Not losing weight-- what am I doing wrong?
Replies
-
Perhaps try working out your TDEE using this site, and see how it compares to what you are taking in
http://calorieline.com/tools/tdee0 -
Okay. Just stop replying on here. It's all my fault. Great. See y'all. :laugh:0
-
Okay. Just stop replying on here. It's all my fault. Great. Maybe I'll just stop eating and die. See y'all. :laugh:
I would ask on the Fitness And Exercise subforum about how to use the HRM. I mentioned this upthread, but maybe you didn't see it.
HRMs are trickier to use than it would first appear. Somebody over there should have good advice on how to use the HRM more effectively.0 -
We all need to take a chill pill
0 -
Sounds like you are overestimating camories burned. Do you use HRM?
I had EXACT same issue - I always eat clean, no junk/processes, lots of lean protein + fruit and veg. I did 3 months of excercises like 45 min intervals + yoga, + 3 times a week running. Tracked my diet of between 1300-1800 ( did one month online dieta dn afollowed their recommendations). Gained weight. ( I also di 5x50 challenge - walking 5 k for 50 days)
A month a go I started eating differently - 1200 a day. NO sugar, no wheat, very little oil ( i do have avos and fish for healthy fats) - lost 6kg in 6 weeks.
I used to wonder - what is wrong with my body, i work out so so so hard, like really hard, those intervals were about killing me... I dont eat junk I even went for thyroid hormone test which came back clean.
Plus - How active are you when you are NOT working out? Do you sit a lot? Do you have sedentary job?
Turns out my body will only let go of fat if I keep in 1000-1200 calorie range, I know MFP keeps on nagging about starvation mode - but i do have lots of fresh fruit and veg juices, so i do not feel hungry or out of energy - still do my workouts and runs.
Earlier in the year I tried 5:2 diet and gained 2 kg.
)
( I know my ticker says lost 3, but it is actually proud 6, i only got back on MFP like 3 weeks ago!)
You just need to figure out your calorie range.0 -
"good morning... just ran across our post... and thought I would toss my 2 cents in... since I ran into a similar issue 3 months ago when I started dieting and excercise. 2 months passed... and the scale never moved! I was devastated and in tears! I couldn't figure it out... so I asked my doctor... and lo and behold... my body was just building up muscle (which weighs more than fat) while my clothes were getting more baggy! =0) So maybe that is what is going on with you at the moment =0) It just seems to be one of those things that "catch up with you". Keep up the good work =0)"
This is the most useful thing on here.0 -
You people are being very unfair. Not everyone in the world has to weigh every thing they eat to lose weight! It' actually a waste of time in my opinion. This girl is working out for 4 hours a day! Obviously she is burning a lot of calories and yall are being so cruel. Where is the support? Even if she wasn't eating exactly 1200 calories, what's a few more? She is working out more than any of you all and is worried and all yall do is say she is underestimating everything.
Occam's razor my friend. First, you must rule out the hypothesis with the least number of assumption. That is almost always that the person who claims they are making higher-than-normal levels of calorie expenditure is overestimating calories burned or plain out being dishonest with themselves. Have a thyroid isuee (~12% of population) requires significantly higher assumptions.
She should get it checked. It won't hurt but she should also take a humble pill and realize she might not be the calorie-burning goddess her HRM claims she is.0 -
You people are being very unfair. Not everyone in the world has to weigh every thing they eat to lose weight! It' actually a waste of time in my opinion. This girl is working out for 4 hours a day! Obviously she is burning a lot of calories and yall are being so cruel. Where is the support? Even if she wasn't eating exactly 1200 calories, what's a few more? She is working out more than any of you all and is worried and all yall do is say she is underestimating everything.
Occam's razor my friend. First, you must rule out the hypothesis with the least number of assumption. That is almost always that the person who claims they are making higher-than-normal levels of calorie expenditure is overestimating calories burned or plain out being dishonest with themselves. Have a thyroid isuee (~12% of population) requires significantly higher assumptions.
She should get it checked. It won't hurt but she should also take a humble pill and realize she might not be the calorie-burning goddess her HRM claims she is.
Okay. My bad. I didn't say I was a calorie burning goddess. All I'm saying is that I weigh 200 lbs and workout for 3-4 hours a day. I SHOULD be losing weight based on my diet combined with that. And I'm not. I'm gonna see a doctor. Seriously, don't be rude. This is supposed to be a supportive community. I GUESS I'VE BEEN WRONG. I'M NOT AN AMAZING CALORIE BURNING GODDESS. THANKING FOR SHINING YOUR LIGHT AND WISDOM ON ME. YOU ARE MY HERO.0 -
You people are being very unfair. Not everyone in the world has to weigh every thing they eat to lose weight! It' actually a waste of time in my opinion. This girl is working out for 4 hours a day! Obviously she is burning a lot of calories and yall are being so cruel. Where is the support? Even if she wasn't eating exactly 1200 calories, what's a few more? She is working out more than any of you all and is worried and all yall do is say she is underestimating everything.
Occam's razor my friend. First, you must rule out the hypothesis with the least number of assumption. That is almost always that the person who claims they are making higher-than-normal levels of calorie expenditure is overestimating calories burned or plain out being dishonest with themselves. Have a thyroid isuee (~12% of population) requires significantly higher assumptions.
She should get it checked. It won't hurt but she should also take a humble pill and realize she might not be the calorie-burning goddess her HRM claims she is.
Okay. My bad. I didn't say I was a calorie burning goddess. All I'm saying is that I weigh 200 lbs and workout for 3-4 hours a day. I SHOULD be losing weight based on my diet combined with that. And I'm not. I'm gonna see a doctor. Seriously, don't be rude. This is supposed to be a supportive community. I GUESS I'VE BEEN WRONG. I'M NOT AN AMAZING CALORIE BURNING GODDESS. THANKING FOR SHINING YOUR LIGHT AND WISDOM ON ME. YOU ARE MY HERO.
You're welcome. I'm not trying to be rude but you came and asked "what am I doing wrong." Tons of people on here with more experience than myself who have answered this question a million times gave their opinion that you were over-estimating calories. You kept blowing them off and saying "you knew what you were doing." Why ask then? Just make the topic "someone tell me I have a medical condition because I'm not losing weight."0 -
Occam's razor my friend. First, you must rule out the hypothesis with the least number of assumption. That is almost always that the person who claims they are making higher-than-normal levels of calorie expenditure is overestimating calories burned or plain out being dishonest with themselves. Have a thyroid isuee (~12% of population) requires significantly higher assumptions.
She should get it checked. It won't hurt but she should also take a humble pill and realize she might not be the calorie-burning goddess her HRM claims she is.
I'm sorry I was a little upset before but I'm in her same position. Taking a chill pill now And I agree with the thyroid issue because it is always better to check. 0 -
You people are being very unfair. Not everyone in the world has to weigh every thing they eat to lose weight! It' actually a waste of time in my opinion. This girl is working out for 4 hours a day! Obviously she is burning a lot of calories and yall are being so cruel. Where is the support? Even if she wasn't eating exactly 1200 calories, what's a few more? She is working out more than any of you all and is worried and all yall do is say she is underestimating everything.
Occam's razor my friend. First, you must rule out the hypothesis with the least number of assumption. That is almost always that the person who claims they are making higher-than-normal levels of calorie expenditure is overestimating calories burned or plain out being dishonest with themselves. Have a thyroid isuee (~12% of population) requires significantly higher assumptions.
She should get it checked. It won't hurt but she should also take a humble pill and realize she might not be the calorie-burning goddess her HRM claims she is.
Okay. My bad. I didn't say I was a calorie burning goddess. All I'm saying is that I weigh 200 lbs and workout for 3-4 hours a day. I SHOULD be losing weight based on my diet combined with that. And I'm not. I'm gonna see a doctor. Seriously, don't be rude. This is supposed to be a supportive community. I GUESS I'VE BEEN WRONG. I'M NOT AN AMAZING CALORIE BURNING GODDESS. THANKING FOR SHINING YOUR LIGHT AND WISDOM ON ME. YOU ARE MY HERO.
Relax. You asked a question and you received answers. (even if you don't like what people have to say) If you are not losing weight, there is a miscalculation somewhere and you have not found a calorie deficit.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
ok. i'm a dumbass. please stop replying so i can bury my head in the sand now.0
-
This content has been removed.
-
Don't worry. You are probably losing fat and gaining muscle. It's a good thing, so forget the scale.0
-
Are you weighing and measuring EVERYTHING you eat and are you logging liquid calories? In the beginning that was my problem. If you are consistently working out and measuring/weighing your food, not drinking your calories and not exceeding calorie allotment....Yeah I would see a Dr.0
-
This content has been removed.
-
No she is not.Don't worry. You are probably losing fat and gaining muscle. It's a good thing, so forget the scale.
Okay. Seriously. This thread is over. Just stop.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
You are not a dumbass. You asked a question because you want to learn. People responded in various ways with various degrees of politeness. Whatever. Just read the posts and find one or some that seem right to you and do that. Ignore the others. Don't bury your head in the sand--keep going!
In my experience, I have gone for periods of 2-4 weeks and the scale doesn't move or goes up (only checking once per week). Then one day, bam!, 4 pounds gone and they stay gone. Hard to stay motivated but you just have to believe that the results will come as a result of your hard work.
I would check your diet. I thought I was eating a healthy, balanced diet, but I was not getting enough protein. Once I started eating more protein, I feel "full" and have a difficult time eating as much food as needed to reach my daily calorie goal.0 -
My comment was addressed at another poster. If you feel you've gotten what you need from it then back out. However, the thread is here and in public so we respond as we feel necessary.
No she is not.Don't worry. You are probably losing fat and gaining muscle. It's a good thing, so forget the scale.
Okay. Seriously. This thread is over. Just stop.
Ok I was just trying to be nice but in my case that is what is happening for me. I am gaining muscle and losing fat. I can tell by how I look and how my clothes fit. 0 -
My comment was addressed at another poster. If you feel you've gotten what you need from it then back out. However, the thread is here and in public so we respond as we feel necessary.
No she is not.Don't worry. You are probably losing fat and gaining muscle. It's a good thing, so forget the scale.
Okay. Seriously. This thread is over. Just stop.
Ok I was just trying to be nice but in my case that is what is happening for me. I am gaining muscle and losing fat. I can tell by how I look and how my clothes fit.
you've been lovely and helpful. thank you very much. i was referring to the other poster.0 -
You are not a dumbass. You asked a question because you want to learn. People responded in various ways with various degrees of politeness. Whatever. Just read the posts and find one or some that seem right to you and do that. Ignore the others. Don't bury your head in the sand--keep going!
In my experience, I have gone for periods of 2-4 weeks and the scale doesn't move or goes up (only checking once per week). Then one day, bam!, 4 pounds gone and they stay gone. Hard to stay motivated but you just have to believe that the results will come as a result of your hard work.
I would check your diet. I thought I was eating a healthy, balanced diet, but I was not getting enough protein. Once I started eating more protein, I feel "full" and have a difficult time eating as much food as needed to reach my daily calorie goal.
great advice. i'll look more at ~what~ food i'm eating. i might be skimping on the protein and eating too much fat.0 -
The one thing that is missing from all this info is how you feel. Don't stress about your current situation. Just keep visualizing yourself as how you want to be and keep putting in the work. Pay attention to the types of food you are eating and how you feel after eating them. Keep water intake high. But just be positive. If you are feeling better and being proud of yourself then the rest will happen if you are doing everything else.0
-
The one thing that is missing from all this info is how you feel. Don't stress about your current situation. Just keep visualizing yourself as how you want to be and keep putting in the work. Pay attention to the types of food you are eating and how you feel after eating them. Keep water intake high. But just be positive. If you are feeling better and being proud of yourself then the rest will happen if you are doing everything else.
you're right. thank you. i'm going to try and approach this journey with a little more positivity.0 -
I don't know if anyone else has said this yet, but if you haven't invested in a measuring tape, you definitely should!
Sometimes you may gain weight, but you're losing inches!
Which just means you're gaining muscle.
Not saying that's the problem, just throwing it out there!0 -
The thing that helped me was increasing my protein. Also look for empty calories that you can get rid of (from juices, soda, and other sweetened drinks). Good luck! You can do this.0
-
I've lost 17 pounds since mid-May with a daily intake of 1400, doing a sensible walk (30-40 mins) a day, doing a couple of big swims and cycles a week, and eating around there, or more if I've exercised (I eat half my calories back, so some days I've gone up to 2200 or even gone over three times in a week and still lost).
If your net calories are minus or only up to 500, you need to eat more. Then you won't feel rubbish. Don't overexercise either, it won't help. Also, if you don't need to lose a lot (e.g. only 20 pounds) then don't go wild with what you want to lose per week. Slow and steady wins the race.
Oh, and listen to what people are telling you and try not to be upset that they're trying to help!0 -
Okay. Just stop replying on here. It's all my fault. Great. See y'all. :laugh:
I just want to say that a little of what everyone said is what you should know and listen to. But ALSO- you are beautiful! You are working so hard, losing inches and that's what's working. A lot of people focus too much on the scale. Look in the mirror! ???? Have a great day. Don't give up.0 -
This content has been removed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions