Lifting while fasting???
tx_angel77
Posts: 34 Member
I have been lifting a couple of times a week and doing cardio a couple of times a week. I decided to do a 1 meal a day fast (for personal reasons, not a crash diet).... and I was curious about any advise on if I should stop lifting/cardio, cut back or just eat a huge meal???? Thanks for any insight.
0
Replies
-
Have you reduced the overall calories you are eating or are you just cramming them into 1 meal? If you are still eating enough to only be in a moderate deficit then I wouldn't change your exercise schedule at all. If reducing to 1 meal a day has caused you to severely reduce calories, I'd reevaluate the 1 meal a day plan.0
-
I'm curious as well.
I've had an issue recently with stomach stuff where I'm having to force myself to eat, but even then I'm hitting about 1000 cals a day at most (I have seen a doc for this many times over the years, it's a random thing, possibly an ulcer, that flares up for a couple weeks a couple times a year for the last six years or so. Maybe just stress). I've been cutting back my workouts, but I really miss them. Is it dangerous to lift when you are only getting 800 cals, even if it is just for a brief time? I feel really good, just pains when I actually do eat.0 -
Well first it is not dangerous to lift on an intermittent fasting diet if done correctly. Unfortunately for all you can't build muscle without a calorie surplus (barring newbie gains sometimes) and you can't lose fat without a calorie deficit. So you probably won't get any stronger, but lifting while dieting will help you preserve muscle. I lift when I am fasting but never on a day I am fasting. I fast twice a week.0
-
If you aren't getting enough calories to really sustain your body while being sedentary, then adding exercise or lifting isn't a good idea.
scg17, have you tried getting extra calories in liquid form? Sometimes that's less difficult for the body to handle. I'm thinking protein powder or packaged protein drinks, smoothies, milk shakes, etc.0 -
If you're going to lift fasted and remain fasted for awhile after, then I recommend taking BCAAs to prevent muscle catabolism. That said, if you can't get all of your daily calories in one meal, then I don't advise doing so.0
-
There's nothing wrong with expending energy while fasted.
I actually am stronger when fasted, but my muscular endurance is junk. Most of my PR lifts come when fasted, and my best bike sessions have been fasted, while taking in just enough heed to keep going for the session. 1 bottle an hour.0 -
I'll agree with this as long as the person is getting adequate energy and nutrition over the long term. I run fasted all of the time. However, I break my fast soon after and get my calories in during the remainder of the day.There's nothing wrong with expending energy while fasted.
I actually am stronger when fasted, but my muscular endurance is junk. Most of my PR lifts come when fasted, and my best bike sessions have been fasted, while taking in just enough heed to keep going for the session. 1 bottle an hour.
Lifting while eating far too few calories on a daily basis seems like an exercise in futility to me.0 -
I lost my weight following the 5:2 way of eating - two days a week very low calories, five days at maintenance calories.
My experience was that the ability to train fasted developed over time. At first even fairly moderate fasted exercise would prompt signs of glycogen depletion - dizzy, wobbly, weak....
But over time (months) there was a noticeable apparent adaptation. I can now train fasted or fed (weights or cardio) with the same intensity and performance and with no adverse effects at all. Also very noticeable that my need to feed on cycle rides is much diminished. Bear in mind though as my weekly calorie deficit was low I wasn't going into a fast day underfed.
My advice for fasted training would be suck it and see - build up progressively.
The other piece of advice would be to keep your overall weekly deficit small if you are training intensively.
0 -
I don't believe in fasting....but to each their own. I would be afraid of becoming weak, fainting, or just plain down dogging my workouts because I had no energy. At that point, what is the point?0
-
This just isn't the case for most people. Many people exhibit enhanced energy from fasting. It takes far more then a mere 16 hour fast to deprive the body of the needed energy for a workout. Your body stores plenty of fuel in the form of glycogen that unless you are going to be doing some serious endurance work, you should be fine energy wise.I don't believe in fasting....but to each their own. I would be afraid of becoming weak, fainting, or just plain down dogging my workouts because I had no energy. At that point, what is the point?
0 -
Unless you are training at high intensity for over two hours you really don't need to be afraid. If you are into endurance exercise then there actually is a very good reason for including some fasted training.I don't believe in fasting....but to each their own. I would be afraid of becoming weak, fainting, or just plain down dogging my workouts because I had no energy. At that point, what is the point?
0 -
I don't believe in fasting....but to each their own. I would be afraid of becoming weak, fainting, or just plain down dogging my workouts because I had no energy. At that point, what is the point?
Your fear is unfounded. The reality is that manypeople eexercise a good bit while "fasting" and do not suffer reduced performance. There is a huge difference between fasting and starvation.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
I exercise, lift and or cardio, every morning fasted. You need to do what works for you. If you find you're having no energy to have a productive workout, then I would re-evaluate.0
-
There are limits on how much you can do without replenishing your body's energy stores. For cardio, it takes an hour or more to deplete the glycogen stores. I'm not sure what it is for lifting, but it should be similar. Given enough time, glycogen stores will rebuild from the body converting fat into glycogen, but it takes a while. So, while expending energy during a fast is okay, it may be necessary to cut long workouts short and wait longer between workouts.
Of course, there is also the problem that you can't gain muscle during a fast because you don't have additional protein to build from.0 -
Lifting while fasted works great for me I wouldn't have any other way. Maybe take some pre-workout before or drink black coffee.0
-
As I said...to each their own. Personally, I do do 2+ hour HIIT style workouts and focus on learning how to properly fuel my body during workouts for my OCR races which can last from 2-5 hours. I've done plenty of workouts before eating in the morning (2 years, 2x a week worth), but honestly I feel better and work harder when I'm properly fueled. I've also seen plenty of people pass out during workouts because they hadn't eaten for awhile. But I'm just speaking to my personal experience, as you all have. My bad if mine is different
0 -
Just means you haven't tried it.I don't believe in fasting....but to each their own. I would be afraid of becoming weak, fainting, or just plain down dogging my workouts because I had no energy. At that point, what is the point?
My fasted and unfasted workouts are at the least equitable, generally the fasted ones are better.
0 -
I don't believe in fasting....but to each their own. I would be afraid of becoming weak, fainting, or just plain down dogging my workouts because I had no energy. At that point, what is the point?
Not everyone fefeels the way you do about it. That's why fasting isn't for everyone.
Truth. Fasting can be very difficult.0 -
if your schedule allows,you could train in the mornings of your fast--that way you're not waiting until the end of the day having to work out on fumes, per se. plus then it's out of the way!0
-
Thanks for the advice everyone. I am new to lifting so this is greatly appreciated!!
I figure I won't be able to gain muscle while on this fast but maybe maintain what I have and maybe even lose some fat. I have been taking in about 800-1000 cal on average during my meal time. I have a hard time getting that much in at one meal but I have been adding liquid calories like protein smoothies to help. I have lifted every day since I started and I haven't felt bad but I have been extremely hungry so I plan my meal for right after my workout. I don't plan on doing any cardio during this time.0 -
if your schedule allows,you could train in the mornings of your fast--that way you're not waiting until the end of the day having to work out on fumes, per se. plus then it's out of the way!
That's a great idea. Actual I have been doing something similar. I have been able to work out early to mid afternoon and then eat within an hour or so of my workout. Something I'm still feeling out but good idea.0 -
TimothyFish wrote: »There are limits on how much you can do without replenishing your body's energy stores. For cardio, it takes an hour or more to deplete the glycogen stores. I'm not sure what it is for lifting, but it should be similar. Given enough time, glycogen stores will rebuild from the body converting fat into glycogen, but it takes a while. So, while expending energy during a fast is okay, it may be necessary to cut long workouts short and wait longer between workouts.
Of course, there is also the problem that you can't gain muscle during a fast because you don't have additional protein to build from.
I'm curious about this. I'm wondering now if I should eat more carbs at my meal to restore the glycogen. Does this equate to muscle recovery? Any thoughts?0 -
Have you reduced the overall calories you are eating or are you just cramming them into 1 meal? If you are still eating enough to only be in a moderate deficit then I wouldn't change your exercise schedule at all. If reducing to 1 meal a day has caused you to severely reduce calories, I'd reevaluate the 1 meal a day plan.
So If I can get enough cals in one meal then lifting every day won't cause any issues? The one meal a day isn't an option to change at the moment but my exercise load can adjust for a time. How do I find out how many calories I need to maintain my lifting schedule? Thanks0 -
tx_angel77 wrote: »Thanks for the advice everyone. I am new to lifting so this is greatly appreciated!!
I figure I won't be able to gain muscle while on this fast but maybe maintain what I have and maybe even lose some fat. I have been taking in about 800-1000 cal on average during my meal time. I have a hard time getting that much in at one meal but I have been adding liquid calories like protein smoothies to help. I have lifted every day since I started and I haven't felt bad but I have been extremely hungry so I plan my meal for right after my workout. I don't plan on doing any cardio during this time.
You can't build muscle and eat at a deficit at the same time. I'm a little confused by your fasting, so I'm not sure if you're fasting every day to create a deficit or if it's a once a week thing. If you're looking to build muscle, you would need to be in a surplus the rest of the days you aren't fasting (and enough of a surplus to overcome the deficit on your fast days).
That said, not quite the same, but I lift "fasted" in the mornings. I lift right after I wake up and before I eat anything. It works best for me, and I find I actually have problems lifting later in the day unless it's right after a meal (which doesn't work with my schedule). So, it's really only me not eating for 9 hours or so before I lift. I haven't had any issues, and I still have strength gains.0 -
There is a lot that needs defined here.
You can fast and be in a calorie surplus is you eat enough during your given window. Is this the case?
Also why are you lifting every day? Is that a particular program?
Carbs and overall calories are just as critical for muscle recovery/building as protein.0 -
I always train fasted!0
-
There is a lot that needs defined here.
You can fast and be in a calorie surplus is you eat enough during your given window. Is this the case?
Also why are you lifting every day? Is that a particular program?
Carbs and overall calories are just as critical for muscle recovery/building as protein.
Lifting every day is a program. It's a four day lifting and two days rest. How do I determine the number of calories I should be taking in during that one meal?0 -
wait, clarify please. You're taking in one meal, and that meal is 800-1000 calories?0
-
wait, clarify please. You're taking in one meal, and that meal is 800-1000 calories?
Yes and I know you are probably going to tell me that is not enough. I have no issues raising my caloric intake to meet the needs of my lifting program. I am doing this for spiritual reasons not to lose weight. With that being said, I'm just trying to find a good balance so that I can continue lifting during this time.
Any advice on finding the correct caloric intake would be appreciated. 0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions