How do devices work together?

Options
I am currently using a Zephyr HXM and Endomondo to track my cardio and would like to add an activity tracker. I've got a lot of them under consideration but I'm wondering how they work together in concert with MFP. For instance would I need to take off a fitbit while I do cardio with my Zephyr on?

I'm considering a Fitbit, Basis, or Withing. From what I understand none of those are designed to track cardio. I've got a lot of research left to do but I wonder how the interactions with MFP work before I make any decision. I also wouldn't mind advice on those three choices.

Replies

  • caseylainetx
    caseylainetx Posts: 6 Member
    Options
    There are lots of posts and discussion about how the fitbit calculates a net amount with MFP. I'm no tech guru, but just comparing the numbers of on vs off, I can tell you this... if your activity is step-based (walking, running, stair climbing, even bike riding b/c of the stepping motion of pedaling) the fitbit does seem to track the activity accurately. I have done all these activities w/out my FB and with to see how the numbers compare, and they come out the same for the most part. One thing to note, the fitbit will sync up to your MFP account as much as you tell it to, and your MFP will adjust immediately to that activity - but when you close out your day it will say one amount remaining, and the next mroning it will be slightly less. This is because it takes a while for your MFP to catch up to the synced amounts, netted with the estimation that MFP makes about your other activity. I'm probably doing a terrible job at explaining or even understanding that,, but just wanted to give the heads up that if you're going totally FB, then leave yourself some wiggle room on the calories. I prefer this small amount of ambiguity because with an absolute 100% exact count/amount/measure I think it gives a false sense of security and too many reasons to slip. As with anything it's an estimation and weight loss is about moderation, and being active - it's not just a numbers game. So I like just letting FB do it's thing, and I do mine, w/out completely depending on FB to tell me how much I can have. Now, here's the kicker, I think if you do aerobic beyond walking, something that is more intense you are supposed to wear your FB +and+ put the activity in, and let MFP return with a net amount. I have done this some, but I mostly only do walking, so not much. Some things I just prefer to go sans FB b/c I like seeing that actual activity in my log. Like eliptical, dancing, swimming. And of course daily activities I always put in - gardening, cleaning, cooking, pushing a stroller. I mostly wear my FB, let MFP do the net # thing, and add any activities that are more than a basic level of exersion. I know that my walking is always at a dog walking pace, and that a 4.0 mph walk is actually a slow jog. I base it off that spectrum.
  • marklpotter
    marklpotter Posts: 11 Member
    Options
    The Basis is out, no MFP sync. And I won't be going totally FitBit. I'll still be using an HRM for cardio so I guess a little experimentation is in order after I get a device. I really wish the Basis synced with MFP because I really like the wealth of information. So now it's down to FitBit or Withings.
  • cmbauer99
    cmbauer99 Posts: 184 Member
    Options
    I use a Polar Loop paired with a H7 Bluethooth HRM and it solves what I need. Was the only fitness tracker I could find at the time that had a HRM built in and could handle HIIT Cardio and running.
  • marklpotter
    marklpotter Posts: 11 Member
    Options
    I love the Zephyr I have. It works really easily with Endomondo which in turn ties in to MFP. My concern is using it along with an activity tracker. What I don't want is the activity tracker to conflict with what I'm already doing. If I have to take it off when I do cardio, that's fine. I'm a little bit of a data nerd so I'm looking for more data that I can process to augment what I am already doing.
  • caseylainetx
    caseylainetx Posts: 6 Member
    Options
    exactly, whatever you choose, as long as you know it is to augment your own management of your progress, then you can't go wrong. It kind of gives me a guide of wheter I've been active or not in my day. Some days that active'ness is more casual movement (grocery shopping, socializing, housework) and sometimes it's more purposeful (actual cardio sessions). So I let it track what it will and anything extra is just icing on the weight-loss cake. Best of luck my friend. You're doing great.
  • marklpotter
    marklpotter Posts: 11 Member
    Options
    I still need to know if devices are going to compete for info in MFP. As in if I need to leave the FitBit at home when I'm using my HXM or not, that sort of thing.