Odd question - vegetarian diet and anger?
vineas
Posts: 84
I occasionally do a 30 day trial of different things (an idea I got from a blog post on stevepavlina.com), and my most recent trial was a switch to a vegetarian diet. I'm about two weeks into the trial, and have been noticing that lately my mood has been very bad - I'm having mood swings and am very quick to anger. Tonight I was online doing my football draft, and my wife called when my turn was just about up. I have some DSL issues that knocks out the internet when a call comes in, takes a few minutes for it to come back. Not too big of a deal, but I was very short with my wife, then when I hung up, I threw the phone down the hallway, screaming the entire time. This is not me normally. That was definitely the worst of things recently, but I've been very short with everyone including my son. I'm normally a very patient person and not prone to quick changes in mood, so I'm a bit weirded out.
Could this have anything to do with my diet switch? I found some correlation to this by googling, but it still seems a bit odd - I wasn't really expecting anything like that, and if anything, shouldn't a vegetarian diet make a person more mellow? Anyone else have ideas?
Could this have anything to do with my diet switch? I found some correlation to this by googling, but it still seems a bit odd - I wasn't really expecting anything like that, and if anything, shouldn't a vegetarian diet make a person more mellow? Anyone else have ideas?
0
Replies
-
Are you eating anything different? Something you normally do not? It might be a food allergy, or it may be something in the food you WERE eating that you are withdrawing from. Other ideas may be blood sugar issues or some other environmental change...sleep changes, stress changes.0
-
r u eating a lot of soy products?0
-
You need to make sure you are not deficent in ANY of your mineral or vitamins...or even protien. Especially if you usually eat mean/protien often when you are not a 'vegetarian'. This could be your body telling you, HEY YOu MISSING SOMETHING!!!!
LOL. I also get irritable and moody when I dont meet my daily goals...its because I'm making it hard for my body to function properly.
Take a look at what you are eating and looking up what it is made up of. You might want to check out Mypyramid.gov to get an idea of what you might be missing.
Hope you feel better!!0 -
you might not be geting enought protein,or b12 vitamins, your body needs a certain amount of protein carbs fats or it could just be a bad withdrawal like i do when i stop smoking this time iv been real sweet:huh:0
-
Are you by chance cutting out sugars, salt and or caffiene? These could easily be the culprit. I did a "cleanse" that went vegetarian for 9 days and the first 3-4 days were miserable I was grumpy and tired but toward the end of the week I felt great.0
-
I don't know, honestly. My daughter is Vegan and I've noticed that since she started eating all Vegan she's been a lot more angry and well... mean.
0 -
I think anytime you change your diet even if its for the better (I honestly don't have an opinion if a vegetarian diet is healthier or not) your going to go through with drawl. Also it is way harder to get in the amino acids and protein that meat gives you even if your an experienced vegetarian. Google amino acids, if I remember right from nutrition classes, protein and amino acid is essential for your hemoglobin to carry oxygen through out your body.This causes all kinds of bad things including mood swings. Just a thought ....and FYI I could be wrong I'm basing this from nursing school 8 years ago
0 -
Not really eating any soy, very little at least. Looking over my diary over the last week or so, I'm close to my goals in the carb/fat/protein areas, a bit lower in protein than before, but still at or near my goals. Most of my protein is coming from dairy products, but I'm not eating much more than before - pretty much the only change in my diet is no beef, chicken, pork or fish (with the exception of 2 days ago at a company party where there were NO vegetarian options). As far as I know I'm getting all my vitamins and minerals.0
-
Are you by chance cutting out sugars, salt and or caffiene? These could easily be the culprit. I did a "cleanse" that went vegetarian for 9 days and the first 3-4 days were miserable I was grumpy and tired but toward the end of the week I felt great.
These were cut out a long time ago, and I never really had this kind of reaction when that was done, just some headaches - which I haven't been having lately.0 -
I think anytime you change your diet even if its for the better (I honestly don't have an opinion if a vegetarian diet is healthier or not) your going to go through with drawl. Also it is way harder to get in the amino acids and protein that meat gives you even if your an experienced vegetarian. Google amino acids, if I remember right from nutrition classes, protein and amino acid is essential for your hemoglobin to carry oxygen through out your body.This causes all kinds of bad things including mood swings. Just a thought ....and FYI I could be wrong I'm basing this from nursing school 8 years ago
I think you may be on to something with the amino acids - from what I've read now, it doesn't look like I'm getting much in the way of them at all. I'll have to hit up GNC for some supplements and see how that helps. Thanks for the heads up on that.0 -
How much raw fruits & veggies are you eating? If your just eating a bunch of processed stuff (especially grains) instead of what you normally eat then this could be the issue. Up your fruits & veggies & look into quinoa (sprout it & have it raw on salads & stuff for an amazing source of amino acids).0
-
Not to sound critical, but if this was your way to handle a very small stress in life, you might need to work on anger management more than dieting right now.Not too big of a deal, but I was very short with my wife, then when I hung up, I threw the phone down the hallway, screaming the entire time.0 -
If you are getting most of your protein (amino acids) from dairy and you are close to your protein goal then you don't need supplements since dairy will have high quality, complete proteins.
I'm not a vegetarian but I know many, many sweet and lovely vegetarian and vegan people. Do you just miss meat? I think when people cut foods out they can just become irritable. For no specific reason other than that they feel restricted.
As for the mentions of teenagers who are angry after they become vegetarian, I think that's just to do with the timing and that dreaded broody teen phase! hehehe0 -
It certainly has nothing to do with vitamin deficiencies - in 2 weeks you couldn't possibly have such a problem. More likely is either (as someone said) withdrawal from something that you actually have an addiction to, or some other change in your life unrelated to the diet change (I'm taking your word for it that this is infact unusual behaviour for you).
The other option is that you're simply hungry and not eating enough. People get irritable when they don't feel satiated. If this is a possibility, have a look at some more filling vegetarian food options. Add tofu or some mock meats or whatever it takes to fill yourself up. Other than that, I can't think of anything.0 -
Not to sound critical, but if this was your way to handle a very small stress in life, you might need to work on anger management more than dieting right now.Not too big of a deal, but I was very short with my wife, then when I hung up, I threw the phone down the hallway, screaming the entire time.
That's the thing - this isn't something I EVER do, it's not me at all - once I calmed down, I realized how extremely odd and out of character it was. I'm a very mellow person, things that make most people mad don't usually even phase me.0 -
If you are getting most of your protein (amino acids) from dairy and you are close to your protein goal then you don't need supplements since dairy will have high quality, complete proteins.
I'm not a vegetarian but I know many, many sweet and lovely vegetarian and vegan people. Do you just miss meat? I think when people cut foods out they can just become irritable. For no specific reason other than that they feel restricted.
As for the mentions of teenagers who are angry after they become vegetarian, I think that's just to do with the timing and that dreaded broody teen phase! hehehe
Unfortunately my daughter is 22, so I can't blame it on teen angst. :-\0 -
I'm a pesco vegetarian. Still consume some dairy, eggs & fish
I agree with other comments in regards to withdrawal. If you consumed meat or animal byproducts on a daily basis and suddenly cut them out then it's obviously an adjustment that your body has to make
Get a good vegan protein powder and vegetarian vitamins.
I'm a happy and well adjusted vegetarian (aside from being a fatty).
I find it puzzling that folks think being angry is a vegetarian trait. It's like saying Christians are dumb. Kinda baseless.
Just my two cents0 -
QUOTE:
QUOTE:
Not too big of a deal, but I was very short with my wife, then when I hung up, I threw the phone down the hallway, screaming the entire time.
Not to sound critical, but if this was your way to handle a very small stress in life, you might need to work on anger management more than dieting right now.
That's the thing - this isn't something I EVER do, it's not me at all - once I calmed down, I realized how extremely odd and out of character it was. I'm a very mellow person, things that make most people mad don't usually even phase me.
I'm his wife and I can agree that this is something he NEVER does. He is honestly the most mellow laid back person ever and it's usually me that is high strung so this behavior was very odd, hence the reason for the question.
I think it's all diet related...have a steak babe!!0 -
I became self-righteous when I became a vegetarian...but I was 20 and calmed down :blushing: .... about once a year I fall off the wagon and eat meat for a couple of weeks. Usually when I stop, all I notice is that I'm more regular and less tired....0
-
It's most likely a mineral deficiency. As a vegetarian, you may (well, basically you MUST) supplement with a B complex, vitamin D (as it's most potent in animal sources, namely oily fish), Iron (depends), and potentially Zinc, Chromium and Magnesium. Irritability goes hand in hand with a Vitamin B complex deficiency.
Also...Check your Omega 3-Omega 6 balance. Many vegetarian diets tend to be much higher in Omega 6 due to the lack of natural Omega 3 sources (i.e. fish) in the diet. If you're not consuming fish, you need to supplement with quality Omega 3, which assuming you're fully vegetarian, you'll need to use a high lignan flax oil. If you will allow it - take a high quality fish oil in capsule or liquid form.
Symptoms of Omega 3 deficiency can be vague and don't typically appear overnight. Rule of thumb is, though, that many diets where one is not consuming oily fish, even those that are "healthy" are deficient in Omega 3.0 -
are you getting enough calories, fat, protein, etc? Try some nuts, beans, and whole grains. Maybe have a treat once in awhile (sugar, anyone?)
Sorry, don't have any better advice.0 -
I'm with your wife, go eat a steak. Ummmm, steak.0
-
I'm not sure why I didn't think of it earlier, but there was one other change at about the same time - we recently picked up a SodaStream (basically a way to make homemade soda) and I've been drinking A LOT of that, after about 3-4 months of only a very occasional soda. I've been using the standard mixes - full of the same artificial flavors, colors and preservatives that I've avoided for the most part in the last several months of not drinking much pre-made soda. These same artificial flavors, colors and preservatives have been linked to increased aggression and ADD/ADHD-like behavior in studies from Europe. I don't know why I didn't look at the labels on these mixes before, it just didn't occur to me for some stupid reason, I'm usually a label nazi.
I bet it was probably some combination of re-introducing these chemicals and possible vitamin deficiencies from the change in diet, though my money's more on the chemicals for causing the change. I'm going to drop the SodaStream and watch my vitamins closer and keep up the diet change, for at least the next couple of weeks.
Thanks all for the suggestions, it definitely opened my eyes to the things I could be missing out on if I don't pay closer attention to what I'm eating - here I thought the only difference would be no longer needing to hit the meat counter at Whole Foods!0 -
I'm not sure why I didn't think of it earlier, but there was one other change at about the same time - we recently picked up a SodaStream (basically a way to make homemade soda) and I've been drinking A LOT of that, after about 3-4 months of only a very occasional soda. I've been using the standard mixes - full of the same artificial flavors, colors and preservatives that I've avoided for the most part in the last several months of not drinking much pre-made soda. These same artificial flavors, colors and preservatives have been linked to increased aggression and ADD/ADHD-like behavior in studies from Europe. I don't know why I didn't look at the labels on these mixes before, it just didn't occur to me for some stupid reason, I'm usually a label nazi.
I bet it was probably some combination of re-introducing these chemicals and possible vitamin deficiencies from the change in diet, though my money's more on the chemicals for causing the change. I'm going to drop the SodaStream and watch my vitamins closer and keep up the diet change, for at least the next couple of weeks.
Thanks all for the suggestions, it definitely opened my eyes to the things I could be missing out on if I don't pay closer attention to what I'm eating - here I thought the only difference would be no longer needing to hit the meat counter at Whole Foods!
Ok, so this goes back to my question if you were cutting particular things like sugar etc out of your diet and YES, the one thing we need to teach this generation coming up is that stuff you can't pronounce should not likely be ingested. Its quite possible you are having some issues with this.
Also, if you are taking supplements you may want to make sure there isn't anything in them that you may be allergic too. People with wheat and corn allergies often have the same add/adhd type symptoms you mentioned!0 -
When you say "vegetarian diet," do you mean you just stopped eating meat without any research?
A vegetarian diet shouldn't in and of itself make you have anger issues or mood swings, but a hormone change would. If you go vegetarian, you HAVE TO make sure you're replacing the nutrients you got from meat with other things and be really careful that you're getting, in particular, enough iron and protein. It's very difficult to get enough iron without eating meat and takes planning and thought.
Anyway, I hope you get to the bottom of it!0 -
Not really eating any soy, very little at least. Looking over my diary over the last week or so, I'm close to my goals in the carb/fat/protein areas, a bit lower in protein than before, but still at or near my goals. Most of my protein is coming from dairy products, but I'm not eating much more than before - pretty much the only change in my diet is no beef, chicken, pork or fish (with the exception of 2 days ago at a company party where there were NO vegetarian options). As far as I know I'm getting all my vitamins and minerals.
My brother in law cannot tolerate dairy - he has a very unusual reaction where it makes him extremely agressive. I think the condition is quite rare, but if you are eating more dairy than usual it might be worth considering. With anything like this, perhaps it is worth a chat with your doctor in case there are other reasons for the mood swings.
Good luck,
Erika0 -
I occasionally do a 30 day trial of different things (an idea I got from a blog post on stevepavlina.com), and my most recent trial was a switch to a vegetarian diet. I'm about two weeks into the trial, and have been noticing that lately my mood has been very bad - I'm having mood swings and am very quick to anger. Tonight I was online doing my football draft, and my wife called when my turn was just about up. I have some DSL issues that knocks out the internet when a call comes in, takes a few minutes for it to come back. Not too big of a deal, but I was very short with my wife, then when I hung up, I threw the phone down the hallway, screaming the entire time. This is not me normally. That was definitely the worst of things recently, but I've been very short with everyone including my son. I'm normally a very patient person and not prone to quick changes in mood, so I'm a bit weirded out.
Could this have anything to do with my diet switch? I found some correlation to this by googling, but it still seems a bit odd - I wasn't really expecting anything like that, and if anything, shouldn't a vegetarian diet make a person more mellow? Anyone else have ideas?
I get like that if I do not take in enough protein.
If you have gone veggie suddenly, make sure you take in food that is protein, no longer eating meat and fish could mean your protein intake is a bit low if you are not supplementing it with other stuff to replace the protein no longer there.0 -
My brother in law cannot tolerate dairy - he has a very unusual reaction where it makes him extremely agressive. I think the condition is quite rare, but if you are eating more dairy than usual it might be worth considering. With anything like this, perhaps it is worth a chat with your doctor in case there are other reasons for the mood swings.
Good luck,
Erika
my son gets like this because of casien (an ingredient found in cow's milk and cow's milk by-products). when he is off dairy products, he is completely normal but when he has something with casien, he becomes autistic-like, rages and has less focus/concentration. it lasts in his system 3 days to 2 weeks.0 -
I agree- probably too much dairy. It can make you sluggish and lazy if you eat/drink too much of it, which can then stress you out. I felt the absolute opposite after giving up animal products- enlightened and content. I don't think it's the meat0
-
I am a vegetarian myself, and the diet actually seemed to make me more calm and gentle. However, I consume a very small amount of dairy, and I take a magnesium supplement. I never thought much of magnesium before, but I had heard doctors were recommending it to people trying to quit smoking and it was supposed to help the mood swings. A couple of people I knew took it while quitting smoking and it did just that. I'm sure smoker or non-smoker, it'd help your mood. 0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions