Binging and overeating too much? (Recovering anorexic?)

I think I'm binging/overeating. I'm a recover anorexic. I'm 18 5'6 and weigh 108 lbs. Here's an example of what I eat by my food/exercise for today.

Breakfast:
Black Coffee (not hungry/too busy)

Exercise:
35 minute walk with dog up and down steep driveway

Lunch:
a half a can of canned chicken (60 calories)
Flatbread (100 calories)
a few pieces of spinach lettuce (2 calories?)

Afternoon snack:
Banana
2 1/2 to 3 TBS of peanut butter

extra snack:
apple

Dinner:
spinach Lettuce
garbanzo beans (110 calories)
organic chicken breast (cooked plain with water)

night snack: (this is where is where I think I binged)
1/3 giant bag of kettle corn popcorn
almost a whole roll of Ritz crackers
2 TBS of grape jelly
4? TBS of peanut butter
a few homemade pumpkin cookies

I'm just so hungry and feel really weak when I don't eat a lot. Maybe something is medically wrong with me, or I just can't admit I'm a glutton. I feel so disgusting.

Replies

  • Ethereal_Whisper
    Ethereal_Whisper Posts: 70 Member
    It's normal to eat much more, and feel like you're bingeing in recovery. You're constantly hungry because your body really needs all the calories it can get to repair itself. Honestly you shouldn't be logging, weighing, or trying to count calories while in recovery. All that will do is sabotage your progress.

    It's not overeating, because you've starved your body. Your body is just trying to get back what it's lost, and get to it's "happy" weight. You're not a glutton, you're not disgusting. You're doing well by giving your body what it needs.
  • sarahjane135
    sarahjane135 Posts: 40 Member
    First I would ask if you are here to gain or maintain? Next, what is your calorie goal and what did the daily calories add up to be? I would try eating a bigger dinner and maybe spice it up a bit if you don't already. A moderately sized and well prepared dinner will help with the urge to binge later. Above all don't feel down on yourself. We all have days were not proud of.
  • With no breakfast, exercise then only a 160 cal lunch your body will be starving try splitting cals a bit more evenly to stop binging eat more regularly without limiting yourself and that should help good luck recovery is hard x
  • jenilla1
    jenilla1 Posts: 11,118 Member
    Typically for me (not a recovering ED) if I don't eat enough throughout the day, I will be starving later and end up eating more than I'd like in the evening. I find it's better for me to make sure that I spread my calories out and keep myself satisfied earlier in the day. That way, I'm not so desperately hungry in the evening. What you've described doesn't sound like gluttony. It sounds like a hungry body demanding food after it didn't get enough earlier in the day. Stop beating yourself up - you're OK! :flowerforyou:
  • paintedlady52
    paintedlady52 Posts: 12 Member
    The day's food is healthy - chicken, spinach, fruit etc - but - yes the evening's food was fairly typical binge food. ( I've been there too with that roll of Ritz crackers and random spoonfuls of sweet stuff :smile: ) As the others here have rightly said - you didn't really take in enough calories during the day so you needed more and craved more. Psychologically you were maybe also depriving/punishing yourself and the binge may have been a rebellion.

    I'm no expert (sorry!) but I'd suggest firstly: 'Only put into your mouth that which you truly believe/know to be good for you'
    This was said to me by a specialist in eating disorders and I have found it helpful in conjunction with other strategies.

    Also - maybe - it might help to plan your day's food in advance to include good nutrition and enough calories for you to either maintain or gain - whichever you want to do.

    Maybe as a recovering anorexic you should try to maintain for a while, until you get used to eating that little bit more food?

    Also perhaps try to accept that you will binge. Don't blame yourself. Seek the causes and learn from that and move forward with that extra knowledge about yourself. The binges should get fewer with the better nutrition and with less self destructiveness.

    Wishing you strength and success. Good luck! xx
  • mangogirl272727
    mangogirl272727 Posts: 95 Member
    When you're recovering from anorexia, it's not binging it's reactive eating. You can find a lot of info on this phenomenon if you just do a bit of research on reactive eating. It's quite common in recovery, however you could definitely minimize it by eating more healthfully during the day. You should be eating 2000 to maintain, significantly more since you still need to gain (specialists recommend between 2500-3500; you should really contact a dietician to address your specific needs). You ate less than 1000 during normal eating hours (breakfast through dinner). That's clearly WAY too low if you're trying to recover. Your intake throughout the day needs to be doubled or tripled.
  • Brolympus
    Brolympus Posts: 360 Member
    Just eyeballing calories from your post, that can't be more than 1200-1400 calories anyways, and I have to ask, WHERE THE HECK IS THE PROTEIN? lol

    If you want to gain lean mass, you need protein in your diet. A piece of chicken at dinner is not going to cut it. You should be trying to eat 1g of protein per 1lbs of body mass. Based on your cal intake, I'm guessing you are somewhere between 100-150lbs range. That means, at minimum, you are shooting for 100g of protein per day.

    Also, I promise eating more protein will help you feel way more satiated and it will reduce the urge to "binge", you will feel too full to think about food.
  • RoughDiamondUK
    RoughDiamondUK Posts: 151 Member
    Instead of the black coffee when you're too busy/don't feel hungry for breakfast, could you switch for a glass of milk or juice? That would give you a little more nutrition and might help?

    (I'm not anorexic so not speaking from experience, it just seems logical to me.)
  • shartran
    shartran Posts: 304 Member
    When you're recovering from anorexia, it's not binging it's reactive eating. You can find a lot of info on this phenomenon if you just do a bit of research on reactive eating. It's quite common in recovery, however you could definitely minimize it by eating more healthfully during the day. You should be eating 2000 to maintain, significantly more since you still need to gain (specialists recommend between 2500-3500; you should really contact a dietician to address your specific needs). You ate less than 1000 during normal eating hours (breakfast through dinner). That's clearly WAY too low if you're trying to recover. Your intake throughout the day needs to be doubled or tripled.


    I agree - When I went through the ED program I ate upwards of 3500 calories. You need someone to work with (professional) because what you are currently consuming is not going to get you to your goals
  • TrailRunner61
    TrailRunner61 Posts: 2,505 Member
    Recovered anorexic/bulimic here. Congrats on working towards getting healthy!

    I think that you need to eat breakfast, something packed with protein, so you don't crave so much later in the evening. To make things more convenient, prepare your breakfast the night before. If I don't, I usually don't eat it either! Try Skinnytaste.com for overnight oat recipes. It's just oats, greek yogurt, fruit, milk (or almond, soy milk). I add chia seeds and nuts sometimes. The combinations are unlimited! You can also boil eggs, peel them and toss them in the frig for the week. Or get stuff prepped to cook an omelet the night before. They cook really fast.
    As far as the binging goes, do the same thing as above. Be prepared for a binge! Keep some healthy, tasty foods around. If possible, don't have crap food in the house to begin with. I like pretzel chips and spicy hummus, nuts, jerky, yogurt, cut up fruit.. basically anything that will nourish my body and taste good too. One of my faves is peanuts in the shell, as it keeps my hands busy too. If you need to, proportion servings into cheap Ziploc bags, so you have them handy.
    I recovered on my own and I don't recommend it. It took me 2 years to go from 96lbs to 115. I probably ate 2,000 calories to get up to that. I did ok, but fast-forward 25 years and I'm still battling some tendencies, especially when I get stressed. It's no different than overeating. Stress. There is a reason why you do it, it's because it's something only YOU can control in your life, while something you can't is stressing you. Please get help if you can.
    Good luck and big hugs!
  • I am not an expert!!!!!!!!!!!

    Last week I lapsed into another Bulimic episode, now I'm recovered again.

    Considering your diet for the rest of your day, then I can see why you feel that the evening is a binge.

    When I was visiting the eating disorder service support groups, it became apparent that a lot of the sufferers had moved from one eating disorder to another.

    The way I view it is that mental disorders are like rivers in our minds, we start thinking or acting one way and our river starts carving a pathway. Yes, you can block the river or divert it, but it's always going to be that much easier to flow that way again.

    To me anorexia is total control.

    Food addiction and binging is lack of control.

    Bulimia is the need for place control on something that's out of control, and that's never going to end well.

    You are doing fantastically by working towards getting over one eating disorder, I would take any advice that rings a bell for you if it can help prevent your 'river' from staying on exactly the same unhealthy path, just changing color from one ED to another.

    Now whatever you do... don't let any of this advice prevent you from continuing with the same great steps that you're taking to get over things. Don't stop trying to eat more, just to avoid triggering a binge episode! Enjoy eating, just try to recognise where your 'danger' areas are.

    I'm almost at the end of my journey of recovery, I've had to:

    Empty all of my cupboards of anything that I would be likely to binge on.

    Recognise what my triggers for a binge are, for me that includes stress and unhappiness, tiredness and boredom. If you think that it's a binge, make a note of how you're feeling and why you think you did it (just for you, so be totally totally honest!)

    Forgive myself. It's not the end of the world. I've just over eaten a bit.

    I DONT HAVE TO RESTRICT TOMORROW TO MAKE UP FOR IT! Restricting is one of my triggers, so I'll only fail if I do this. I just have to work out how to avoid doing it again and start tomorrow as a happy new day.

    Acknowledging and coming to the realisation that I will fail.
    (Yes I know I should be able to eat normally, I've done it before, I should be able to do it again, but if I try to re-introduce a trigger food before I'm ready, I'm going to feel a lot worse than if I don't try to rush myself. And that's ok)

    Be ok that it's going to take a long while.
    The older I get the more I realise that time isn't wasted by going slowly, if you ACTUALLY GET THERE! What's wasted is rushing it and hoping you get there soon. Then flopping on your face. A lot of MFP philosophers will back this up.

    Love myself.
    (Now this is a tad odd, but I'm baring my journey here so please no-one laugh or mock, and I certainly don't and never have intended to insult or demean anyone; one of the most wake up calls moments was when I realised that personally, part of the reason that I didn't want to become fat was that I believed all of the media lies that fat women weren't sexy. So I worked on trying to see larger ladies as sexually attractive, the erm.... internet... is very good at providing situations of larger ladies not only being attractive but also being honest, confident and enjoying themselves a lot more than I was at the time. Yes a tad dodgy, *embarrassed* what can I say, it helped shrink my body dysmorphia)

    For me the first step had to be focusing on one thing at a time, so I started with the stopping purging.

    I'd try to cover as many of your nutritional bases as your ED comfort zone will let you. (Baby steps remember, no-ones born perfect. And when you feel comfortable, build up the layers little by little)

    Try to be aware of for you what situations/feelings/foods are triggers and work out how to avoid them. It's easier to cut them out or replace them with healthy alternatives out to begin with and build them back into your life later.

    If at the moment you're not purging, PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE DON'T START. <3

    There's a certain level of low in life, when your heads in the lavatory bowl, you're bladders leaking because you couldn't control it at the same time as vomitting, your eyes are running and burning from the fumes from your stomach acid and you're still trying to purge your stomach lining - Yeah, that tub of icecream? Not really worth the price of that quick fix solution to overeating.

    If you have started purging, do as much as you can to STOP IT NOW! Dead! Before it becomes an ADDICTION in itself. :(

    Yes you might hate yourself after a binge and think that you're a waste of space in this universe. I know personally that a lot of my suicidal times were after a bingeing session. But with those levels of extra binge calories it will still take a long while to add up to anything serious.

    If you want to binge, take out your back up delicious and divine meal from the freezer, zap it in the microwave, four minutes ping and away we go, yeah it's calories you were intending to eat, but it could have been a lot worse!

    I don't know if this waffle will help you. I doubt it, everyone has to do it for themselves, it's only afterwards that we go, "awwww yeah, I see what they meant now. "

    Be kind to yourself hon. <3<3
  • Graelwyn75
    Graelwyn75 Posts: 4,404 Member
    I would not call it a binge, but rather a reaction to a) not eating enough in the daytime and b) your body trying to grab whatever nutrition it can to repair itself. You are also still on the light side, weight wise, so of course, your body is going to drive you to eat more. Do not feel guilty, ashamed, gluttonous, scared. Just try and view it logically, objectively and put your mind into action on ways to balance things out while still recovering.

    Try and eat a more substantial lunch and dinner. Have a decent portion of protein such as chicken, fish, eggs, dairy... add some carbs like rice, potato, quinoa, wholegrain bread, and some nice vegetables with a bit of butter.

    Snack on nuts, seeds, fruit, hard boiled eggs, even oatmeal. Think nutrition to help heal your body and give you the energy to go forward as your mind will not really enter a healthy place until you are eating enough and the right things. It is okay to have a little chocolate, cake or ice cream sometimes too, as long as you are covering your other bases.

    This is very common in anorexia recovery, so much so that there are entire articles about it. You are not alone.
    Do some research.
    youreatopia is a good site and has an article on this particular recovery issue.
  • Raynne413
    Raynne413 Posts: 1,527 Member
    I strongly agree with Graelwyn. That doesn't sound like a binge at all. I think it seems like a lot of food to you because you are SO used to limiting yourself. You've gotten some great advice in this thread and I hope you will listen. Best wishes!!!!
  • Ludka13
    Ludka13 Posts: 136 Member
    You didn't eat much during the day so naturally when the evening came you ate more food.

    I get not wanting to eat in the morning but you could have a glass of milk (or soy milk). Add some chocolate syrup or Ovaltine to it. Or you can have a protein shake in the morning, that's what I did for years. Or have a can of Ensure or Boost or something. There are lots of nutritious liquid options. You need to rehydrate in the morning and you can get some calories in while you do that. And still have coffee on top of that.
  • superhippo95
    superhippo95 Posts: 21 Member
    you are starving yourself throughout the day so you eat more at night. Still see anorexic qualities by using black coffee as appitite supressent.,
  • typicallystrange
    typicallystrange Posts: 29
    edited October 2014
    first of all, you're eating waaaay too little during the day! not to mention breakfast if very important! You're 'binging' because your body needs the food, in fact, it's a good thing that you're 'binging'. please don't think that you're a 'pig' or a 'glutton' for eating that amount, ideally, in recovery you should be eating 3500 calories a day!
    in recovery eat whenever you feel hungry, and eat whatever you want! trust me, at this point all you need to worry about is getting enough food into you!
    in recovery i felt ravenous, like i would eat until my stomach was so so full, but i would still crave more food. i kept eating whenever i felt hungry, and you know what? After a month of that i no longer felt ravenous. i no longer 'binged'. it's just your body telling you i needs more food.

    http://www.youreatopia.com/blog/2012/10/31/bingeing-is-not-bingeing.html
  • cosmiqrust
    cosmiqrust Posts: 214 Member
    1. you probably should be eating breakfast. if you're not feeling too hungry in the mornings, it's probably because you're still feeling full from the night binge. maybe try liquid calories? i try to force myself to at least get a protein drink down or make a smoothie (i'm the same way, though, i'm never hungry in the morning). it doesn't have the same bulk as a meal, but it's something to fuel the body.
    2. your lunch is making me sad. i perked up a bit when i saw your snack, but it's still not nearly enough, especially depending on how long you wait to have the snack. maybe throw some cheese and condiments on that wrap at least?
    3. just in general you need to balance out your meals. eat more during the day, maybe give yourself a sweet or two during the day so you aren't breaking down and eating ALL the sweets at night. i know it's tough, but you're not a glutton, your body is just desperate for nutrients and hitting up the nearest and most delicious source. i promise if you maintain a good balance the binges will stop.