should i invest in a treadmill ?

jyogit
jyogit Posts: 280 Member
daft question which I'm sure will get me some even dafter answers but … i work 12hr shifts and sleep the rest of the day ..getting to a gym is impossible .. I do have a huge empty warehouse to run around in at night while i work but on my days off i tend to rest up ..i can't go out running in the sunshine as i get bad migraines with too much sunlight .. i also have dodgy knees .. would investing in a cheap second hand treadmill be wise for me ?
I've read a load of threads on here saying weights is the way to go and I'm sure that will come later for me when i have actually got more into the whole routine of it all ..i will ask the weights questions at that point :)

help ..anyone ?

Replies

  • chivalryder
    chivalryder Posts: 4,391 Member
    No.

    Waste of money.

    If you need something to get you going, get a gym membership or use YouTube videos. They're free!
  • SezxyStef
    SezxyStef Posts: 15,267 Member
    do you want a treadmill?

    I just tossed mine about 6 months ago as it just collects dust...

    I do lift yes...not hard to get into at all.

    You could start with body weight exercises google convict conditioning or you are your own gym...

    There are lots of full body and /or cardio workouts on fitnessblender.com too...

    I would take advantage of that warehouse space and do body weight and walking/running/HIIT workouts.
  • Lofteren
    Lofteren Posts: 960 Member
    If you have knee problems I would strongly advise against low intensity, steady state jogging as that will probably just make it worse. If I were you I'd get a heavy bag. It'd be a lot cheaper, it doesn't require electricity, it never breaks, you can get a much more effective and applicable workout from it than you can with a treadmill and you'll learn some striking techniques which may or may not come in handy but it's always good to know you can throw a mean right cross, just in case!
  • _lyndseybrooke_
    _lyndseybrooke_ Posts: 2,561 Member
    I second YouTube videos. Look up FitnessBlender.com. Treadmills are torture devices. Do HIIT or cardio kickboxing or something. I think investing in some dumbbells or a kettlebell or two would be better than a treadmill - and you can use those with FitnessBlender routines as well. If you don't have the time to commit to a proper lifting program, then at least do SOME resistance training until you're ready.
  • hummingbird71
    hummingbird71 Posts: 298 Member
    I guess one question you need to ask yourself is... will you ACTUALLY USE the treadmill if you get it? So many people get it, use it for a bit then it becomes a collect all. I personally have a treadmill, elliptical machine and a punching bag. I USE BOTH the treadmill and the elliptical, son uses the punching bag. Now, I will say during the spring and fall I don't use it much because I would much rather be outside walking/running or doing other outside activities. But since you are not able to get out in the sun and you like to walk then I would say YES IT WOULD BE A GOOD investment. You would just need to get yourself into a routine of using it. Good luck!
  • mabelbabel1
    mabelbabel1 Posts: 391 Member
    I'd vote Yes!
    I love walking, but since losing my dogs the lovely long walks stopped, it was too tough for me to go on my walks without them. So, I dusted off my old treadmill, turned up the radio and off I went....it's not quite the same, but it works for me now.
    I also have a bad knee (ligament damage) and have found that walking on an incline and gradually strengthening my quads by doing bridges and squats (really baby ones to start with and stopping before it hurt) has helped tremendously.

    So, yes, I'd say a treadmill is a great idea if you enjoy walking and will use it.
  • BrianSharpe
    BrianSharpe Posts: 9,248 Member
    The most important question is whether or not you would use it. I know marathon runners who use their treadmills to keep fit through the winter, personally the monotony drives me nuts and I'll happily risk frostbite. Some people love them, some hate them.

    A "cheap second hand treadmill" is never a good idea unless you're getting the deal of the century, a good second hand treadmill, on the other hand, can be a great way to let someone else take the depreciation hit - I buy lots of things used, if you're patient and do your research you can save tons of money on all sorts of products.

    Another thing to think about are your "dodgy knees", while running does not cause undue wear and tear (contrary to the mythology) you may want to try to address the underlying cause for your knee problems before taking it up. Many problems can be addressed through strength training ( weak hips & glutes frequently manifest themselves as knee pain) but you may want to see a physiotherapist or sports medicine specialist before making the investment.

    Good luck!
  • erockem
    erockem Posts: 278 Member
    I used a cheap treadmill several times when I started and restarted. I had trouble sticking to it, noisy, boring, painful. I'm glad I didn't spend much. I got a new recumbent exercise bike ($120 walmart). It was quiet, I could sit and read, watch TV, etc. 30 lbs later, invested in the real thing, then Gym membership, then running, then weight lifting, and finally swimming. SW 245 CW 183-190 (cut-maintenance).

    If you can afford the treadmill go for it, at the very least, it will be a learning experience to bigger and better things.
  • engodwin
    engodwin Posts: 516 Member
    are you going to use it?

    If you are going to actually use it then it's not a waste.

    However, I agree with other posters that knee problems and treadmills aren't the best combo.

    Also, if you work 12 hours and sleep for 12 hours then when would you be using this treadmill?

    You can do both cardio and weights... And you don't need equipment.

    Also, youtube is a great resource for workout "stuff"
  • tquill
    tquill Posts: 300 Member
    Treadmills are torture devices.

    False... they are clothes racks. :)
  • jyogit
    jyogit Posts: 280 Member
    Thanks - i do take advantage of the huge space and stuff fin there at the moment .. i can safely do about 2-3 miles jogging without it really bothering my knees at all ..i just wondered if a treadmill would've been easier on the knees for me in the long run ..
    like the idea of the punchbag :) .. have been shadow boxing with the hand weights for a while as I've only just started getting into it all .. i can't REALLY set up a gym in there as its work.. lol whatever i do i have to pack away after use and back into my car so the treadmill would've been an idea for my days off really. Think i will persevere and up the dumbbell weights for now and see if santa clause brings me anything to help out in the future.. lol
    i don't want to get a bodybuilders figure at the end of it.. id just like to trim the body fat and drop some weight while getting fit and putting on a bit of muscle .. which ..i can already see muscle coming back
    thanks again everyone
  • lishie_rebooted
    lishie_rebooted Posts: 2,973 Member
    Crap knees and cheap treadmills are not a good combo.
  • lishie_rebooted
    lishie_rebooted Posts: 2,973 Member
    Thanks - i do take advantage of the huge space and stuff fin there at the moment .. i can safely do about 2-3 miles jogging without it really bothering my knees at all ..i just wondered if a treadmill would've been easier on the knees for me in the long run ..
    like the idea of the punchbag :) .. have been shadow boxing with the hand weights for a while as I've only just started getting into it all .. i can't REALLY set up a gym in there as its work.. lol whatever i do i have to pack away after use and back into my car so the treadmill would've been an idea for my days off really. Think i will persevere and up the dumbbell weights for now and see if santa clause brings me anything to help out in the future.. lol
    i don't want to get a bodybuilders figure at the end of it.. id just like to trim the body fat and drop some weight while getting fit and putting on a bit of muscle .. which ..i can already see muscle coming back
    thanks again everyone


    You're not gonna get a bodybuilders figure by accident.
    Its gonna take years and years of hard work, bulk/cut cycles, and lots of lifting weights. And maybe roids too depending which bodybuilder youre talking about.
  • MeanderingMammal
    MeanderingMammal Posts: 7,866 Member
    If you have knee problems I would strongly advise against low intensity, steady state jogging as that will probably just make it worse.

    Of course that advice could be considered to be complete boll*x. Personally I've had reconstructive surgery on knees and ankles and I currently run about 40km/ week, predominantly trails, and I'm half way through a half marathon training cycle.

    Running with the correct form can help issues around the knees and ankles, but a treadmill really isn't going to encourage the stimulation that'll do that. Trail running has a lot of potential to help, because the different stresses and movements create a significant amount of fine control around the joints and help build up the muscles.

    That said I do agree that low intensity walking really isn't hugely beneficial, one needs to use a mixed programme of sessions to get the best from it. Focus on form, and work up to more challenging sessions over time.

    So I'd agree with various upthread that a dreadmill isn't a sound investment for you. If you really can't run outside then find something else; swim, row, resistance training. You'll get some benefit now from bodyweight training so no need for any investment at all until you've got more experience..
  • jyogit
    jyogit Posts: 280 Member
    some great advice .. my knee issue is that i had an accident with concrete some yrs ago,.. i was laying some concrete at home and kneeled in it.. the chemicals burned right through thick jeans and i had 3rd degree burns on both knees .. since then they've been not right lets just say.. lol
    they don't bother me walking as i used to walk loads with my dogs and loved it,but i lost them now and i don't want another dog ..
    its nice to hear from real people and real experiences with these things and they help more than traipsing through websites of advice and tube videos .. much appreciated ..
  • dandee1307
    dandee1307 Posts: 15
    I would not buy it. Dust collector for me.

    I bought those weighted cuffs and ankle bracelets and wore them during the day. It is taxing in the beginning. i´d start like that. Maybe get something liek fitbit, just to see how much you move during the day. Try parking your car further away from work (or even better, buy a bike and ride that to work if that is possible).

    But don´t go waisting hundreds of dollars on somethign that will most likely be the bane of your existences as you will not use it and constantly remind you of that as well.
  • blueboxgeek
    blueboxgeek Posts: 574 Member
    I bought one and eventually got fed up at looking at the huge clothes rail that I ended up using it for.

    Having a huge warehouse to workout in sounds fun!

    It really is amazing what can be achieved with body weight workouts. Add a couple of dumbbells or a kettlebell to the mix and you would be able to come up with a great workout.
  • feedmedonuts
    feedmedonuts Posts: 241 Member
    I see some different opinions on here, but as someone who also works 12 hour shift...days and graves....I have found my treadmill to be VERY beneficial. Often the gym is closed on days that I work because of my hours and even when I'm off I'm usually getting my crew rest, so it's nice to have the treadmill to fall back on. Especially in South Florida where it has been raining buckets and when I lived in Washington and it was rainy/snowy outside. I feel I don't have an excuse to say "screw it I don't feel like working out today" when I have a treadmill. So if I can't make it to the gym and don't feel like doing much else, I can at least get myself to get in a treadmill workout. I had knee issues also from overdoing it at plyometrics and the option to walk on a slight incline or a quicker pace is still helpful. It has been useful while pregnant also and all I've been doing is walking on it and utilizing my HRM. I found some awesome HIIT treadmill routines online that were challenging and effective.

    Different strokes, different folks. But I am one who actually uses my treadmill, not just for collecting dust, and yes I did get a nicer one...forget the cheapy ones!
  • DR2501
    DR2501 Posts: 661 Member
    I'd say no - get a rowing machine instead. Much better all over cardio, much more fun (try pyramids or other HIIT workouts), some resistance thrown in. I'd also get a kettlebell and use free online videos to get started.
  • VBnotbitter
    VBnotbitter Posts: 820 Member
    We are on our second treadmill and wore the first one out. We don't live in an area that is conducive to running outside, and my husband rehabbed a knee injury by walking on a steep incline. If you are likely to use it go for it, otherwise as other have said it ends up as a clothes rack
  • SinCityFit
    SinCityFit Posts: 96
    I LOVE LOVE LOVE mine. I wanted one for years (I'm a triathlete) and finally got one this year. I love being able to get my run in if I'm unable to get outside early in the morning or later (I work nights and here in Vegas it gets to be 100+ degrees). I love running outside and there's a dog park less than half a mile away from my front door (0.375 miles or so) that I use and I love running there and I also run 1-2 times a week with a run group in different locations but I love the flexibility. Mine was bought 100% from overtime funds. No regrets here. I've used it a few times (I was hit by a car while I was on mile 33 of a 100-mile bike ride to raise funds for Diabetes so it went unused for a few months) and love everything about it. Love being able to watch Netflix, Hulu, YouTube, etc. while on it and music videos are great because it's music but also visual stimuli.

    Anything you use is worth it.

    P.S. I also have a bike trainer so that I can use my outside bike inside. I'm done riding outside, I've already been hit twice by cars not paying attention (they were at fault both times). Only doing triathlons which are closed course from now on.
  • SKME2013
    SKME2013 Posts: 704 Member
    If you have bad knees I would not get a treadmill but either a stationary bike or elliptical which are both easier on your knees. I also use Bandlastics, which are resistance bands to strengthen my muscles.
    Stef.
  • Capt_Apollo
    Capt_Apollo Posts: 9,026 Member
    this is what you think you'll do

    home_category_treadmills_3_1_3.jpg

    this is what will actually happen

    6a00e554f403b68834010535eca804970b-500wi.jpg

    i work 12 hour night shifts myself. it sucks, but you need to find away to work out despite them. either immediately after a shift, or right before.