Switching to less cardio/ more weights..?
FitnessLover001
Posts: 188 Member
Has anyone ever switched their routine up and cut back on cardio and done more weights? I love love love cardio, so I know this will be hard for me, and I truly don't want to cut out all cardio (I do a 10mile run once a week). I was told that all of the cardio I do is burning my muscle fibers and I should look at lifting weights more.
I kind of want to, I just don't want to cut out all cardio. I currently do 60 min of cardio and 20-30 min of weights 6 days a week. Is it possible to continue with this same routine 3 days a week and then 3 days a week I do 30 min of cardio and 60 min of weights…? or will that still be too much cardio? I do want to build muscle, I'm not trying to be "skinny" I just really love the way I feel after a hard core cardio session so that's why I like doing cardio.
Anyyyy suggestions…?
I kind of want to, I just don't want to cut out all cardio. I currently do 60 min of cardio and 20-30 min of weights 6 days a week. Is it possible to continue with this same routine 3 days a week and then 3 days a week I do 30 min of cardio and 60 min of weights…? or will that still be too much cardio? I do want to build muscle, I'm not trying to be "skinny" I just really love the way I feel after a hard core cardio session so that's why I like doing cardio.
Anyyyy suggestions…?
0
Replies
-
Yeah I'm considering something similar but i will be honest and say I'm fearful of cutting back the cardio and stalling out. So yeah, not a helpful answer but I'm curious to see opinions as we'll....0
-
You're not doing a massive load of cardio. You could keep your hour per week and just add to your weight lifting. I currently do about 3 hours of lifting per week (three sessions) and I'm up to about 2 hours of running per week (training for a 13 mile leg of a relay race). As long as you don't move it up too quickly and have the time, you should be fine.
If you're concerned about the possible muscle loss of a long run (though I don't think that happens with something as short as 10 miles), you could just do a few shorter runs vs one long one.0 -
Yeah, definitely make the switch. It'll improve your body's composition.0
-
Yeah, definitely make the switch. It'll improve your body's composition.
That would depend entirely on what her body composition and fitness goals are.0 -
Bumping this so I can see the answers that come up. I'm in the same boat: cardio 6 days a week, calorie deficit, no weight loss. I know I need to start some sort of weight training, but I don't want to cut out cardio in the process. I feel healthier than I have in a very long time and don't want to lose that.0
-
if you're working out 6 days a week and not losing weight, you're not at a calorie deficit.Bumping this so I can see the answers that come up. I'm in the same boat: cardio 6 days a week, calorie deficit, no weight loss. I know I need to start some sort of weight training, but I don't want to cut out cardio in the process. I feel healthier than I have in a very long time and don't want to lose that.0 -
Yeah, definitely make the switch. It'll improve your body's composition.
That would depend entirely on what her body composition and fitness goals are.
OP wrote she wants to build muscle.0 -
Yeah I wasn't worried about the cardio tearing my already built muscles, but I was told that my heart rate was really high while doing all that cardio and I was burning my muscle fibers, which wasn't good at all. I'm sure it could be true, but I didn't know that an hour of cardio a day would do that. I just have a lot of endurance built up that doing 30 min of cardio seems really little to me (no offense to anyone! I'm not trying to belittle short amounts of cardio,I'm just used to doing more than that)0
-
That's actually not true. I am in the same boat and have been doing so for 6 weeks. It has to do with metabolism and speeding it up again rather than misunderstanding the idea of calorie deficit.0
-
Yeah, definitely make the switch. It'll improve your body's composition.
That would depend entirely on what her body composition and fitness goals are.
OP wrote she wants to build muscle.
You can build muscle while still having a cardio element to your workouts. 60 minutes of cardio a week will not hamper that goal.
OP, as long as you're eating at a surplus with adequate protein and a lifting routine that encourages hypertrophy, you can build muscle. You don't have to switch if you don't want to. But if you want to really buckle down and focus solely on muscle building, cutting out the cardio and devoting that extra time to lifting would be a good path to follow.0 -
Just want to follow this conversation!! My cardiologist encouraged me to get more active and since doing lots of cardio, I've seen an improvement in the heart issue I was having and have lost about 15 pounds. I too, love to run and am planning on a 1/2 marathon in Jan.
