Do crunches work?
geeky1
Posts: 142 Member
If yes, how many is recommended? If no, what IS recommended to give great looking abs (where you have lines on each side)?
0
Replies
-
crunches work only if you dont have a large layer of fat over your stomach
concentrate on shifting the fat and do crunches as well and you will see results. Do 10000 crunches and if you dont shift any fat you wont see any results.
depending on what you do you can do them once a week to 3 times a week. 20-30 minute sessions. You need to find atleast 10 good ab exersices which you rotate round so your routine will be varied. you dont only need to do crunches0 -
Low bodyfat=see them abs!0
-
YES cruches do work. I say start off with what your body can handle but as long as the routine is effective for you. I have been doing an 11 minute ab workout everyday for 2 weeks and I SEE the results and my abs starting to take shape and change..
It's like with anything else you begin you have to start gradually and build your self up. You may not do as many reps as someone who has been working on abs for a long time. I had to keep in mind that I have to go at my own pace so I dont overdue it. I stopped comparing myself to someone else's sucess and soley focus on my own goals.
YOU CAN DO IT!!!0 -
Most people if they have been working their abs correctly over a number of months have fantastic set of well formed abdominal muscles. However, they will never be visible because of a layer of fat covering them as the last poster said. All the crunches in the world won't change that.
Work on reducing BF% if you want to see your abs. As it is not possible to spot reduce fat you have to work on lowering your overall BF% across your whole body. As a general rule of thumb women will start noticing their abs (the lines as you say) at about 20% with noticeable separation at about 18% and under.
The abs have a number of functions including protecting internal organs and providing core stability. However one of their principal functions is to bring the rib cage closer to the pelvis. Anything which provides that type movement will isolate the muscles and work them. This is why crunches work. However don't forget that the abs do not simply include the rectus abdominis (the ones in the middle.) They also include other muscles but particularly the oblique and transverse abdominis (the ones at the side) To work them on the basis of what was previously discussed you need to adopt a twisting motion from side to side. Unsuprisingly a twisting ab crunch works them effectively.
Next rep range. This is the subject of debate. However, my view that abdominal muscles are just that, MUSCLES. They should be worked like other muscles as a result. Doing hundreds of crunches at high speed will do very little but mimic a cardio workout and place excessive reptitive strain on your spine. Clearly not a good thing. In my opinion a lower rep range where you perform the exercise s-l-o-w-l-y through the full range of motion with good form is preferred For "big" exercise where the spine is supported such as bench press or DL a low rep range is up to about 4- 8 reps. With abs because your spine is enaged and in motion anything from 12 - 20 should be enough and considered "low."
Now, rest time. As with your muscles this is very important. My opinion is if you have worked hard enough then you should allow at least 48 hours before working your abs DIRECTLY again. So if you do crunches to work your rectus abdominis on Monday, don't do them again until Wednesday. There's nothing to stop you working alternate ab muscles on alternate days though. Eg crunches on Monday and side bends on Tuesday.
Finally, there's nothing wrong with exercising your abs INDIRECTLY every day through running or weight training exericse which involve core use. In fact that is beneficial as a strong core has numerous health benefits. In fact, it is possible to have a good set of abs without ever doing a single specific ab exercises due to this. However, your BF will need to be sufficiently low to see them as said right at the very beginning.0 -
Low bodyfat=see them abs!
Is there a certain percentage where they become more visible?
n/m msf74 answered my question
0 -
Even if you DO have fat covering your abs doing crunches before you lose all the weight works! No reason NOT to do the crunches even if you are fat! A strong core is necessary in so many ways. Then as the weight comes off you have some definition already.0
-
Everyone is different. For most women, you need to get in the 12-14%.Low bodyfat=see them abs!
Is there a certain percentage where they become more visible?
n/m msf74 answered my question
0 -
Even if you DO have fat covering your abs doing crunches before you lose all the weight works! No reason NOT to do the crunches even if you are fat! A strong core is necessary in so many ways. Then as the weight comes off you have some definition already.
That was what I was hoping for. I know that I have still a lot of weight to lose, so I want to start doing the exercises which will make great shape for later when the body fat is not so obvious. I knew someone who has a lap band and is losing the weight without exercising; there is loose skin and a not great shape happening. I want the end result to show what I have been working on along the way, if that makes sense?0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 398.2K Introduce Yourself
- 44.7K Getting Started
- 261K Health and Weight Loss
- 176.4K Food and Nutrition
- 47.7K Recipes
- 233K Fitness and Exercise
- 462 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.7K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153.5K Motivation and Support
- 8.4K Challenges
- 1.4K Debate Club
- 96.5K Chit-Chat
- 2.6K Fun and Games
- 4.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 12 News and Announcements
- 21 MyFitnessPal Academy
- 1.6K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 3.2K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions



