Limited budget and Healthy eating????
tobitude
Posts: 89 Member
I have to ask this because I am trying to make this work. I have a family of four and we are on a very limited budget, we do our best to stay with mostly healthy options but when you reach the end of your budget lean meats and healthier breads and some of the other healthy options are just out of the question (we do make sure we have some on a regular basis). We buy things when they are on sale and I get my fruits and veggies from a local farmers market to keep the cost low.
So anyway I am asking if it is gonna be possible for me to accomplish this with having to make choices due to cost rather than healthy choices, or am I just wasting my time????
For example 99 cent loaf of bread is cheaper than whole grain and last longer for a family of four, and chicken leg quarters are cheaper than chicken breasts.
If anyone else is dealing with this issue and having success I would love to hear how you are able to do this.
Not looking for judgement just looking for some feedback.
So anyway I am asking if it is gonna be possible for me to accomplish this with having to make choices due to cost rather than healthy choices, or am I just wasting my time????
For example 99 cent loaf of bread is cheaper than whole grain and last longer for a family of four, and chicken leg quarters are cheaper than chicken breasts.
If anyone else is dealing with this issue and having success I would love to hear how you are able to do this.
Not looking for judgement just looking for some feedback.
0
Replies
-
You can only do your best with what you have, but at the end of the day it's calories in vs calories out to lose weight. It helps to eat healthier for other reasons, but losing the weight will make you healthier than you are now regardless.0
-
Eating chicken leg quarters is fine. Take the skin off and bake it.0
-
Frozen vegetables might be cheaper, and sometimes have more nutrients than fresh vegetables. With chicken, would taking the skin off and cooking it in different ways make up the difference between legs and breasts? You could try things like that.
Do you have the time to make things from scratch? They can be cheaper that way. Or could you feed your family more of the cheapest options and less of the expensive ones?0 -
Hello!
Me and my wife are both in college and are on a limited budget also. It's diffidently difficult to stick to healthy eating when most of the healthy stuff is much more expensive. We have found that as long as the food isn't terrible for you, it seems to work with weight loss. Like with the chicken, you may not be able to afford the fancy lean chicken, but if you get the regular chicken and cut any of the fat off, it's still a better alternative then just getting ground beef or other greasy type meat products. Somethings boil down to a little more work at home for a cheaper cost. Hope that helps some!0 -
It's hard. I do as much shopping as I can at a bulk store (Sam's Club) then I re-package and portion out everything. They don't have everything I'm looking for but I'm on a super thin budget, so this has helped some. Good luck and great job for being on top of eating healthy.0
-
when it comes to the chicken, take off the skin when cooking. Bread... make your own using different. A bag of wheat flour and yeast goes a long way. Any leftovers???? FREEZE THEM FOR A DIFFERENT MEAL. Homemade soups also go along way.
I raised 5 kids on a very very strict budget being a single mom, its all about planning and researching... Its a pain in the *kitten* but well worth it0 -
Buy in bulk, buy when it's on sale, instead of paying extra for stewing beef buy a cheaper cut of roast and cube it yourself for stewing, buy a whole chicken when the per pound price is cheaper than the thighs or breasts alone. Grow some of your own herbs or veggies if you've got room, if you don't have room look into sprouting, there's lots of options for sprouting and it only takes an empty mason jar.
Make some of your own bread...
Healthy eating doesn't have to be expensive I question the "organic" labels on so many things, room-mate has a jar of face cleaner that is 78% organic, to me its either all organic or its not qualified as organic.
But definitely be prepared to buy in bulk, I buy a 12 pack of canned soup when it goes on for $6 sold individually they are $1.49 each so I save almost $1 per can by buying more of them than I may immediately need but they are shelf stable so I don't mind them sitting so I don't have to pay full price. Same when tuna goes on for $1 a can, I'll buy a dozen of them which will last me 3 months or so..0 -
Whole grains and beans are pretty cost effective. Especially if you cook them yourself rather than buy them canned. Try incorporating more vegetarian meals into your weekly meal plans too. A big part about this weight loss journey is changing current habits and trying new things. Rather than just substitute lower calorie versions of what you already eat maybe explore new recipes? Good luck!0
-
I competely understand the budget thing. For bread, the best bet is going to be to shop around. Try Target, Wal-Mart and Costco/Sams/BJs. You should be able to find something less expensive there. My husband is a vegetarian, but the kids and I are not. I purchase all out meat at Costco. We only eat, chicken breast, fish and ground turkey (this I get as needed from Target). Buyin in bulk on the meat helps with the bottom line cost wise. You can also cut back on the amount of meat you consume. You could have one meat free day a week or month.
Vegetables are easier, because frozen works just fine and is WAY cheaper. For any of this stuff if you want organic go to Trader Joe's if you have one or check into a CSA for group buying on organic produce.
Check out these people. http://today.msnbc.msn.com/id/28295159/ns/today-money/. I see them on the Today show all the time and they support a family of 7 on $44,000. Not sure how lean they eat, but you might get some great ideas.
Good luck to you!0 -
That's right it is calories in vs. calories out. When I started I continued to eat the same old junk as I did to gain weight in the first place but in moderation and within my calorie goals and I lost weight without starting to exercise or even eat healthier but just by staying within my calorie goals. I have since started to eat healthier and add in a little exercise because this site has helped me realize the benefit of it but overall if you stay at your calorie goal you will lose weight.
A few months ago there was a story on the news about someone actually started a "junk food" diet and ate stricktly out of a vending machine for a couple of weeks and ate complete junk food (chips, cookies, candy) and managed to actually lose weight just because they stuck with a calorie goal. I figure if someone that only eats junk can loose weight by counting calories then anyone can.0 -
I see you live in Florida, so you should have plenty of sunshine. Are you in a home? If so and you have some room in your yard you can make a small garden. You will have some of your own veggies and it is an activity that will help keep you active. We had one growing up and while (back then) I hated working in it there was nothing tastier than picking something and then taking it in and eating it.0
-
Believe me, you're not the only one on a budget... You can still succeed in making yourself healthier by the preparation of those foods you have to buy on sale...for example, bake rather than fry and what-not or by practicing portion control. There are ways to do this on a budget and I'd much rather see you try than give up because you think you're not being healthy enough... Take it one step at a time.0
-
Yes! I have a family of 4 as well and we stick to a tight budget. I do not shop for boxed or frozen convienent meals - they might seem to be easier and cheaper but they are not. I purchase a loaf of whole wheet bread for $1.09. I also get the frozen veggies for $1 because I know that they will last longer if for some reason we don't get to eating them right away. I also buy yogurt, or cottage cheese in a bigger tub rather than indidual containers. Make sure that you are shopping for filling foods like multi grain pastas. Even if it costs a little bit more that the other stuff your family will be fuller for longer and not eat as much food.
Another trick that I have is to make up some meals ahead of time and freeze them. These make for easy on the go lunches. My kids need to have a packed lunch every day so their meals usually consist of pb&j sandwich, yogurt or string cheese, fruit or apple sauce, and a snack pack pudding. If we have left overs I'll send them with that and also a piece of fruit. I generally eat left overs for lunch or soup. Deli meat is expensive so I try to limit what I buy. This past week I bought a turkey on sale made it and then we had left over turkey sandwiches.
Good Luck. Remember that coupons are great too as long as you were already going to purchase it.0 -
i try to buy when things are on sale and portion it and stick it in the freezer.,.,usually around holidays in cali there are alot of sales so i try to keep extra money that week.,.,.,i know here we have a food for less and you can get week bread on sale 2 loaves for a little over 2 buck.,.,.,it is hard i am on a budget too....and coupons! those always help it extra time to look for coupons but sometimes you can get great deals...0
-
We are a family of 5. I do not work I am a full time student, we make less than 30,000 a year, and we do not receive any assistance.
If you buy healthy food you will see you are filled up longer adn you will not eat as much food. Also make everything from scratch. Yes the day you go to the store and buy all the ingredients it is more expensive than if you loaded up with the cheap stuff. However, the cheap stuff is gone quickly, and the other stuff is still there.
I buy meat that has been marked down due to the expiration date. At the store I shop at they mark it 40% off 2 days before it expires. Then I freeze it if I can not use it right away. Clip coupons. Find a way to save money and be healthy too.
Good luck!!0 -
I am in the same boat, I have a family of seven and we have to eat what we can afford to buy.
I focus on portion control and try the best to include the MOST healthy choices we can manage.
It may not be the BEST options, but they are the BEST options for us.
We chose the best solutions we can make within our budget.
I think that you need to applaud yourself for trying the best you can to do what you are able with the resources you have.0 -
What everyone else has said is great so I'm not going to rehash... some things I thought of:
Exercise is a great way to offset the extra calories you get so find something you like... also...
If its possible, why not consider making a garden. It doesnt have to be fancy and it works two fold: You get free veggies AND you get some exercise. Spend a half hour a day on the garden and bam, theres a half hour of Light / Heavy labor... in fact... thats probably not a bad idea for yours truly.
Either way, keep at it and good luck!0 -
I am on a pretty limited food budget as well. Tuna is a good option and usually pretty cheap. Yes also frozen veggies are usually cheaper than fresh. If you have the money to buy larger quantities of things like meat it is almost always cheaper in bulk and freeze smaller portions. Store brand wheat bread isn't that much higher in calories than some of the more expensive brands, and I don't eat enough bread to worry much about a few extra calories when I do eat it. Chicken it doesn't really matter what part of the chicken it is as much as it matters how you cook it. Planning my menu ahead of time has helped a lot too. Plan your menu while looking at the weekly specials or sales. You can definitely still eat healthy on a limited budget, it just takes a little bit more work. :-)0
-
I see there are four Aldi stores in Orlando. Have you done any shopping there? I find their prices to be much lower than even WalMart. For example, a gallon of skim milk at Aldi is $2.24, at WalMart it is over $3.
Aldi carries very nice whole chickens, frozen, for .89 cents a pound. You should be able to not only feed your family a delicious meal, but have enough left over for a casserole.
Aldi carries a line of reduced fat/sodium foods called Fit and Active. There is a very good chicken noodle soup that compares to Progresso for half the cost. Their breakfast cereals are also much less expensive than the name brands and are just as good. Is it a pain to have to take your own bags and bag your own groceries? Sure, but the savings are worth it.
Here's another trick I used to use (fed four kids on a limited budget). Divide four pounds of lean ground meat into five meals. You won't even notice the difference and getting the "free" meal makes up for the expense of buying better ground beef.
I don't work for Aldi - but I do do 99% of my shopping there. We live on our Social Security Checks - less than $25,000 a year - and by being very careful, we're OK.0 -
Whole grains and beans are pretty cost effective. Especially if you cook them yourself rather than buy them canned. Try incorporating more vegetarian meals into your weekly meal plans too. A big part about this weight loss journey is changing current habits and trying new things. Rather than just substitute lower calorie versions of what you already eat maybe explore new recipes? Good luck!
I love the vegetarian idea! My family and I eat vegetarian meals at least 3 times a week. It gets my kids to try new things too. We also buy our meat from a butcher. It's completely worth the upfront cost because it's the leanest cuts and cheaper that buying at the store every week. My husband also hunts therefor we have plenty of venison steaks and roasts. They are lean and practically free for us.0 -
Shop the perimeter and avoid the center isles of stores that include boxed and processed food. Processed food is not cheaper then healthy food. I rarely if ever eat bread. Frozen veggies are perfectly fresh and healthy. Most people can't grasp the concept that the portion size of a TV dinner which to some seems like nothing is the perfect sized portion for EVERYBODY. Once you've achieved the weight you desire and accepted whats a normal sized portion you will save dollars. Most chicken breasts are 6-9 ounces so one is enough to feed 3 people. One leg quarter is more then enough protein for 2 people. Buy on sale always and put in the freezer. Eating healthy really is NO more expensive then eating unhealthy.0
-
I eat "surimi" often for my protein, often. It's the "artificial crab" stuff, made from fish. I like it, and it happens to be inexpensive, when it's on sale - particularly the larger size packs. It works out to about 60 cents per half cup serving, which has 70 calories, 6 grams protein and 0 fat - but it is highly processed - and lots of sodium.0
-
I struggled with this at first as well. But after seeing the MANY weight related issues that our extended family members have gone through, my husband and I decided that the health "savings" were much greater than the pocketbook cost of the food. For us, the "cost" wasn't as much as we had assumed anyway. When you're replacing the junk food with the healthy food, there really isn't a huge cost increase. If you try to buy the healthier foods WITH the junk foods, then yes, the grocery bill will go way up.
Another thing we found that as we got into eating healthier was cheaper ways to make it work. At first, it seems daunting, but just keep up with it and you'll find ways to cut your budget while still eating healthier. We have found food co-ops to be WONDERFUL for getting cheap, fresh, healthy foods. Check around and see if there are any in your area. Watch for sales. We usually get chicken breasts from our local grocery store for slightly more than the legs (when we watch sales) but when you take into consideration that we're not paying for the bones or skin, we figure we actually come out ahead!
Good luck! It's hard at first but stick to it and it will eventually pay off!0 -
I have a family of 4 and my food budget is $400 a month. It's not easy. Here are some things I do:
Stock up on what's on sale. Last week boneless skinless chicken breasts were $1.88 a pound. I bought about 50 pounds of it. Developing a good stock is hard to start with a limited budget. You can't always drop 25% of your budget on just chicken for example. But do what you can when you can. After a few months the stocks start to grow and it gets easier.
When figuring meat cost by weight consider the parts you don't eat. Yes, leg quarters are cheaper by the pound, but you aren't eating that bone. 70% ground beef gets super cheap sometimes, but you aren't eating all that fat that comes out during cooking. When you make a burger with 94% ground beef it doesn't shrink.
I never spend more than $2 a pound on any meat. How? I hit up the grocery stores in the morning and snag the marked down meats. It's either eaten that day or it goes in the freezer. Marked down meat scares some people but I've never had a problem with it. I don't do marked down fish though.
Check out the bulk bins. Oatmeal is cheap and filling. It's even cheaper in bulk. I also get pancake mix and dried fruit there. The kids like picking what flavor of pancakes they will get. I make them with Pam on a nonstick skillet. I get soup base there too. Soup makes you feel like you're eating a lot more than you really are. And spices,... man spices are expensive in a little bottle, and pennies from the bunk bins.
I've never seen a Goodwill that didn't have a bread machine for sale. Used bread machine + bulk bin ingredients and you can make your own healthy bread. Throw in all those happy little nuts and twigs that are good for you. I spend a day doing it and I have a months worth of healthy bread. Just toss it in the freezer.
Gotta love the freezer! If you run out of room you can usually find a stand alone freezer in the local classifieds. Even after the electricity cost in pays for its self in food savings.0 -
I know how you feel, but like another member said, it's Calories in vs Calories Out...I usually buy a whole roasted chicken from the supermarket for $5.99, which makes 2 decent meals for 2 people. I have a leg and thigh one day and a breast and wing the next. It's all about portions.0
-
i dont buy the expensive breads. i eat the 99cent loafs (its lowest in cal anyway), as long as u get wheat vs white.
i shop on $200 a month for me and my mom (she probably spends $50 of her money on stuff she specifically wants, so $250). I eat alot of baked potatoes and rice. fat free milk instead of whole milk is same price but lower fat & calories. lots of stuff like that r same price but just different, so price wont be different.
With meat i cut out as much fat as possible. I have ground beef sometimes but limit my amount. If Im gunna make hamburger helper or meat in my spaghetti i make sure to really drain it well, and also instead of using a whole pound the receipe calls for i use .75lbs or .5lbs, which saves money AND calories/fat.
I have steak and pork, etc, and just watch portions.
Canned tuna on sale (my moms been finding it at 25cents a can, so we have 20cans right now), then i mix it with yogurt instead of mayo to save calories and add in some celery for a veggie.
I rarely buy fresh fruits. I get canned ones and lil indivdual cups. also frozen ones r good for smoothies, etc. this month on my list i have some fruits like grapes and raisins, but unless i can afford the fruit, i dont get it.
Veggies seem cheap to me so far, lots of carrots, celery, spinach, brocolli for me. i like mine fresh, canned has to much sodium generally, and im not big on frozen veggies personally but thats just me. I probably eat carrots everyday. good snack, filling than other veggies.
I shop at winco and they have seasonings in bulk (just refill ur old garlic powder instead of buying a new bottle, etc), saves money. they have nuts and such too that i plan to look at next time i go.
Go online and use coupons, get a newspaper with the coupons in it, etc... will help save money.
I buy a whole loaf of regular cheddar cheese and dont worry about low cal ones that are more expensive, i cut my slices really thin so they arent a full ounce..
beans n such r cheap, however i dont like beans, so i dont use them.
be careful with processed foods and such items. compare labels.
the cheap 75cent can of spaghetti sauce is under half the calories of the expensive jarred ones... wheat noodles instead of regular... leg quarters r fine, remove any skin or fat like that..
Just count ur calories and try not to go over.. i eat cheap, im full all the time, and im never over on calories (until i go out or something like that). I personally buy bagged chicken breast, frozen, skinless, boneless, etc and one bag is $5 and lasts me like 3weeks because ur only using half a breast for a 4oz serving..
I dont feed a family as big as yours, however i have to eat cheap as well...
oh and if u have the option, doing things like popping ur own popcorn can save u money, instead of individually wrapped packages. make ur own meals instead of anything boxed or pre-made.0 -
My fiance and I are on a tight budget. We have been cooking a lot with beans and in the crock pot. I make taco soup,bean soup, bean chili, etc. we usually get 10 one cup servings out of our recipes and will eat off the crock pot meal all week for lunches and dinners. If I do put in meat I will buy 1lb of ground turkey on sale and put 1 lb in the recipe, it provides even more protein in addition to the beans. Bean are less than a dollar a can and really make a meal filling!0
-
I appreciate all the replies and have picked out a few of the responses and plan on using them.
For the bread, as much as I would like to say I am a good cook that is the only thing I am not able to make from scratch. If you would like a brick feel free to call me for a loaf of homemade bread LOL.
Some of the things we already do to make sure we stay in budget, and some of the things I will pick up and start using.
I am also the queen of the freezer and buy stuff cheap or on discount and freeze it.
Thanks for everything, and feel free to friend me if you need a friend with similat issues LOL.0 -
I understand exactly where you are coming from, I would buy the expensive bread for yourself and take 2 slices place them in a freezer bag. ( Do this with the whole loaf). That way it wont go stale and therefore you are saving on waste. Frozen veg is just as good as fresh and much cheaper ( especially the out of season variety). Make homemade soups you can literally use anything and throw it in, always going to be filling and low calorie ( as long as you dont use cream). Eggs are relatively cheap and can be so versatile. As for fruit go to the supermarket and buy the damaged fruit, take it home and make smoothies. Chicken quarters are fine as long as skinless and so many recipes can be used. Buy rice and wholemeal pasta in bulk always the cheaper option. Hope some of these tips help. love and hugs.xx0
-
Something else you could do is make up for own cereal/muesli. You can buy all sorts of breakfast grains (oats, bran, millet, rice, wheatgerm etc etc) and add some sultanas, some coconut, whatever is cheap at the time and make up a big batch of cereal. It'll save loads of money and will keep well as long as you have a decent air-tight container.
If you don't have the space or time to grow your own veggies, maybe you could just make a little herb garden in a pot plant. This way you can grow a number of different herbs and use them in your cooking. You get the benefit of lots of nice fresh herbs to flavour your meals meaning you can cook with less fat and salt.
Buying in bulk is also good. I've stopped buying the individual tubs of yoghurt, but kept a couple of the tubs and washed them out. And now I buy the 1kg tubs and spoon portions into the little tubs for snacks. I do the same with tinned fruit.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions