Too easy. Ami doing something wrong? PLZ help!

qbanyto
qbanyto Posts: 18 Member
edited September 25 in Health and Weight Loss
So the "my fitness pal" app on my iPhone tells me I should be consuming the max of 2100 calories. 

Ok...

The world tells me to burn more calories than I consume. Obviously that's nearly impossible to do on a day to day basis and unhealthy. 

Another article told me I shouldn't eat more than the 2100 caloric amount but also not to eat less than 1400 calories. 

I aiming for fat loss btw.  

So anyways, I'm here doing my diet and realize that I have to eat alot to get to my 2100 caloric limit. Some how it feels wrong. Like it's too easy. 

Can some one slap me?

Any info please. I really need a clear but simple answer. And can you provide an example of your explanation? Thanks guys and gals!

Replies

  • MzBug
    MzBug Posts: 2,173 Member
    Nothing that complicated about it. If MFP says your net calorie goal is 2100 per day, it has already figured in the necessary deficit to have you lose weight as you specified (1-2 pounds per week as long as you have your activity level entered correctly) without additional exercise. 2100 per day for an active 25 year old male is reasonable. The suggested minimum caloric level for a man to get the required nutrition for your body to function properly is 1500 net per day. They have found that it is very difficult to get the proper nutrition by consuming less. If you exercise in addition to your normal daily activity level you get to consume those calories too (if you desire). You will see posts on the boards that argue for and against consuming exercise calories, but it will come down to personal choice. The extra calories earned by exercising do come in handy if you like to have an adult beverage once in a while, or if you have a special occasion where there will be lots of food and beverages involved.

    It really is that simple. The hard part comes in when you log your food and beverage choices and amounts. Do yourself a favor and be brutally honest when it comes to logging your stuff. Measure everything until you get used to portion control. Educate yourself about any specific needs you may have and the necessary dietary requirements (either medical conditions or wishing to build muscle). Read the "stick pinned" items at the beginning of the message boards. Use the "search" function, and use the "help" (aka FAQ) function. Feel free to ask questions, and I am sure you will get plenty of opinions.

    Good Luck!
  • qbanyto
    qbanyto Posts: 18 Member
    Is it really that easy? Why do so many people make counting calories hard? I was always a carb counter but now that I'm counting calories I have a wider selection of foods to eat and it's incredibly simple to count them. Thanks to the iPhone!

    So to answer my question, is lay man terms, how much calories do I eat per day to lose weight (1-2lbs) perweek?
    I usually like to do cardio in the morning since Its more beneficial I hear. But I will be weight lifting as well. So basically consume all my 2100 calories to start seeing weightloss?
  • qbanyto
    qbanyto Posts: 18 Member
    Bump skipity bump bump
  • shaunshaikh
    shaunshaikh Posts: 616 Member
    I eat 2,200 calories a day on average and lose a pound a week. It just depnds on your metabolic rate and how much you exercise. Calories in, calories out.
  • MzBug
    MzBug Posts: 2,173 Member
    Is it really that easy? Why do so many people make counting calories hard? I was always a carb counter but now that I'm counting calories I have a wider selection of foods to eat and it's incredibly simple to count them. Thanks to the iPhone!

    So to answer my question, is lay man terms, how much calories do I eat per day to lose weight (1-2lbs) perweek?
    I usually like to do cardio in the morning since Its more beneficial I hear. But I will be weight lifting as well. So basically consume all my 2100 calories to start seeing weightloss?

    It is that easy. Calorie counting used to be a royal pain in the butt because you had to have the calorie book and detail out exactly how much of whatever was used to make a recipe or meal, paper and pencil, calculator, and a large chunk of time to write it all down. Most people would log once a day, and often forgot a bit of this or that in the calculations and would go over the allowed amount. It was a very frustrating experience.

    In order to lose a pound a week you need to cut your total calories (BMR plus activity and exercise) by 3500 a week (500 per day). For a 2 pound loss you need to cut 1000 per day. MFP took most of the guess work out and figured out your BMR and activity level (WITHOUT EXERCISE) and gives you your calorie amount per day to lose what ever amount you chose when you set up your profile. If you are not sure what you put you can look at your goals from your home page. Since many people have busy lives MFP did not include any exercise in the equasion. Sometimes you just don't have the time to do anything. Sometimes you just don't feel like it. Some people start with great expectations of an hour of exercise a day, but in reality can only do it 3 times a week. MFP ADDS calories in when you log your exercise. Those calories are available for you to consume WITHOUT it negatively affecting your goal of 1-2 pounds per week. Quite simply, the more you exercise the more you get to eat.

    If you consume your 2100 calories a day you should see a drop in weight. That is assuming everything is entered correctly. If after 3 weeks you are not seeing results you can ask on the message boards for someone to look over your food and exercise logs and give an opinion on why you may not be seeing results. Remember than MFP does not have doctors, nurses, trainers, or any other medical staff (though some are members of MFP and will offer their professional opinions). Any advice, tips, or suggestions are OPINIONS and should be treated as such. You should always check with your physician if you are having any problems.
  • qbanyto
    qbanyto Posts: 18 Member
    Wow thanks for the info guys. Basically on the app I Put in to lose 2 lbs a week. So if I stay within the 2100 calorie a day u should lose about albs a week right?

    I ask cause if I change the weekly goal to 1 lbs per week, my daily caloric intake increases.

    Sorry I'm asking alot. It just seems like one of those "too good to be true" things. 2100 colries is alot of food. It doest even feel like a diet. Maybe society and the media has convinced me to starve to lose weight lol
  • shaunshaikh
    shaunshaikh Posts: 616 Member
    The theory behind it is that there are roughly 3,500 calories in a pound of fat. Therefore, to lose one pound of fat in a week, you would want to take in 500 less calories per day than you burn. If you want to lose two pounds in a week, double that number -- 1,000 calorie per day deficit.

    MFP estimates your metabolic rate based on your height, gender, age, etc. and then subtracts 250, 500, 750, or 1,000 based on your goal. Typically, leaner people need to be on the lower end of the goals and people with a lot more fat to lose need to be on the higher end.

    One thing that you'll get from counting calories from every single thing you injest is that it really IS that easy to go over your caloric limit if you're used to making bad decisions or if your'e just ignorant to putting stuff in your body. I had no idea that a typical dinner at Oliver Garden was 2,500+ calories in one sitting if you include the bread sticks I housed on a regular basis. Or that the giant Mexican platter with the basket of chips was 3,000+. A lot of stuff IS eye-opening.

    Good luck with losing weight and make sure to reach out for help along the way.
  • fcrisswell
    fcrisswell Posts: 234 Member
    MFP really does make it that easy.

    I use to HATE logging/journalling my food intake no matter how many times my doctor would suggest it. It was too time consuming....laborious. Carrying a little notebook everwhere and writing things down all the time.

    A couple weeks ago I found this app on my android phone and LOVE it. It is sooooo easy. I love the scanner and hardly even have to type in what I need anymore. Most of us tend to eat regular foods so once it is in there it is on your list. Easy peasy. I now can see why I could not lose the "baby" weight....my grazing/snacking eating habits while pregnant carried over after he was born. I did not think I was eating a whole lot but throughout the day it adds up fast.

    AS long as you entered the correct info at set-up then you are good to go. And you can always adjust your goals/settings as you lose/not lose. Let's face it...we are not all the same and do not all have the same metabolisms. One equation fits most but along the way may need some tweeking. Good Luck!
  • qbanyto
    qbanyto Posts: 18 Member
    Thanks for the response!!

    Well so far I've been doing pretty well. Except my first day. I POSSIBLY went over by 5 calories. But I should he fine right? It won't happen again I hope.

    I'm very specific about what I log in so the calculations should be tight. Except today. I had spaghetti with ground beef. Had about 3 cups since I had about 1088 calories to play with for the day. I'm assuming on the MFP app, the "spaghetti with ground beef (homemade)" meal includes the marinara sauce. Other wise it would be noodles and ground beef , no?
  • MzBug
    MzBug Posts: 2,173 Member
    Never assume anything... remember the entries are made by other users, from other countries, and even their own recipes. Sometimes the information may not be correct for what you have on your plate. Better to enter stuff item by item or use the recipe function if it is something you make quite often.
  • qbanyto
    qbanyto Posts: 18 Member
    yea i guess. i check most of them by product and app and the info matches. better safe than sorry i guess :)
  • elliecolorado
    elliecolorado Posts: 1,040
    I always enter my own recipes in the recipe section putting in exactly how much of everything that I used while making it. you can use what is in the database here, but the only way to be 100% sure that you are counting everything you eat is to not assume that your recipe is the same as someone elses and put in your own recipe. It takes some time at first, but after a while you will have recipes in for foods that you make regularly.
This discussion has been closed.