Getting kind of frustrated..
meg_balh
Posts: 37 Member
So (apart from yesterday) I have been eating pretty clean (my food log is open) and exercising for about two weeks now. I lost 8 lbs the first week and have now gained 4 of those 8lbs back. I have been going to the gym consistently and started weight lifting (kettleball classes and machines) along with cardio. I have a very physical job as a nurse aide (fitbit said I took 23,000 steps alone at work on sunday). WHY AM I NOT LOSING WEIGHT? or even worse, gaining it back? Is it really that I am just gaining muscle? I am definately sore the days after my kettleball classes. I also took measurements and they are the same as when I started. Is it just too soon to tell?
0
Replies
-
When you first start, as you saw, you can lose alot of weight from your body flushing out. You didnt lose 8 pounds of fat that first week, much would have been plain water weight, nor did you gain 4 lbs of fat/muscle when you started to exercise.
When you start to exercise more intensefly the muscles will retain more water to help function/rebuild.
Once you are on a more routine regimin of exercise you will start to see the weight go down even with that extra H20 in the muscles.
Stay with it with the exercise and eating better and it will all start to even out0 -
Weight loss will never be linear. Ever. As stated, you didn't lose 8 lbs of fat in a week, just like you didn't gain 4 lbs in a week. Water retention for muscle repair from picking up exercise, possible sodium intake could cause retention, whether or not you've had a good bowel movement all effect what the scale says.
You will not gain muscle in a deficit, nor would it be easy to do without a good amount of protein and solid resistance training program, even in a surplus. You can, however, gain strength, this is not the same thing as muscle building. So, don't worry about that.0 -
Are you weighing and measuring all of your foods and liquids?0
-
Looking through your diary, I noticed the following:
-You're over your daily sodium most days. You could be retaining water
-You appear to be using measuring cups. I see a lot of items with 1 cup, 1/2 cup, 1 tbsp. I recommend weighing your food. 1 cup of rice can vary by a LOT of calories. Food scales are more precise.
-From April 20th- May 5th, you were over your daily calories 11 days. That's 11/16 days. You're over your calorie goal 68% of the time.
In general:
-One week to one week is not enough time to see if you're gaining OR losing.
-When you lost weight, did you adjust your daily calories? I recommend adjusting it every 5 lbs. It will substantially drop your daily calories as you lose weight0 -
Two weeks isn't enough to see results. The 8 pounds the first week was likely a lot of water weight lost, and the 4 pounds the second week was likely water your body is retaining to help your muscles repair themselves. This is typical when you first start working out. Consistency is key.
Also make sure you're tracking accurately, which means using a food scale to weigh your portions. The other day you logged a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. It's really unlikely that entry is accurate. There are too many variables, such as the brand of bread you used and how much and what brand of peanut butter and jelly you used. It's much more accurate to track and log ingredients separately. It's a pain when you first start, but you get used to it quickly.0 -
This is fantastic analysis. Take what this user says to the bank, there's a lot of value in it0
-
If you're confident in your logging, this is probably just water retention due to implementing a new exercise routine. If so, the weight will come back off with a little time and patience.0
-
I guess what struck me with your diary was the sodium amounts - you exceeded the sodium every single day - when I do that, I retain water, ankles get swollen, and the scale reflects that0
-
Looking through your diary, I noticed the following:
-You're over your daily sodium most days. You could be retaining water
-You appear to be using measuring cups. I see a lot of items with 1 cup, 1/2 cup, 1 tbsp. I recommend weighing your food. 1 cup of rice can vary by a LOT of calories. Food scales are more precise.
-From April 20th- May 5th, you were over your daily calories 11 days. That's 11/16 days. You're over your calorie goal 68% of the time.
In general:
-One week to one week is not enough time to see if you're gaining OR losing.
-When you lost weight, did you adjust your daily calories? I recommend adjusting it every 5 lbs. It will substantially drop your daily calories as you lose weight
Nailed it0 -
As others have pointed out, the sodium is a big factor in water retention.So (apart from yesterday) I have been eating pretty clean (my food log is open)
Not positive what "eating clean" is in this instance (since it has so many definitions), but even nutrient dense foods ("healthy" foods) need to be monitored for caloric intake. Going over on calories is the same whether by eating an apple or eating potato chips (yes, it's easier to go over with one vs the other).0 -
Did you think you'd lose 8lbs a week every week until you reached goal weight? Two weeks is nothing in the grand scheme of losing weight. You didn't gain it all in two weeks. Give the process time, and every one offered great advice as far as watching sodium and weighing food. Stick with it, results will come.0
-
i had a quick look at your diary. If I had to take a guess after a quick cursory glance I would say you are retaining water now. In the past few days your sodium intake has been quite high. And truthfully a lot of foods on mfp that contain small amounts of sodium don't display it. So your actual sodium intake is probably higher than advertised. I'm guessing in the first week you had a few low sodium days prior to your weigh in and that caused you to flush a lot of the fluid out of your system. But now you are retaining it again.0
-
When you first start, as you saw, you can lose alot of weight from your body flushing out. You didnt lose 8 pounds of fat that first week, much would have been plain water weight, nor did you gain 4 lbs of fat/muscle when you started to exercise.
When you start to exercise more intensefly the muscles will retain more water to help function/rebuild.
Once you are on a more routine regimin of exercise you will start to see the weight go down even with that extra H20 in the muscles.
Stay with it with the exercise and eating better and it will all start to even out
^^ THIS!!0 -
You haven't been at it that long....0
-
In general:
-One week to one week is not enough time to see if you're gaining OR losing.
This is exactly why I normally try to lose weight/ eat right/ exercise FIRST on my own (not using MFP) for at least 10 days. Then, I start (again) back on MFP. I hate it when I see the initial loss (5 lbs) and the min I see the 1lb weight "gain" or whatever, I get anxious!0 -
A gallon of water weighs nearly 8 pounds, you are more than 50% water. You need patience and accuracy.0
-
DUMP THE SCALE. The fluctuations I used to see would literally piss me off after working so hard to eat healthy and exercise. I'd think I did great until I stepped on the scale only to see the numbers stay the same or worse-- go up. I blamed it on the scale -- went out and bought a $140 scale thinking that would make the difference... the only loss I saw was $140.
So, I decided to break up with the scale... I started out telling myself I'd give it a month... after 1 month, I'd weigh myself. When the month was up, I was afraid to. My clothes were beginning to hang loose, but I was afraid if I stepped on the scale, I'd see a number I didn't want to see... so I decided to wait until I had gone down an entire clothing size. Well, that day came and went and then decided I'd wait until I was a size 10... never wore a size 10 in my life (largest size I wore was a 26.... but this go-round of weight loss had me wearing a very tight size 18 -- did manage to lose some in the past -- got down to a size 12, but then got lazy).
One day, I slipped into a size 10 pair of jeans...wow.... decided I didn't care about the numbers on the scale anymore...decided to wait and see if I'd ever fit into a single digit size... took about 3 weeks, I think...and suddenly the size 10 was a little too loose...and amazingly I was now wearing a size 8.... 4 weeks ago, I bought my first pair of size 6 jeans. I don't know what I weigh... I am, by no means, too thin.... I know that someday I will have to step on the scale to see what that almighty number is... but for now, it doesn't matter. I am healthy, I am happy and I can honestly say I would probably not be where I am today if I didn't break up with the scale. For me, tracking my food on MFP was (and is) the best measure there is....
Try going a month without weighing and then see where you are....0 -
WHY AM I NOT LOSING WEIGHT? you are.
or even worse, gaining it back? you aren't
Is it really that I am just gaining muscle? absolutely not
I am definately sore the days after my kettleball classes. I also took measurements and they are the same as when I started. Is it just too soon to tell? yes
You've been at this for 2 weeks. You've lost 4 lbs total so far. That's 2 lbs a week. Pretty fast loss actually.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.7K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.2K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions