Can fruit make you fat?

If:

CaloriesIn-CaloriesOut = 0 for the day (this is SO hypothetical for a million reasons, but assume that you are at that exact zero mark where if you so much as need energy to take a breath you'll be netting negative and burning fat X-D). Where was I? Oh right if you are at the specific point where your body is netting 0 calories and you eat an apple and an equal amt of calories of refined sugar at the same time - you'll get fat from both. :-D

If, however, you start doing jumping jacks while you eat said apple and an equal amount of cals from refined sugar - you'll get some of those calories packed on as fat. Most of them will probably be from the apple (depending on how slow you do the jacks and how many calories you burned from them). Why? Because it goes through your system slower. The sugars in the refined sugar are known as "processed sugar". A lot of the work that your stomach is made to do has already been done. You get the sugar high faster, it leaves just as fast, and the end products start turning to fat quicker. Whereas the apple will take more energy to process and will process slower. The energy expenditure from jumping jacks will already be covered by the sugar before the apple finishes digesting.

Does this make fruit bad? No. Not even close. That fast sugar high screws with your insulin levels, hormones, hunger levels...it's really a train wreck to the system.

Plus eggs have high cholesterol.

OMG, we're not going to bring this irrational fear of eggs back onto the boards are we? :sick:

Was it hard to take the words out of my mouth? :-D

If you eat a couple of dozen eggs a week then you have to worry about the cholesterol. An egg a day for breakfast is entirely healthy. But if you want to be an egg-whiter, that's your choice. I'd never be able to throw out yolks or pay more for processed partial eggs in a carton. :-)

Exactly - one egg a day, no problem. several a day - starts to be. I have seen no irrational fear of eggs on here, but it's common sense not to eat too many.

you shouldn't over eat anything....that were we all run into problems...

fruit...should not make you fat, not. Fat = fiber and better sugars than anything you can find in a package, so while there is potential to over eat fruit, i would rather over eat fruit, than eat a bag of chips or box of cookies or thing of ice cream.

if you track everything you eat, and you make sure you eat enough protein, and good carbs...you should be good to enjoy the fruit you want while sticking in your daily allowance of calories.

one thing i have noticed on MFP is that their daily allowance of fiber is way tooo low....so track that as well and dont be shy to go way over whatever the daily limit on that one is.


good luck

If u r eating a ton of fruit and getting fat then I would say it is the other things making u fat. Like the cream with the strawberries etc

Have a look at the 801010 diet which is basically fruit and veg with a few nuts. It is not so much for weight loss but a long term thing. The book is v good.

There is a website called 30 bananas a day which is full of people who follow that diet, some are fat but generally they are not and they talk of eating 3000+ cal a day and loosing. I think it must be to do with fruit using more energy to digest. From what I have learnt on that site and others experience if they eat 2000 of normal food they may stay the same but they can eat 3000 of fruit and veg and loose