Jogging-Unhealthy?
Options
Replies
-
HEY.... I JUST STARETED JOGGING FOR 30MINS BEFORE WORK FOR THE LAST MONTH AND A HALF AND I LOVE IT ..... IT HAS CHANGED MY BODY AND GAVE ME A GREAT NEW WAY TO CHALLANGE MYSELF. I'VE ONLY HERD JOGGING ON AN INCLINE IN HARD ON YOUR KNEES........ NUT IT'S A GREAT MORNING WORK OUT - KEEP IT UP SISTA0
-
I always told myself I "couldn't" run because I had bad knees.
Now that I do run, my knees never felt better! Actually... everything feels better.
I figured for once I should listen to my doctor, and it likely saved me from needing a knee replacement before I was 30. I was born with messed up knees (missing ligaments/muscles and malformed bone structure). Makes losing weight a pain in the *kitten*. Thank goodness for elliptical machines!0 -
I actually disagree with the "bad on your knees" / form argument. I've been a runner for 6 years and haven't had any joint problems. I think, in fact, that running makes your joints stronger. Think of it from a muscle standpoint -- people could say that weight lifting is bad because it's so hard on the muscles. Indeed, lifting does tear down and actually rip muscle fibers -- until the body adapts and builds new, stronger ones in their place. I believe something similar happens in the joints (barring any degenerative disorders that are NOT running, but rather genetic, related). You beat them up running, and as had been said, as long as you don't overdo it, you're going to get stronger and more durable joints in their place. The human body is a remarkable adaptive machine, built to handle far more stresses than the modern western lifestyle will EVER place upon it, and that includes those ultra runners, etc., out there.
The only reason it'd be bad for your joints is because of bad form. A good way to test if your form is proper is to try running barefoot. It forces you to run with perfect form because slamming an unprotected heel into the ground is immensely painful. However padded shoes let people do some pretty nasty things.
Some people's bodies can take the strain on their knees, but others can't. Plus, everyone benefits from proper form out of the fact that its a whole lot easier to run faster, and longer with good form. Heel striking basically causes force to be exerted in the opposite direction of the direction you're running (up through the heel, ankle, knee, and then pelvis and hip). This basically causes you to stop for a moment every time you impact.
Striking with the front of your foot basically gives you a natural shock absorber (your knee and hip are bent, so they act like a spring), and it lets you keep your center of gravity in front of the impact point, so there is no lost momentum.
Here's a video that explains it better than i can in text:
http://www.youtube.com/user/njsportsmed#p/a/u/2/9itkEkcQ8WM
And here's an article from Harvard athletic studies:
http://www.barefootrunning.fas.harvard.edu/4BiomechanicsofFootStrike.html0 -
Striking with the front of your foot basically gives you a natural shock absorber (your knee and hip are bent, so they act like a spring), and it lets you keep your center of gravity in front of the impact point, so there is no lost momentum.
Here's a video that explains it better than i can in text:
http://www.youtube.com/user/njsportsmed#p/a/u/2/9itkEkcQ8WM
My body forced me to do this naturally. I had to figure out how NOT to "jiggle" too much. Sorry. TMI. I know.0 -
Striking with the front of your foot basically gives you a natural shock absorber (your knee and hip are bent, so they act like a spring), and it lets you keep your center of gravity in front of the impact point, so there is no lost momentum.
Here's a video that explains it better than i can in text:
http://www.youtube.com/user/njsportsmed#p/a/u/2/9itkEkcQ8WM
My body forced me to do this naturally. I had to figure out how NOT to "jiggle" too much. Sorry. TMI. I know.
No worries, running ain't glamorous. It's messy, bouncy, gooey, and sometimes smelly0 -
Time to adjust my jogging style, thanks everyone0
-
I've been getting this alot when I tell people I am training for a marathon. Invariably the 1st thing they say is "you will wreck your knees".
It's unfortunate because I genuinely think they mean well, but the are just severely misinformed about running, since 99.9% of the people that tell me that, have never run.0 -
I know I'm probably not the norm, but my knee problems went away when I started running MORE. I think part was the muscle tone around my knees getting better AND the weight loss incurred from the running. My mother-in-law once told me that running was uncivilized. People say the dumbest things to people trying to make their lives better...0
-
The human body is designed to run. People only get hurt when they do it wrong.
I see you have vibrams! I have them too and have been loving them! I assume you are as well? I feel a lot less pain in my heal.0 -
Form - try to align your body naturally for you, and focus on striking the ground as lightly as you can (try for silence)
Shoes - its important; get the right type for you. Go to a running store or try Road Runner Sports website.
Miles - new or returning runners, ease into the miles. Racking up miles too quickly will end up in injuries and chair time.
Advise - ignore the naysayers. Adults... do what you like, do what works for you!0 -
thank you everyone that posted all of this information........@msarro.....big thanks. It seems like it's obvious to the runners that these concerns are myths.....but until now, I must say I was believing them and letting it play on my mind. I've been considering doing the c25k.....because it's been a dream to run! But, I have joints that aren't so nice (broken/surgery....) but maybe I can do this.....0
-
The human body is designed to run. People only get hurt when they do it wrong.
I see you have vibrams! I have them too and have been loving them! I assume you are as well? I feel a lot less pain in my heal.
The only bad thing about the Vibrams is stepping on rocks in the dark. But that is only a short lived pain.0 -
jogging for no reason for long periods is not recommended
if your gonna run you need to do it with intensity to work muscles for about 20min
problem is heart problems in the future....
jogging/running at a steady pace is not exercise.....
to live a long healthy life resistance training is the only way....
theres a lot of science and studys behind this and I believe it more than a beachbody infomercial:laugh:0 -
bump0
-
Running for long distances at a slow to moderate pace reengineers your cardiovascular system.
It increases the size & capacity of the heart
increases the blood volume
increases the red blood cell count
increases the number of capillaries in the muscles
increases the number of mitochondria in the muscles0 -
My arthritis has actually decreased since I started running.0
-
How do you strike with the ball of your foot???? I land on my heal regardless of whether or not Im wearing shoes?0
-
How do you strike with the ball of your foot???? I land on my heal regardless of whether or not Im wearing shoes?
Lean forward slightly... your body should be in a forward posture while running.0 -
Running for long distances at a slow to moderate pace reengineers your cardiovascular system.
It increases the size & capacity of the heart0 -
Running for long distances at a slow to moderate pace reengineers your cardiovascular system.
It increases the size & capacity of the heart
From the article: "Now, said Dr. Paul Thompson, a cardiologist at Hartford Hospital, it is known that if the heart is healthy, there is never a point at which it is too big."
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/07/07/health/07hearts.html0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 392.1K Introduce Yourself
- 43.6K Getting Started
- 259.9K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.7K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.4K Fitness and Exercise
- 403 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.8K Motivation and Support
- 7.9K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.4K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.4K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions