Polar HRM: Everything you ever wanted to know
c7eat2live
Posts: 308 Member
Alrighty. So I got my NEW Polar today, and thought it was about time to do a little review, since heart rate monitor talk comes up so often.
My stats...Bought my first monitor in October of 2010, a Polar FT7. Im a woman (cause yes, the HRM is different for men and women and I was at basically my MFP starting weight. I was working out pretty regularly, but since I went by the calories on the machines (HUGLY over-estimated ) I really wasn't losing any weight at all. Well, that all changed within my first week of having the monitor, I just graduated to a fancier model, 15 pounds lighter! and I KNOW that change would not have happened without some motivation. My burn goal went from 200-300 per workout to 500 and about 3500/week!
Nitty gritty details: the FT7 ($100ish on BestBuy.com or sim retailer) is great. it has a chest strap (that you dampen prior to wearing) with a receiver that snaps in and a watch-like viewer. It tells you basically when you are in "fat burn" or "fitness" (although, according to a lot that I have read lately, that is all kinda a bunch of you know what...and I don't pay too much attention, staying mostly in fitness, which is a higher HR and losing plenty of fat that way). You enter all your personal stats (height, weight, age) etc. And then once you press start you can scroll through Time and Time elapsed, HR, the HR chart that shows your fitness zone, and calories burned. Pretty basic. easy to scroll, easy to use the backlight. If your gym is like mine it synchs right into most of the machines (treadmill, elip, stat bike) so you can see your HR without staring at your wrist. I also have used it during circuit training, dancing, yoga, pilates, swimming and hiking. The only general issues I have with the performance of the HRM is making sure I have accurate contact between my chest and the chest strap. if you do not dampen prior to wearing, or if you lose some contact (like in yoga and swimming) it will go into "check transmitter" mode. Only other major downside to this model??? the battery is either irreplaceable, or you need o send it to the manufacturer.
So today I graduated to a Polar FT60 ($180-325, depending on who has the best deal.Mine was cheaper cause BesBuy was having a sale). I got it because...well for one it had STELLAR reviews everywhere....a rarity. and it has WAY more menu options. Your workout is shown in three zones, and depending on if you want to lose weight, increase, or maximize your fitness level, it tells you how long to be in each zone...honestly I kinda don't care as much about this feature. Its cool because you get a little personal guidance, but maybe not super necessary, The coolest feature ever?! its GPS compatible. You can get distance and speed right there in your scroll menu. which is AWESOME if you're training for an event, or just want to get accurate mileage and speed for personal reasons.
Downsides to this model: the GPS transmitter is BIG.but on the upside it is light weight and its yet another thing strapped to your body along with the watch and chest strap. If that annoys you, it might not be the best option. Also I guess you need to get away from tall buildings and trees to get accurate signals, SO not an issue here in the desert but something to consider. The other downside to the FT60? It has quite a large menu to scroll through while you are working out. It shows HR, zones, speed, distance, time etc. usually when I am running I stick it on HR and leave it at that because scrolling through is too annoying (best for interval management) and the buttons are also kinda flat and low, making them a little tricky. HUGE upside to this model? It has a user replaceable battery. Its sleeker and nicer looking than the FT7 (big time) and it has way more options for training.
Bottom line? A heart rate monitor can radically change your workout routine. It is great for every level of fitness-interested person from walker to athlete. You will get a more accurate calorie burn count than any machine will tell you. You can wear it in or out of the gym. If you feel like you need a little extra push, this might be the thing for you! check it out! (btw, completely NOT affiliated, just a consumer)
Please let me know if you have any other questions I might be able to help answer!!
My stats...Bought my first monitor in October of 2010, a Polar FT7. Im a woman (cause yes, the HRM is different for men and women and I was at basically my MFP starting weight. I was working out pretty regularly, but since I went by the calories on the machines (HUGLY over-estimated ) I really wasn't losing any weight at all. Well, that all changed within my first week of having the monitor, I just graduated to a fancier model, 15 pounds lighter! and I KNOW that change would not have happened without some motivation. My burn goal went from 200-300 per workout to 500 and about 3500/week!
Nitty gritty details: the FT7 ($100ish on BestBuy.com or sim retailer) is great. it has a chest strap (that you dampen prior to wearing) with a receiver that snaps in and a watch-like viewer. It tells you basically when you are in "fat burn" or "fitness" (although, according to a lot that I have read lately, that is all kinda a bunch of you know what...and I don't pay too much attention, staying mostly in fitness, which is a higher HR and losing plenty of fat that way). You enter all your personal stats (height, weight, age) etc. And then once you press start you can scroll through Time and Time elapsed, HR, the HR chart that shows your fitness zone, and calories burned. Pretty basic. easy to scroll, easy to use the backlight. If your gym is like mine it synchs right into most of the machines (treadmill, elip, stat bike) so you can see your HR without staring at your wrist. I also have used it during circuit training, dancing, yoga, pilates, swimming and hiking. The only general issues I have with the performance of the HRM is making sure I have accurate contact between my chest and the chest strap. if you do not dampen prior to wearing, or if you lose some contact (like in yoga and swimming) it will go into "check transmitter" mode. Only other major downside to this model??? the battery is either irreplaceable, or you need o send it to the manufacturer.
So today I graduated to a Polar FT60 ($180-325, depending on who has the best deal.Mine was cheaper cause BesBuy was having a sale). I got it because...well for one it had STELLAR reviews everywhere....a rarity. and it has WAY more menu options. Your workout is shown in three zones, and depending on if you want to lose weight, increase, or maximize your fitness level, it tells you how long to be in each zone...honestly I kinda don't care as much about this feature. Its cool because you get a little personal guidance, but maybe not super necessary, The coolest feature ever?! its GPS compatible. You can get distance and speed right there in your scroll menu. which is AWESOME if you're training for an event, or just want to get accurate mileage and speed for personal reasons.
Downsides to this model: the GPS transmitter is BIG.but on the upside it is light weight and its yet another thing strapped to your body along with the watch and chest strap. If that annoys you, it might not be the best option. Also I guess you need to get away from tall buildings and trees to get accurate signals, SO not an issue here in the desert but something to consider. The other downside to the FT60? It has quite a large menu to scroll through while you are working out. It shows HR, zones, speed, distance, time etc. usually when I am running I stick it on HR and leave it at that because scrolling through is too annoying (best for interval management) and the buttons are also kinda flat and low, making them a little tricky. HUGE upside to this model? It has a user replaceable battery. Its sleeker and nicer looking than the FT7 (big time) and it has way more options for training.
Bottom line? A heart rate monitor can radically change your workout routine. It is great for every level of fitness-interested person from walker to athlete. You will get a more accurate calorie burn count than any machine will tell you. You can wear it in or out of the gym. If you feel like you need a little extra push, this might be the thing for you! check it out! (btw, completely NOT affiliated, just a consumer)
Please let me know if you have any other questions I might be able to help answer!!
0
Replies
-
I have the polar ft60 as well and i LOVE it
Great review.0 -
Thanks for the review! I have the FT7 but it's good to know about an upgrade when that time comes:)0
-
I got the polar ft7 about 2 weeks ago and I love, love, love it!!! Thanks for letting me know that when the battery dies, I have to buy another....0
-
yeah it may be replaceable at the factory, I didnt check that out people have told me that theirs have lasted years, so I wouldnt worry too much and yes it really is awesome! I love them both for sure.0
-
I got the polar ft7 about 2 weeks ago and I love, love, love it!!! Thanks for letting me know that when the battery dies, I have to buy another....
you send it into the factory and the replace the battery for you.0 -
The FT7 has batteries that can be replaced by the user.0
-
I have the FT 90 and its awesome.0
-
really?! mine definitely doesnt. The FT60 clearly shows you how to open the back and replace. and the 7 doesnt...hmmm...I'll google
"The estimated average battery life of the Polar Wrist Receiver is 1-2 year(s), depending on model, in normal use (2h/day, 7 days a week). Note that an excessive use of the backlight and the beep signal will shorten the battery life.
Many new Polar products have user changeable batteries in both the watch and transmitter.
Polar Receivers with user changeable batteries.
Running
Cycling
Fitness
Other
RS400
CS100
FA20
AXN300
RS800
CS200
FT40
AXN500
CS400
FT60
AXN700
CS600
FT80"
quoted from the Pola rusa site0 -
I had the ft7 for maybe a week and I lost the watch part to it! I still have the chest strap, but so I'm thinking that I might have just dropped the watch coming back from the gym, but I'm really not sure! I just started Insanity too, so it would be so nice to have it! If I don't end up finding my watch, I'm going to have to buy a new one when I get the money.
Oh, but for the week that I had it, I loved it!0 -
I don't have an HRM, do you guys sugesst I get one?
Is it really a drastic change compared to what the treadmill and bike say?0 -
I got the polar ft7 about 2 weeks ago and I love, love, love it!!! Thanks for letting me know that when the battery dies, I have to buy another....
The newest FT7 does have an easily replaceable battery. You just require the battery and a knife or spoon or flat tip screw driver.0 -
My FT7 has the coin operated battery covers on both the watch and transmitter. Maybe the older models don't, but right off Polar's website it states FT7 batteries are user replacable0
-
ok awesome thanks for clearing that up!0
-
I don't have an HRM, do you guys sugesst I get one?
Is it really a drastic change compared to what the treadmill and bike say?
Sometimes yes! And you can use it when you aren't in the gym.
find out how many calories you are burning when you are walking around a mall doing your shopping etc. Or doing housework etc.0 -
I don't have an HRM, do you guys sugesst I get one?
Is it really a drastic change compared to what the treadmill and bike say?0 -
I found my heart rate monitor while I was cleaning my room! It was actually in the same bag that I had thought it was in all along, just in a different pocket! I honestly can't believe that I hadn't checked there right away lol! Needless to say, I am still happy about finding it!0
-
My HRM is my motivator. I have the FT4.
FYI: If you are a swimmer and use your HRM when in the water, I would suggest you send your Polar HRM in for the battery replacement because they check and make sure its still waterproof. My instructions say I can replace the battery myself but they suggest I send it in for that reason.0 -
I'm also in love with my FT4. The most important feature for me is the current HR display while working out. Like any other human, I tend to drop the intensity a little when really tired. My HR Monitor lets me know I'm slacking!0
-
I got the polar ft7 about 2 weeks ago and I love, love, love it!!! Thanks for letting me know that when the battery dies, I have to buy another....
You don't have to. You can replace the battery...or if you go to Best Buy (like I did), I got the warranty and they completely cover the battery replacement..0 -
Thanks for taking the time to review, this is perfect for me as I've just been looking at getting a HRM this morning. I'm fed up of guessing my burn, I always under estimate anyways but think a HRM would keep me in check x0
-
I don't have an HRM, do you guys sugesst I get one?
Is it really a drastic change compared to what the treadmill and bike say?
If you are wanting to know how many calories you are REALLY burning when exercising, YES! That was one of the best purchases I have made in regards to healthy living. The numbers on machines and MFP are pretty different than what I get on my HRM.0 -
I have an old FT11 (dont think they are made anymore but I have seen it on some internet stores) anyway all of the features of the FT7 plus own zone and guidelines for what level to be training at for how long - varies from day to day -battery is totally user replaceable and I have seen this model for as cheap as $80
does not have a GPS function like the FT 60 though0 -
Just to make sure I am reading it right, the machines told you lower calories burned than the HRM? Or the other way around? My HRM says I burn 100-300 calories more while running!0
-
I have a bodybugg and I absolutely love it..0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.8K Introduce Yourself
- 43.9K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 22 News and Announcements
- 1.2K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions