Is there an optimum time to exercise?

Victorian131
Posts: 130
HI I was just wondering whether it makes a difference if you work out in the morning or evening? I know that a morning work out can help boost metabolism etc. But if you're main workout is in the evening would it still be as effective as one in the middle of the day?
0
Replies
-
I was told that I should vary my exercise and change my timing occasionally to fool my body clock....I am not sure how it works but apparently the body gets used to being fed and exercised at certain times so it helps to confuse it now and again by eating and exercising when it least expects it. This can kickstart your metabolism and weight loss to get going again. Has anybody else heard that?0
-
Working out in the morning is optimal, but working out at any time is much better than not working out at all.0
-
ok thanks
its just annoying because all the exercise classes I enjoy doing and really give me a good work out are all in the evening. I find myself going to the gym twice because I feel bad not doing any real exercise until 7pm and then tiring myself out before the actual class begins!
0 -
Ok, here is what i was told (though i shamefully rarely follow it. The "optimum" time to work out is first thing in the morning before breakfast because it kicks your metabolism into high gear.0
-
as a mother of 2 working 2 jobs and also running a soccer league i have started the 5am work out and I have to say it sucks when the alarm goes off but i feel fabulous when i am done and they day seems that much better0
-
As a student I dont so mornings so well, I live an hour away from my job so have to get up at 7 to get in on time, I only work part time so I guess on the days I have college I could try getting up at 7. The only thing is I do evening classes at college to fit everything in so Im scared of being too tired to learn at the end of the day since Im usually up til midnight working on my thesis etc. I think Ill try it for a week or so see if I notice any difference. It may be why Im exercising a lot but not seeing many results yet. Ill report back in a week or so if anyone is interested.0
-
The "optimum" time is whenever you have enough time, energy, and focus to fully commit to your workout. For some people, that's first thing in the morning. For others, it's some other time. If you have to drag yourself through a workout at 5 AM, it's going to be far less effective than if you waited until your mind and body are better prepared for it.0
-
i also heard that before breakfast is the best time to workout. i work split shifts so i usually go to the gym in between. on my days off i try to get to the gym first thing in the morning. i find that even though i dont feel motivated to go, after ive done my workout i feel 100% better.0
-
Working out in the morning is optimal, but working out at any time is much better than not working out at all.
That's not actually correct. The preferred time physiologically is around 3pm. It's when you're less likely to release cortisol in response to exercise, and therefore more likely to get a) the effects of training you're hoping for and b) recover quickly.
Saying that, training at any time is fine. Competitive swimmers train both at early mornings and late at night. Train whenever suits you best.
The tricking your body thing that others have mentioned doesn't work either.0 -
I saw on Doctor Oz's show that he stressed that you weigh yourself first thing as soon as you get up,and use the bathroom as you will weigh your lightest in the morning.
He also said that the best time to exercise is 5 minutes after you get up and weigh yourself as you are burning calories from all different parts of your body and you are burning fat immediately. If you eat breakfast (or lunch, etc.) first and then exercise, you have to burn through what food you have eaten before you can burn fat.0 -
I saw on Doctor Oz's show that he stressed that you weigh yourself first thing as soon as you get up,and use the bathroom as you will weigh your lightest in the morning.
He also said that the best time to exercise is 5 minutes after you get up and weigh yourself as you are burning calories from all different parts of your body and you are burning fat immediately. If you eat breakfast (or lunch, etc.) first and then exercise, you have to burn through what food you have eaten before you can burn fat.
The first bit's right, the second bit isn't.
The whole part of this website is to encourage people to realise that it's not about when you add or remove calories from your body, but it's about the net spend over a period of time. If you do 300kcals of exercise, it makes no difference if you do this first thing in the morning or last thing at night. You're right you're more likely to burn fat directly after a fast (you don't eat when you sleep) but this will limit your performance levels, and reduce your endurance. Athlete's will always train any time between meals, ensuring their blood sugar is high enough when they start exercising, and that they refuel after.
Someone interested in weightloss should worry less about immediate refuelling, but as I said initially, it is net calorie loss over a period of months which makes a difference, not making sure you're burning fat at the time of exercise.0 -
Thanks
Yeah Ive heard a lot of people saying exercise before you eat something. That isnt an option for me, I physically couldnt do it. I tried it once and had tunnel vision for the rest of the day and felt generally dizzy and sick during and afterwards. I normally have a light breakfast, go for a short run (about 10 mins round the local park), a fairly large salad for lunch over the space of an hour or so while I get on with uni work, go to the gym in the evening(45 mins cardio and 10 mins swimming) before class then have a medium-small dinner depending how much work out I did and how hungry I feel.
Maybe I am eating too late though or something because whatever Im doing doesnt seem to be wrking yet, over a week Ive lost nothing weight or inches wise. Its really demoralising.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 394.8K Introduce Yourself
- 44K Getting Started
- 260.6K Health and Weight Loss
- 176.2K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.7K Fitness and Exercise
- 444 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153.2K Motivation and Support
- 8.2K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 4.1K MyFitnessPal Information
- 16 News and Announcements
- 1.3K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.8K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions