Do I look like I've lost that much weight?
ladyoflucky13
Posts: 41 Member
Hello,
Second post ever. Anyhow, I have been losing weight for like 5 years now very slowly on and off. Since I've lost slowly, I'm not having that much of an issue with motivation or dealing with the lifestyle change because I know I'm going to just keep going (although I did recently get a Bodybugg and am hoping it will help me speed up my progress a bit). However, when I look at how much I've lost and look at myself in the mirror, I just don't feel like I've changed that much. Even when I compare pictures and my clothes sizes before and now, there doesn't seem that much of a difference considering I've lost over 100lbs so far. Has anyone else who has been very heavy felt this way? I mean, I still seem to be able to reasonably fit into most of the clothes I wore when towards my heaviest. I'm not in danger of falling off the wagon or anything, but it can be a bit of a downer sometimes. It would be nice to hear from anyone else who has had this issue.
Here is a picture comparing when I was about 340ish (as I was getting to my heaviest) to now that I'm about 245. To me it looks more like a 40lb weight loss than 100lb. What do you think?
Second post ever. Anyhow, I have been losing weight for like 5 years now very slowly on and off. Since I've lost slowly, I'm not having that much of an issue with motivation or dealing with the lifestyle change because I know I'm going to just keep going (although I did recently get a Bodybugg and am hoping it will help me speed up my progress a bit). However, when I look at how much I've lost and look at myself in the mirror, I just don't feel like I've changed that much. Even when I compare pictures and my clothes sizes before and now, there doesn't seem that much of a difference considering I've lost over 100lbs so far. Has anyone else who has been very heavy felt this way? I mean, I still seem to be able to reasonably fit into most of the clothes I wore when towards my heaviest. I'm not in danger of falling off the wagon or anything, but it can be a bit of a downer sometimes. It would be nice to hear from anyone else who has had this issue.
Here is a picture comparing when I was about 340ish (as I was getting to my heaviest) to now that I'm about 245. To me it looks more like a 40lb weight loss than 100lb. What do you think?
0
Replies
-
It's hard to compare your body because the pics are taken at different angles. Try taking a pic with the same angle as your before shot. I can definitely see a difference in your face. Great job.0
-
It's hard to compare your body because the pics are taken at different angles. Try taking a pic with the same angle as your before shot. I can definitely see a difference in your face. Great job.
^Agreed with the above.
OP, what kind of exercise routine are you doing?0 -
The loss is clear, especially in your face but I can also see it in your legs,wrists, fingers. & midsection. I completely understand where you are coming from. I started at 365 & am down to 300 & usually don't feel like I can see much of a change but when I look at pictures from a year ago the difference is clear. My tops, shirts, blouses & dresses all still fit but are a bit looser, I have had to buy new pants though as they started falling off.
I think that when we loose weight slowly we don't notice it as much & also we expect to look the way we did the last time we weighed that amount but time changes our bodies & what I looked like at 300 lbs 8 years ago & what I look like at 300 today are very different. I am trying to focus on other things like new shapes & muscle definitions that I am seeing in my arms & legs & shoulders instead of clothing sizes & over all appearance.
You look great & congratulations !0 -
You can see the loss in your face, and I bet you feel very different and hopefully happier/healthier!
In the future, you would probably be able to judge better with more form-fitting clothes, although you may not be comfortable with that. Loose fabric can hide your true shape.
Good luck with your journey, and congrats!!!!
:flowerforyou:0 -
When I started losing weight it was by diet alone. Over the last 3.5 years or so I started going to the gym and doing 20-30m a couple times a week to where I am now able to go 5-6 times a week for 1.5-2hrs. I had a fling with weight training for a while, but had to stop both because of a knee issue (that really flares up with lower body work) and I hurt my shoulders a few months back when my arms slipped on one of those standing ab raise things where you raise your legs up while your arms are at a 90 degree angle. So I am now doing mostly cardio, but am hoping to start weight training again eventually.0
-
It's immediately noticeable. If you told me you lost 100 lbs I wouldn't really question it; it looks like you've lost around that.0
-
you can def tell you look GREAT !!!!!!
0 -
Agreed that there is enough difference in the angle of the photo that it's not a great comparison. Additionally, the black pants in the first photo completely hide the shape of your legs, so tough to compare there as well. Based on the loss you can tell from your face and wrists, I'd bet if you were standing more sideways in the 2nd picture we'd see a tremendous shrinkage in your stomach compared to the first.0
-
Thank you everyone. I've mostly been a lurker, but it is really nice to get positive feedback. I guess I will have to start posting more often. 0
-
When I started losing weight it was by diet alone. Over the last 3.5 years or so I started going to the gym and doing 20-30m a couple times a week to where I am now able to go 5-6 times a week for 1.5-2hrs. I had a fling with weight training for a while, but had to stop both because of a knee issue (that really flares up with lower body work) and I hurt my shoulders a few months back when my arms slipped on one of those standing ab raise things where you raise your legs up while your arms are at a 90 degree angle. So I am now doing mostly cardio, but am hoping to start weight training again eventually.
Honestly, try to get back into weight training, even if it is body weight stuff for awhile while you build up strength and heal.
From personal experience, I cut my calories aggressively and was dependent on just cardio. This meant that I was losing the scale number, but not so much the inches (mostly because the scale loss included a lot of muscle mass). Even though I lost 60lbs, I only dropped 3-4 sizes. It seemed like it should have been a lot more so after some floundering about, I started focusing more on strength training. Even though I stayed at the same weight, ended up dropping 2 sizes.
Maybe once you get a few months in with strength training, your body composition will improve even as you continue to lose the body fat. I'd also make sure you are getting adequate protein. Doing these two things will help minimize the muscle mass loss and help with your body composition. 0 -
You look wonderful.
I would not guess that you had lost 100 lb. But I also would not guess that you weighed as much to begin with. If I had to guess I'd say you were around 290 and now 230, without knowing your height or anything.
I bet you move so differently and more freely, which makes a HUGE difference in the way you look and feel as well as how you're perceived by others. Congratulations on your amazing progress!!!
ETA: I just went back and reread your post and I wanted to add that I have also been losing sort of slowly since 2008 from a high weight of 307 (128 lb so far but it took me 4-5 years to lose the first 45 lb). So we have something a little bit in common there!! I also wanted to tell you that I wore the same clothes from 307 down to the 230s-240s before I finally saw a major change and HAD TO buy new clothes. And after that the changes came much more quickly with regard to clothing cuts, styles, and sizes. Now it's every 15 lb or so.
I wish you the best!!! Slow and steady wins the race :-)0 -
Yeah even though the angle isn't the same I can definitely tell. Your face, wrists, and upper half of your body is a lot smaller than what it was. Your doing fantastic! Keep up the good work!0
-
I do feel like I must be losing my weight in places that aren't as visible and relevant to clothes sizing, like my feet (really see my veins there a lot more), lower arms, lower calves, etc. I do think it is a good idea to get back into weight training to help maintain muscle mass, although I think I need a bit more time before my shoulders don't hurt/pinch so much when I do upper body lifts (tried about a month ago and it was still fairly painful). Of course, whenever I lift, I aim to lift for bulk (I always think that way I'll be adding/maintaining muscle as much as possible) using heavy weight and low reps. I suppose I can focus on lower weight and higher reps until I can handle the heavier lifting again.0
-
I do feel like I must be losing my weight in places that aren't as visible and relevant to clothes sizing, like my feet (really see my veins there a lot more), lower arms, lower calves, etc. I do think it is a good idea to get back into weight training to help maintain muscle mass, although I think I need a bit more time before my shoulders don't hurt/pinch so much when I do upper body lifts (tried about a month ago and it was still fairly painful). Of course, whenever I lift, I aim to lift for bulk (I always think that way I'll be adding/maintaining muscle as much as possible) using heavy weight and low reps. I suppose I can focus on lower weight and higher reps until I can handle the heavier lifting again.
What about keeping to the lower reps/higher weight but trying different variations (maybe even dumbbell variations too) of the exercises to see if they might not aggravate you as much?
But then again, not sure what you mean by higher reps.
If you are sticking with 8-12 that could help with endurance while still focusing on hypertrophy?0 -
I am just a hair under 5'8". I have to look up how to reply to and quote specific posts...0
-
I am just a hair under 5'8". I have to look up how to reply to and quote specific posts...
If you look at the options under each post, you'll see the quote button (don't press reply). That will allow you to quote and respond to a specific poster 0 -
I am just a hair under 5'8". I have to look up how to reply to and quote specific posts...
If you look at the options under each post, you'll see the quote button (don't press reply). That will allow you to quote and respond to a specific poster
Nice. Thank you.0 -
What about keeping to the lower reps/higher weight but trying different variations (maybe even dumbbell variations too) of the exercises to see if they might not aggravate you as much?
But then again, not sure what you mean by higher reps.
If you are sticking with 8-12 that could help with endurance while still focusing on hypertrophy?
I tried different things, but I felt like I was improving my strength best by putting the weight high to where I could do just about 3-4 reps (not super great form on some moves, but not awful either), then drop the weight 5-15lbs at a time depending on exercise and doing as many reps as possible at the new weight, and continuing that kind of process for about 4-5 sets (form getting better as the weight dropped). Generally, I didn't usually go over 8 reps for most exercises. I think I had seen this training referred to as a reverse pyramid at some point.
Edit: Of course, I suppose while my shoulders are healing I can aim for the 8-12 rep range with lower weight. I imagine I've definitely lost strength in the months I have only done cardio. It is probably going to be a little sad to see the lower weight when I lift, though.0 -
What about keeping to the lower reps/higher weight but trying different variations (maybe even dumbbell variations too) of the exercises to see if they might not aggravate you as much?
But then again, not sure what you mean by higher reps.
If you are sticking with 8-12 that could help with endurance while still focusing on hypertrophy?
I tried different things, but I felt like I was improving my strength best by putting the weight high to where I could do just about 3-4 reps (not super great form on some moves, but not awful either), then drop the weight 5-15lbs at a time depending on exercise and doing as many reps as possible at the new weight, and continuing that kind of process for about 4-5 sets (form getting better as the weight dropped). Generally, I didn't usually go over 8 reps for most exercises. I think I had seen this training referred to as a reverse pyramid at some point.
Edit: Of course, I suppose while my shoulders are healing I can aim for the 8-12 rep range with lower weight. I imagine I've definitely lost strength in the months I have only done cardio. It is probably going to be a little sad to see the lower weight when I lift, though.
That's a pretty cool method. Are you planning on following a program? Or did you follow a program before? Or just made one on your own?0 -
What about keeping to the lower reps/higher weight but trying different variations (maybe even dumbbell variations too) of the exercises to see if they might not aggravate you as much?
But then again, not sure what you mean by higher reps.
If you are sticking with 8-12 that could help with endurance while still focusing on hypertrophy?
I tried different things, but I felt like I was improving my strength best by putting the weight high to where I could do just about 3-4 reps (not super great form on some moves, but not awful either), then drop the weight 5-15lbs at a time depending on exercise and doing as many reps as possible at the new weight, and continuing that kind of process for about 4-5 sets (form getting better as the weight dropped). Generally, I didn't usually go over 8 reps for most exercises. I think I had seen this training referred to as a reverse pyramid at some point.
Edit: Of course, I suppose while my shoulders are healing I can aim for the 8-12 rep range with lower weight. I imagine I've definitely lost strength in the months I have only done cardio. It is probably going to be a little sad to see the lower weight when I lift, though.
That's a pretty cool method. Are you planning on following a program? Or did you follow a program before? Or just made one on your own?
I had looked up a lot of different methods and experimented until I found what I felt worked best for me. I never really felt like lifting 10-12 reps was really building the muscles the way I wanted (didn't really see big increases in the amount I could lift). By starting with high weight, low reps I felt like I was hitting that strength/bulk range while still dropping it down to where I could have good form and all of the assisting muscle groups would still get hit well. I didn't want to just always aim for the heavy weight, low rep either for fear of being like some of the guys I've seen at the gym using lots of momentum and having horrible form for all their sets because they go as heavy as possible the whole time.0 -
Also, it is entirely possible that quite a bit of the fat you lost was in the invisible kind. The stuff that worms its way between your organs and makes for people who "Carry it well." Never thought that was a bad thing until I saw a scan comparison that displayed a person with fat all over the place, and then after mass loss. After that.. damn.. I don't want to wear it well, I don't want to "wear" it at all anymore, well, no more than is necessary for a healthy life. 0
-
Also, it is entirely possible that quite a bit of the fat you lost was in the invisible kind. The stuff that worms its way between your organs and makes for people who "Carry it well." Never thought that was a bad thing until I saw a scan comparison that displayed a person with fat all over the place, and then after mass loss. After that.. damn.. I don't want to wear it well, I don't want to "wear" it at all anymore, well, no more than is necessary for a healthy life.
I have definitely thought about that. Even though I am still quite heavy, I am sure I'm much healthier internally. I remember reading about how bad fatty livers are and how even morbidly obese people can fairly quickly improve it by entering a caloric deficit for a period of time. I certainly hope my liver and insides are looking hotter now.
0 -
What about keeping to the lower reps/higher weight but trying different variations (maybe even dumbbell variations too) of the exercises to see if they might not aggravate you as much?
But then again, not sure what you mean by higher reps.
If you are sticking with 8-12 that could help with endurance while still focusing on hypertrophy?
I tried different things, but I felt like I was improving my strength best by putting the weight high to where I could do just about 3-4 reps (not super great form on some moves, but not awful either), then drop the weight 5-15lbs at a time depending on exercise and doing as many reps as possible at the new weight, and continuing that kind of process for about 4-5 sets (form getting better as the weight dropped). Generally, I didn't usually go over 8 reps for most exercises. I think I had seen this training referred to as a reverse pyramid at some point.
Edit: Of course, I suppose while my shoulders are healing I can aim for the 8-12 rep range with lower weight. I imagine I've definitely lost strength in the months I have only done cardio. It is probably going to be a little sad to see the lower weight when I lift, though.
That's a pretty cool method. Are you planning on following a program? Or did you follow a program before? Or just made one on your own?
I had looked up a lot of different methods and experimented until I found what I felt worked best for me. I never really felt like lifting 10-12 reps was really building the muscles the way I wanted (didn't really see big increases in the amount I could lift). By starting with high weight, low reps I felt like I was hitting that strength/bulk range while still dropping it down to where I could have good form and all of the assisting muscle groups would still get hit well. I didn't want to just always aim for the heavy weight, low rep either for fear of being like some of the guys I've seen at the gym using lots of momentum and having horrible form for all their sets because they go as heavy as possible the whole time.
*nods* Form is top priority.
In regards to reps - (and this is usually for the main lifts as accessory work can lead to the rep range being a bit wider/higher)
1-5 reps tends to focus on strength with a bit of hypertrophy.
6-12 tends to focus on hypertrophy (which sounds like you might be aiming more for) with secondary focus on strength. Also, the higher you'd go in the rep range would also help with endurance.
15+reps is cardio/endurance.
So sticking closer to the 6-8 rep range could be better for you while allowing you to do the lift weight you want while working on your body composition goals as well as with helping with endurance a bit.
Are you following a program that lays out the exercises? Bodybuilding.com has a great exercise database if you need to find variations on certain lifts that might be easier as you get back into things.0 -
Oh and I wanted to put this link in here for you:
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/groups/home/10118-eat-train-progress
It's to the Eat Train Progress group here on MFP. It's run by Sidesteel and Sarauk2sf. They are really helpful, knowledgeable people and if anything, the stickies they have are worth reading through even if you don't join the group.0 -
ETA: I just went back and reread your post and I wanted to add that I have also been losing sort of slowly since 2008 from a high weight of 307 (128 lb so far but it took me 4-5 years to lose the first 45 lb). So we have something a little bit in common there!! I also wanted to tell you that I wore the same clothes from 307 down to the 230s-240s before I finally saw a major change and HAD TO buy new clothes. And after that the changes came much more quickly with regard to clothing cuts, styles, and sizes. Now it's every 15 lb or so.
I wish you the best!!! Slow and steady wins the race :-)
Trying to bold for the first time. This is the sort of experience I was hoping to get some insight into. I definitely hope that the change in size will start happening quicker as I continue to lose weight. Thank you for sharing this. Congratulations on your progress. Hopefully, I'll be following you soon. 0 -
Oh and I wanted to put this link in here for you:
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/groups/home/10118-eat-train-progress
It's to the Eat Train Progress group here on MFP. It's run by Sidesteel and Sarauk2sf. They are really helpful, knowledgeable people and if anything, the stickies they have are worth reading through even if you don't join the group.
Thanks for the link and information. I will definitely take some time to peruse this.0 -
Congrats on the progress, OP.
Nearly everything I'd want to say has been said already, except...
...I really like your attitude to the feedback you've gotten in this thread. So many times, people get ultra-defensive when people offer opinions that may not be exactly what they wanted to hear. I don't have any studies to support this, but I have to believe that this kind of reasonableness and positive attitude will be remarkably valuable assets as you continue making progress. Best of luck. :flowerforyou:0 -
1-5 reps tends to focus on strength with a bit of hypertrophy.
6-12 tends to focus on hypertrophy (which sounds like you might be aiming more for) with secondary focus on strength. Also, the higher you'd go in the rep range would also help with endurance.
15+reps is cardio/endurance.
It has been a while since I actually looked up which reps do what, but this is why (when I originally planned it out and saw the numbers) I liked starting our with 3-4 reps and going up. It seemed like I hit both strength and hypertrophy as I went along. Although, I am making the assumption that you can hit both ranges and make progress on both. In reality, especially on a calorie deficit, I'm not sure how far my gains could have/can really go. I was only about two months into my reverse pyramid routine when I hurt my shoulders. I may have just been experiencing the "newbie gains" phenomenon.0 -
I'm having the same issue. I've lost over 50 pounds and am down a couple pants sizes... yet NO ONE outside my immediate family has noticed any change! I've also taken one picture a month, in the same clothes, same angle, etc., and I can't see a difference at all! (In the mirror, in profile, I can see a change.)
But!! That's not stopping me. I feel better, I have more energy, and I know it's just a matter of time before the changes start showing. I'm in this for the long haul, whether anyone ever notices or not! It used to be too daunting to think of this process lasting 2-3 years or more, but now... it doesn't matter. Tracking my food is my new normal. I've realized that basic math and science applies here: Eat fewer calories, lose weight.
Thanks to all of you. This thread has been encouraging.0 -
I'm having the same issue. I've lost over 50 pounds and am down a couple pants sizes... yet NO ONE outside my immediate family has noticed any change! I've also taken one picture a month, in the same clothes, same angle, etc., and I can't see a difference at all! (In the mirror, in profile, I can see a change.)
But!! That's not stopping me. I feel better, I have more energy, and I know it's just a matter of time before the changes start showing. I'm in this for the long haul, whether anyone ever notices or not! It used to be too daunting to think of this process lasting 2-3 years or more, but now... it doesn't matter. Tracking my food is my new normal. I've realized that basic math and science applies here: Eat fewer calories, lose weight.
Thanks to all of you. This thread has been encouraging.
Thanks for sharing. I definitely get the feeling that it takes a lot more pounds of loss when you are heavy to actually lose the dress sizes than when you get smaller. I am also not going to let it discourage me. I know I am getting healthier and there is nothing more important than that. I want a long, healthy life ahead of me and even if it takes another 5 years to get into the healthy weight range, it will be worth it for the rest of my life.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions