We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

I need help!is it the correct workout for burning fat?

tysthebest
tysthebest Posts: 10
edited February 27 in Fitness and Exercise
Ok so after a long time of excuses I started doing exercise.firstly I am a female and 5 feet and 7 inches and I am a student.I started following an exercise program I found on the internet(p4p).the one I've been doing is about 18 minutes long and it involves doing mixed exercises: squats,forward lunges,lateral lunges,vertical leg crunches, four times abs,foot to foot crunch,concentrated hip extension,lateral hip extension,leg pull down,double crunch .these are all and the program makes you repeat some of them twice or three times(especially lunges).anw after all this time without exercise the first two days of exercise my legs felt kinda numb and from waist down I was cramped.for the next two days I only went cycling but I started my exercise regularly after that.I lost a bit of weight but my thighs aren't getting smaller so I'm afraid of building muscle(getting bulky).from what I read in the intwrnet there are a lot of girls who are afraid of getting bulky or building muscle before losing weight(burning fat) .I kinda have the same worries.what do you suggest I do?what exercises?how much time should I exercise,and should I exercise hard?what about diet? I just want to tone my muscles only and to lose fat.Can anyone help and enlighten the situation please?any help is appreciated. Excuse me if I have any gammatical mistakes I am not english. Thanks! (I am not talking about weight-lifting) :)

Replies

  • ShannonS921
    ShannonS921 Posts: 194
    I am in no way an expert. However, ANY exercise is better than none at all. You will NOT get bulky by lifting weights, you will get leaner, tone, and burn fat.

    Good luck!
  • skullshank
    skullshank Posts: 4,323 Member
    in order for someone to gain significant muscle and get "bulky", they need to eat at a surplus and lift heavy weights. this is even MORE difficult for a woman, and often times lots of supplements are needed to assist in this effort.
    if you are eating at a deficit, this will not happen to you.

    what are your current stats?
    i see your height, but what is your weight?

    if you want to maintain your lean mass while eating at a deficit, look into a weight lifting program and hit/up your protein macro.
    fat will be burned at a deficit, but my understanding is that HIIT training can help with this as well.

    there is no way to reduce your fat from certain areas first, so while your thighs may not be getting smaller at the moment, fat may still be reducing overall. (how much weight have you lost?)

    patience and consistency are so key in this process. stick with it and keep kicking *kitten*.
  • tysthebest
    tysthebest Posts: 10
    Thanks for the links but I wasn't talking about weight lifting.the exercise I am doing is what I have described.you think that those exercises may get me muscley? Thank you :)
  • BrianSharpe
    BrianSharpe Posts: 9,248 Member
    Thanks for the links but I wasn't talking about weight lifting.the exercise I am doing is what I have described.you think that those exercises may get me muscley? Thank you :)

    No..... building muscle takes a lot of hard work and a caloric surplus. You may, however, find that if your % of body fat gets very low that you look lean and strong but don't worry about bulking up.
  • tysthebest
    tysthebest Posts: 10
    I wasn't talking about weight lifting.the exercises I'm doing are those I described above.you think those exercises might get me muscley?thank you :)
  • skullshank
    skullshank Posts: 4,323 Member
    Thanks for the links but I wasn't talking about weight lifting.the exercise I am doing is what I have described.you think that those exercises may get me muscley? Thank you :)

    no, these exercises will NOT get you muscley, as we stated already.

    what are your goals?
    purely weight loss?
  • only time to breifly skim your post, however...

    Often times, yes, there are lots of concerns from women I know that weight training will make them "bulky" or look like one of the body builder girls. In short, You do not have to worry about that. For a guy, let alone a woman, getting that kind of physique is EXTREMELY difficult. Getting toned is hard enough (not to discourage you, just to allay any concerns you're going to get massive muscles)

    In fact, to burn fat effectively you HAVE to put on some muscle. I read that each pound of muscle you add, your BMR increases by approximately another 50 calories or so. So you'd burn an extra 50 calories a day just by existing with that extra pound of muscle. Not sure how accurate that is, but the basic part is true. more pounds of muscle = more calories needed to sustain them. If your diet stays in check, then the extra muscle will help burn off fat reserves. That is the other sad part, like 75% of fat loss is keeping your diet under control (but luckily you have myfitnesspal.com)

    You should look at doing some basic moves to add strength and tone to your body, and then move on to some circuits and some high intensity interval training to shread the fat off. I wish I had more time to write here, but I'm sure others can expand (or refute) what I'm saying. Just PLEASE don't believe the common misconception of...

    "if you want to burn fat, just do cardio" that's BS and any good trainer will stress the importance of building/maintaining muscle mass for any long term fitness goal.

    Also, while there are dangers in it if you don't get the form of the moves down pat, crossfit is an excellent all-around strength/conditioning/fat shreading. I don't go to a crossfit club, but I happily grab their workouts online and use at my gym.
  • tysthebest
    tysthebest Posts: 10
    I am 69 kilograms and I've lost 2 in the past week :)
  • Jim_Barteck
    Jim_Barteck Posts: 274 Member
    1) It takes testosterone to build big muscles. Unless you have some kind of hormonal imbalance, you don't have enough natural testosterone to "bulk up" in the way that women tend to fear. If you look at the "bulky" female bodybuilders, you'll probably notice that many of them have very masculine facial features. They weren't born that way: it's a tell-tale sign of steroid use and hormone supplementation.

    2) It's going to take muscle to burn fat. Period. Without muscle, your metabolism will rapidly plummet and you'll constantly be eating fewer and fewer calories every day without losing any weight. Can you lose weight without building any muscle? Yes. But then you'll be "skinny fat." You'll look flabby at whatever weight you wind up at because in losing weight you'll also be losing what muscle you already have if you're not doing any kind of resistance training in the process.

    3) Fat pretty much follows the "first on, last off" rule. If that's where you gained it first, then you can bet that it's the last place it's going to come off. Regardless of what anyone might tell you, it is impossible to "spot reduce." Exercising your thighs isn't going to make the fat come off your thighs any faster than doing any other kind of exercise. It will come off when you have burned enough for your body to use it - no faster and no slower.

    4) With regard to the specific program, the real answer is "anything that gets you moving and active." There is no such thing as a "best" program other than "one that you'll stick with and keep doing." So long as you're burning more calories than you're eating, you will lose weight. That being said, the bigger the muscle that you're using to exercise, the more calories you're burning. For example, doing squats is a big calorie burner because it involves using the biggest muscles in your body - your quads and glutes. On the other hand, arm curls or ab crunches are practically useless for burning calories because the only muscles being used are the relatively small biceps or abdominus rectus muscles. The back, chest, and thighs are your biggest muscles. So when you're selecting exercises, try to find those that engage your larger muscles rather than isolating small ones. If you're not familiar with which exercises work which body parts, then I would recommend exrx.net which has a very good kinesiology breakdown of the muscles and which exercises are good at working them.
  • tysthebest
    tysthebest Posts: 10
    Toning my muscles,weight loss,staying healthy :)
  • Sam_I_Am77
    Sam_I_Am77 Posts: 2,093 Member
    I dont' see anything about your nutrition plan. Exercise doesn't matter all that much if your nutrition isn't good. Exercise can help augment or "prime" your body for weight loss, but ultimately the nutrition must be there.
  • tysthebest
    tysthebest Posts: 10
    Thank you!
  • tysthebest
    tysthebest Posts: 10
    Thanks!
  • tysthebest
    tysthebest Posts: 10
    Thank you for your reply!
  • mnricha927
    mnricha927 Posts: 23 Member
    1) It takes testosterone to build big muscles. Unless you have some kind of hormonal imbalance, you don't have enough natural testosterone to "bulk up" in the way that women tend to fear. If you look at the "bulky" female bodybuilders, you'll probably notice that many of them have very masculine facial features. They weren't born that way: it's a tell-tale sign of steroid use and hormone supplementation.

    2) It's going to take muscle to burn fat. Period. Without muscle, your metabolism will rapidly plummet and you'll constantly be eating fewer and fewer calories every day without losing any weight. Can you lose weight without building any muscle? Yes. But then you'll be "skinny fat." You'll look flabby at whatever weight you wind up at because in losing weight you'll also be losing what muscle you already have if you're not doing any kind of resistance training in the process.

    3) Fat pretty much follows the "first on, last off" rule. If that's where you gained it first, then you can bet that it's the last place it's going to come off. Regardless of what anyone might tell you, it is impossible to "spot reduce." Exercising your thighs isn't going to make the fat come off your thighs any faster than doing any other kind of exercise. It will come off when you have burned enough for your body to use it - no faster and no slower.

    4) With regard to the specific program, the real answer is "anything that gets you moving and active." There is no such thing as a "best" program other than "one that you'll stick with and keep doing." So long as you're burning more calories than you're eating, you will lose weight. That being said, the bigger the muscle that you're using to exercise, the more calories you're burning. For example, doing squats is a big calorie burner because it involves using the biggest muscles in your body - your quads and glutes. On the other hand, arm curls or ab crunches are practically useless for burning calories because the only muscles being used are the relatively small biceps or abdominus rectus muscles. The back, chest, and thighs are your biggest muscles. So when you're selecting exercises, try to find those that engage your larger muscles rather than isolating small ones. If you're not familiar with which exercises work which body parts, then I would recommend exrx.net which has a very good kinesiology breakdown of the muscles and which exercises are good at working them.

    QFT. I love this explanation. I don't post here often, but I read and lurk a lot and I wish every person would read this simple explanation of the basics. I know there is more that goes into all of this, but on a basic level this is great information.
  • tysthebest
    tysthebest Posts: 10
    Well my diet is mostly healthy.although I sometimes eat junk food.
  • skullshank
    skullshank Posts: 4,323 Member
    "healthy" and "junk" are subjective terms.

    how much are you eating vs. how much you're burning?
  • ninerbuff
    ninerbuff Posts: 49,151 Member
    Exercise is for fitness and overall health. Calorie deficit is for weight loss. Too extreme a calorie deficit will reduce lean muscle faster reducing your metabolism.

    Contrary to what people think, exercising burns calories and it takes quite a bit of it to even tap out your glycogen levels before burning fat.
    The number ONE way to burn fat (with a calorie deficit)..............................sleep and rest. Truth.

    A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
    IDEA Fitness member
    Kickboxing Certified Instructor
    Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
  • tysthebest
    tysthebest Posts: 10
    Well I joined myfitnesspal just today so I don't know exactly how much I am eating.what I can surely tell you is that with this exercise program I have lost 1 kg (about 2 pounds) in about 1 week
  • ninerbuff
    ninerbuff Posts: 49,151 Member
    Regardless of what anyone might tell you, it is impossible to "spot reduce." Exercising your thighs isn't going to make the fat come off your thighs any faster than doing any other kind of exercise.
    WELL not "impossible", but probable. There actually was a clinical study done to prove it could be done, but I doubt anyone would work out (anaerobically of course) a bodypart for 3 hours to burn off an insignificant amount of fat that's not even visually detectable.
    Experimental study done in University of Coppenhagen Denmark

    The 10 subjects, all healthy young men, fasted overnight and avoided smoking or any beverages that might affect the results (alcohol, caffeine, nicotine) for 12 hours prior to exercise. At this point, the experiment began using an exercise protocol completely unlike the weight training used to build muscle, limiting the applicability of the findings for a strength athlete. The subjects performed three hours of leg extensions (with two breaks of 30 minutes each) at varying intensities, to see what effect the exercise had on the overlying adipose tissue. One aspect of the study design that seemed a bit flawed was that one leg was exercised at two different intensities during the session for one hour total, while the other was exercised at only one intensity, but for two hours total. One would assume that the ongoing exercise in the opposite legs would keep the general (whole body) sympathetic tone (adrenalin levels) and lipolysis (fat breakdown) elevated, making it more difficult to detect local differences as the study progressed.

    http://www.musculardevelopment.com/articles/research-and-review/1429-scientific-breakthrough-spot-reduction.html?showall=&start=1#.U8f180CmU1I
    Yeah, not gonna attempt this.

    A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
    IDEA Fitness member
    Kickboxing Certified Instructor
    Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
  • skullshank
    skullshank Posts: 4,323 Member
    so how much are you trying to lose?

    are you measuring everything you consume?

    how many cals are you shooting for?
  • ninerbuff
    ninerbuff Posts: 49,151 Member
    Well I joined myfitnesspal just today so I don't know exactly how much I am eating.what I can surely tell you is that with this exercise program I have lost 1 kg (about 2 pounds) in about 1 week
    Common if all you did was increase your calorie burn. Weight loss happens if you burn more than you consume. Don't expect this to be the norm though unless you're obese or really overweight. 1% of your weight should be your target loss each week.

    A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
    IDEA Fitness member
    Kickboxing Certified Instructor
    Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
This discussion has been closed.