For the LADIES: Menstual Cycle & Weight

Options
So this is why I'm suddenly starving?! Good to know. LoL!

So fellow ladies what do you think? Will an bagel kill me?

I hope not because I can't remember the last time I was this hungry. O_o

~ Joanna


MENSTRUAL CYCLE & WEIGHT

While there may be minor changes in metabolism, food intake and cravings throughout the menstrual cycle in addition to possible water retention, these will not impact weight-loss success.

Food cravings, overeating and weight gain are commonly reported during the one to two weeks before menstruation occurs. But what is the science to support these symptoms, and what is their impact on weight-loss success?

Food Intake and Metabolism
While overeating is the popular perception, research has shown that there are only minor changes in actual food intake throughout the menstrual cycle. Most studies suggest an increase in eating of around 100 to 200 calories in the days before bleeding occurs,1,2 but this appears to be offset by the small rise in metabolism (around 5 to 10 percent)3 that occurs during the same time period. In other words, the body tends to adjust the calories in/calories out on its own. Therefore, in a weight-stable state, no changes in weight will occur.

However, if actively losing weight by following a restricted-calorie food plan, the likely result would be a slight (but hardly noticeable) increase in weight loss due to the increased metabolism without the usual increase in calories. Alternatively, the result instead could be a slightly greater difficulty in following the food plan because of increased hunger during that period.

Food Cravings
Although food cravings are commonly reported during certain times of the menstrual cycle, the scientific evidence on the subjects is limited. Some smaller studies suggest a link, particularly a craving for high carbohydrate sweets.4,5 These studies also show that cravings tend to occur more often in women with premenstural syndrome (PMS) and that the cravings increase as symptoms worsen.6 While more research is needed to understand food cravings, the good news is that they do not appear to translate into large increases in calorie intake and subsequent weight gain.

Water Retention
The most likely reason for a weight gain is water retention. While this is a common symptom that can be particularly discouraging when following a structured food plan,7 the weight gain is usually minor and temporary (that is, any weight that is gained is lost around the time of menstruation). Furthermore, water retention can be lessened during this time period by making small dietary changes, like reducing sodium and increasing fluids.

Bottom Line: Major fluctuations in eating and weight during certain periods of the menstrual cycle are a common perception, but studies done in the area find that the changes are minor, temporary and will not impact weight-loss success.


This content is reviewed regularly. Last updated September 24, 2009.

ORIGINALLY POSTED: http://www.weightwatchers.com/util/art/index_art.aspx?tabnum=1&art_id=42321&sc=801

Replies

  • audjrey
    audjrey Posts: 360 Member
    Options
    There's great truth in this article, whoever wrote it. And no, a 300 calorie bagel isn't going to make you gain weight. Consistently eating 3, 500 calories each day will, however.
  • thisisjulz
    Options
    They have thomas whole wheat bagel thins, they are so yummy! Not as much as a regular bagel but with 2tbs low fat cream cheese they are just as good! :)

    http://www.thomasenglishmuffins.com/Our-Products/Bagels/Bagel-Thins/Thomas-100-Whole-Wheat-Bagel-Thins-Bagels-(8-pack)/Default.aspx
  • Christie81
    Christie81 Posts: 88 Member
    Options
    Thanks for posting this...I needed to hear this :) It's currently my TOM and I'm a pound heavier than I was last week. Glad to know that it is just probably water retention...I feel a bit bloaded too. It has not stopped my workouts and clean eating though! :)
  • AniMarieSt
    AniMarieSt Posts: 119 Member
    Options
    They have thomas whole wheat bagel thins, they are so yummy! Not as much as a regular bagel but with 2tbs low fat cream cheese they are just as good! :)

    http://www.thomasenglishmuffins.com/Our-Products/Bagels/Bagel-Thins/Thomas-100-Whole-Wheat-Bagel-Thins-Bagels-(8-pack)/Default.aspx

    I did eat a Thomas Everything bagel thin. They are so awesome!
  • AniMarieSt
    AniMarieSt Posts: 119 Member
    Options
    I've stopped weighing myself when it's my TOM. I just give it til I'm done and then weigh myself. It always shows either a lb or two heavier and then it goes right back down, or it shows me as losing no weight and then I'll go down a few lbs. Its funny.
  • AniMarieSt
    AniMarieSt Posts: 119 Member
    Options
    There's great truth in this article, whoever wrote it. And no, a 300 calorie bagel isn't going to make you gain weight. Consistently eating 3, 500 calories each day will, however.

    I can't imagine eating that many calories in a day! I may have gained which is why I'm here, but thank god it wasn't at that rate, LoL!

    Thanks for the validation!

    ~ Joanna
  • runswithkats
    Options
    Thanks for the post. I have always wondered about the cravings. Mine kick in about a week prior and have been fighting it this week with a couple of slip ups. So much good info on MFP! In the past I would have given up and gone back overeating/cycle of depression after blowing it but I'm learning that the weight still comes off even though I'm not doing some crazy crash diet. It's slow but steady!
  • leafyq
    leafyq Posts: 21
    Options
    I never notice any changes in my body/mind when I'm on my cycle. Maybe it's because I'm on birth control?
  • AniMarieSt
    AniMarieSt Posts: 119 Member
    Options
    I never notice any changes in my body/mind when I'm on my cycle. Maybe it's because I'm on birth control?

    It could be, that would make since.
  • kittyinaz
    kittyinaz Posts: 300 Member
    Options
    Oy, I'm dealing with that right now. I'm about a week out from starting and the munchies kicked in today. I was surprised I was able to stay under calories! (not sure how I'll do the rest of the week haha!)

    It's funny because I started my period when I was 18, and have ALWAYS had irregular periods. However, since I started eating healthy in January I've had a regular period every month. So I'm not sure if I notice the period munchies more now that I'm on a calorie restricted diet or if since my body was so screwed up I didn't get the munchies before. OR maybe I just ate so much that I didn't have the munchies haha.

    Anyway, those bagel thins are WICKED good! Mmm!