Sugar cravings - how do you cope?
Replies
-
You have issues with binge eating, not sugar.
And the two are completely unrelated? Wrong, at least for some people. Binge eating is not psychological at all in my experience; rather, one of many symptoms of malnutrition/disordered metabolism.
OP: the only way I cope is that I don't eat added sugar at all and I limit natural sugars. I have zero sugar cravings when I'm barely eating any sugar. The first week or two of cutting the sugar is not much different than coming off of drugs, unfortunately, but it can be done. Or you can just struggle for years trying to use moderation and willpower as many here will advise... which was a big fail for me. Glad I found a better way.0 -
Werther's Original Sugar Free does the trick!0
-
Wow! This is one of the BEST threads of responses I have seen in awhile! I love it. All of it is actually really good advice. There is a lot too!
Moderation
Sugar Free
Distraction
Water
Natural Alternatives
and the impossible - don't eat it at all.
Everyone is different and I can see each working for someone.
I applaud your attitude that this is a life-style change and not a diet to drop and go back to your ways. In that case think of weening off the worst offenders. Use the scare tactics people mentioned. Watch the videos that tell you what is really in this junk food. I like to browse Pinterest for fitness tips when I am craving. Seeing all the work-out options and fit people really makes me realize what I am working for.
I also use fat to substitute. I will have 1 serving of nuts and drink like 16oz of water to get the full feeling. I find that fat cuts the craving. I also pick out healthier choices to use at times when I know I will want sugar. If I get a 4pm craving I save a piece of fruit and eat it. The greek yogurt and fruit is great too!
I also make a chocolate smoothie for less then 300 calories with frozen banana that you would never know is a complete meal unless I told you. Tastes like something from an ice cream shop.
Vega One Chocolate (soy and whey free meal shake powder mix)
Ghiradeli Cocoa powder (1tsp)
Chia Seeds 1tsp soaked (for a 10 min about) in 1 cup of non-dairy drink (unsweetened- like almond of coconut milk)
1/2 frozen banana
Few cubes of ice
Blend till smooth
Personally I love sugar. The healthier the meal... the harder the craving hit after. I think keeping nothing that will trigger a binge, and only things that are 200 cal or less satisfying chocolate helps.
I also avoid ALL Sugar-free items because I find it sends my cravings through the roof. I mean from 10-1000! That's me personally.
Best of luck and keep at it.0 -
Moderation. It does sound like you are really just emotional binge eating though. What a horrible thing for your husband to say, just before he went away for work, I can only imagine what you might be doing with that comment in your head. I have dark chocolate nearly every day. 4 Squares. 136 calories. I can fit it into my day easily. It fits my macros. I enjoy it. I don't have to give it up... if I'm sensible.0
-
What helps for me a little bit of something sweet with hot skim milk. A latte in the morning with sugar free vanilla syrup and hot milk with chocolate flavour Ovaltine as my bedtime snack. I started with almost 2 tablespoons of Ovaltine and have gradually whittled it down to 2 tsp. Really helps keep those sweet cravings at bay for me, plus will eat a small amount of dark chocolate once a week or so. Also a small amount of a dessert if it looks really great, and is homemade. I find saying no to myself makes the cravings stronger.0
-
I drink cocoa with 1/2 stevia packet.
I don't think that moderation is going to work for you.
Clean out all the junk out of your home.0 -
I agree.....it toke me about two weeks of not eating any sugar (white flour) to finally not crave for it.
Unfortunately, after three months of reading that it doesn't matter where the calories come from only how many I burn. I decided to allow myself one day a week of eating the foods I was not eating (dark chocolate w/salt, Oreo cookies, pizza, etc). I stay within my calorie burned when I do this.
PROBLEM .......I am now struggling with the cravings. I am not feeling as good as I was. My energy level has decreased. I am not losing the same amount of fat.
As of tomorrow, I am not eating anything white again. Hopefully, I can last two weeks again.
My advise.....if it matters....struggle with the addiction for two weeks. You won't have the terrible cravings.
As for your husbands comment, Ummmmmm....I'll be nice.....good thing he is going to be gone for a while. Don't worry about what he said. Worry about you. Take this time to evaluate what you want. Take the time to decide what is the best for you (diet, exercise). Join a gym. Join a group of other dieter. See your doctor, nutritionist, etc.
Good luck......If you want a friend to struggle with....I'm here0 -
>I don't think you should stay away from sugar. I'm firmly in the moderation camp. If you deny yourself something you love, when you break down and eat it (which is inevitable, IMO), you'll binge on it.
This has not been my experience. If I avoid things, then when I have them, maybe I'll have two instead of one, but I won't go all out.
That's why I said IMO
It's what I do, so my opinion is based on my experience
0 -
I also make a chocolate smoothie for less then 300 calories with frozen banana that you would never know is a complete meal unless I told you. Tastes like something from an ice cream shop.
Vega One Chocolate (soy and whey free meal shake powder mix)
Ghiradeli Cocoa powder (1tsp)
Chia Seeds 1tsp soaked (for a 10 min about) in 1 cup of non-dairy drink (unsweetened- like almond of coconut milk)
1/2 frozen banana
Few cubes of ice
Blend till smooth
This sounds like a great substitute! I may have to experiment with making something similar with what I have laying around.0 -
As for your husbands comment, Ummmmmm....I'll be nice.....good thing he is going to be gone for a while. Don't worry about what he said. Worry about you. Take this time to evaluate what you want. Take the time to decide what is the best for you (diet, exercise). Join a gym. Join a group of other dieter. See your doctor, nutritionist, etc.
Everyone has made really good points about the binge eating. I don't think I've ever looked at it that way, but you're probably right. I look at what/when I eat and it's usually when I'm bored or I feel like I've "deserved" it somehow (long day at work, etc).
Don't be too hard on my husband. I started getting healthy because of a medical issue, so I'm definitely in this for me. His comment came several weeks into my weight loss journey and was in context of a larger conversation about how we're living our lives. We foster some pretty open communication in our marriage 0 -
I am about eight weeks into trying to lose about 50 lbs. Before deciding it was time to get healthy, I would eat sugar like it was going out of style. It didn't seem unreasonable to eat an entire bag of Oreos over a two-day period. Cookies and dark chocolate are what really gets me. Honestly, I've never learned how to eat healthy, so the last eight weeks have been a HUGE change for me. I've been slowly trying to incorporate fruits and vegetables and other whole foods into my diet, but there are many years of bad habits to undo.
For the first six weeks or so I was doing a reasonable job of staying away from the sugar. Sure, I'd slip up once or twice a week, but generally I was able to not binge too bad.
Then one day last week I just HAD to have these double-chocolate cookies from Safeway. They tasted like heaven. Now every day since then it's been something. York peppermint patties, Skittles, Starbucks pastries, and last night, the killer: an entire box of those original amazing cookies. I didn't eat all of them (I think that would have killed me), but I wanted to. I ate three (900 calories!) and felt physically sick to my stomach. This morning I was snacking on yet another one (yes, after I felt so horrible last night!) before I stepped on the scale and there it was...
I was up a pound and a half from my lowest weight, which I recorded on Monday. 20% of my progress undone because I just can't seem to put down the sugar. I don't want to log this weight. I want to get rid of it and continue making progress toward a healthier, more fit me.
Part of my problem is that my husband left last week until September for work. It's easier to eat right and exercise when you have an "audience," particularly when that audience has helpfully told you recently that you're too fat to be attractive. (Which is the truth so, while it's bugged me a bit, has been good motivation.) But honestly the bigger problem is years and years of giving in to myself whenever I had a sugar craving.
So, what do you suggest to put an end to the sugar habit? I bought myself some "healthy alternatives" in the form of Fiber One brownies and Healthy Choice fudgesicles, but at the end of the day I think those just encourage the cravings. If you've sat all the way through this novel of a post, I hope you'll be able to give me some advice!
I don't think you should stay away from sugar. I'm firmly in the moderation camp. If you deny yourself something you love, when you break down and eat it (which is inevitable, IMO), you'll binge on it.
Allow yourself a treat a day - like an oreo or two, or a mini snickers, or a small bowl of ice cream. Just make sure it fits into your calorie goals. Try to get prepackaged stuff, so you're not staring at a large bag of stuff you really want.
If you feel you cannot do the above due to lack of self control, then I don't think you've actually decided to lose the weight. I know that sounds harsh, but you if you're going to change your lifestyle, you're doing to have to have self control.
Also - make sure you're doing this weight loss stuff because YOU want to, not because your husband says you're too fat.
*****THIS!****0 -
Sweet fruit like strawberries, watermelon, and honeydew. Not much in the way of calories, but they do take the edge off of my sweet tooth nicely. There's also the aforementioned gum and Crystal Light. You will find that the less refined sugars you eat, the lower your tolerance for them becomes. But, you will be less sluggish and more alert.
Now if I could only do something about my diet soda addiction.....0 -
I want to let you know that I have had the same issues as you have. You have an addiction and it needs to be treated that way. First of all I would not suggest you carry around anything sweet because what happens is you will eat it and it will start your binge eating. You have to get rid of all the sweets in your house. It's no different than drugs or alcohol and it needs to be treated that way. I can tell you this. I would wake up wanting sugar so badly that I would convince myself to just eat a little bit of sugar. Then it would start and when I was done I would feel so guilty. I knew I couldn't control it and cutting out sugar is the hardest thing I have ever done. You are not lazy or stupid or weak. I am very successful and have control over everything in my life but sugar kicked my butt and when I would binge eat it was like I was a different person. I would easily eat more calories binging for an hour than I did in food the previous two days combined. If I ate a cookie I would have to eat the entire row so the other cookies wouldn't get lonely. I loved food and I rationalized that I was just a big boned person. I just tried to accept who I was and to be honest I knew I was lying to myself. I tried every diet that is under the sun because I didn't want to lower my calories or the high I got from eating. It became a hobby of mine to try different diets. I am sure you have experienced some of the things I have and I want you to know that your not alone. I want you to know that your beautiful and smart. You can beat this as soon as you start treating this like an addiction. Food addiction is actually the worst worldwide epidemic in history. Give yourself a break because if you get the right people in your life who can help you and give you support then you can beat this. You can do it and I for one believe in you. Please friend me and I will help you as much as I can. I will do my best and I won't let you down and I wont judge you. Take care. Midas0
-
Ive dealt with this for YEARS. I'm a sugar addict..HARDCORE. The ONLY thing that works for me, is to keep it out of my eyesight. MY thing is once i start thinking about it if I see it, I obsess over it until I eat it. Its gotta stay out of my house. Then I'm good!0
-
i dont have one0
-
I think a lot of times you have to go cold turkey. I say that because you can't "dwindle" down sweets when you're used to eating them...its like trying to smoke less each day...much harder in my opinion. I'm not saying you can't have anything sweet, but I think you should make a goal and say "For one week I won't eat any refined sugar" and after that week you can treat yourself IF you really want it. Then once you have that make a goal of another week. I found substituting coffee whenever I get a sweet craving works WONDERS...if you like coffee, maybe try it out...not too late at night though, eheh.0
-
Second the notion of making a smoothie. I make a smoothie that is about 430 calories, often it is one of my meals.
It has
2 tbsp cocoa
1.5 cups unsweetened almond milk
4 cubes of ice
2 tbsp almond butter unsalted
1 banana
1 tbsp of honey
I've aways had a big sweet tooth as well, It is sweet but does not have tons of sugar, and to me it feels like I'm having a big desert, plus its filling because of the almond butter.
Drink one of these instead of the half bag of Oreos. You may find it takes care of the craving, and has far less calories and sugar than the half bag of oreos.0 -
Think of sugar like a drug. Sugar is basically crack of the food world. It is very addictive. You have a little, you want more. Every time you let yourself have one oreo, you are going to want to eat 5 more. So best course of action, have no oreos. Also I highly recommend against "healthy" alternatives. There is nothing healthy about a FiberOne bar, and if you check the nutrition label, I bet they have as much sugar as the oreoes. A better snack would be fresh fruit (cherries and grapes are in season) or celery with peanut butter (sugar free of course).
It also sounds like you might be eating out of boredom or stress. When you are eating not because you are hungry, but to satisfy some other craving, ask yourself if it's really worth it. Ask yourself why you want to eat - are you bored, tired, angry? Then find another way to deal with it. Usually no matter what the emotion is, a 5-10 minute walk can help distract you. When I'm at work I often have sugar cravings in the afternoon. Rather than reach for the candy bowl, I take a lap around the building.
One thing that helped me break my sugar habit was doing a 14-day no sugar challenge. After two weeks without having any added sugars in my diet it was easier to resist. You can sign up at http://fedupmovie.com/#/page/home and they will send you daily tips and reminders to keep accountable.
Another thing that sometimes helps me, make a cup of herbal fruit tea and sip that instead. Keeps your mouth busy without the sugar.
Definitely agree with this!!! I came to realize that I eat out of boredom as well. To get that under control I started making tea when I would end up in the kitchen instead of pulling out a snack. Works well for me and I buy tea often!!0 -
I control my sugar cravings by not depriving myself. If I deprived myself of sugar all together, I'd go insane and binge. I reward myself every night with a tablespoon of mini chocolate chips. It may not seem like a lot, but if you eat them one at a time, they actually last quite a while. It keeps me from craving things like chocolate chip cookies and all my other weaknesses 0
-
Bump.0
-
Get "The Sugar Diet" from Prevention magazine (Prevention.com). Get deluxe (expanded?) edition as has more tables etc. Rodale is the mother company and publisher. It recommends a complete removal of sugar from diet then adding back as treat but even if you don't do that it really opens your eyes to what is going on.0
-
If Im absolutely craving some chocolate, (I dont tend to keep it in the house now as I cant resist- sugar is as addictive as heroin!) I have to walk to the shop to get it, but now I buy a mini bar instead of a full sized bar. But now I extend my walk and do a couple of laps around the block, so by the time I get home, Ive already burnt off the chocolate.
Snacking at night used to be my biggest downfall but now filling up on high protein dinners like quinoa, tofu and soy sauce with veg, I find Im not even remotely hungry, and if I do think out of habit 'Id like some chocolate', I ask myself how hungry I actually am. The answer is usually zero. Or I have some frozen orange juice ice cubes, which taste delicious, give you a mini sugar fix, and have very few calories, as they are squeezed from actual oranges, not processed juice.
Also thinking 'Ive eaten well today, I dont want to ruin that for a temporary high of eating crap, when I know 100% that tomorrow I will regret it when Im stepping on my scale', and 'processed food is full of chemicals and crap that shouldnt be consumed, why would I put that in my body?', are both powerful mantras for me.
The cravings do go away after a few days of no sugar, and if you do have a binge, be kind to yourself and know that you can start again, youve already done it, and get back on the wagon.
Good luck!0 -
Consider trying to stay under 25g of sugar a day. Sugar is addictive and the more you "treat" yourself, the more you will crave it. Allow yourself one cheat meal a week to have your sugar, but this should not be a daily thing. When you do get a sugar craving try reaching for nuts or cheese.0
-
One of the things that I've taken to doing is buying the Thinsations treats. They're 100 calories per bag, and it gives me the satisfying feeling of finishing the whole bag, while still only eating 100 calories. So long as you don't eat the entire box in one sitting, it still gives you that sweet (or salty, depending on what you get) taste without allowing you to go overboard with calories.
I have a small container that I toss in my bag when I go to work (for a snack in addition to lunch) I can fit sweet and salty bagged snacks in there and I can only have what fits in the box (usually like 2 bags or a bag and a bar) Sometimes I eat them all - sometimes I don't eat any of it.
Plus, I eat and log them before I go to the gym after work, so I can think better about how many empty calories I'm consuming.0 -
As for your husbands comment, Ummmmmm....I'll be nice.....good thing he is going to be gone for a while. Don't worry about what he said. Worry about you. Take this time to evaluate what you want. Take the time to decide what is the best for you (diet, exercise). Join a gym. Join a group of other dieter. See your doctor, nutritionist, etc.
Everyone has made really good points about the binge eating. I don't think I've ever looked at it that way, but you're probably right. I look at what/when I eat and it's usually when I'm bored or I feel like I've "deserved" it somehow (long day at work, etc).
Don't be too hard on my husband. I started getting healthy because of a medical issue, so I'm definitely in this for me. His comment came several weeks into my weight loss journey and was in context of a larger conversation about how we're living our lives. We foster some pretty open communication in our marriage
Emotinal eating, comfort foods. I think a big part of the problem isn't so much the sugar and it's chemical/physical properties, but your mental relationship with food. (don't take this as a negative criticism - I do this too). We develop a relationship of sorts with certain foods that make us happy, and then when you cut them out we are left with nothing to fill the void, and the longer we just push and try to deprive ourselves, the more lopsided it gets, and then we cave and binge.
The key is to try and find other things that make you happy that will fill the void - this will take some effort and retraining yourself. Instead of cookies, maybe find a chewing gum you like - if you must eat or chew on something, or find some other low calorie alternative in case you can't resist a binge, or start finding activities you can use to fill the void.
It's the habit of making ourselves happy with food that we need to work on - and it can be tricky, because eating does make most people feel good, and it's readily available.0 -
If I'm hungry, but don't know what exactly what I want, I:
a) write more than 100 words, if possible
b) go for a walk / workout
c) take a nap0 -
My grandma controls her sugar cravings by eating granola cereal mixed in sugar free cool-whip, Portioned correctly, it makes for a nice snack. You can add fruit, more nuts, or eat it the simple way. I'm not sure how many calories and all is in it, but it's worked wonders for her.0
-
Lots of great pointers here, and I'm also in the moderation camp bc, I have some serious sugar cravings too. For me it's hormonal, and I know that.
I think a few other people said it but I am seconding the motion that Greek yogurt with fruit and I add a few nuts and that usually sates the craving. It kind of tastes like a sunday, kind of.
What also works for me is making my own treats with stevia or another low GI sweetener and experimenting on how to make sweets with less of the bad stuff and more off the good stuff. You can even make sweetener from ground up dates, and make some pretty tasty guilt free treats.0 -
Nuts..
I buy a big bag and put them in 30g lots in little snaplock bags. When the sugar/cookie/chocolate cravings gets so bad Im about to cave, I eat the nuts with a glass of water. Works a treat every time.0 -
When I see all that good stuff at the grocery store, as much as I want it, I just keep walking. The receptionist at work has a candy dish on the counter and I limit myself to one or two little candy bars a day (under 100 cal). That satisfies me enough, because I can't not have sugar.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions