Is walking a good enough exercise to be doing?

andyj1984
andyj1984 Posts: 76
edited September 26 in Fitness and Exercise
Quite frankly at the moment I'm not fit enough to go for a jog, or swimming (would probably have a heart attack! LOL), so I'm focusing on daily walking and cycling exercises. According to the exercise log for yesterday, my 2 hour walk I went on (approx 7 miles) burned 675 calories. That seems rather a lot to me (I weigh approx 250lb).

Is that actually accurate? I ask, because I'm eating back those calories from the exercise, and want to make sure I'm doing it correctly. I would have thought walking wouldn't use all that much energy, compared to say swimming or jogging?

Is walking really that good for you? And as far as I understand, the less you weigh the longer you have to walk to burn the same calories?

I do plan on taking up jogging and swimming in a few months time, but only when I think my body can handle it! LOL

Sorry for the newbie question, I did search beforehand but didn't really get an answer.
«1

Replies

  • royam01
    royam01 Posts: 123
    Walking is great! That's the way I started :) Its relaxing and if you walk fast enough you can really work up a sweat! Good luck with everything!
  • kristelpoole
    kristelpoole Posts: 440 Member
    I didn't look anything up, but that sounds about right for your weight. If you can stick to walking for 2 hours a day, I'm sure you'll see something start to change. It'll take more the less you way, yes, but you're off to a good start. Keep up the good work and make sure those are healthy calories! :)
  • darrenham
    darrenham Posts: 110 Member
    Yes it is.

    Specifically, you were walking for 2hrs, so yes you will burn a lot of calories. I have suspected that the calorie figures on here are a little excessive for exercise. But having followed my predicted kcal intake for a week, I lost a pound, exactly as it said, so you can trust it. As a heavy person, you'll be burning even more calories on that walk than someone of a lower weight, so it's possible that that figure is even conservative.

    Keep it up, and don't forget to make your walk faster as your body gets used to the exercise over the weeks. Only then will you be able to progress to more intensive exercises like swimming and jogging.

    Keep up the good work.
  • BflSaberfan
    BflSaberfan Posts: 1,272
    any exercise is better than nothing and walking is great! Dont be afraid to push your self though. Even if its a 10 second sprint, tomorrow make it 20 seconds...etc.
  • SarahJaneDeschamp
    SarahJaneDeschamp Posts: 359 Member
    walking is good hun, sounds bout right to me :) keep it up x
  • crthiel
    crthiel Posts: 2
    Anything to generate more activity is good and 2 hours of walking burning 600 or so calories isn't too bad. Once you start running and swimming though, you'll burn that much in less than half the time.
  • trejon
    trejon Posts: 203
    Walking is an awesome way to start! Go at your own pace and then work your way up. Create challenges that YOU can complete not anything someone else makes for you unless you need this. Maybe Day I to the mailbox and back then progress. Walking a little is better than sitting alot. Any activity burns calories - cleaning, washing clothes, playing with kids - just do something.
  • I've had trainers tell me walking is a great exercise to do and a great place to start!! One of them said "Just keep moving! No matter what you're doing!" That's actually how I got started as well and am now in the gym doing Spin Class and other things but still love to walk! Total I've lost 57lbs! (10 since I starte MFP!)

    And I think for 7 miles that should be accurate on calories. So keep up the good work. That's awesome!!
  • hroush
    hroush Posts: 2,073 Member
    I would say don't eat back all the calories as MFP tends to over estimate. I say split the difference with half.

    I think you should start trying the www.c25k.com program. If you can walk for 2 hours, you can jog for the little bit that they require you to in the first week. You'll be surprised at how quickly you can make progress if you push yourself. For example, when I started losing weight, I was 280. I decided if I was going to lose weight, I needed to start running, so everyday I tried to go one more lap around the track. By the time I was down to 260 I was running a 7 minute mile!
  • luv_lea
    luv_lea Posts: 1,094 Member
    Walking is great! Everyone has to start at their comfortable pace~Good job!
  • Hi - well done on the 7mile walk in 2 hours that's good going - I find the calories burned on MFP a little high and tend to use them with a pinch of salt. You might find this website helpful as it maps your walk and then figures out the calories, you can get an app for the iphone/ipod touch/blackberry as well.

    http://www.mapmywalk.com

    Walking is a great exercise - I'm training for the Moonwalk a power walking marathon and have lost lots of inches if not the pounds at the mo.
  • bluebird321
    bluebird321 Posts: 733 Member
    I use walking as my exercise (mostly treadmill). It does burn calories and it's a good way to gently kick off an exercise program.
  • Christine1110
    Christine1110 Posts: 1,786 Member
    You will need to buy a HRM to be sure...and mostly because your eating you exercise calories, or you could be eating to many calories. I have a heart rate monitor, and only eat half of my calories back. If your going to buy one....make sure it has a chest strap to be more accurite. Good luck.

    Sounds like a great walk by the way, and walking is a great exercise....just keep your heart rate up ; )



    2639362.png
  • andyj1984
    andyj1984 Posts: 76
    Thanks for the replies! My medium term goal is to get back into swimming, I used to LOVE swimming as a child...I have my 1 mile badge somewhere ;) That is one of the motivations for getting fit and healthy, so I can enjoy swimming again!
  • srp2011
    srp2011 Posts: 1,829 Member
    Yes, walking is a great exercise, and the fact that you're walking 7 miles is amazing - great job! I've tried walking a 9 mile loop around the lake near my home, and I can only do it once a year - then I'm in pain for a week, and swear it off for another year. The calories burned sounds about right (they would be higher for swimming and jogging) and it is dependent on weight, so as you lose weight, you would burn fewer calories doing the same thing. At the same time, you'll be building more muscle from exercise, which burns more calories at rest, so it all works out. Just get out there and keep moving!
  • jamaka1
    jamaka1 Posts: 412 Member
    i love walking, i lost all my weight from that. i do the treadmill, elliptical, stairs, anything that keeps me moving. i dont like to run bc my ankles hurt and if i dont enjoy it then i will quit which is not good so i walk. you are on the right track, keep it up and you will be sharing ur success story soon.:laugh:
  • HeidiMightyRawr
    HeidiMightyRawr Posts: 3,343 Member
    If the walking you're doing is more than you would've done before you came here and make an effort to get fit then yes I'd say that's great - anything is better than nothing at all :)
    As far as the calories goes, it does sound about right since the more you weigh the more you burn so I'd aim to eat at least most of them back. If you're still unsure about the calories burnt though, a HRM would probably be best as those are going to be the closest to what you're actually burning.
  • Walking is a terrific way to start.
    Good for you!
    7 miles is awesome and you should be so proud of yourself.
    Get moving is all that matters - log it - eat healthy - log that too and you will see results.
    When that walk starts to get easy, bump it up to walking it faster or walk longer to keep seeing results.

    Best of luck! We are here for you
  • andyj1984
    andyj1984 Posts: 76
    It helps that there is a massive nature reserve about a mile away from my house... Its lovely to walk around :)
  • dad106
    dad106 Posts: 4,868 Member
    I primarily do walking as my form of exercise and I've lost 15 pounds that way. I hate running, so walking it is for me.
    I also tend to eat back most of my exercise calories and I've lost weight.
  • shreddingit
    shreddingit Posts: 1,133 Member
    no! you need resistance training also....eating back what you walked not such a good idea
  • traceyrbb
    traceyrbb Posts: 39 Member
    i asked the same question a while back and got a lot of good responses about it. walking is the only cardio i do and have done since january and have lost inches and 18 pounds so far. i have kids and a job and don't have time to do much more than that. mostly my treadmill but now that it's starting to get warmer out i will be walking outside too! i did find that my treadmill was calculating a lot of calories burned but i got a pedometer and that calculates a lot less. not sure that either are correct but have claimed the pedometer from last week forward. may get an HRM but may be too much money for me. keep it up! walking is GREAT exercise! i started at 2.5 miles an hour but now that seems soooo slow to me! :smile:
  • Tree72
    Tree72 Posts: 942 Member
    Walking is a great way to get back into exercising. That's how I started too.

    I think your numbers sound about right. I've heard several people say a good way to estimate is about 100 calories per mile. You'll burn it off faster running, but you still cover about the same distance. (In other words you burn about the same calories to run a 10 minute mile as to walk a 20 minute mile.) And at 7 miles in 2 hours, that's about 3.5mph, which is a somewhat brisk walk. So that should be good for getting your heart rate up a bit.

    Congratulations on a great start.
  • saldridge
    saldridge Posts: 125 Member
    It's a great exercise if you put some time in - like you did. 2 hours is great and 7 miles is actually fairly fast for walking!!!

    I am a little suspicious when people are trying to add up walking to a from the car at the store or walking around the office.

    I believe it counts as exercise if the activity itself gets you to run up a good sweat. So tanning in the sun sweating, no. Casually wiping off the kitchen counter, no. Laying in bed under a down comforter sweating, no (don't laugh, someone here actually asked that -- he/she may have just been trying to be flippant, but that's just stoopid).
    I guess the bottom line as to what counts is "Use common sense". Did you feel exhausted afterwards? Did you run up a good sweat? Do your arms, legs, back feel like you put some work in?
  • johnwhitent
    johnwhitent Posts: 648 Member
    Activity is good! My wife is exactly where you are in fitness. We are walking together to help get her started back with an exercise routine. Right now she can injure herself just walking uphill. But she will stick with it and when she can she will add cycling and swimming. After that she wants to join me in doing P90X, and the long range goal is doing a triathlon. Fourteen years ago she was an AT thru hiker, but years of office work and no exercise has taken a toll. I encourage you as I encourage her - stick with it! We all have the rest of our lives; no need to try to do it all in one day/week/month. Success is attained by those who stick with it, not those who start with a sprint but quit after a short time. Four years ago I was overweight, out of shape, had high blood pressure, etc. But over these last four years I have ploddingly attained the best fitness of my life. I adore trail running, cycling, P90X, and several other activities. My wife knows that she can do it because she watched me do it. So can you! Do what you can and increase as you can. Find activities that you enjoy, it well help keep you motivated. You can do it!
  • jsteras
    jsteras Posts: 344 Member
    My main exercise is walking, I walk about 3.0 , I do increase to 3.5 to get the heart rate up there and when I do a walk for an hour or more I am hot , sweating and breathing hard. Not everyone can jog or run. I probably will never be a person that jogs, but I love walking. After a good walk I am sore the next day and I keep a watch on my heart rate to keep it up there so I know I am getting a good work out and burning calories. I have lost 12 pounds in the last three weeks. I started at only being able to walk a mile I am now up to 3.5 miles in about 70 minutes. Good for you on your walk you are ahead of the game if you can walk that far to start out. I would say increase speed and then you won't have to walk as long. I do also recommend the Jillian Michaels DVD Last chance workout. I have been doing that also ,she uses circuit training which is great.
  • andyj1984
    andyj1984 Posts: 76
    no! you need resistance training also....eating back what you walked not such a good idea

    I don't understand this comment. Everyone else has said its okay, but this seems to be suggesting something different? There is so much jumbled up information about, I'm getting confused. Perhaps I should speak to a trainer? Or dietician or something?

    I was under the simple impression that to lose weight just stick to the net calories every day (eating healthy of course), plenty of exercise (including walking), which you then also have to eat back so you keep your natural metabolsim up?

    What is resistance training? Is this like weights or something?
  • hroush
    hroush Posts: 2,073 Member
    no! you need resistance training also....eating back what you walked not such a good idea

    I don't understand this comment. Everyone else has said its okay, but this seems to be suggesting something different? There is so much jumbled up information about, I'm getting confused. Perhaps I should speak to a trainer? Or dietician or something?

    I was under the simple impression that to lose weight just stick to the net calories every day (eating healthy of course), plenty of exercise (including walking), which you then also have to eat back so you keep your natural metabolsim up?

    What is resistance training? Is this like weights or something?

    Everyone has their own ideas on how to lose weight. Are some better than others? Probably. Walking is a good way to start out, check out the c25k program I mentioned earlier. Would it benefit you to incorporate weight training? yes. Should you start working out 1+ hour a day 7 days a week? I say no since you are just starting it would be a very quick way to burn out. I say continue what you are doing and when you're ready for more, go for more.

    The equation for losing weight is simple: calories burned > calories in. How you do it is where it can get sticky.
  • andyj1984
    andyj1984 Posts: 76
    Thankyou hroush, that is a very useful post! I'll stick to what I have been doing the last few days, and see what happens. I might give the C25k a go! It looks manageable! LOL
  • Michelleanon
    Michelleanon Posts: 40 Member
    Hi there, I started off with walking 5 days a week for at least 45-60mins. Lost 24lbs between that and the change of lifestyle where it comes to eating. Now I have decided I need to up my game and have started the gym 3 times a week and walking twice a week.
    I won't give up the walking as It is great to get fresh air in your lungs and clear your mind. Keep going and you WILL get results :flowerforyou:
This discussion has been closed.