However, I'm *super* intrigued by the success stories I'm seeing here of those that have transitioned to more weigh lifting. Would love to learn if both can be done.0 -
I don't think your cardio is excessive the way it is now. You could probably keep your runs and add in more weights and be fine.0
-
Does anyone else notice the amount of muscle the op has in her avatar?0
-
if you're eating at a deficit, you'd be losing weight unless you have a thyroid problem or something of this sort.
do you weigh all your food accurately on a scale and keep a diary of everything you eat? if so, is it possible you have lower lean body mass and higher body fat % than the average person of your height/weight? i was 40% bodyfat instead of the 30.5% that was standard at my height and weight, and as a result, i needed and burned a lot less calories.Bumping this so I can see the answers that come up. I'm in the same boat: cardio 6 days a week, calorie deficit, no weight loss. I know I need to start some sort of weight training, but I don't want to cut out cardio in the process. I feel healthier than I have in a very long time and don't want to lose that.0 -
Bumping this as well, very interested to see postings. 0
-
I'm in exactly the same boat.
I'm wanting to start weight lifting but honestly I'm terrified that if I step away from any cardio that my weight loss will stop. Cardio has been a godsend for me, I'm consistently losing 11-12lbs a month (avg) and honestly with that success I don't want to stop or slow down. I have 40ish pounds to go to meet my goal and I want to make that by Christmas and I'm scared that moving away from any cardio will cause me to fail to make that goal.
I'm going to the gym and cardio'ing my *kitten* off 6 days a week, so if I split those 6 days up between cardio and weight lifting what can I expect to occur?
I'm 6'1" and a large build, 52 years old and want to lose weight and build muscle, I want to be able to do some tough mudder runs and do some fun stuff like that.
I'd love some input!0 -
Does anyone else notice the amount of muscle the op has in her avatar?
My avatar is me currently and I'm in a calorie deficit as well. Like I said, I do 20 min of weights daily so I know I have some muscle definition, but I just didn't know if the muscle fibers in my legs were "being ruined" because I was told I do way too much cardio (running, efx precor machine, elliptical machines). So I really want second opinions to see if anyone thinks that 60 min of cardio a day is too much and if I need to cut back0 -
Has anyone ever switched their routine up and cut back on cardio and done more weights? I love love love cardio, so I know this will be hard for me, and I truly don't want to cut out all cardio (I do a 10mile run once a week). I was told that all of the cardio I do is burning my muscle fibers and I should look at lifting weights more.
I kind of want to, I just don't want to cut out all cardio. I currently do 60 min of cardio and 20-30 min of weights 6 days a week. Is it possible to continue with this same routine 3 days a week and then 3 days a week I do 30 min of cardio and 60 min of weights…? or will that still be too much cardio? I do want to build muscle, I'm not trying to be "skinny" I just really love the way I feel after a hard core cardio session so that's why I like doing cardio.
Anyyyy suggestions…?
I'm not an expert, but how does doing cardio "burn muscle fibers?" Maybe if you do hours of cardio a day, and are already lean (like under 18% BF for a woman), but otherwise, I don't see how that happens. I know marathoners can lose muscle mass, but again, very lean, and hours of running....
Am I mistaken?0 -
Has anyone ever switched their routine up and cut back on cardio and done more weights? I love love love cardio, so I know this will be hard for me, and I truly don't want to cut out all cardio (I do a 10mile run once a week). I was told that all of the cardio I do is burning my muscle fibers and I should look at lifting weights more.
I kind of want to, I just don't want to cut out all cardio. I currently do 60 min of cardio and 20-30 min of weights 6 days a week. Is it possible to continue with this same routine 3 days a week and then 3 days a week I do 30 min of cardio and 60 min of weights…? or will that still be too much cardio? I do want to build muscle, I'm not trying to be "skinny" I just really love the way I feel after a hard core cardio session so that's why I like doing cardio.
Anyyyy suggestions…?
I'm not an expert, but how does doing cardio "burn muscle fibers?" Maybe if you do hours of cardio a day, and are already lean (like under 18% BF for a woman), but otherwise, I don't see how that happens. I know marathoners can lose muscle mass, but again, very lean, and hours of running....
Am I mistaken?
I'm not an expert either and I'm not saying cardio does that. I'm just saying I was told that by a man that works in Golds and has been weight lifting for years. I didn't really know how true that was, that's why I came to the forum0 -
Has anyone ever switched their routine up and cut back on cardio and done more weights? I love love love cardio, so I know this will be hard for me, and I truly don't want to cut out all cardio (I do a 10mile run once a week). I was told that all of the cardio I do is burning my muscle fibers and I should look at lifting weights more.
I kind of want to, I just don't want to cut out all cardio. I currently do 60 min of cardio and 20-30 min of weights 6 days a week. Is it possible to continue with this same routine 3 days a week and then 3 days a week I do 30 min of cardio and 60 min of weights…? or will that still be too much cardio? I do want to build muscle, I'm not trying to be "skinny" I just really love the way I feel after a hard core cardio session so that's why I like doing cardio.
Anyyyy suggestions…?
I'm not an expert, but how does doing cardio "burn muscle fibers?" Maybe if you do hours of cardio a day, and are already lean (like under 18% BF for a woman), but otherwise, I don't see how that happens. I know marathoners can lose muscle mass, but again, very lean, and hours of running....
Am I mistaken?
I'm not an expert either and I'm not saying cardio does that. I'm just saying I was told that by a man that works in Golds and has been weight lifting for years. I didn't really know how true that was, that's why I came to the forum
Yeah, I am curious as to others' input on that, also.0 -
I kind of want to, I just don't want to cut out all cardio. I currently do 60 min of cardio and 20-30 min of weights 6 days a week. Is it possible to continue with this same routine 3 days a week and then 3 days a week I do 30 min of cardio and 60 min of weights…?
Yep. Assuming you're fit enough to do it, and that the lifting program makes sense, nothing wrong with that at all.0 -
No, cardio does NOT "ruin your muscle fibers".
High volumes of cardio will inhibit one's ability to achieve maximal gains in muscle mass. It does not stop muscle mass gain. And if calorie and protein intakes are adequate, and you are lifting weights, it will not lead to a substantial loss in existing mass either--unless you are really big.
This is another instance of a discussion being skewed by the more extreme perspective. If your goal in maximum mass or maximum power, then, no, you should not be doing a lot of cardio (esp running). But for the average person, you should be able to maintain or even gain some mass even with doing a lot of cardio.0 -
Has anyone ever switched their routine up and cut back on cardio and done more weights? I love love love cardio, so I know this will be hard for me, and I truly don't want to cut out all cardio (I do a 10mile run once a week). I was told that all of the cardio I do is burning my muscle fibers and I should look at lifting weights more.
I kind of want to, I just don't want to cut out all cardio. I currently do 60 min of cardio and 20-30 min of weights 6 days a week. Is it possible to continue with this same routine 3 days a week and then 3 days a week I do 30 min of cardio and 60 min of weights…? or will that still be too much cardio? I do want to build muscle, I'm not trying to be "skinny" I just really love the way I feel after a hard core cardio session so that's why I like doing cardio.
Anyyyy suggestions…?
I'm not an expert, but how does doing cardio "burn muscle fibers?" Maybe if you do hours of cardio a day, and are already lean (like under 18% BF for a woman), but otherwise, I don't see how that happens. I know marathoners can lose muscle mass, but again, very lean, and hours of running....
Am I mistaken?
Top marathoners also actively avoid gaining mass, since the extra weight slows them down, so they aren't really a meaningful comparison.
Triathletes carry more muscle mass and they do at least as much cardio training as marathoners--the high volume of cardio doesn't burn their muscles.0 -
I'm not an expert either and I'm not saying cardio does that. I'm just saying I was told that by a man that works in Golds and has been weight lifting for years. I didn't really know how true that was, that's why I came to the forum
It's not true. Read what Azdak wrote above.0 -
No, cardio does NOT "ruin your muscle fibers".
High volumes of cardio will inhibit one's ability to achieve maximal gains in muscle mass. It does not stop muscle mass gain. And if calorie and protein intakes are adequate, and you are lifting weights, it will not lead to a substantial loss in existing mass either--unless you are really big.
This is another instance of a discussion being skewed by the more extreme perspective. If your goal in maximum mass or maximum power, then, no, you should not be doing a lot of cardio (esp running). But for the average person, you should be able to maintain or even gain some mass even with doing a lot of cardio.
Thank you for confirming that.0 -
I was all about cardio every day for an hour (or more) a day. A little more than 3 months ago I switched to 10 min of high intensity cardio a day and 30 min (or less depending on what I'm working) of weight training 4 days a week. The 5th day I do 30 min of cardio (it's actually the 3rd day breaking up the week of workouts). I have noticed a HUGE difference. My body looks better and I feel better without spending my life on the never ending wheel and hours in the gym. I found my routine on www.simplyshredded.com/the-ultimate-female-training-guide GOOD LUCK TO YOU!0
-
Yeah, definitely make the switch. It'll improve your body's composition.
That would depend entirely on what her body composition and fitness goals are.
OP wrote she wants to build muscle.
You can build muscle while still having a cardio element to your workouts. 60 minutes of cardio a week will not hamper that goal.
I thought she said 360 minutes of cardio/week...thats the 60min she does for 6 days that is...0 -
I finished nine weeks of heavy weights/no cardio and calorie surplus. Gained ten pounds but the body fat stayed within 1% of my starting point. Now I am about to switch back to calorie deficit and increased cardio. I won't know for a few weeks how much muscle mass I gained after the body fat is burned off.0
-
I went from getting 4-6 hours a week of cardio (Insanity) with 3 hours of weight lifting, to 2-3 hour of cardio and 3 hours of HIIT weight lifting (best of both worlds).
At first when I started doing Insanity my heart rate was really high and I would have to take breaks for it to normalize, but by the end of the 2nd week, I had a hard time getting my heart rate up there. Your body will adapt to just about anything you put it through exercise wise, it is quite the brilliant machine.
My advice is to make the switch. With proper diet, and adequate calorie intake, you could even do both; or a HIIT routine like me to get the best of both worlds.
Remember when beginning to lift weights if it isn't something you've done before...
Concentrate on proper form. It's more about the body mechanics you are lifting with vs. the amount of weight. It doesn't hurt to go to a gym and spend a few sessions with a personal trainer going over form and tempo.
Gradually increase weight. It doesn't matter if you start with 5lb dumbbells or an empty barbell. Heavier is not always better/does not automatically mean better gains.
In my personal opinion, the exercises that have helped me gain the most strength are:
Deadlifting - Great for your lower back and core, works out more muscles than you'd think, I believe it really promotes growth and development in your whole body.
Front/Overhead Squats - Works pretty much the same muscles as a back squat, less stress on the back and knees, and it will test your flexibility and keep it in check. Overhead variation will really test and improve your posture with proper form.
Pull Up - It's a great compound upper body exercise, you can up/alleviate the intensity by using weights or resistance bands, your over all grip strength will go through the roof - especially important for lifting heavier weights.
Military Press/Push Up - I personally feel the standing military press is more effective, it will engage your core like no other. Both exercises will benefit from each other, the latter more so.
Farmer's Walk - Loaded carries are great for overall strength, especially the trapezius and shoulders. It'd definitely be as/if not more effective at improving your grip strength. Best of both worlds really, get your cardio in at the same time.
Battle Ropes - You want a whole body strength and cardio workout? These will be your best friend, and there are a ton of variations on exercises. Never a dull moment.
I also play soccer with my kids, go for bike rides with my wife, and jog by myself. Which pretty much sums up my cardio exclusive exercises.
Either way, if it is what you want to do, then make the switch. Cardio itself isn't bad for you, too much I suppose could be, but balancing it with weight lifting is a great idea. If it's time you're worried about, then develop a HIIT weight lifting routine and do both at the same time.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions