Are my calories off?
drwaddy
Posts: 50 Member
Hi everyone,
Ok, I started this new life change to finally conquer obesity about a month ago, just a little over.
In the last month I've only been using MFP to track my food for a little over 2 weeks, but my diet has stayed very consistent around the same amount of macros for a month.
Here is a bunch of math:
From what I have been able to gather from multiple sites, all of which have different numbers, but ultimately I just went with one which is IIFYM calculator using the calculations I got from other sites.
Supposedly I have the following:
TDEE = 3557
BMR = 2361
BMI = 46.24
Body Fat # = 47.80
I got that from using these measurements and facts:
Age = 28
Weight = 390lbs
Height = 6'5''
Waist size at your naval? 62 Inches
Waist size at narrowest point: 56 Inches
Hip size at widest point? 60 Inches
Neck at narrowest point? 20 Inches
Wrist circumference? 8 Inches
Forearm at largest point? 15 Inches
Given that, I have been told that I can eat 3120 calories a day and stand to lose 1 lb a week... as I should be creating an imbalance of ~500 calories a day, and assuming I only eat 2580 on Sunday, which would give me ~ 3500 calories a week below maintenance.
MFP says that I can east 3108 based on those calculations, so things seem to be consistent across all the calculators I'm using...
Again this site I'm sure assumes a lot, but it thinks I'm burning about 500 calories a workout, and when I go into the gym and I've been going for a machine or two I begin to look like I'm in the shower... I just pour sweat while I'm lifting, and I lift like crazy, not to mention I pant like a fat kid doing wind sprints...
I lift for 1 hour a day, 6 days a week, and here is my circuit:
Monday - Wednesday - Friday:
Bicep Curl = 90 Reps at 50lbs
Back Extension = 90 Reps at 170lbs
Calf Raises = 90 Reps at 230lbs
Pull Downs = 90 Reps at 90lbs
Row = 90 Reps at 90lbs
Ab Press = 90 Reps at 130lbs
Tuesday - Thursday - Saturday:
Tricep Extensions = 90 Reps at 50lbs
Hamstring Curls = 90 Reps at 110lbs
Fly = 90 Reps at 90lbs
Delts = 90 Reps at 50lbs
Squats = 90 Reps at 390lbs
Overhead Press = 90 Reps at 20lbs
Chest Press = 90 Reps at 50lbs
It takes me give or take an hour to get through both circuits doing 15 reps, then taking a small rest, then continuing until I've done 3 sets on each machine, then I repeat this.
So, we've established I'm exercising and I'm dieting... Based on what I've calculated I should be losing a pound a week and I should be down around 4 to 5 lbs total in my last month of effort.
Except I'm not down 1 single pound... I've gone up a pound in fact...
So, let's look at my macros:
In the last 16 days I have had the following macros:
Calories per day = 2684
Protein per day = 219 grams
Carbs per day = 190
Fats per day = 106
Let's assume that as consisted over the last month... That would mean I had created a deficit of 436 a day which means I should be down ~4 lbs
So, as I've written all this out I'm coming to the conclusion I've gained ~ 4 lbs of muscle / water that's offsetting what I've burned, or are my calories way off?
"Edit" I think I suck at math actually... I think the fact that I eat 2684 calories and are allowed 3100 means I'm down an additional 400 ish calories which should put me at around 1000 calories a day deficit from maintenance? I don't even know anymore /facepalm
Ok, I started this new life change to finally conquer obesity about a month ago, just a little over.
In the last month I've only been using MFP to track my food for a little over 2 weeks, but my diet has stayed very consistent around the same amount of macros for a month.
Here is a bunch of math:
From what I have been able to gather from multiple sites, all of which have different numbers, but ultimately I just went with one which is IIFYM calculator using the calculations I got from other sites.
Supposedly I have the following:
TDEE = 3557
BMR = 2361
BMI = 46.24
Body Fat # = 47.80
I got that from using these measurements and facts:
Age = 28
Weight = 390lbs
Height = 6'5''
Waist size at your naval? 62 Inches
Waist size at narrowest point: 56 Inches
Hip size at widest point? 60 Inches
Neck at narrowest point? 20 Inches
Wrist circumference? 8 Inches
Forearm at largest point? 15 Inches
Given that, I have been told that I can eat 3120 calories a day and stand to lose 1 lb a week... as I should be creating an imbalance of ~500 calories a day, and assuming I only eat 2580 on Sunday, which would give me ~ 3500 calories a week below maintenance.
MFP says that I can east 3108 based on those calculations, so things seem to be consistent across all the calculators I'm using...
Again this site I'm sure assumes a lot, but it thinks I'm burning about 500 calories a workout, and when I go into the gym and I've been going for a machine or two I begin to look like I'm in the shower... I just pour sweat while I'm lifting, and I lift like crazy, not to mention I pant like a fat kid doing wind sprints...
I lift for 1 hour a day, 6 days a week, and here is my circuit:
Monday - Wednesday - Friday:
Bicep Curl = 90 Reps at 50lbs
Back Extension = 90 Reps at 170lbs
Calf Raises = 90 Reps at 230lbs
Pull Downs = 90 Reps at 90lbs
Row = 90 Reps at 90lbs
Ab Press = 90 Reps at 130lbs
Tuesday - Thursday - Saturday:
Tricep Extensions = 90 Reps at 50lbs
Hamstring Curls = 90 Reps at 110lbs
Fly = 90 Reps at 90lbs
Delts = 90 Reps at 50lbs
Squats = 90 Reps at 390lbs
Overhead Press = 90 Reps at 20lbs
Chest Press = 90 Reps at 50lbs
It takes me give or take an hour to get through both circuits doing 15 reps, then taking a small rest, then continuing until I've done 3 sets on each machine, then I repeat this.
So, we've established I'm exercising and I'm dieting... Based on what I've calculated I should be losing a pound a week and I should be down around 4 to 5 lbs total in my last month of effort.
Except I'm not down 1 single pound... I've gone up a pound in fact...
So, let's look at my macros:
In the last 16 days I have had the following macros:
Calories per day = 2684
Protein per day = 219 grams
Carbs per day = 190
Fats per day = 106
Let's assume that as consisted over the last month... That would mean I had created a deficit of 436 a day which means I should be down ~4 lbs
So, as I've written all this out I'm coming to the conclusion I've gained ~ 4 lbs of muscle / water that's offsetting what I've burned, or are my calories way off?
"Edit" I think I suck at math actually... I think the fact that I eat 2684 calories and are allowed 3100 means I'm down an additional 400 ish calories which should put me at around 1000 calories a day deficit from maintenance? I don't even know anymore /facepalm
0
Replies
-
Bump0
-
Is this new exercise you are doing? I have to assume yes...if so any new exercise will create water/glycogen stores in your muscle which mask weight loss...
This can take a couple weeks...up to 6 weeks...for that to settle down and you have a Whoosh...where you lose a large amount of weight.
http://www.bodyrecomposition.com/fat-loss/of-whooshes-and-squishy-fat.html
As well if you are lifting and due to your weight you could be gaining muscle...*first time I've got to say that*
the other factor is your logging..it doesn't appear you weigh all of your food..that is key to logging accurately...that being said you have a margin of error larger than most...
Don't stress out too much you are on the right path as far as I can see...just be patient...0 -
Yeah, I started the exercise on april 10th, and I've gained very noticeable muscle... Like, I know it sounds stupid but I think I would be ripped if I was 10% body fat...0
-
Since it is new exercise you will get the whoosh etc. and the scale weight will come down.
It's great you started weights now as opposed to later..often time people wait (like me) and say things like "gosh I wish I had started this from the start"...
you will lose more fat, less muscle and be better for it.
Congrats on your start btw...you will do great.0 -
It's great you started weights now as opposed to later..often time people wait (like me) and say things like "gosh I wish I had started this from the start"...
And me0 -
Are you taking measurements? If not, you should be. It's not unusual to lose inches but not scale weight, and vice versa.
Usually, we'd tell people to give any changes a solid month before making any more, but it sounds like you've done that. I'd recommend weighing all your food for another 2-3 weeks and see what happens. I'd bet you'll get past the initial water retention and see a big loss within that time.0 -
Also, since you're new to lifting, you're in the perfect position to see some newbie muscle gain. Take advantage of them! I'd stay at a moderate deficit for awhile, keep your protein nice and high, and keep lifting. That window doesn't last forever, so please don't do anything crazy like drastically reduce your intake. If you continue to see small scale losses but you start losing inches, this is probably what's happening (you'll be gaining a small amount of muscle and losing fat).0
-
Also, since you're new to lifting, you're in the perfect position to see some newbie muscle gain. Take advantage of them! I'd stay at a moderate deficit for awhile, keep your protein nice and high, and keep lifting. That window doesn't last forever, so please don't do anything crazy like drastically reduce your intake. If you continue to see small scale losses but you start losing inches, this is probably what's happening (you'll be gaining a small amount of muscle and losing fat).
I know right lucky guy...*very jealous here*:bigsmile:0 -
Also, since you're new to lifting, you're in the perfect position to see some newbie muscle gain. Take advantage of them! I'd stay at a moderate deficit for awhile, keep your protein nice and high, and keep lifting. That window doesn't last forever, so please don't do anything crazy like drastically reduce your intake. If you continue to see small scale losses but you start losing inches, this is probably what's happening (you'll be gaining a small amount of muscle and losing fat).0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.9K Introduce Yourself
- 43.9K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 429 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153.1K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 15 News and Announcements
- 1.2K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions