member
    I always have found that I seem to lose faster if I limit carbs. I decided this morning to get some protein powder and to start lowering my daily carb limit.
    I used to maintain or even lose pretty well with 20gms each meal, not counting non-starchy veggies.
  • ILiftHeavyAcrylics
    ILiftHeavyAcrylics Posts: 27,732 Member
    Depends on your goals. Right now I'm averaging about 200 carbs per day because I'm on limited exercise. Before I got hurt I was averaging closer to 300, because I needed the energy for workouts.

    The important thing to ask yourself is whether you're getting the right number of calories and enough fat/protein.

    http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/819055-setting-your-calorie-and-macro-targets
  • ILiftHeavyAcrylics
    ILiftHeavyAcrylics Posts: 27,732 Member

    DAMMIT! Too slow. :laugh:

    :flowerforyou:
  • pink_and_shiny
    pink_and_shiny Posts: 1,036 Member
    I totally hear this threat title in Ron Burgundy's "Scotchy scotch scotch..." voice.
  • I totally hear this threat title in Ron Burgundy's "Scotchy scotch scotch..." voice.

    XD nice
  • mickey9694
    mickey9694 Posts: 74 Member
    D:
    Does someone have an answer or personal experience.

    I dislike looking up stuff on google, I just find articles saying completely different things. Random studies and a bunch of "health experts" claiming lots of things for profit on their products.

    Personal experience. I lost about 34 lbs. in a lil under 3 months when my carb intake was under 30 grams per day. I ate a ton of fat and a moderate amount of protein, and was in ketosis. 150 grams would be a cheat day for me lol
  • D:
    Does someone have an answer or personal experience.

    I dislike looking up stuff on google, I just find articles saying completely different things. Random studies and a bunch of "health experts" claiming lots of things for profit on their products.

    Personal experience. I lost about 34 lbs. in a lil under 3 months when my carb intake was under 30 grams per day. I ate a ton of fat and a moderate amount of protein, and was in ketosis. 150 grams would be a cheat day for me lol


    I would love for that to happen, tho that seems a little fast. Did you have any trouble with keeping the weight off?
    Tho I don't think I could do that. I tend to eat fruit more than veggies. I need my banana and apple a day =w="

    I've already lowered my intake to 100. If I see progress I may lower it a bit more.
  • mickey9694
    mickey9694 Posts: 74 Member
    D:
    Does someone have an answer or personal experience.

    I dislike looking up stuff on google, I just find articles saying completely different things. Random studies and a bunch of "health experts" claiming lots of things for profit on their products.

    Personal experience. I lost about 34 lbs. in a lil under 3 months when my carb intake was under 30 grams per day. I ate a ton of fat and a moderate amount of protein, and was in ketosis. 150 grams would be a cheat day for me lol


    I would love for that to happen, tho that seems a little fast. Did you have any trouble with keeping the weight off?
    Tho I don't think I could do that. I tend to eat fruit more than veggies. I need my banana and apple a day =w="

    I've already lowered my intake to 100. If I see progress I may lower it a bit more.

    Didn't gain anything back. When I hit my target weight, I brought carbs back in and my weight stayed the same.
  • Depends on your goals. Right now I'm averaging about 200 carbs per day because I'm on limited exercise. Before I got hurt I was averaging closer to 300, because I needed the energy for workouts.

    The important thing to ask yourself is whether you're getting the right number of calories and enough fat/protein.

    http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/819055-setting-your-calorie-and-macro-targets

    Very true.

    With what I've read so far, I know going over 150 would make me gain. I'm just not active enough. I'm female, and I normally spend most my days writing or drawing, which takes very little movement. =A=" (tho I am adding walks to my routine which will eventually turn into jogs)

    Anyways thanks for the advice :)
  • jrose1982
    jrose1982 Posts: 366 Member
    I would love for that to happen, tho that seems a little fast. Did you have any trouble with keeping the weight off?
    Tho I don't think I could do that. I tend to eat fruit more than veggies. I need my banana and apple a day =w="

    I've already lowered my intake to 100. If I see progress I may lower it a bit more.

    It is easier to do it gradually. I started with a 20 g/day limit and found it difficult. This time I started at 50. For the first 3-4 weeks I was averaging 55-65 g/day. Then I easily reduced it to 40-50 g/day.
  • I would love for that to happen, tho that seems a little fast. Did you have any trouble with keeping the weight off?
    Tho I don't think I could do that. I tend to eat fruit more than veggies. I need my banana and apple a day =w="

    I've already lowered my intake to 100. If I see progress I may lower it a bit more.

    It is easier to do it gradually. I started with a 20 g/day limit and found it difficult. This time I started at 50. For the first 3-4 weeks I was averaging 55-65 g/day. Then I easily reduced it to 40-50 g/day.

    20 seems very low for me as well. I may do 50 g every other day, while the other days remain at around 100. The main issue is money XD

    I'm currently job hunting so I'm limited on what I can eat. My grandparents love to buy processed foods and rarely pick up whole grain food or any natural foods (since they eat out all the time). I'll spend at least a half hour in the kitchen figuring out a meal that won't be "too bad" lol

    Ex. I used cambells tomato soup today, with 1 cup noodles, plus 1 slice american cheese. That was the healthiest thing I could come up with lol but it still put me at 150 carbs >////<"

    Anyways, I'm rambling, thanks again for the advice.
  • This content has been removed.
  • jrose1982
    jrose1982 Posts: 366 Member
    20 seems very low for me as well. I may do 50 g every other day, while the other days remain at around 100. The main issue is money XD

    I'm currently job hunting so I'm limited on what I can eat. My grandparents love to buy processed foods and rarely pick up whole grain food or any natural foods (since they eat out all the time). I'll spend at least a half hour in the kitchen figuring out a meal that won't be "too bad" lol

    Ex. I used cambells tomato soup today, with 1 cup noodles, plus 1 slice american cheese. That was the healthiest thing I could come up with lol but it still put me at 150 carbs >////<"

    Anyways, I'm rambling, thanks again for the advice.

    Ouch, that's tough. You might try to get them to buy more veggies and less noodles or bread. Canned or frozen vegetables are not bad and have a long shelf life. So you might be successful with getting them to buy that. You can use spaghetti squash in place of pasta in most recipes, and it has a decent shelf life too.

    What you're doing isn't low-carb by any means, it's just lower carb than what most Americans eat. But drastically reducing pasta, bread, and sugar will get you pretty close to 100 g/day. I mention that because a lot of people think you're crazy if you say you're on a low-carb diet, so that might not convince your parents to help you. But if you tell them you're trying to eat healthier and need to eat more vegetables, they might be more willing to support you.

    You might also plan a few healthy meals and propose to your parents that you would like to cook them dinner once in a while, but you need their help buying the groceries. (And actually cook for them of course). That might also get them to buy better ingredients.

    Good luck!
  • tennisdude2004
    tennisdude2004 Posts: 5,609 Member
    Is the 150 carb limit healthy? I just wanna make sure, cause if it is "pushing the carb limit" than I wanna make sure I don't go over.

    If you love your carbs eat more - it's healthy
    If you're not too fussed about carbs eat less - it's healthy.

    As long as you are in a deficit you should loss weight.

    Carbs are a convenient fuel source but are not essential. 50 - 100g of carbs in veg and fruit should give you all the micro nutrients you need from carbs.

    Just make sure you're getting enough protein.
  • ILiftHeavyAcrylics
    ILiftHeavyAcrylics Posts: 27,732 Member
    Depends on your goals. Right now I'm averaging about 200 carbs per day because I'm on limited exercise. Before I got hurt I was averaging closer to 300, because I needed the energy for workouts.

    The important thing to ask yourself is whether you're getting the right number of calories and enough fat/protein.

    http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/819055-setting-your-calorie-and-macro-targets

    Very true.

    With what I've read so far, I know going over 150 would make me gain. I'm just not active enough. I'm female, and I normally spend most my days writing or drawing, which takes very little movement. =A=" (tho I am adding walks to my routine which will eventually turn into jogs)

    Anyways thanks for the advice :)

    I doubt that's true, assuming calories are in line. The only reason it would be is if you have a health issue like PCOS or insulin resistance. And if that were true hopefully you'd have told us in the OP.

    Strictly from a weight perspective, calories are what matters. You may find that a certain macronutrient ratio keeps you full longer (I need to eat a lot of carbs/fat to feel full, for example, other people find protein more sating) and that may help you stick to your calorie goal. I lost my first 30 lbs or so with almost no exercise and on a diet of mostly carbs. I did it that way because of health issues (and because I love carbs) and I wouldn't recommend it, btw, but it can be done.

    If you're thinking of taking up jogging I'd strongly recommend not dropping your carbs too low. They're already kinda low to me.
  • Eleonora91
    Eleonora91 Posts: 688 Member
    I used to be over with carbs when I started dieting because I am vegetarian and it happens often that I can't reach my protein or fat intake. It doesn't make any difference until you're within your calorie limit. The only difference will be that your macro ratios won't be exactly 50-20-30 or whatever you set them to be. Part of your calories will be coming from carbs instead of fats or proteins, but still, it doesn't make any difference on how you lose weight.
    Keto diets such as Atkins are just particular diet regimes and you are *not* obliged to follow them, you will always lose weight until you're in a calorie deficit. It's all about limiting your calories. I'd rather eat less fats than limiting my bread or sugars, but that's just me. Just find what suits you best, be consistent and you'll see a loss.