Not burning a lot during exercise...
ybba12490
Posts: 252
A lot of people on here are burning 800+ calories every time they workout.
I, on the other hand, burn only about 300 or so. I never meet my daily cal intake in the first place, so after exercise even more calories get added.
Should I try burning more and eating more?
I, on the other hand, burn only about 300 or so. I never meet my daily cal intake in the first place, so after exercise even more calories get added.
Should I try burning more and eating more?
0
Replies
-
I'm in the same vote and workout an hour to and hour and a half a day, so I would like to know as well.0
-
It will be different for everyone because we all have different weights and fitness levels...I have worked out awhile now so my heart rate needs a lot to really get high....Even during soccer and boxing I will never burn that high0
-
I would like to know too.......I ran 4 miles today and only burned 350 calories.....0
-
You should eat your calories from exersise back! on days i know i'm going to the gym, i log my exersie in the morning , then have bigger meals those days!
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/10589-for-those-confused-or-questioning-eating-your-exercise-calo
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/61706-guide-to-calorie-deficit
This is just a part of it! please read the link above
Generally someone with a BMI over 32 can do a 1000 calorie a day (2 lbs a week) deficit
With a BMI of 30 to 32 a deficit of 750 calories is generally correct (about 1.5 lbs a week)
With a BMI of 28 to 30 a deficit of 500 calories is about right (about 1 lb a week)
With a BMI of 26 to 28 a deficit of about 300 calories is perfect (about 1/2 lb a week)
and below 26... well this is where we get fuzzy. See now you're no longer talking about being overweight, so while it's still ok to have a small deficit, you really should shift your focus more towards muscle tone, and reducing fat. This means is EXTRA important to eat your exercise calories as your body needs to KNOW it's ok to burn fat stores, and the only way it will know is if you keep giving it the calories it needs to not enter the famine response (starvation mode)
Good luck on your journey0 -
How long are you working out for? And what are you doing?
I use a HRM and burn 110+ calories per 10 mins or so.0 -
How are you logging your caloric burn? Is it with a HRM, or using the MFP (or other website) database?
This is all about finding what works best for you. If you're not meeting your caloric intake, try eating an extra item at each meal. Add in a few small snacks throughout the day. If you're allready at a huge deficit, you don't want to add to it by working out harder and keeping your food intake the same. Increase your food intake so you can find a good balance and healthy caloric deficit.
What are your eating habits like?0 -
I have read a lot of people have purchases a heart rate monitor that will give them more accurate readings on their calorie expenditure. Sometimes I think others may over-estimate it.
Personally I don't have time for 3 hour work out sessions....or if I made time I would be a walking zombie. That's just me.
I try everyday to get SOMEthing in because it is a healthy habit to have. My main focus right now is to get back to healthy eating a porton control. When the baby gets older and sleeps better I will get in the extra calorie burn eventually.
If you CAN then go for it. But, the amount of calories you burn is very individualy for everyone depending on your shape, weight, health, muscle tone (more muscle meansmore calories burned), etc.0 -
I'm the same, I'm often shocked when I see MFP-friends burning 800 or even more than 1000 on exercise (like dancing!). In fairness, I don't do any proper workouts, just go for walks, but like today, I burned 135 cals in 30 mins (and that was at a very fast speed).
Sometimes I secretly wonder if they are logging it wrong or something.0 -
hey guys...
depending on what your goal is, i always tell people, "diet is 85-90% of everything you do.... there is absolutely NO workout that can make up for a bad diet." so i would focus on making sure you have your diet solid and just right for you.. then worry about everything else.. if you have your diet right on track, it will all fall into place after that.
everyone is different, so dont focus on what everyone else is doing... just focus on you and your goals and what you are trying to do.0 -
If you're doing the same exercises every day, then your body gets more adapt at doing them and therefore burns fewer calories.
I've only been doing the same routine for 5 days now, and I'm already burning 80 calories less a session than I was when I started. Got to switch it up again!0 -
How long are you working out for? And what are you doing?
I use a HRM and burn 110+ calories per 10 mins or so.
generally I will work out 30-60 minutes... just depends on the day. Usually I will switch around on cardio machines to get variety and end up burning 200 something on those, then I will do weights, then I will walk about a mile on a track which takes about 20 minutes. I don't have a HRM but I just ordered one online so hopefully it will help.0 -
Yes, eat more and burn more! Both are more fun. I would say that 800+ calories in a work out is a lot of working out, that is running pretty fast for about 1 hour straight. Not the end of the world but not in most people day to day regiment. My recommendation would be to do 300 cals of cardio (20-30 minutes) and then do 20-30 minutes or so of high intensity circuit training (HIIT). This will build more muscle and give you a higher overall level of fitness plus it will burn about 150-200 extra calories and get you up around 500 cals a day. I use www.crossfit.com for my weight/HIIT training, but there are plenty of other sites if that doesn't float your boat.0
-
I think more and more will be better - maybe something more intense for your workouts as well - not just longer. You can burn as much at 30 calories a minute on an elliptical machine if you work hard enough (hill or interval training). I shoot for 800 calories in 30 mins on the elliptical. I swim three times a week and can burn over 1000 calories each time I do that. A one hour aerobics class or spinning class can get you over 800 calories or more as well, and when you push hard (like high intensity interval training) it keeps your body burning more calories throughout the day. When you then fuel up with more lean proteins and quality carbs your body becomes a fat burning machine.
Eat well - Eat more -Push harder.0 -
My Dr told me you don't eat back the calories as its pointless doing the exercise in the 1st place then !!
You are mean't to burn as many calories as you eat in a day....remember that sitting down burns calories too as does everyday living
I work out 6 days a week and go on the calories my treadmill says ....even though I really push it with hand weights ect I don't add extra cals burn't.......I then dog walk and sort horses so my calories burnt add up
Stay strong and concentrate on yourself hun0 -
If you're doing the same exercises every day, then your body gets more adapt at doing them and therefore burns fewer calories.
I've only been doing the same routine for 5 days now, and I'm already burning 80 calories less a session than I was when I started. Got to switch it up again!
Crossfit! I only repeat workouts once or twice a year! (There are other similar programs but I like crossfit)0 -
How are you logging your caloric burn? Is it with a HRM, or using the MFP (or other website) database?
What are your eating habits like?
I log my calories with MFP, I don't have a HRM but I just ordered one online so it will be here soon
I eat very healthy, usually only drink water or low cal drinks, eat fruits, veggies, non/lowfat dairies, whole grains etc.0 -
I used to say the same thing before I got my HRM. My elliptical would cheat me out of 50 calories for every 10 minutes I was using it...I usually would do 40...thats 200 calories I wasn't counting as burned calories. If you do not have a HRM I suggest you get one!0
-
I should have added... with the calories I'm eating daily I feel full and satisfied even after I workout. I don't want to eat if I'm not hungry0
-
1. they may say they are burning that much but it is still a TOTAL GUESS...and I always doubt those huge numbers unless they are doing some really difficult exercise with variations built in for major effect.
2. you should underestimate those calories in case you are over estimating the effect.
3. CHANGING your routine burns more calories. Doing the same thing each time you burn less each time as your body gets used to it.
Calorie burn depends on a lot of factors that are not factored into these burn guesses.
1. how big you are, if you are large you burn more, the smaller you are the less you burn
2. how out of shape you are, out of shape people burn more, the better shape you are in, the less you burn cause your body is efficient. An obese person can burn a ton of calories on a walk, while someone in shape will burn barely more than standing around.
3. how difficult is the exercise? Running, spinning or jump training (plyometrics) burns a ton while riding a bike burns much less (especially if you are used to it). Squats burn a lot, while pushups burn much less.
Bottom line is I would not get hung up on the numbers too much. All of this is just a calculation that has a lot of factors in. Base your actions on the results. If you are getting good results, keep on the same track. If not then step it up. If you are changing up your exercise, doing it regularly and making it diffucult, going for the burn, making the last part of the exercise as intense as possible, you will burn a lot. But if you are doing the same exercise all the time, not going for it totally and slowing down at the end of the exercise you will burn less each time you do it.
B :-)0 -
It's quite confusing, I agree! When I started working out a year ago, I was glad to have burned 300 cal. Now, I'm fit enough so that a half hour run is warming up. So 800 Cal per training is not a huge achievement for me now. That is not to say that it isn't hard work. I have noticed that I am one of the few people who really sweats in the gym. There's a lot of people who take it quite (or very) easy. That seems to include the power lifters, you know the really broad guys in the weights section. They seem to do very little. But when they do, wow, it hurts just watching what they lift.0
-
It really depends on the intensity and duration of the exercise, and the weight of the person. Obviously someone who weighs 200 pounds versus someone who weighs 120 pounds will burn a LOT more.
And intensity is important too! Do you do interval training? Because if you're walking at the same speed for a straight 20 minutes, you're going to burn less then someone who switches it up to warm up, fast walking, moderate pace, to fast walking and so on every few minutes. And if you're using the eliptical machine, you have to put up the resistance and also do interval training to get maximum calorie burn!0 -
It is your workouts. I start mine with 30-45 min cardio (running doesnt burn much for me so I do stairs or eliptical and/or jump roping) then I do 20-40 interval/circuit traning. Thats burns tons of calories. Last week a 90 min session burned almost 900 calories. You need to hike up the intensity and get a HRM. Check out my workouts I posted the last 2 days. They will burn over 300 calories no problem. If I do not go over 500 calories I will keep going; good luck0
-
It is your workouts. I start mine with 30-45 min cardio (running doesnt burn much for me so I do stairs or eliptical and/or jump roping) then I do 20-40 interval/circuit traning. Thats burns tons of calories. Last week a 90 min session burned almost 900 calories. You need to hike up the intensity and get a HRM. Check out my workouts I posted the last 2 days. They will burn over 300 calories no problem. If I do not go over 500 calories I will keep going; good luck0
-
How long are you working out for? And what are you doing?
I use a HRM and burn 110+ calories per 10 mins or so.
generally I will work out 30-60 minutes... just depends on the day. Usually I will switch around on cardio machines to get variety and end up burning 200 something on those, then I will do weights, then I will walk about a mile on a track which takes about 20 minutes. I don't have a HRM but I just ordered one online so hopefully it will help.
It usually takes me 2 hours to burn 1200 calories. But it is all high intensity cardio.
However, I also take blood pressure medication. And it becomes difficult to reach my target heart rate. Sometimes I can barely reach 800 calories in 2 hours. So I try to wait till after my workout to take my meds.
If you use medication for anything, make sure it is not affecting your ability to reach your targeted heart rate.0 -
I would also mention that it matters how much you weigh, and/or how much you need to lose.
When I weighted 269, I burned about 200 more cals in the same workout than I do now, simply because I was moving more weight around.
I can still bust out a 1000+ burn, but heck I am still in the 220's.
Also, I firmly believe if you service your body like the precision machine it is, then it will perform better altogether...I don't put 15 gallons of gas in my 45 gallon fuel tank and wonder why it won't just coast on the fumes. Same with fueling my body for optimum performance. Feed it to lose it.0 -
My Dr told me you don't eat back the calories as its pointless doing the exercise in the 1st place then !!
You are mean't to burn as many calories as you eat in a day....remember that sitting down burns calories too as does everyday living
I work out 6 days a week and go on the calories my treadmill says ....even though I really push it with hand weights ect I don't add extra cals burn't.......I then dog walk and sort horses so my calories burnt add up
Stay strong and concentrate on yourself hun
Uhhhh...not to start another war, but...
Yes, you burn calories just living. That's what MFP takes into account when assigning us a number to start from, then subtracting calories to fit our goals of 1 - 2 pounds of loss per week.
So, it's not pointless. Exercise is to strengthen muscles, build endurance, increase our lungs efficiency (along with most other bodily functions), etc. It's not just about the calories burned. So...if you're all ready operating at a loss to lose weight, and you burn more calories from exercise, calories need to be gained back 1) to replenish the nutrients burned during that exercise, and 2) to get back to the level of calories needed to create a deificit to lose weight.
If that's too complicated, please go here: www.shouldieatmyexercisecalories.com0 -
How long are you working out for? And what are you doing?
I use a HRM and burn 110+ calories per 10 mins or so.
I only burn about 40 calories per 10 minutes :sad: What am I doing wrong? I am often going over my max heart rate so it's not that I'm not pushing hard enough...0 -
How are you logging your caloric burn? Is it with a HRM, or using the MFP (or other website) database?
What are your eating habits like?
I log my calories with MFP, I don't have a HRM but I just ordered one online so it will be here soon
I eat very healthy, usually only drink water or low cal drinks, eat fruits, veggies, non/lowfat dairies, whole grains etc.
Good job on the HRM. MFP consistently undercalculated my caloric burn by a few hundred calories. With the HRM, I'm getting a more accurate picture of what I am doing during an exercise.
For the past week, I've burned:
- 765 calories in 75 minutes
- 803 calories in 25 minutes
- 829 calories in 78 minutes
- 495 calories in 45 minutes
- 952 calories in 80 minutes
- 651 calories in 74 minutes
- 769 calories in 59 minutes (today)
I'm not exactly the most physically fit guy. I'm also 5'11" and 197 pounds. I'm definitely going to burn more than a 5'2" 135 lb female, when doing the same activity at around the same exertion level. Hell...some days I'm really feeling it and hit every activity harder, while others I wimp out a little and take it easy. It can mean a difference of 100-200 calories from the week before. Your attitude and intensity level can play a big part in your caloric burn.
Do you eat three larger meals a day, or three smaller meals with snacks in between? I've switched to the later and it has really helped me to fit in the extra calories I need, and helped regulate my blood sugars quite a bit. I used to get weekly migraines, but now I am down to about one or two a month.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions