We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Do you drink a protein shake before or after working out/wal

Posts: 142 Member
edited September 2024 in Food and Nutrition
I want to drink a protein shake, but I don't know when I'm supposed to drink it. I was also wondering if anyone has any suggestions on ones that work/taste well. Another thing, does it count for a meal or a snack? Any advice would be appreciated! Thanks!

Welcome!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Replies

  • 1. I always drank them after...for me if I drank them first my tummy would hurt -> but that is just me :)
    2. I liked the Special K's Milk Chocolate and Strawberry
    3. You can count them as whatever you like. I did both, depending on my mood/calorie need.
  • Posts: 15
    I usually drink mine prior to working out.

    I add milk
    whey protein
    frozen blueberries
    half a banana
    its goooood
  • Posts: 548 Member
    If you're doing it to give your body fuel then I would drink it before and aim for a ratio of something like 70% carbs, 20% protein, and 10% fat. If you're doing it to give your body tools to repair and build muscles then drink it after and aim for something like 40% carbs, 40% protein, 20% fat.

    Idea is that carbs are mainly (but not entirely) fuel and protein are mainly (but not entirely) best for muscle repair/building.
  • Posts: 15
    I drink my protein shakes after working out... And I make my own with my Magic Bullet (blender would work as well)

    1 c. milk (1%)
    1 scoop soy protein powder
    1/2 c frozen berries

    275 cal
  • after after after!!!!!!!!!!
    you want to feed your muscles after you work them out!!!!!!!!!!!
    and your metabolism is high after you workout!!
  • Posts: 254 Member
    I drink mine after working out when I decide to have one. Sometimes I'll make one with a powder from GNC that i'll mix with water and throw in the blender with frozen fruit. Other times if I 'm in a rush I'll have a pre-made one called Mix 1.
  • Posts: 103
    I usually drink one after my workout in the morning -- "they" say to get protein in you pretty quickly after a workout to help your muscles recover.

    A caution: If you go with a store-bought/premade shake, watch the sugar content. Some of them have more than 10 grams of sugar, which is a lot!
    I use whey protein (which has, like, 2 grams of sugar -- but each is different), skim milk and strawberries. Yes, there's some natural sugar in the milk and strawberries, but that's not the sugar you need to be careful of.
    It's tasty, filling (keeps me full 'til lunch) and I get a serving of fruit in. And it's about 250-300 calories total, depending on what kind of whey protein I'm using.
  • Posts: 135 Member
    drink after, the protein will help build/repair muscles used during working out. also might pair it with a healthy light carb (half apple or such) this is done cuz glycogen stores in muscles have been depleted and this will help to replenish them.
  • Posts: 106
    I would also like to start drinking protein shakes BUT they always make me feel nauseaous after. any ideas?
  • Posts: 127
    I drink mine right after and make it with Silk Almond Milk- Chocolate flavor with crushed ice or frozen coffee ice cubes and blend it into a Protein Frappe. I find that it really helps muscle recovery and keeps me from having muscle soreness and charlie horses.
  • Posts: 62 Member
    I drink it after a work out, as recommended from my coach.

    1) 1 scoop chocolate whey protein powder
    2) 1 cup almond milk
    3) 5 ice cubes
    4) alternate between frozen unsweetened cherries, strawberries and blueberries.

    If I do at is a meal replacement, I do it in the morning for breakfast on occasion, then I do the same first 3 ingredients but will do a tbsp of earth balance peanut butter and half a banana.
  • Posts: 62 Member
    I drink it after a work out, as recommended from my coach.

    1) 1 scoop chocolate whey protein powder
    2) 1 cup almond milk
    3) 5 ice cubes
    4) alternate between frozen unsweetened cherries, strawberries and blueberries.

    If I do at is a meal replacement, I do it in the morning for breakfast on occasion, then I do the same first 3 ingredients but will do a tbsp of earth balance peanut butter and half a banana.

    Forgot to add that all gets put in the blender :tongue:
  • Posts: 135 Member
    sneakers have you tried to half the dose called for post workout? or to mix with different substance rather then milk try water or soy/almond/skim milk. Could also try different type of protein source: soy, whey, or casein. The Casein is a slow digesting protein and that may help.
  • Posts: 1,260 Member
    I do a couple shakes throughout the day.
    But typically the answer you're going to get will be after.
    I like to get a good dose of protein and carbs after a workout.
  • Posts: 903
    If you are talking straight whey protein, then any time is fine. A protein blend works as a great meal replacements and a protein blend that also contains fats and carbs is great post workout.
  • Posts: 567 Member
    I drink them in the morning sometimes as a meal replacement - and if I'm doing this then I make a green monster and layer it as follows:

    - 2 cups washed spinach, ripped up (it blends completely and you don't taste it but you are getting tons of veggies and minerals!)
    - 1 tbsp ground flax seed
    - 1 scoop whey protein powder (usually vanilla)
    - 1 banana
    - 1 c. almond or soy milk
    - 1 tsp cocoa powder
    - 2 ice cubes

    blend until smooth and enjoy a delicious chocolately banana smoothie that will keep you full for hours!

    If I'm having one after I work out, I usually just do

    - 1/2 c. almond milk
    - 1/2 c. water
    - 3 ice cubes
    - whey protein

    to keep it lower carb and mainly protein for muscle recovery.
  • Posts: 1,670 Member
    I have Shakeology after a hard workout - or sometimes in the morning for breakfast.
    Its yummy... choc pb is my favorite mix ins
  • Posts: 4,519 Member
    after
  • Posts: 2,073 Member
    I always drink mine after, but I think I'll have one before today as well for a snack.
  • Posts: 1,260 Member
    I always drink mine after, but I think I'll have one before today as well for a snack.

    good call.

    I've really started enjoying mine with oats and peanut butter. I just put enough water to make a "batter" and then freeze it for a few minutes so its nice and cold.
  • Posts: 222 Member
    AFTER! & soy protein mix with almond milk taste great! unfortunately, it's sweentened. I have to start drinking the unsweentened almond milk...
  • Posts: 157
    bump
  • Posts: 548 Member
    - 2 cups washed spinach, ripped up (it blends completely and you don't taste it but you are getting tons of veggies and minerals!)

    CLEVER!!!! Totally going to do this! Thx :bigsmile:
  • Posts: 254 Member
    I would also like to start drinking protein shakes BUT they always make me feel nauseaous after. any ideas?

    It may be the kind of protein drink or mix that you are using or what you are mixing it with? Have you tried multiple kinds and got the same results?
  • Posts: 142 Member
    Thanks, everyone! I appreciate all your feedback. This really helped! I love this site! lol
  • Posts: 46
    I'm not a a big protein shake drinker right now, but I've heard arguments saying that anything you put in your body before a work out will still be under digestion after a work out as well (which technically is true) unless you're working out for 4 or 5 hours at a time. The basic logic behind was the same thing as, you can't have a car with an empty tank, drive it around for an hour, and then fuel it up. But you can fill up a car, and drive it around for an hour and still have fuel left. This article was a body building site though. It's a an interesting take on it, and it makes sense. In this same article it suggested that breakfast was even more important than a post work out meal.
  • Posts: 207 Member
    I drink mine right after and make it with Silk Almond Milk- Chocolate flavor with crushed ice or frozen coffee ice cubes and blend it into a Protein Frappe. I find that it really helps muscle recovery and keeps me from having muscle soreness and charlie horses.

    love this idea
This discussion has been closed.