Your body knows what nutrient deficiencies you have and craves foods with those nutrients
Replies
-
My mum says if you crave ginger, there's a storm coming... or something0
-
Wheelhouse15 wrote: »lemurcat12 wrote: »Wheelhouse15 wrote: »astronomicals wrote: »Scarecrowsama wrote: »sugar, also, is more addictive than cocaine,
soooo true.... same goes for heroin
Do you have a study on that because I'm undecided on which I should take
...
Also, what does it even mean?
Usually the reference is to a study that shows that rats get as much pleasure from sugar as heroin, but that's hardly the same thing. I've never quit heroin or cocaine (did quit drinking, though), but I know from experience that dropping added sugar and even fruit for a while did not cause any painful withdrawal symptoms or really anything negative. So I'm, shall we say, skeptical.
More significantly, whether something is like cocaine or heroin would seem to me to have less to do with whether it is difficult to stop eating, for whatever reason that might be the case (i.e., coffee IS addictive, and lots of people might have trouble giving up their favorite foods without being addicted, and clearly none of us can give up water), and more to do with the effect of being an addict on your life. I was fat (without being addicted to food, IMO) and think it's quite perverse to compare that to the harm caused by drug addiction.
You do reslize that was sarcasm or did you miss it in your need to go on a diatribe? Of course I dont buy the comparison.
Yes, of course I realized it was sarcasm. I was trying to supplement your point, not argue.
And I wouldn't call it a diatribe, although if you must...
0 -
Your body will crave what it is ACCUSTOMED to getting. Too much salt - you crave salty snacks. Too much sugar? You crave more sweets and MOST importantly, too many CARBS = EATING MORE CARBS. Don't get stuck in that cycle! More natural, healthy fats and less carbs, people!
Check out http://www.foodmatters.tv and http://www.hungryforchange.tv for your proof, OP. 0 -
lemurcat12 wrote: »Wheelhouse15 wrote: »lemurcat12 wrote: »Wheelhouse15 wrote: »astronomicals wrote: »Scarecrowsama wrote: »sugar, also, is more addictive than cocaine,
soooo true.... same goes for heroin
Do you have a study on that because I'm undecided on which I should take...
Also, what does it even mean?
Usually the reference is to a study that shows that rats get as much pleasure from sugar as heroin, but that's hardly the same thing. I've never quit heroin or cocaine (did quit drinking, though), but I know from experience that dropping added sugar and even fruit for a while did not cause any painful withdrawal symptoms or really anything negative. So I'm, shall we say, skeptical.
More significantly, whether something is like cocaine or heroin would seem to me to have less to do with whether it is difficult to stop eating, for whatever reason that might be the case (i.e., coffee IS addictive, and lots of people might have trouble giving up their favorite foods without being addicted, and clearly none of us can give up water), and more to do with the effect of being an addict on your life. I was fat (without being addicted to food, IMO) and think it's quite perverse to compare that to the harm caused by drug addiction.
You do reslize that was sarcasm or did you miss it in your need to go on a diatribe? Of course I dont buy the comparison.
Yes, of course I realized it was sarcasm. I was trying to supplement your point, not argue.
And I wouldn't call it a diatribe, although if you must...
I missed the purpose since it seemed to be a direct response to me. Apologies if I overreacted.0 -
lemurcat12 wrote: »Wheelhouse15 wrote: »lemurcat12 wrote: »Wheelhouse15 wrote: »astronomicals wrote: »Scarecrowsama wrote: »sugar, also, is more addictive than cocaine,
soooo true.... same goes for heroin
Do you have a study on that because I'm undecided on which I should take...
Also, what does it even mean?
Usually the reference is to a study that shows that rats get as much pleasure from sugar as heroin, but that's hardly the same thing. I've never quit heroin or cocaine (did quit drinking, though), but I know from experience that dropping added sugar and even fruit for a while did not cause any painful withdrawal symptoms or really anything negative. So I'm, shall we say, skeptical.
More significantly, whether something is like cocaine or heroin would seem to me to have less to do with whether it is difficult to stop eating, for whatever reason that might be the case (i.e., coffee IS addictive, and lots of people might have trouble giving up their favorite foods without being addicted, and clearly none of us can give up water), and more to do with the effect of being an addict on your life. I was fat (without being addicted to food, IMO) and think it's quite perverse to compare that to the harm caused by drug addiction.
You do reslize that was sarcasm or did you miss it in your need to go on a diatribe? Of course I dont buy the comparison.
Yes, of course I realized it was sarcasm. I was trying to supplement your point, not argue.
And I wouldn't call it a diatribe, although if you must...
0 -
There are lots of peer reviewed articles involving animals eating strange things to supplement nutrient deficiencies...just not so many for us crazy humans.0
-
I used to have an indian buffet deficiency but I cleared that up at lunch time.0
-
GenesiaElizabeth wrote: »Your body will crave what it is ACCUSTOMED to getting. Too much salt - you crave salty snacks. Too much sugar? You crave more sweets and MOST importantly, too many CARBS = EATING MORE CARBS. Don't get stuck in that cycle! More natural, healthy fats and less carbs, people!
Check out http://www.foodmatters.tv and http://www.hungryforchange.tv for your proof, OP.
I think he asked for peer reviewed not commercial but some of the food did look good.0 -
JoannaEngel84 wrote: »There are lots of peer reviewed articles involving animals eating strange things to supplement nutrient deficiencies...just not so many for us crazy humans.
You should watch My Strange Addiction!
0 -
GenesiaElizabeth wrote: »Your body will crave what it is ACCUSTOMED to getting. Too much salt - you crave salty snacks. Too much sugar? You crave more sweets and MOST importantly, too many CARBS = EATING MORE CARBS. Don't get stuck in that cycle! More natural, healthy fats and less carbs, people!
Check out http://www.foodmatters.tv and http://www.hungryforchange.tv for your proof, OP.
*shrug*
Doesn't work that way for me. Too much greasy food and suddenly I'm craving salad with vinaigrette and other acidic foods, like pickles. Too much sugar and I want savory stuff. Eat fewer sweet things and eventually I'll be dreaming about cake.
I think my palate just wants variety.0 -
GenesiaElizabeth wrote: »Your body will crave what it is ACCUSTOMED to getting. Too much salt - you crave salty snacks. Too much sugar? You crave more sweets and MOST importantly, too many CARBS = EATING MORE CARBS. Don't get stuck in that cycle! More natural, healthy fats and less carbs, people!
Check out http://www.foodmatters.tv and http://www.hungryforchange.tv for your proof, OP.
*shrug*
Doesn't work that way for me. Too much greasy food and suddenly I'm craving salad with vinaigrette and other acidic foods, like pickles. Too much sugar and I want savory stuff. Eat fewer sweet things and eventually I'll be dreaming about cake.
I think my palate just wants variety.
Sounds like pickles and ice cream time!
0 -
GenesiaElizabeth wrote: »Your body will crave what it is ACCUSTOMED to getting. Too much salt - you crave salty snacks. Too much sugar? You crave more sweets and MOST importantly, too many CARBS = EATING MORE CARBS. Don't get stuck in that cycle! More natural, healthy fats and less carbs, people!
Check out http://www.foodmatters.tv and http://www.hungryforchange.tv for your proof, OP.
*shrug*
Doesn't work that way for me. Too much greasy food and suddenly I'm craving salad with vinaigrette and other acidic foods, like pickles. Too much sugar and I want savory stuff. Eat fewer sweet things and eventually I'll be dreaming about cake.
I think my palate just wants variety.
Are you actually asserting that there might be variability among people, and that in fact paying attention to what works for the individual might be most helpful?
0 -
Nutrients are nutrients! Take them or leave them, up to you. But until you have tried it (getting your essential nutrients from juicing, veggies and natural foods), then you can't say it doesn't work or "I'm just the way I am... I'm an INDIVIDUAL".
While that's true - we ALL still need these nutrients and our bodies still act the SAME way when we eat the junk food (giving in to the "fake" cravings we have). We get fat, tired, lazy, foggy minded and we don't feel how we WANT to feel.... Hence why we are HERE, to make changes to improve our health and physical appearance.
Again, less carbs and more healthy fats.. and of course around at least 100g of protein a day.
I don't really care about commercial vs peer either. I just wanted to share this in hopes someone will try it and see it for themselves. 0 -
I don't think I would be able to eat that much protein in one day - nor want to.0
-
lemurcat12 wrote: »Wheelhouse15 wrote: »lemurcat12 wrote: »Wheelhouse15 wrote: »astronomicals wrote: »Scarecrowsama wrote: »sugar, also, is more addictive than cocaine,
soooo true.... same goes for heroin
Do you have a study on that because I'm undecided on which I should take...
Also, what does it even mean?
Usually the reference is to a study that shows that rats get as much pleasure from sugar as heroin, but that's hardly the same thing. I've never quit heroin or cocaine (did quit drinking, though), but I know from experience that dropping added sugar and even fruit for a while did not cause any painful withdrawal symptoms or really anything negative. So I'm, shall we say, skeptical.
More significantly, whether something is like cocaine or heroin would seem to me to have less to do with whether it is difficult to stop eating, for whatever reason that might be the case (i.e., coffee IS addictive, and lots of people might have trouble giving up their favorite foods without being addicted, and clearly none of us can give up water), and more to do with the effect of being an addict on your life. I was fat (without being addicted to food, IMO) and think it's quite perverse to compare that to the harm caused by drug addiction.
You do reslize that was sarcasm or did you miss it in your need to go on a diatribe? Of course I dont buy the comparison.
Yes, of course I realized it was sarcasm. I was trying to supplement your point, not argue.
And I wouldn't call it a diatribe, although if you must...
Heh.0 -
I know for a fact that my body craves that sugary cerials because of vitamin b12 deficiency, and that McDonalds burger because my fat intake was below recommended (unlimited on a bulk for optimal hormone production)0
-
GenesiaElizabeth wrote: »Your body will crave what it is ACCUSTOMED to getting. Too much salt - you crave salty snacks. Too much sugar? You crave more sweets and MOST importantly, too many CARBS = EATING MORE CARBS. Don't get stuck in that cycle! More natural, healthy fats and less carbs, people!
Check out http://www.foodmatters.tv and http://www.hungryforchange.tv for your proof, OP.
*shrug*
Doesn't work that way for me. Too much greasy food and suddenly I'm craving salad with vinaigrette and other acidic foods, like pickles. Too much sugar and I want savory stuff. Eat fewer sweet things and eventually I'll be dreaming about cake.
I think my palate just wants variety.
Same for me. I assume we aren't THAT uncommon, and thus why it's expected that you will have coffee with a sweet dessert and so on. Most people have that "too much" reaction, IME.0 -
For me the more crap I eat the more I want to eat. Though Im seriously worried about my peanut butter cup deficiency...0
-
This content has been removed.
-
This thread is hilarious0
-
GenesiaElizabeth wrote: »Nutrients are nutrients! Take them or leave them, up to you. But until you have tried it (getting your essential nutrients from juicing, veggies and natural foods), then you can't say it doesn't work or "I'm just the way I am... I'm an INDIVIDUAL".
While that's true - we ALL still need these nutrients and our bodies still act the SAME way when we eat the junk food (giving in to the "fake" cravings we have). We get fat, tired, lazy, foggy minded and we don't feel how we WANT to feel.... Hence why we are HERE, to make changes to improve our health and physical appearance.
Again, less carbs and more healthy fats.. and of course around at least 100g of protein a day.
I don't really care about commercial vs peer either. I just wanted to share this in hopes someone will try it and see it for themselves.
What is with all the carb hate...????
I prefer to get my nutrients from just food....the stuff I want to eat.
I eat "junk food" and I am not fat, tired or lazy thanks..and my foggy mind only happens after a hang over....
"cravings" can be two things imho desire for a certian food due to taste...ie my chocolate bar every night or needs my husbands need for more protien once he started lifting again. My need for calcium and protien (craved chicken and sour cream) while I was pregnant...
ETA: I will eat carbs and healthy fats and protien and because those are in line I won't worry so much about the micros.
0 -
This thread is giving me massive sarcasm cravings.
0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions