yoga as strength training?
Options
Replies
-
- holding Chaturanga dandasana is very good for core strength and definitely engages chest, triceps and rhomboid muscles as well as the whole of the posterior chain.
edit: post redefinition.0 -
Look up Forrest Yoga on YouTube. If that's not strength training, nothing is.0
-
It most certainly counts as resistance training if you are doing any forms that use your body as a weight or involve resistance like the plank for example.0
-
Strength training is about progressive loading, so as long as you're continuously striding toward a more difficult pose it is. If you're just following a routine out of a book, a video or whatever, then not so much.0
-
The term "strength" training tends to get used as a catch all for anything that involves resistance and/or engaging your muscles...in reality, "strength training" is a real thing...not all resistance work is "strength training" even though you may make some strength gains, you have to actually train specifically for strength to be "strength training."
That said, yoga is a very good exercise and very good for you and pretty much everyone should incorporate it into a well balanced fitness regimen.0 -
I lifted and was a marathon runner for years. While this made me "fit", it wasn't until I started practicing yoga that I became toned and picked up flexibility, balance and stress reduction. I know I am far stronger now because of yoga. Do a hand stand for three minutes and tell me that's not strength training. The real key is you will only continue any form of exercise if you enjoy it. If you enjoy yoga, do that. Namaste.0
-
The term "strength" training tends to get used as a catch all for anything that involves resistance and/or engaging your muscles...in reality, "strength training" is a real thing...not all resistance work is "strength training" even though you may make some strength gains, you have to actually train specifically for strength to be "strength training."
That said, yoga is a very good exercise and very good for you and pretty much everyone should incorporate it into a well balanced fitness regimen.
Hi - do you mean that strength training is something you do specifically focussed on gaining strength - be it weights or progressive bodyweight training - whereas the strength you may gain through something like progressively more intense/difficult yoga is more a side benefit?0 -
I have been told continuously that weight training is the key to keeping your metabolism going and holding on to your muscle. Does yoga serve this function well? Anyone have experience with this? I hate lifting weights but find yoga pleasant, challenging, and relaxing.
Im going to go out on a limb here and say No, yoga does not count as strength training, unless you do the dance pose with a 10lb weight in your hand and another one strapped to your foot lol yoga helps tremendously when incorporated into strength training if you use it before and after you may find weights easier and more enjoyable.
^^^^^^^ This0 -
I have been told continuously that weight training is the key to keeping your metabolism going and holding on to your muscle. Does yoga serve this function well? Anyone have experience with this? I hate lifting weights but find yoga pleasant, challenging, and relaxing.
Im going to go out on a limb here and say No, yoga does not count as strength training, unless you do the dance pose with a 10lb weight in your hand and another one strapped to your foot lol yoga helps tremendously when incorporated into strength training if you use it before and after you may find weights easier and more enjoyable.
I disagree here. It may be that my response is biased as I was taught how to exercise using my body weight in place of barbells, but it is possible. When I lost weight and started working out, i found myself with a six pack - never having picked up a barbell/dumbbell/resistance training machine in my life (thus far....i did start using them later on). If you do positions in which you're balancing/holding a large amount of your body weight, that surely helps as you're forced to hold up however many pounds you weigh. In yoga, your body mass = your barbells
In terms of the different types of yoga, there are plenty and you should check them all out to find one that suits you! There is one or two specifically for fitness that you may want to look for.
Like people have mentioned, lifting is a bit different than yoga, but in the end they both build muscle.0 -
I do yoga, and I lift heavy...I like them both. But no, yoga isn't strength training. It definitely helps, I love the core movements and being stronger in yoga has helped me be stronger in the weight room, but you still need to deadlift and squat yoga is perfect for the "in between" days, and to just let your stress go. There is power yoga, or hot yoga, but I still wouldn't think it's comparable to weight lifting. You aren't going to get "buff" by lifting weights, you're not a man, and even men have a hard time bulking.
Agreed. Before I started lifting weights I certainly felt that yoga qualified as strength training, and I suppose it is to a point where you use body weight to strengthen yourself, but compared to the strength gains that have come from lifting weights, they are definitely not equal for making you stronger. That being said, I feel like they complement each other nicely so I do both.
OP, if you aren't sold on weight training, then stick to yoga. It certainly does have it's strengthening merits, and it's good for the soul. But I would encourage you to research weight training. It won't make you look "buff" or too muscly, unless you start taking testosterone or steroids.0 -
It depends on your goals as well. If your intent is to BUILD muscle, you are not going to do that with Yoga. If you just want to "strengthen" body parts with no real definition....then yea, go for Yoga.0
-
0
-
These are some really excellent points. I guess I'm not too worried about "buffing" up. I do like the points that were made for improving strength vs. general health and maintenance. I think for now, since it's challenging enough, I'll stick to yoga. It's easily available for me without a gym membership and added equipment.0
-
It depends on your goals as well. If your intent is to BUILD muscle, you are not going to do that with Yoga. If you just want to "strengthen" body parts with no real definition....then yea, go for Yoga.
I agree with this to a point. You would not expect to build a great deal of muscle mass, but you would see some real definition, especially as excess fat is burned off, revealing existing muscle.0 -
Yoga combines strength conditioning, balance, and flexibility. All yoga classes are not created equal. We have some extremely challenging yoga classes at my gym that incorporate heavy elements of strength training.0
-
depends on the practice.... challenging vinyasa/power yoga...yes.0
-
For someone who has never done yoga before, which workout is the place to begin?0
-
For someone who has never done yoga before, which workout is the place to begin?
I started body building, and honestly started yoga because i was so freakin' sore after lifting weights. Now I lift every other day, and yoga every other day, and my DOMS seemed to have calmed down. Some of the stretches feel so good lol It doesn't matter what you start with, they're both beneficial in their own respect.0 -
0
-
0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 391.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.5K Getting Started
- 259.7K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.6K Food and Nutrition
- 47.3K Recipes
- 232.3K Fitness and Exercise
- 393 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.7K Motivation and Support
- 7.8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.3K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 938 Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.3K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions