Cardio & Calorie question...
Pretty_Little_Loser
Posts: 38 Member
Hi all! This is my first forum topic so please bear with me...
My trainer ( an ex-body builder/weightlifter guy) told me yesterday that i should only be doing 1/2 hour of cardio a max amount of 5 times a week. Is this true? I feel like I don't "do enough" or sweat it out enough if I don't do cardio for an hour. Maybe its just a mental thing?
What do you all do? I see ladies on here that do two hours of cardio a day...
I'm 38 years old, 5'4" started out at 240.6 and in 6 weeks have lost 20 pounds (220 now). I have a fitbit One and track my steps to keep me moving through the day. I am somewhat sedentary during the day (desk work) but get up and move about quite a bit though I don't work a sweat or move fast or carry heavy things.
I'm also a bit mixed up about the calorie intake that MFP says here. My daily goal is 1340 and I'm more than satisfied at that goal but I worry that it is too low as I get lower in pounds, will it make it more difficult to lose? For the activity level on MFP - I have it set to "lightly active" with a gym goal of 5 X a week for 1 hour each. On my weight lifting days I do feel more hungry so i eat back some of my calories up to 1500-1600 for the day total. Do you eat back your cardio calories?
I just don't want to sabotage myself down the road if I am doing something wrong now. I want to lose 100 pounds by next summer/ end of next year.
Thanks for any advice! Please don't persecute me for my lack of knowledge!
Love and Blessings to you all!
My trainer ( an ex-body builder/weightlifter guy) told me yesterday that i should only be doing 1/2 hour of cardio a max amount of 5 times a week. Is this true? I feel like I don't "do enough" or sweat it out enough if I don't do cardio for an hour. Maybe its just a mental thing?
What do you all do? I see ladies on here that do two hours of cardio a day...
I'm 38 years old, 5'4" started out at 240.6 and in 6 weeks have lost 20 pounds (220 now). I have a fitbit One and track my steps to keep me moving through the day. I am somewhat sedentary during the day (desk work) but get up and move about quite a bit though I don't work a sweat or move fast or carry heavy things.
I'm also a bit mixed up about the calorie intake that MFP says here. My daily goal is 1340 and I'm more than satisfied at that goal but I worry that it is too low as I get lower in pounds, will it make it more difficult to lose? For the activity level on MFP - I have it set to "lightly active" with a gym goal of 5 X a week for 1 hour each. On my weight lifting days I do feel more hungry so i eat back some of my calories up to 1500-1600 for the day total. Do you eat back your cardio calories?
I just don't want to sabotage myself down the road if I am doing something wrong now. I want to lose 100 pounds by next summer/ end of next year.
Thanks for any advice! Please don't persecute me for my lack of knowledge!
Love and Blessings to you all!
0
Replies
-
Hello and welcome. Half an hour 5 times a week is enough for most people I will agree with that. I'm not sure your trainers reasoning behind that statement is though the fact he's a weightlifter etc makes me think he just doesn't like cardio I have heard some people say before such things as too much cardio and you'll not lose weight. We all know this to be true with all those fat Distance runners and professional cyclists ;-). I run more than an hour most days it's not stalled my loss I would always take anything any trainer says with a pinch of salt a lot of them seem to come out with most bizzare un proven nonsense
The thing with exercise the best thing to do is something you enjoy and can keep up. If you want to do more than 30 minutes do so as long as your eating enough and your not overdoing it great.
As for your calories goals the best thing to do is look at this thread this will help you set up sensible goals. Also make sure you eat at least a portion of your exercise calories back to fuel what you're doing in the gym
Follow the linky and good luck
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/1175494-a-guide-to-get-you-started-on-your-path-to-sexypants?hl=guide+to+sexypants&page=1#posts-183615940 -
For cardio, I think the recommended minimum is 30 minutes x 5 days a week for heart health. Beyond that, its up to you. Of course a body-building guru is against cardio.
I use a Fitbit One - LOVE it - and MFP. I log all food, water in MFP. I have a set a total daily burn goal (and increase every now and then) and make sure I move enough between regular activity & Cardio that Fitbit shows me hitting this #. It incorporates my BMR, which is roughly 1 calorie per minute, so if I'm within 180 calories of my burn goal by 9pm, I know I'll hit my target.
I explained that, to explain this: my current total burn goal is 2150 per day. I typically eat between 1400-1600 which gives me a 500 calorie deficit and a little extra to spare. Which I like, as I know Fitbit may be 'off' in my total burn estimation. And though I try not to, I may make errors in my calories in. So I like having this cushion.
As you get smaller, and fitter: your body will naturally burn less calories doing the same activity. You can increase intensity, or fit in more activity to make it up. And in time as you get closer to your goal - you'll probably need to drop your deficit. I plan to go to a 250/day deficit starting in August.0 -
I typically workout between 30/45 min a day, so if it's a cardio day, I make sure I PUSH myself for that amount of time. I mean, there are people who walk for 2 hours a day, which technically is cardio, and I know for some, that is a big effort. For me, I make sure that I am going as hard as I can for that shorter amount of time, and when that gets easy, I make it harder. I try to beat my run times every time I run, at least by a few seconds (I'm still slow as hell). So, I guess the point is, there's nothing wrong with 30 minutes if it's an intense 30.0
-
I explained that, to explain this: my current total burn goal is 2150 per day. I typically eat between 1400-1600 which gives me a 500 calorie deficit and a little extra to spare. Which I like, as I know Fitbit may be 'off' in my total burn estimation. And though I try not to, I may make errors in my calories in. So I like having this cushion.
Wait - you have a negative net calories every day?!0 -
I explained that, to explain this: my current total burn goal is 2150 per day. I typically eat between 1400-1600 which gives me a 500 calorie deficit and a little extra to spare. Which I like, as I know Fitbit may be 'off' in my total burn estimation. And though I try not to, I may make errors in my calories in. So I like having this cushion.
Wait - you have a negative net calories every day?!
I think she means TDEE.0 -
I think she means TDEE.
Thank goodness! Was really worried there for a sec!0 -
The incredible shrinking woman!0
-
My trainer ( an ex-body builder/weightlifter guy) told me yesterday that i should only be doing 1/2 hour of cardio a max amount of 5 times a week.My daily goal is 1340 and I'm more than satisfied at that goal but I worry that it is too low as I get lower in poundsDo you eat back your cardio calories?0
-
It's complete bull****. Do what you want to. I am a distance runner who dropped 110 pounds. I LOVE to run and I lift twice a week. Find your own goals. You don't "have to" do any cardio or any exercise for that matter to lose weight.0
-
Do you have your loss set at 2lbs/week? I was losing 1-1.5 lbs per week at 1900-2000 (net) when I weighed 220 lbs.
You could probably eat more and ensure you don't lose as much muscle if you aimed for a slower weight loss.0 -
Depends on your goals... When I wanted to drop the weight fast I did the weight lifting and worked my way up to 1 hour of cardio a day 6x a week. Excess cardio messes with muscle build though so after I hit my goal weight then I dropped down to 30 minutes of cardio a day 4-5x a week. Nothing will drop weight faster than cardio and you need at least 20 minutes to get into the fat burning zone. After that first 20 minutes or so most of what you burn is being fueled by fat so the longer you go after that the better!0
-
My trainer ( an ex-body builder/weightlifter guy)
Here's where you can search for people in your area who are certified by the American College of Sports Medicine:
http://members.acsm.org/source/custom/Online_locator/OnlineLocator.cfmtold me yesterday that i should only be doing 1/2 hour of cardio a max amount of 5 times a week.
If you want to lose, you might have to do twice that.
Have a look at the "exercise" post on my blog.
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/blog/MKEgal
From the CDC (http://www.cdc.gov/healthyweight/physical_activity/index.html)
"To maintain your weight: work your way up to 150 minutes of moderate-intensity aerobic activity, 75 minutes of vigorous-intensity aerobic activity, or an equivalent mix of the two each week."
(The page explains moderate & vigorous.)
"Most weight loss occurs because of decreased caloric intake. However, evidence shows the only way to maintain weight loss is to be engaged in regular physical activity."I'm 38 years old, 5'4" started out at 240.6 and in 6 weeks have lost 20 pounds (220 now).
At 5'4", the top end of a healthy BMI range would be 140 pounds.
So you have 80 lb to go.
Again from the CDC:
"evidence shows that people who lose weight gradually and steadily (about 1-2 pounds per week) are more successful at keeping weight off ...
To lose weight, you must use up more calories than you take in. Since one pound equals 3,500 calories, you need to reduce your caloric intake by 500-1000 calories per day to lose about 1-2 pounds per week."
http://www.cdc.gov/healthyweight/losing_weight/index.html
So you should aim to hit your goal weight in no less than 40 weeks, up to 80.I want to lose 100 pounds by next summer/ end of next year.My daily goal is 1340 and I'm more than satisfied at that goal but I worry that it is too low
1340 is within the acceptable range, you'd be losing a bit more than a pound a week.
Currently you need 2200 cal to maintain your weight at 220 lb.
To lose 1 lb a week, you should be at 1700 cal per day.
For 2 lb, 1200 cal (which is the lowest you should go without a doctor monitoring you).
Or you could eat 1400 calories (which would maintain you at 140 lb) and that will slowly but surely bring you to 140 lb.as I get lower in pounds, will it make it more difficult to lose?
So you'll have to up the time, or the intensity, of your exercise, &/or reduce your calories.Do you eat back your cardio calories?0 -
Nothing will drop weight faster than cardio
In fact, do weights every other day at most. Some people have 2 days in between.
Again, have a look at my blog post about exercise. Toward the bottom it explains the difference in what you should be doing (re: weightlifting) depending on whether your goal is to increase muscle mass or endurance.
As a woman, don't worry that you're going to be bulking up. Unless you put lots of effort into it, or use drugs, you're not going to be grossly over-muscled like body builders.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions